Democrat Party (epithet)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Democrat Party (phrase))
Jump to: navigation, search


Democrat Party is an epithet for the Democratic Party in the United States, used in a disparaging fashion by the party's opponents. While historical and occasional current usage includes neutral appearances (including, historically, from within that party), the term has grown in its negative use since the 1940s, in particular by members of the Republican Party—in party platforms, partisan speeches and press releases—as well as by conservative commentators.[1] While there is grammatical argument regarding the propriety of use of both of the terms, with ending and without, ongoing use of the shortened term for political ends is a source of irritation to members of the Democratic Party.[2]

Reasons for use[edit]

The term Democrat Party is an epithet for the Democratic Party of the United States,[3][4][5] used disparagingly by the party's opponents.[6] The following appeared in The New York Times in 1984:

The term 'Democrat Party' has been used in recent years by some right-wing Republicans on the ground that the term used by Democrats implies that they are the only true adherents of democracy.[7]

Language expert Roy Copperud said it was used by Republicans who disliked the implication that Democratic Party implied to listeners that Democrats "are somehow the anointed custodians of the concept of democracy".[8] According to Oxford Dictionaries, the use of Democrat rather than the adjective Democratic

is in keeping with a longstanding tradition among Republicans of dropping the –ic in order to maintain a distinction from the broader, positive associations of the adjective democratic with democracy and egalitarianism.[9]

Political commentator William Safire wrote in 1993 that the Democrat of Democrat Party "does conveniently rhyme with autocrat, plutocrat, and worst of all, bureaucrat".[10] Hendrik Hertzberg writes in The New Yorker:

There’s no great mystery about the motives behind this deliberate misnaming. 'Democrat Party' is a slur, or intended to be—a handy way to express contempt. Aesthetic judgments are subjective, of course, but 'Democrat Party' is jarring verging on ugly. It fairly screams 'rat'.[11]

Political analyst Charlie Cook attributed modern use of the term to force of habit rather than a deliberate epithet by Republicans.[12] Journalist Ruth Marcus stated that Republicans likely only continue to employ the term because Democrats dislike it.[3] Marcus stated that disagreements over use of the term are "trivial",[3] and Hertzberg calls use of the term "a minor irritation" and also "the partisan equivalent of flashing a gang sign".[11]

Grammar[edit]

Among authors of dictionaries and usage guides who state that the use of Democrat as a noun is ungrammatical are Roy H. Copperud,[8] Bergen Evans,[13] and William and Mary Morris.[14][further explanation needed]

Ruth Walker, the long-time language columnist for the Christian Science Monitor,[15] while stating that Democratic is the correct term in most instances, places the adjectival use of Democrat within a broader trend:

We're losing our inflections—the special endings we use to distinguish between adjectives and nouns, for instance. There's a tendency to modify a noun with another noun rather than an adjective. Some may speak of 'the Ukraine election' rather than 'the Ukrainian election' or 'the election in Ukraine', for instance. It's 'the Iraq war' rather than 'the Iraqi war', to give another example.[16]

According to the British newspaper The Economist,

The real reason 'Democrat Party' is wrong is not because it's ungrammatical, but because it's incorrect in another way—the party is simply not named the Democrat Party, but the Democratic Party. Calling it anything else is discourteous.[17]

History of usage[edit]

19th century[edit]

The Oxford English Dictionary says the term was used by the London press as a synonym for the more common Democratic Party in 1890: "Whether a little farmer from South Carolina named Tillman is going to rule the Democrat Party in America—yet it is this, and not output, on which the proximate value of silver depends."[18] In American history, many parties were named by their opponents (Federalists, Loco-Focos, Know Nothings, Populists, Dixiecrats), including the Democrats themselves, as the Federalists in the 1790s used Democratic Party as a term of ridicule.[19] Addressing a gathering of Michigan Republicans in 1889, New Hampshire Republican Congressman Jacob H. Gallinger said:

The great Democrat party, laying down the sceptre of power in 1860, after ruling this country under free trade for a quarter of a century, left our treasury bankrupt, and gave as a legacy to the Republican party, a gigantic rebellion and a treasury without a single dollar of money in it.[20]

Early 20th century[edit]

The 1919 New Teachers' and Pupils' Cyclopaedia entry for Woodrow Wilson states that "In 1912, Wilson was the Democrat Party nominee for President..."[21] In July 14, 1922, a newspaper in Keytesville, Missouri, posted an advertisement for its primary elections with the Democratic candidates identified as "Representing: Democrat Party".[22]

