Jump to content

Military impostor

Edit links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by SamFraseThatPays (talk | contribs) at 10:54, 20 May 2021 (→Notable military imposters). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Alan Mcilwraith, who falsely claimed to be a highly decorated British Army officer[1] (2005). His uniform and medals were purchased online.

A military impostor is a person who makes false claims about their military service in civilian life.[2][3][4] This includes claims by people that have never been in the military as well as lies or embellishments by genuine veterans. Some individuals who do this also wear privately obtained uniforms or medals which were never officially issued to them.

In British military slang, such impostors are called "Walts", based on James Thurber's fictional character, Walter Mitty, who daydreamed of being a war hero.[5] In the United States since the early 2000s, the term "stolen valor" has become popular slang for this kind of behavior, so named for the 1998 book of that name.[6] Other terms include "fake warriors",[7] "military phonies",[8] "medal cheats",[9] and "military posers".[10]

Lying about military service or wearing a uniform or medals that were not earned is criminalized in some circumstances, especially if done with the goal of obtaining money or any other kind of tangible benefit, though laws vary by country.[11]

Behaviors

Military impostors engage in a broad range of deceptive behaviors, all intended to garner recognition from others. An impostor may make verbal statements, written claims, or create deceptive impressions through actions, such as wearing a uniform, rank insignia, unit symbols, medals, or patches.[2]

Generally impostors fall into two broad categories: civilians who have never been in any branch of the military, and real veterans who make false claims exaggerating their experiences or accomplishments. Impostors in the latter category may claim any of the following:

  • Being the recipient of awards that were not earned
  • Having a longer service duration
  • Having a more favorable discharge
  • Holding a higher rank than one actually held
  • Having served with a different branch of the military
  • Having served with a different unit that is more famous
  • Being a different role or occupational specialty
  • Involvement in a war or specific engagement one was not present for
  • Performing a brave or valorous act that never happened
  • Participation in "special" or "secret" operations
  • Being a prisoner of war (POW).[12]

While many individuals outright fabricate some or all of their military service history, others employ equivocation tactics or similarly misleading language that avoids making a technically false statement, but still gives a deceptive impression. A common example is stating one was in a branch of the military during a specific war. In many contexts, such a statement implies that the speaker was deployed to a combat zone, even if in reality never left their home country. A similar misleading statement is boasting about being a member of a branch or unit that is well known for its combat prowess and heroic achievements, when the speaker was purely in a logistical role without any combat experience. Impostors also frequently claim to be part of "classified" operations as an excuse for why they cannot provide details when confronted, or why there is no record of their actions or service.[13]

Motivations

Historically, when military record-keeping was less accurate than it is now, some men falsely claimed to be war veterans to obtain military pensions. Such men added a few years to their ages and claimed service in obscure units. Most did not make extravagant claims, because they were seeking money, not public attention that might expose them. There were numerous U.S. media reports in the 1950s of men claiming to be Confederate veterans over 110 years old, and most articles debunked these stories, saying the men had exaggerated their ages and made fraudulent pension claims years earlier and then found themselves in the spotlight after the last genuine Civil War veterans died off. Walter Williams, noted below, is considered one of these impostors, though some people continue to believe his claim.

In the modern world, reasons for posing as a member of the military or exaggerating one's service record vary, but the intent is almost always to gain the respect and admiration of others.[2] Philosophy professor Verna V. Gehring describes such people as "virtue impostors," in that they don't necessarily adopt the identity of another person, but instead adopt a false history for themselves to impersonate virtues and characteristics.[8] Many are only motivated by social recognition, attempting to exploit the reverence and respect for veterans in their country. These individuals often become absorbed in a fantasy of being a veteran that they attempt to live out in real life, sometimes even inserting themselves into public events or ceremonies, or volunteering for interviews with journalists about their alleged experiences.[2] Others are motivated by more direct gains, such as impressing employers, casting directors, audiences, investors, voters in political campaigns or romantic interests.[14]

Occasionally impostors use their claims in an attempt to intimidate others, such as claiming to be a trained sniper or ex-special forces, or use their fabricated experiences as a pretense of authority for their opinions on political matters.[15] False claims of military service are also used by panhandlers to increase donations, sometimes coupled with real or fake injuries that are implied to be combat-related.[16]

