Nonfirstorderizability

In formal logic, nonfirstorderizability is the inability of an expression to be adequately captured in particular theories in first-order logic. Nonfirstorderizable sentences are sometimes presented as evidence that first-order logic is not adequate to capture the nuances of meaning in natural language.

The term was coined by George Boolos in his well-known paper "To Be is to Be a Value of a Variable (or to Be Some Values of Some Variables)." Boolos argued that such sentences call for second-order symbolization, which can be interpreted as plural quantification over the same domain as first-order quantifiers use, without postulation of distinct "second-order objects" (properties, sets, etc.).

Examples

• A standard example is the Geach–Kaplan sentence: "Some critics admire only one another."

If Axy is understood to mean "x admires y," and the universe of discourse is the set of all critics, then a reasonable translation of the sentence into second order logic is:

$$\exists X(\exists x,y(Xx\land Xy\land Axy)\land \exists x\neg Xx\land \forall x\,\forall y(Xx\land Axy\rightarrow Xy))$$

That this formula has no first-order equivalent can be seen as follows. Substitute the formula (y = x + 1 v x = y + 1) for Axy. The result,

$$\exists X(\exists x,y(Xx\land Xy\land (y=x+1\lor x=y+1))\land \exists x\neg Xx\land \forall x\,\forall y(Xx\land (y=x+1\lor x=y+1)\rightarrow Xy))$$

states that there is a nonempty set which is closed under the predecessor and successor operations and yet does not contain all numbers. Thus, it is true in all nonstandard models of arithmetic but false in the standard model. Since no first-order sentence has this property, the result follows.

• The concept of identity cannot be defined in first-order languages, merely indiscernibility.
• The compactness theorem implies that graph connectivity cannot be expressed in first-order logic.

See also

• Branching quantifier
• Generalized quantifier
• Plural quantification
• Reification (linguistics)

References

• George Boolos (1984). "To Be is to Be a Value of a Variable (or to Be Some Values of Some Variables)". Journal of Philosophy. 81 (8). The Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 81, No. 8: 430–49. doi:10.2307/2026308. JSTOR 2026308. Reprinted in Boolos, George (1998). Logic, Logic, and Logic. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. ISBN 0-674-53767-X. {{cite book}}: Cite has empty unknown parameter: |coauthors= (help)

External links

• Printer-friendly CSS, and nonfirstorderisability by Terence Tao