New Philosophers

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

The New Philosophers (French: nouveaux philosophes) is the generation of French philosophers who broke with Marxism in the early 1970s. They include Alain Finkielkraut,[1] André Glucksmann, Pascal Bruckner, Bernard-Henri Lévy, Jean-Marie Benoist, Christian Jambet, Guy Lardreau, Claude Gandelman, Jean-Paul Dollé and Gilles Susong. They criticized Jean-Paul Sartre and post-structuralism, as well as the philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche and Martin Heidegger.

Beginnings[edit]

The term was created by Bernard-Henri Lévy in 1976. Most of the philosophers he included in that description had a previous history of Marxism with which they had recently broken. Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn's writings on The Gulag Archipelago had a profound effect upon many of these former Leftists.[citation needed]

Basic characteristics[edit]

The New Philosophers rejected what they saw as the power-worship of the Left, a tradition which they traced back to at least Hegel and Marx. They argued that various "master thinkers" had created the foundations for systems of oppression. More recently Pascal Bruckner has targeted multiculturalism.

Heterogeneity[edit]

Because they are defined by a negative quality (i.e., the rejection of systems of authoritarian power) the New Philosophers are very disparate. In 1978, Michael Ryan argued that they exist in name only; their "homogeneity derives from their espousal of heterogeneity."[2] They have been described as "a brand name" for an "extremely heterogeneous group of about ten intellectuals who are held together more from without than from within... they do not serve as representatives of any clearly defined political movement or force."[3]

Criticisms[edit]

They were attacked as superficial and ideological by critics such as Gilles Deleuze,[4] Pierre Vidal-Naquet,[5] Pierre Bourdieu,[6] Alain Badiou,[7] Jean-François Lyotard,[8] and Cornelius Castoriadis.[9]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Bernard-Henri Lévy, Left in Dark Times, Random House Publishing Group, 2008, p. 43.
  2. ^ Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak and Michael Ryan (June 1978). "Anarchism Revisited: A New Philosophy". Diacritics, 67-68
  3. ^ Oskar Negt and Jamie O. Daniel (1983) "Reflections on France's 'Nouveaux Philosophes' and the Crisis of Marxism". SubStance 11(4), 56-67
  4. ^ Gilles Deleuze, « Les nouveaux philosophes », supplément au n° 24 de la revue Minuit, repris dans Deux régimes de fous, Minuit, p. 132.
  5. ^ La critique du Testament de Dieu de Bernard-Henry Lévy (1979)
  6. ^ Pierre Bourdieu, « Le hit-parade des intellectuels français, ou Qui sera juge de la légitimité des juges ? », Homo academicus, Minuit, 1984, annexe 3.
  7. ^ Éric Aeschimann, « Mao en chaire », Libération, 10 January 2007.
  8. ^ Jean-François Lyotard, Instructions païennes, Éditions Galilée, 1977. Le groupe des nouveaux philosophes, dont Lyotard analyse les pratiques discursives, est ici appelé la Cie Clavel. Cf. aussi du même, La condition postmoderne, Minuit, 1979, et Le postmoderne expliqué aux enfants (1982-1985), Galilée, 1988.
  9. ^ Christos Memos. "Castoriadis and Social Theory: From Marginalization to Canonization to Re-radicalization". In: Alex Law and Eric Royal Lybeck (eds.). Sociological Amnesia: Cross-currents in Disciplinary History. Palgrave Macmillan, 2015. p. 190.