Detection

Military imposters are frequently caught and exposed due to mistakes and inconsistencies in their stories or behaviors. For example, they may be too young or too old to have been in the war they say they were or too young for the rank they claim to be, might inadvertently profess to have been in two different places at once, or might state factually incorrect information about the war they allegedly were part of. Among imposters that wear uniforms, they often make mistakes about the placement of patches, insignia and medals, and may have some from the wrong branch or from old campaigns they could not possibly have taken part in.[17] Real veterans often can spot mistakes more readily, especially if they were part of the same branch the imposter claims to have served in.[18]

Some countries have ways of verifying military service and certain claims within it. In the United States, most real veterans that have been separated from the military for any reason has a DD Form 214 they can present - although other forms are possible, ex. DD-256 - which indicates their branch, rank, unit, MOS/AFSC, awards, and other information. Alternatively, requests can also be made to the National Personnel Records Center using the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) to verify service. Other claims can be verified against public lists, such as recipients of the Medal of Honor or the prisoner of war list from the Vietnam War. Several websites are specifically devoted to verifying the claims of alleged military imposters, and if discovered to have lied, proceed to shame the perpetrator publicly.[10][7][9][19][20][21]

False accusations

Accusations do occasionally backfire, with real veterans accused of being imposters.[22] Doug Sterner, a Vietnam War veteran who catalogs military awards, and Stolen Valor author B.G. Burkett, note that some modern veterans have become hypersensitive to imposters, leading to vigilantism or even turning detection into a "hunting game."[23][24] A common error is placing too much emphasis on the neatness of a uniform or certain quirks about how it's worn, which is not necessarily compelling when a veteran is older and has been out of the service for several decades.[23] Another is making too many inferences based on older regulations, such as gender restrictions that were in place in the past.[25] Even FOIA requests to the National Personnel Records Center, considered the most thorough type of verification for US veterans, are not perfect and sometimes fail to find a record even if the veteran is genuine.[26] Sterner states, "There’s some people that feel good about confronting people, and making themselves look big by trying to take them down. But when they do that, they’re going to make mistakes."[24]

Criminal laws

Laws vary between countries regarding false statements about military service or the wearing of uniforms or medals.

Australia

Under the Australia's Defence Act, 1903, as amended, it is a federal crime to falsely claim to be a returned soldier, sailor or airman. It is also a crime to wear any service decoration one has not earned.

Canada

In Canada, section 419 of the Criminal Code makes it a crime to wear a uniform from the Canadian Forces without authority as well as any awards or marks not earned. It additionally makes it a crime to possess any fraudulent discharge papers, commissions, warrants or military ID, including those that are forged, altered or belong to someone else.[27]

China

In the People’s Republic of China, it was an offence to wear a uniform from the People's Liberation Army or People's Armed Police without authority, or possess any fraudulent discharge papers, commissions, warrants or military ID, including those that are forged, altered or belong to someone else, and shall be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not more than three years, criminal detention, surveillance, or deprivation of political rights; if the circumstances are serious, it will be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not less than three years but not more than ten years.[28] This crime refers to the act of fraudulently pretending to be a soldier’s identity or job title in order to obtain illegal benefits, and damage the prestige of the armed forces and their normal activities.

According to the provisions of Article 372 of the Criminal Law of the People’s Republic Of China, anyone who commits this crime and the circumstances are serious shall be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not less than three years and not more than ten years.[28] The so-called "serious circumstances" generally refers to the impersonation of soldiers many times, including those who do not change behavior after repeated instruction; those who pretend to be soldiers in illegal and criminal activities and cause bad influence; those who pretend to be military leaders at all levels, confidential personnel, etc.[29]

United Kingdom

In the United Kingdom, it was an offence under the Army Act 1955 to wear real or replica military decorations with intent to deceive. However, this law was superseded by the Armed Forces Act 2006, which lacks this prohibition.[20]

It is still a crime in the UK for a civilian to wear a uniform of the armed forces without authorization under the Uniforms Act 1894,[30] and false claims of military service used to obtain money or other enrichment are prosecuted under the general crime of fraud.[20] In November 2016, the Defence Select Committee recommended making the wearing of unearned medals a criminal offence punishable by up to six months imprisonment.[31]

United States

In the United States, the Stolen Valor Act of 2005, which criminalized any false claim regarding military service, was struck down as violating the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment. Subsequently, the Stolen Valor Act of 2013, which makes it a federal offense to falsely claim to have received any of several major military awards with the intention of obtaining money, property, or other tangible benefits, was passed and remains in effect.[32] There are additional laws criminalizing the altering or forging of discharge documents,[33] and attempting to obtain veteran's benefits from the government.

