Jump to content

Red Roses for Me

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Ss112 (talk | contribs) at 00:01, 5 February 2015 (→Critical reception: Fixed links.). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

This article is about the Pogues album. For the play, see Red Roses for Me (play).
Untitled

Red Roses for Me is the debut studio album by the London-based band The Pogues and was released in October 1984. It is filled with traditional Irish music performed with punk influences. Traditional songs and ballads mixed with Shane MacGowan's "gutter hymns" about drinking, fighting and sex was innovative at the time. Or as lead singer MacGowan explained the music: "I couldn't believe that nobody else were doing it, so we went on doing it ourselves..." The title "Red Roses for Me" is the name of a play by Sean O'Casey, though his works do not show any direct influence upon the band. O'Casey's song of the same name has been recorded by The Dubliners. The album reached number 89 in the UK album charts.

The front of the album shows the band with the exception of drummer Andrew Ranken (pictured in inset) sitting in front of a picture of United States president John F. Kennedy. The back features Shane MacGowan pictured with his foot in a cast. Accordion player James Fearnley has a bottle sticking out of his coat, while bass player Cait O'Riordan is seen holding a can of beer.

Critical reception

Professional ratings
Review scores
SourceRating
AllMusic[1]
Melody Makervery favourable[2]
Mojo (2004 reissue)[3]
NMEvery favourable[4]
Q (1994 reissue)[5]
Q (2004 reissue)[6]
Record Mirror[7]
Robert ChristgauB+[8]
Sounds[9]

The UK music press hailed The Pogues debut album as a breath of fresh air, with positive reviews. Melody Maker felt that "the quality of their music, even the very nature of it, is strangely irrelevant. What's important is their existence at all. For the Pogues are a gesture – a particularly bloody two-fingered one – aimed at all things considered current and fashionable in 1984... Theirs is a gut reaction to traditional music – and with it comes all the motion, intensity and vigour that has largely been lost to these songs since the early days of the folk revival in the Sixties."[2] NME stated, "From the strummed banjo and lilting accordion that preface a roaring singalong 'Transmetropolitan' to the final unidentified voice offering an unaccompanied 'diddly I di di' refrain, there exists a wealth of evidence that Shane MacGowan's faith in the power of positive drinking-music has paid premiums. The raucous surge and evocative noise that has filled the capital's pubs and clubs has come through the stark sobriety of the studio set-up to arrive intact in all its sweat-soaked beer-stained glory... If you think they've rehabilitated a music that's been asleep for a while you're dead wrong – on both counts. The music has never been away, and The Pogues in all their irreverent 'seriousness' have taken it out on a limb, where it all started, where it belongs."[4] Awarding the album 3¾ stars out of five, Sounds said, "Red Roses for Me is a satisfyingly impure, purposefully imperfect and totally irresistible collection of lasting resentment, rebellious roars, watery-eyed romance and uproarious jigs... Surprisingly, this record works. It manages to convey the sullied, brazen and raucous spirit of their live set very effectively."[9] For the 1994 reissue of the album Q observed that the album "rushes along at an unholy amphetamine gallop... they sound utterly intoxicated both with their own enthusiasm and the spirit of the jig and the reel".[5]

Mark Deming of AllMusic gave Red Roses for Me three and a half out of five stars, calling it "good and rowdy fun", but felt that "on Rum Sodomy & the Lash and If I Should Fall from Grace with God, the Pogues would prove that they were capable of a lot more than that".[1] Robert Christgau gave the album a B+ and proclaimed "tepid it ain't".[8]

Track listing

The original UK LP has the following track listing

  1. "Transmetropolitan" (Shane MacGowan) – 4:15
  2. "The Battle of Brisbane" (MacGowan) – 1:49
  3. "The Auld Triangle" (Brendan Behan) – 4:20
  4. "Waxie's Dargle" (Traditional) – 1:53
  5. "Boys from the County Hell" (MacGowan) – 2:56
  6. "Sea Shanty" (MacGowan) – 2:24
  7. "Dark Streets of London" (MacGowan) – 3:33
  8. "Streams of Whiskey" (MacGowan) – 2:32
  9. "Poor Paddy" (Traditional) – 3:09
  10. "Dingle Regatta" (Traditional) – 2:52
  11. "Greenland Whale Fisheries" (Traditional) – 2:36
  12. "Down in the Ground Where the Dead Men Go" (MacGowan) – 3:30
  13. "Kitty" (Traditional) – 4:23

Bonus tracks

The first CD issue of the album had a total of 14 tracks, adding "Whiskey You're the Devil" as track 8. In 2004 a remastered CD was issued adding a total of 6 bonus tracks to the original UK album listing. "Repeal of the Licensing Laws" was the B-side of "The Boys from the County Hell" their second single. "And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda" was the B-side of their first single, "Dark Streets of London". "Whiskey You're the Devil" and "Mursheen Durkin" were the B-sides of their third single, "A Pair of Brown Eyes". "The Wild Rover" was the B-side of their fourth single, "Sally Maclennane".

  1. "The Leaving of Liverpool" (Traditional)
  2. "Muirshin Durkin" (Traditional)
  3. "Repeal of the Licensing Laws" (instrumental) (Stacy)
  4. "And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda" (Eric Bogle)
  5. "Whiskey You're the Devil" (Traditional)
  6. "The Wild Rover" (Traditional)

Personnel

The Pogues:

Additional personnel:

References

  1. ^ a b Red Roses for Me - The Pogues | Songs, Reviews, Credits, Awards at AllMusic Edit this at Wikidata
  2. ^ a b Irwin, Colin (6 October 1984). "Review: The Pogues – Red Roses for Me". Melody Maker. London, England: IPC Media: 36.
  3. ^ Gilbert, Pat (December 2004). "Review: The Pogues – Red Roses for Me". Mojo (133). London, England: EMAP: 123.
  4. ^ a b O'Hagan, Sean (13 October 1984). "Review: The Pogues – Red Roses for Me". NME. London, England: IPC Media: 36.
  5. ^ a b Cooper, Mark (June 1994). "Review: The Pogues – Red Roses for Me". Q (93). London, England: EMAP: 134–35.
  6. ^ Aizlewood, John (January 2005). "Review: The Pogues – Red Roses for Me". Q (222). London, England: EMAP: 141.
  7. ^ Cordery, Mark (6 October 1984). "Review: The Pogues – Red Roses for Me". Record Mirror. London, England: Spotlight Publications: 20.
  8. ^ a b "CG: the pogues". Robert Christgau. Retrieved 20 May 2014.
  9. ^ a b Rouse, Rose (6 October 1984). "Review: The Pogues – Red Roses for Me". Sounds. London, England: Spotlight Publications: 38.
  10. ^ "The Medusa Fora • View topic - The Star of the County Down?". Pogues.com. Retrieved 20 May 2014.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Red_Roses_for_Me&oldid=645677106"