Late 20th century[edit]

The noun-as-adjective has been used by Republican leaders since the 1940s, and in most GOP national platforms since 1948.[citation needed] By the early 1950s the term was in widespread use among Republicans of all factions.[23] When Senator Thruston Ballard Morton became chairman of the Republican National Committee in 1959, he indicated that he had always said Democratic Party and would continue to do so, which contrasted with his predecessor, Meade Alcorn and National Republican Senatorial Committee chairman Barry Goldwater, both of whom used Democrat Party.[24] According to Congressional Quarterly, at the 1968 Republican National Convention "the GOP did revert to the epithet of 'Democrat' party. The phrase had been used in 1952 and 1956 but not in 1960 and 1964".[5]

According to William Safire, Minnesota Governor Harold Stassen, campaign manager to Republican Wendell Willkie during the 1940 presidential campaign, explained that because the Democratic Party was at that time partly controlled by undemocratic city bosses, "by [Frank] Hague in New Jersey, [Tom] Pendergast in Missouri and [Edward Joseph] Kelly-Nash in Chicago, [it] should not be called a 'Democratic Party.' It should be called the 'Democrat Party.'"[25]

Columnist Russell Baker wrote regarding the use of the phrase at the 1976 Republican National Convention:

The origin of this illiterate phrase, goes back, I believe to the era of Sen. Joseph R. McCarthy. [...] The chief trouble with 'the Democrat party' is that it makes the Republicans saying it sound both illiterate and coy, and, so, is like a shotgun that is all kick and no fire. [...] A party whose membership is down to 22 percent of the electorate, as the Republican party is, hardly needs ways to irritate voters from the opposing party whom it must seduce if it is to succeed.[26]

During the 1984 Republican National Convention, use of the term was a point of contention among the delegates.[27] when a member of the Republican platform committee asked unanimous consent to change the phrasing of a platform amendment to read Democrat Party instead of Democratic Party, New York Representative Jack Kemp objected, saying that would be "an insult to our Democratic friends" and the committee dropped the proposal.[7]

Newt Gingrich, in a campaign in the 1980s and 1990s to produce a Republican majority in the United States House of Representatives, relied heavily on words and phrases that cast Democrats in a negative light.[28] The phrase Democrat Party gained new currency when the Republican Party, led by Gingrich, gained control of the House of Representatives in 1994.[4]

In 1996, the wording throughout the Republican Party platform was changed from Democratic Party to Democrat Party: Republican leaders "explained they wanted to make the subtle point that the Democratic Party had become elitist".[29] During that same period, bumper stickers for the Democratic presidential campaign of Bill Clinton and Al Gore sometimes used the phrase "Vote Democrat".[10] A proposal to use the term in the August 2008 Republican platform for similar reasons was voted down, with leaders choosing to use Democratic Party. "We probably should use what the actual name is," said Mississippi Governor Haley Barbour, the panel's chairman. "At least in writing."[29]

Early 21st century[edit]

By George W. Bush[edit]

Following his inauguration in 2001, President George W. Bush often used the noun-as-adjective when referring to the Democratic party.[30] In 2006, Ruth Marcus, an opinion-writer and columnist for The Washington Post, noted that "[t]he derisive use of 'Democrat' in this way was a Bush staple during the recent campaign", and she chastised Bush, alleging he was being intentionally offensive.[3] Marcus went on to say the argument about the term was "trivial, sticks-and-stones [...] linguistic bickering".[3] Bush spoke of the "Democrat majority" in his 2007 State of the Union Address, although the advance copy that was given to members of Congress read "Democratic majority".[12][31] Democrats complained about the use of Democrat as an adjective in the address: John Podesta, White House Chief of Staff for Bush's predecessor Bill Clinton, argued that it was "like nails on a chalkboard," although Congressional historian Julian E. Zelizer argued that "It's hard to disentangle whether that's an intentional slight".[12] Political analyst Charlie Cook doubted it was a deliberate attempt to offend Democrats, saying Republicans "have been [using the term] so long that they probably don't even realize they're doing it".[12] Bush joked about the issue in a February 4, 2007 speech to House Democrats, stating "Now look, my diction isn't all that good. I have been accused of occasionally mangling the English language. And so I appreciate you inviting the head of the Republic Party."[32][33]

By Donald Trump[edit]

Republican presidential aspirant Donald Trump wrote on the social messaging platform Twitter in October 2015 that the Democratic Party's upcoming first presidential debate should be called the "Democrat Debate" rather than "Democratic".[34]