Notable military imposters

  • Joseph A. Cafasso – American con artist and former Fox News military analyst who claimed to have been a highly decorated Special Forces soldier and Vietnam War veteran. He actually served in the U.S. Army for only 44 days in 1976.
  • Wes Cooley – Former U.S. Congressman from Oregon who claimed to have fought in the Korean War. He served in the U.S. Army for two years, but was never in Korea. Convicted of lying in an official document.
  • Brian Dennehy – American actor who claimed to have fought and been wounded in the Vietnam War. He served in the United States Marine Corps from 1959 to 1963. He was not wounded and did not serve in Vietnam.[34]
  • George Dupre – Canadian who claimed that he worked for the SOE and the French Resistance during World War II. Dupre served in World War II, but he was never in France or with the SOE. Was the subject of a best-selling book about his fabricated experiences. Confessed after being interviewed by a reporter who tricked him by dropping false names.
  • Frank Dux - American martial artist, fight choreographer and author who claims he was on covert missions to Southeast Asia while serving with the United States Marine Corps and was awarded the Medal of Honor, and that he was also a CIA field officer. Dux served in the United States Marine Corps Reserve from 1975 to 1981, but was never sent overseas, never received the Medal of Honor, and never was recruited by the CIA.
  • Joseph Ellis – American professor and historian who claimed a tour of duty in the Vietnam War. He had a graduate student deferral of service until 1969 and then taught history at West Point until 1972. He issued a public apology in August 2001.
  • L. Ron Hubbard - Science fiction author and founder of Scientology. The Church of Scientology presents Hubbard as a "much-decorated war hero who commanded a corvette and during hostilities was crippled and wounded".[35] According to Scientology publications, he served as a "Commodore of Corvette squadrons" in "all five theaters of World War II" and was awarded "twenty-one medals and palms" for his service.[36] He was "severely wounded and was taken crippled and blinded" to a military hospital, where he "worked his way back to fitness, strength and full perception in less than two years, using only what he knew and could determine about Man and his relationship to the universe." Hubbard's official Navy service records indicate that "his military performance was, at times, substandard", that he was only awarded a handful of campaign medals and that he was never injured or wounded in combat and was never awarded a Purple Heart.[37] Most of his military service was spent ashore in the continental United States on administrative or training duties. He briefly commanded two anti-submarine vessels, USS YP-422 and USS PC-815, in coastal waters off Massachusetts, Oregon and California in 1942 and 1943 respectively.
  • Jonathan Idema – American con artist who claimed to be a U.S. government-sponsored special forces operative in Afghanistan, and that he had 12 years of Special forces service, 22 years of combat training, and 18 years of covert operations experience. In actuality, he served in the army from 1975 to 1984 primarily in the U.S. Army Reserve and while he did serve with the 11th Special Forces Group, it was purely as logistical support. He never saw combat and was never sent overseas. Convicted of fraud in 1994 and later convicted in 2004 by an Afghan court of capturing and torturing citizens he believed were terrorists.
  • M. Larry Lawrence – American real estate developer and later United States Ambassador to Switzerland who claimed to be a Seaman, First Class in the Merchant Marine during World War II and a veteran of the Arctic convoys. Upon his death, he was buried in Arlington National Cemetery with a eulogy delivered by President Bill Clinton. A year later, his claims of service were exposed as fraudulent and his remains disinterred.
  • Jack Livesey – British historian, military advisor on film productions, and author who claimed to have a distinguished twenty-year career in the Parachute Regiment. He actually served as a cook in the Army Catering Corps for three years.
  • Jesse Macbeth – anti-war activist who claimed to be an Army Ranger and veteran of the Iraq War. In reality he was discharged from the Army after only 44 days for being "unfit for duty". Confessed in federal court after being charged with possessing a forged or altered military discharge certificate and making false statements in seeking benefits from the Veterans Administration.
  • Joseph McCarthy - United States Senator, falsely claimed participation in 32 aerial missions in order to qualify for a Distinguished Flying Cross and multiple awards of the Air Medal, which the Marine Corps chain of command decided to approve in 1952 because of his political influence.[38][39] McCarthy also publicized a letter of commendation which he claimed had been signed by his commanding officer and Admiral Chester W. Nimitz, then Chief of Naval Operations.[40][41] However, his commander revealed that McCarthy had written this letter himself, probably while preparing award citations and commendation letters as an additional duty, and that he had signed his commander's name, after which Nimitz signed it during the process of just signing numerous other such letters.[42][41] A "war wound"—a badly broken leg—that McCarthy made the subject of varying stories involving airplane crashes or anti-aircraft fire had in fact happened aboard ship during a raucous celebration for sailors crossing the equator for the first time.[43][44][45] Because of McCarthy's various lies about his military heroism, his "Tail-Gunner Joe" nickname was sarcastically used as a term of mockery by his critics.[46][47][48]

