In addition to football, Wolfley competed in weight lifting, boxing, sumo wrestling and martial arts. In 1981, he placed fifth in the World's Strongest Man competition. In 1985, Wolfley placed second in the first professional sumo wrestling tournament ever held in North America. In 2002, Wolfley lost a four round boxing match to Butterbean. He also holds a black belt in Jiu Jitsu.
Wolfley and his wife Faith have three daughters, Megan, Hannah, and Esther, and three sons, Kyle, 'CJ', and 'Max'. He and Faith are the former owners of the Wolfpack Boxing Club, formally MASC, in Carnegie, PA where they taught boxing, martial arts and other athletics.