Media organizations[edit]

According to Media Matters for America, the "ungrammatical" and "partisan" use of the phrase Democrat Party has been replicated by the Associated Press, CNN, The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, and the Chicago Tribune.[35]

National Public Radio (NPR) directed its staff in 2010 to use the adjective Democratic rather than Democrat.[36] According to Ron Elving, NPR's senior Washington editor, it was the organization's policy to call parties by the name that they use to refer to themselves, saying: "We should not refer to Democrat ideas or Democrat votes. Any deviation from that by NPR reporters on air or on line should be corrected".[37]

Responses[edit]

Delegates to the Democratic National Committee once proposed using "Publican Party" instead of "Republican Party". The committee failed to accept the proposal "explaining that Republican is the name by which the our opponents' product is known and mistrusted".[38] Sherman Yellen suggested "The Republicants" as suitably comparable in terms of negative connotation in an April 29, 2007 Huffington Post commentary.[39] Other progressive blogs such as Daily Kos use the term "Republicon", to suggest Republicans "are con artists, evil, and after your money".[40][better source needed]

On the February 26, 2009 edition of Hardball with Chris Matthews, Republican Representative Darrell Issa referred to "a Democrat Congress". The host, Chris Matthews, responded by saying:

Well, I think the Democratic Party calls itself the Democratic Party, not the Democrat Party. Do we have to do this every night? Why do people talk like this? Is this just fighting words to get the name on?[41]

Issa denied that he intended to use "fighting words", to which Matthews replied, "They call themselves the Democratic Party. Let's just call people what they call themselves and stop the Mickey Mouse here—save that for the stump."[41]

In March 2009, after Representative Jeb Hensarling (R–Texas) repeatedly used the phrase Democrat Party when questioning U.S. Office of Management and Budget director Peter Orszag, Representative Marcy Kaptur (D–Ohio) responded, saying:

I’d like to begin by saying to my colleague from Texas that there isn’t a single member on this side of the aisle that belongs to the 'Democrat Party'. We belong to the Democratic Party. So the party you were referring to doesn’t even exist. And I would just appreciate the courtesy when you’re referring to our party… to refer to it as such.[42]

Notes[edit]

This article incorporates material from the Citizendium article "Democrat Party (epithet)", which is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License but not under the GFDL.

