Jump to content

Talk:Donald Vroon

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Various Tags

[edit]

I noticed that this article has been tagged for quite some time. Here are the problems with this article:

  • The article's subject is of debatable notability. There are numerous Classical music critics - including those who are objectively more notable and who are published in major periodicals - who do not have a Wikipedia article.
  • The sourcing for this article is limited in the extreme. Existing sources point to the subject's own publication (American Record Guide), a web newsgroup, and wikiquote. This kind of sourcing would not pass muster in any reviewed article.

The article has been tagged for more than a year, and finding adequate sourcing may be something of a challenge. I am inclined to list this for deletion. I welcome other opinions before noting it as such.

72.185.104.55 (talk) 00:46, 5 August 2014 (UTC)I would argue not to delete. He owns and is chief editor of a long standing magazine.[reply]