In literature

Cyrus Trask, a character in John Steinbeck's novel East of Eden, loses his leg in the first and only action he saw during the U.S. Civil War. He subsequently creates an entire military career, encompassing nearly every battle of the war, and stating that he was a personal advisor to President Lincoln.

See also

References

  1. ^ Seenan, Gerard (12 April 2006). "Captain Sir Alan KBE - call-centre worker". The Guardian. Retrieved 1 February 2015.
  2. ^ a b c d Henry Mark Holzer (August 9, 2012). Fake Warriors: Identifying, Exposing, and Punishing Those Who Falsify Their Military Service. Madison Press. ISBN 978-0985243784.
  3. ^ Sterner, Doug; Sterner, Pam (February 4, 2014). Restoring Valor: One Couple's Mission to Expose Fraudulent War Heroes and Protect America's Military Awards System. Skyhorse Publishing Company, Incorporated. ISBN 978-1626365513.
  4. ^ "Fake War Stories Exposed". cbsnews.com. 11 November 2005. Retrieved 2015-04-07. Civil War
  5. ^ Green Chris (30 January 2015). "Homeless Veterans appeal: UK needs new law to stop 'Walter Mittys' posing as war heroes". The Independent. Retrieved 30 January 2015.
  6. ^ Bernard Gary Burkett (1 January 1998). Stolen Valor: How the Vietnam Generation was Robbed of Its Heroes and Its History. Verity Press. ISBN 978-0-9667036-0-3.
  7. ^ a b Henry Mark Holzer, Erika Holzer. "The Fake WarriorsS Project". fakewarriors.org. Retrieved 2015-04-03.
  8. ^ a b Gehring, Verna V. (2003). "Phonies, Fakes, and Frauds - and the Social Harms They Cause". Philosophy and Public Policy Quarterly. 23 (1/2). Retrieved 2015-05-21.
  9. ^ a b "Australian & New Zealand Military Imposters (ANZMI)". anzmi.net. Retrieved 2015-04-29.
  10. ^ a b "Guardian Of Valor". Guardian Of Valor. Retrieved 2017-07-08.
  11. ^ "Is it illegal to wear medals you weren't awarded?". BBC News. 13 January 2010. Retrieved 30 January 2015.
  12. ^ "AP: More POW claimants than actual POWs". msnbc.com. Retrieved 2015-04-07.
  13. ^ Larsen, Erik (13 February 2015). "Stafford mayor's 'stolen valor' problem". Asbury Park Press. Retrieved 2015-04-03. He told people, including reporters, that he had been sent on secret missions as a self-described "spook," and that his true service record remained classified 40 years after the war. When asked how he could acknowledge being a spy if his service record was still classified, he simply stopped talking about the matter.
  14. ^ "The men who impersonate military personnel for stolen glory". The Independent. Retrieved 20 June 2020.
  15. ^ Ross, Brian; Walter, Vic (September 21, 2007). "Anti-War YouTube 'Vet' Admits He Is Faker". ABC News. Retrieved 2007-09-22.
  16. ^ "Army veteran confronts Florida panhandler for posing in military uniform". ABC7 Los Angeles. Retrieved 2015-04-03.
  17. ^ "US Attorney's Office - Eastern District of NC". justice.gov. Archived from the original on 2014-01-15. Retrieved 2015-05-06. The indictment alleges that the Air Force uniform that PHILLIPS wore was decorated with the following military medals and ribbons:...European-African-Middle Eastern Campaign Medal
  18. ^ "Stolen valor? Man confronts "soldier" in uniform whom he believes is an impersonator". FOX6Now.com. Retrieved 2015-04-07.
  19. ^ Lilyea, Jonn. "Stolen Valor". This ain't Hell, but you can see it from here. Retrieved 2015-04-03.
  20. ^ a b c Shute, Joe (21 February 2015). "The Walter Mitty Hunters exposing fake veterans". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 29 April 2015.
