Magic circle (mathematics)

For other uses, see Magic circle (disambiguation).

Yang Hui's magic concentric circles – numbers on each circle and diameter (ignoring the middle 9) sum to 138

Magic circles were invented by the Song dynasty (960–1279) Chinese mathematician Yang Hui (c. 1238–1298). It is the arrangement of natural numbers on circles where the sum of the numbers on each circle and the sum of numbers on diameters are identical. One of his magic circles was constructed from the natural numbers from 1 to 33 arranged on four concentric circles, with 9 at the center.

Yang Hui magic circles

Yang Hui's magic circle series was published in his Xugu Zhaiqi Suanfa《續古摘奇算法》(Sequel to Excerpts of Mathematical Wonders) of 1275. His magic circle series includes: magic 5 circles in square, 6 circles in ring, magic eight circle in square magic concentric circles, magic 9 circles in square.

Yang Hui magic concentric circle

Yang Hui's magic concentric circle has the following properties

• The sum of the numbers on four diameters = 147,
  • 28 + 5 + 11 + 25 + 9 + 7 + 19 + 31 + 12 = 147
• The sum of 8 numbers plus 9 at the center = 147;
  • 28 + 27 + 20 + 33 + 12 + 4 + 6 + 8 + 9 = 147
• The sum of eight radius without 9 = magic number 69: such as 27 + 15 + 3 + 24 = 69
• The sum of all numbers on each circle (not including 9) = 2 × 69
• There exist 8 semicircles, where the sum of numbers = magic number 69; there are 16 line segments (semicircles and radii) with magic number 69, more than a 6 order magic square with only 12 magic numbers.

Yang Hui magic eight circles in a square

Yang Hui 8 magic circles in a square 八阵图

64 numbers (1–64) are arranged in eight circles, each with eight numbers; each circle sums to 260. The total sum of all numbers is 2080 (=8×260). The circles are arranged in a 3×3 square grid with the center area open in a way that also makes the horizontal / vertical sum along the central columns and rows is 260, and the total sum of the numbers along both diagonals is 520.

Yang Hui magic eight circles in a square

40 + 24 + 9 + 56 + 41 + 25 + 8 + 57

=260

14 + 51 + 46 + 30 + 3 + 62 + 35 + 19

=260

45 + 29 + 4 + 61 + 36 + 20 + 13 + 52

=260

48 + 32 + 1 + 64 + 33 + 17 + 16 + 49

=260

37 + 21 + 12 + 53 + 44 + 28 + 5 + 60

=260

(49 + 16 + 1 + 64) + (60 + 5 + 12 + 53)

=260

38 + 22 + 11 + 54 + 43 + 27 + 6 + 59

=260

7 + 58 + 39 + 23 + 10 + 55 + 42 + 26

=260

47 + 31 + 2 + 63 + 34 + 18 + 15 + 50

=260

(14 + 51 + 62 + 3) + (7 + 58 + 55 + 10)

=260

(40 + 57 + 41 + 56) + (50 + 47 + 34 + 63) + (29 + 4 + 13 + 20) + (22 + 11 + 6 + 27)

=2 × 260 = 520

Yang Hui magic nine circles in a square

Yang Hui 9 magic circles in a square 连环图

72 numbers from 1 to 72, arranged in nine circles of eight numbers in a square; with neighbouring numbers forming four additional eight number circles: thus making a total of 13 eight number circles:

NW		N		NE
	x1		x2
W		C		E
	x3		x4
SW		S		SE

Extra circle x1 contains numbers from circles NW, N, C, and W; x2 contains numbers from N, NE, E, and C; x3 contains numbers from W, C, S, and SW; x4 contains numbers from C, E, SE, and S.

• Total sum of 72 numbers = 2628;
• sum of numbers in any eight number circle = 292;
• sums of three circles along horizontal lines = 876;
• sum of three circles along vertical lines = 876;
• sum of three circles along the diagonals = 876.

Ding Yidong magic circles

Ding Yidong magic circles – numbers on each circle (solid colour) sum to 200 and numbers on each diameter (dashed grey) sum to 325

Ding Yidong was a mathematician contemporary with Yang Hui. In his magic circle with 6 rings, the unit numbers of the 5 outer rings, combined with the unit number of the center ring, form the following magic square:

4	9	2
3	5	7
8	1	6

Method of construction:

Let radial group 1 =1,11,21,31,41

Let radial group 2=2,12,22,32,42

Let radial group 3=3,13,23,33,43

Let radial group 4=4,14,24,34,44

Let radial group 6=6,16,26,36,46

Let radial group 7=7,17,27,37,47

Let radial group 8=8,18,28,38,48

Let radial group 9=9,19,29,39,49

Let center group =5,15,25,35,45

Arrange group 1,2,3,4,6,7,9 radially such that

• each number occupies one position on circle
• alternate the direction such that one radial has smallest number at the outside, the adjacent radial has largest number outside.
• Each group occupies the radial position corresponding to the number on the Luoshu magic square, i.e., group 1 at 1 position, group 2 at 2 position etc.
• Finally arrange center group at the center circle, such that

number 5 on group 1 radial

number 10 on group 2 radial

number 15 on group 3 radial

...

number 45 on group 9 radial

Cheng Dawei magic circles

Cheng Dawei, a mathematician in the Ming dynasty, in his book Suanfa Tongzong listed several magic circles

• 
• 
• 

Extension to higher dimensions

Andrews's sphere with numbers 1 to 62 arranged along intersections of 5 circles of latitude (grey) and 6 circles of longitude (coloured)

In 1917, W. S. Andrews published an arrangement of numbers 1, 2, 3, and 62 in eleven circles of twelve numbers each on a sphere representing the parallels and meridians of the Earth, such that each circle has 12 numbers totalling 378.

Relationship with magic squares

Magic circle derived from magic square

A magic circle can be derived from one or more magic squares by putting a number at each intersection of a circle and a spoke. Additional spokes can be added by replicating the columns of the magic square.

In the example in the figure, the following 4 × 4 most-perfect magic square was copied into the upper part of the magic circle. Each number, with 16 added, was placed at the intersection symmetric about the centre of the circles. This results in a magic circle containing numbers 1 to 32, with each circle and diameter totalling 132.

6	15	4	9
3	10	5	16
13	8	11	2
12	1	14	7

References

• Lam Lay Yong: A Critical Study of Hang Hui Suan Fa 《杨辉算法》 Singapore University Press 1977
• Wu Wenjun (editor in chief), Grand Series of History of Chinese Mathematics, Vol 6, Part 6 Yang Hui, section 2 Magic circle (吴文俊 主编 沈康身执笔 《中国数学史大系》 第六卷 第六篇 《杨辉》 第二节 《幻圆》) ISBN 7-303-04926-6/O