  1. ^ Safire (1993), pp. 163f.
  2. ^ According to Nelson (2016), "'Democrat Party' [is the] Republicans' long-standing epithet for the Democratic Party and source of tremendous irritation among Democrats" (p. 98).
  3. ^ a b c d e Marcus, Ruth (November 22, 2006). "One Syllable of Civility". The Washington Post: A21. Retrieved April 12, 2017. 
  4. ^ a b Schlesinger, Robert (2008). White House Ghosts: Presidents and Their Speechwriters. New York: Simon and Schuster. p. 96. ISBN 0-7432-9169-7. 
  5. ^ a b "Republicans Adopt Moderate Stance in 1968 Platform". CQ Almanac 1968 (24th ed.). Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly. 1969. ISSN 0095-6007. 19-984-19-986. (Subscription required (help)). 
  6. ^ Siegal, Allan M.; Connolly, William (2015). The New York Times Manual of Style and Usage (5th ed.). Crown/Archetype. ISBN 978-1-10-190322-3. 
  7. ^ a b "Democrats Find Ally In Republican Camp". The New York Times. United Press International. August 17, 1984. 
  8. ^ a b Copperud (1980), pp. 101–2.
  9. ^ Martin, K.C. (November 4, 2014). "What are the most common American political insults?". OxfordWords Blog. Oxford University Press. 
  10. ^ a b Safire, William (1996). "Oh Hell, What's in an Adverb?". National Journal. Vol. 28 no. 27-52. Washington, DC: National Journal Group. p. 1615. 
  11. ^ a b Hertzberg, Hendrik (August 7, 2006). "The 'Ic' Factor". The New Yorker. Retrieved April 12, 2017. 
  12. ^ a b c d Copleand, Libby (January 25, 2007). "President's Sin of Omission? (Dropped Syllable in Speech Riles Democrats)". The Washington Post. Retrieved March 31, 2007. 
  13. ^ Copperud (1980), p. 101.
  14. ^ William Morris and Mary Morris, Harper Dictionary of Contemporary Usage (1975), p. 175.
  15. ^ Linda K. Fuller (2011). The Christian Science Monitor: An Evolving Experiment in Journalism. ABC-CLIO. p. 81. 
  16. ^ Walker, Ruth (January 27, 2005). "Republicans, Democrats, and the Afghan on the Couch". Christian Science Monitor. Archived from the original on March 12, 2007. 
  17. ^ "Names: What's wrong with the 'Democrat Party': Johnson". The Economist. 15 February 2012. 
  18. ^ OED under "Democrat" 4 citing the London Spectator November 15, 1890 p. 676.[full citation needed]
  19. ^ Safire (1993), p. 176.
  20. ^ Michigan Club, Detroit (1890). Proceedings... Annual Meeting of the Michigan Club: 1889. p. 43. 
  21. ^ Holst, Bernhart Paul (1919). The New Teachers' and Pupils' Cyclopaedia. VI. Chicago, IL: Holst Publishing Company. p. 3158. 
  22. ^ Chariton County Clerk (July 14, 1922). "Notice of Primary Election". Chariton Courier. Keytesville, MO. p. 6. 
  23. ^ Feuerlicht, Ignace (October 1957). "Democrat Party". American Speech. 32 (3): 228–31. JSTOR 453829. OCLC 67159091. doi:10.2307/453829. 
  24. ^ Donovan, Robert J. (April 18, 1959). "Big Change: Morton To Say Democratic, Not Democrat Party". Cincinnati Enquirer. Cincinnati, OH. Herald Tribune News Service. p. 1. (Subscription required (help)). 
  25. ^ Safire (1988), p. 35.
  26. ^ Baker, Russell (September 5, 1976). "Democrat Party? — Suggestion for GOP: Drop the Illiterate Phrase". Fort Lauderdale News and Sun-Sentinel. Fort Lauderdale, FL. New York Times News Service. p. 3E. (Subscription required (help)). 
  27. ^ Raum, Tom (August 28, 1984). "What's in a Name?". Del Rio News Herald. Del Rio, TX. Associated Press. p. 4. (Subscription required (help)). 
  28. ^ Braswell, Sean (July 15, 2016). "Newt is Back: Can He Raise Trump's Rhetorical Game?". Ozy.com. Retrieved April 12, 2017. 
  29. ^ a b Woodward, Calvin (August 26, 2008). "No More 'Democrat Wars' for GOP Spinmeisters?". USA Today. Associated Press. 
  30. ^ AP Staff (July 23, 2004). "Bush Courts Black Voters at Urban League". Associated Press (AP). Retrieved April 12, 2017 – via FoxNews.com. 
  31. ^ Office of the Press Secretary (January 23, 2007). "President Bush Delivers State of the Union Address". WhiteHouse.Archives.gov. Archived from the original on May 2, 2013. Retrieved April 12, 2017. 
  32. ^ Abramowitz, Michael; Kane, Paul (February 4, 2007). "At Democrats' Meeting, Bush Appeals for Cooperation". The Washington Post. Retrieved March 31, 2007. 
  33. ^ Levey, Noam H. (February 4, 2007). "Bush reaches across partisan divide". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved April 12, 2017. 
  34. ^ Collins, Eliza (October 13, 2015). "Trump says he'll live-tweet 'boring' Democratic debate". Politico.com. Arlington, VA. 
  35. ^ Brown, Joe (October 10, 2007). "GOP Strategists Christen 'Democrat [sic] Party' — and the Media Comply". MediaMatters.org. Retrieved April 12, 2017. 
  36. ^ Nelson (2016), pp. 99–100.
  37. ^ Shepard, Alicia C. (March 26, 2010). "Ombudsman, "Since When Did It Become the Democrat Party?"". NPR.org. Retrieved April 12, 2017. 
  38. ^ Safire (1993), pp. 163–164.
  39. ^ Yellen, Sherman (April 29, 2007). "The Republicants". Huffington Post. Retrieved October 25, 2010. 
  40. ^ "djtyg" (October 5, 2007). "The New Word: Republicon" (blog). Daily Kos. Retrieved April 12, 2017. [better source needed]
  41. ^ a b Mullins, Anne Schroeder (February 26, 2009). "Don't Call Democrats, Democrats!". Politico.com. Retrieved April 12, 2017. 
  42. ^ Frick, Ali (March 3, 2009). "Rep. Kaptur Scolds GOP: ‘Democrat Party’ Doesn’t Exist". ThinkProgress.org. Retrieved March 4, 2009. 

References[edit]

Further reading[edit]

External links[edit]