  21. ^ "Stolen Valour Canada". stolenvalour.ca. Retrieved 2015-04-29.
  22. ^ "Sacramento Marine Vet Says He Was Beaten Over Mistaken Case Of Stolen Valor". CBS Sacramento. Retrieved 2016-06-02.
  23. ^ a b Vendel, Christine (June 5, 2015). "Harrisburg police officer wrongly accuses veteran, 75, of 'stolen valor'". The Patriot-News. Retrieved 27 July 2015.
  24. ^ a b Larimer, Sarah (June 5, 2015). "The problem with calling out 'stolen valor': What if you're wrong?". The Washington Post. Retrieved 15 December 2015.
  25. ^ ""Prissy Holly", CPT Lyndsay Lowery Accused Of Stolen Valor For Saying She Was Platoon Leader Of An Infantry Platoon". Guardian Of Valor. Retrieved 2015-12-15.
  26. ^ Pfankuch, Thomas B. (September 15, 2002). "Duval man struggling to reclaim military valor". jacksonville.com. Retrieved 2016-06-02.
  27. ^ "Criminal Code - 419 Unlawful use of military uniforms or certificates". laws.justice.gc.ca. Retrieved 2015-05-19.
  28. ^ a b "Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China | Congressional-Executive Commission on China". www.cecc.gov. Retrieved 11 April 2021. Public Domain This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
  29. ^ "中华人民共和国刑法释义：第372条-第373条". 9 Dec 2020. Retrieved 10 Apr 2021.
  30. ^ "Uniforms Act: Section 2", legislation.gov.uk, The National Archives, 1894 c. 30 (s. 2)
  31. ^ Bingham, John (22 November 2016). "MPs back new 'Walter Mitty' medals law to criminalise 'military imposters'". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 23 March 2018.
  32. ^ "18 U.S. Code § 704 - Military medals or decorations | LII / Legal Information Institute". law.cornell.edu. Retrieved 2015-05-31.
  33. ^ "18 U.S. Code § 498 - Military or naval discharge certificates | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute". law.cornell.edu. Retrieved 2015-05-31.
  34. ^ Green, Jonathan (October 22, 2004). "Mock Heroics". Financial Times. Retrieved April 16, 2020.
  35. ^ Lamont, pp. 19–20
  36. ^ Rolph, p. 16
  37. ^ Sappel, Joel; Welkos, Robert W. (1990-06-24). "The Mind Behind the Religion, Chapter 2: Creating the Mystique: Hubbard's Image Was Crafted of Truth, Distorted by Myth". Los Angeles Times. Archived from the original on June 12, 2008. Retrieved 2009-07-14.
  38. ^ Reds: McCarthyism in Twentieth-Century America
  39. ^ Giblin, James Cross (2009). The Rise and Fall of Senator Joe McCarthy. Boston: Clarion Books. p. 34. ISBN 978-0-618-61058-7.
  40. ^ Carrier, Jerry (2014). Tapestry: The History and Consequences of America's Complex Culture. New York: Algora Publishing. p. 232. ISBN 978-1-62894-048-0.
  41. ^ a b The Rise and Fall of Senator Joe McCarthy.
  42. ^ Tapestry: The History and Consequences of America's Complex Culture
  43. ^ Herman, Arthur (1999). Joseph McCarthy: Reexamining the Life and Legacy of America's Most Hated Senator. Free Press. p. 264. ISBN 0-684-83625-4.
  44. ^ Morgan, Ted (November–December 2003). "Judge Joe: How The Youngest Judge In Wisconsin's History Became The Country's Most Notorious Senator". Legal Affairs. Retrieved August 2, 2006.
  45. ^ Underdogs: The Making of the Modern Marine Corps.
  46. ^ Garraty, John (1989). 1,001 Things Everyone Should Know About American History. New York: Doubleday. p. 24
  47. ^ O'Brien, Steven (1991). Santa Barbara, ABC-CLIO, p. 265
  48. ^ "Connecticut Cartoonists #5: The Philosopher of Okefenokee Swamp". The Comics Journal.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Military_impostor&oldid=1024143804"