Jump to content

Talk:Glenn Anderson/GA1

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

GA Review

[edit]
GA toolbox
Reviewing

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Cloudz679 (talk · contribs) 16:49, 15 January 2014 (UTC)[reply]

I'll be taking a look at this nomination. C679 16:49, 15 January 2014 (UTC)[reply]

Resolved issues

[edit]
  • I have read the article and made a few minor changes. Here are my initial findings:
  • " In 64 games, Anderson recorded 62 goals, 69 assists, and 131 points, good enough for third place in the goal scoring race, and eight in the point scoring race.[7]" why not "…131 points, the third most goals and eighth most points on the team"?
  • Done
  • "he was nominated to the Second All-Star Team." is this the league's team?
  • Yes, I clarified it.
  • "In 1978–79, Anderson and Ken were recruited to play in the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) for the University of Denver by their head coach, Marshall Johnston. He played in 41 games, and led the team in points with 55." whose head coach? Who played in 41 games? Who is Ken? Use surname.
  • Done
  • "Making his professional debut with the Oilers, Anderson recorded 30 goals, 23 assists, and 53 points in 58 games." in his first season?
  • Done
  • "During the playoff run, Anderson scored 12 points in nine games, establishing himself as a "clutch" playoff performer, which means Anderson had a knack for scoring timely goals.[3]" ref only supports the points total, not the rest.
  • Changed it to "fierce" to match the reference.
  • "In 1982–83, Anderson helped the Oilers remain as division champions." prose
  • Hopefully fixed
  • "After being held scoreless in the previous rounds, Anderson scored his only three goals in the Finals, two of them being game-winners." only three playoff goals?
Yes, I clarified it.
  • "After playing part of the next season with Augsburger and the National Team again, Anderson signed with the Canucks due to his former Oiler teammate and friend Esa Tikkanen already playing there." ref*
  • All located in ref 44. I deleted the friend part though as it does not mention friend anywhere.
  • Stats listed do not perfectly correlate with the reference
  • Done

That's all for now. C679 20:46, 16 January 2014 (UTC)[reply]

Unresolved issues

[edit]
  • "Anderson, and Ken, one of the Berry brothers, began their junior hockey career with the Bellingham Blazers of the British Columbia Junior Hockey League (BCJHL) in 1977–78" the season or simply 1977?
  • LOH stated the 1977–78 season.
  • Done
  • "He also played one game with the New Westminster Bruins of the Western Canada Hockey League (WCHL)." this is a fragment really. how is it connected with the rest of the paragraph?
  • I removed it seeing as it does not add much to the article.
  • "Along with his friend Ken, they joined the National Team which was managed by Father David Bauer.[9]" prose
  • Changed it to "He and Berry joined the National Team. Father David Bauer was in charge of the team and Anderson would later cite him as a major reason to his future success."
  • "He also played in seven games in the same season with the Seattle Breakers of the Western Hockey League (WHL), which had previously been known as the WCHL." similar to the last paragraph, the final sentence appears to be an afterthought and it should be better integrated into the paragraph.
  • I removed it seeing as it does not add much to the article.
  • "In 1980–81, the Canadian National Team program was not continued.[11]" The reference doesn't support the sentence
  • Changed reference.
  • Fixed
  • "Anderson set a career high in assists with 16 during the playoff run." ref
  • Is a reference really needed? One can just go to the stats table and check. The stats table also contains the reference.
  • That's what I am asking for. Use the same reference if you will, but otherwise there is just unlimited stats with no clear way for the reader to see where they are from. C679 20:58, 17 January 2014 (UTC)[reply]
  • Went back and added references to every single stat mention.
  • "This was the second time Anderson had reached the 50 goal plateau in his career and the third time he had reached the 100 point plateau." ref
  • Went back and added references to every single stat mention.
  • "He was also selected to play in his third consecutive All-Star Game." ref
  • Went back and added references to every single award mention.
  • "Anderson scored 88 points during the season, and he was selected to play in the All-Star Game." ref
  • Went back and added references to every single stat mention.
  • "With the Oilers, eliminated early on in the playoffs, it gave Anderson the option to play for Team Canada in the World Championships in Sweden." prose
  • Changed to "After being eliminated from the playoffs, Anderson played for Team Canada at the World Championships in Sweden"
  • "He got a contract of $400,000 but never played with the Canucks, as upon signing as a free agent in January, he had to clear re-entry waivers, and his former team, the Oilers, claimed him." prose
  • Changed to "Anderson signed with the Canucks as a free agent for the reported sum of 400 000$. His reasons for joining the team were because of former Oiler teammate Esa Tikkanen already playing there, and a desire to finish his career in his hometown. However, Anderson never played for the Canucks as the Oilers picked him up on re-entry waivers. Anderson expressed his disappointment at these turn of events, as he wanted to play in Vancouver instead."
  • Done
  • Sorry, I got mistaken between the 400,000$ in the Oilers section and the late career. Fixed now.
  • "He negotiated a clause with his then current team, the Toronto Maple Leafs, which would allow him to participate. But the league had to approve first, and there was a policy that only players with less than one year of NHL experience could join." prose
  • Changed to "He negotiated a clause with his then current team, the Toronto Maple Leafs, to grant him the right to play for Team Canada. Anderson also had to grant approval from the league but he was turned down. The league had instituted a policy that only players with less than one year of NHL experience could join. The league's decision caused an outrage in Canada."
  • Hopefully fixed.
  • "He was accused of owing the mom more than $125,000 in child support." prose
  • Changed to "He was accused of reneging on his payments to the mother"
  • Hopefully fixed.
  • "He currently lives in New York with his wife Susan, a real estate broker, and daughter Autumn." ref. "currently" is dated, try to reword as well
  • Changed to "He resides in Manhattan with his wife Susan, and daughter Autumn."
  • "He runs a fantasy camp, plays in charity and oldtimers games, and owns a hockey school in Connecticut.[3]" what is a fantasy camp?
  • Specified
  • "He started up Glenn Anderson's Cell-City, a company specializing in car phones, and has partnered up with four other businessmen on a deal that would supply water to an island in the north of the Bahamas.[31]" the details of this "deal" are not really noteworthy. Is there a better reference (that it actually happened)?
  • I tried to find a better reference but I was unable to find any. Seems like this is the only reference that has a mention of this deal.
If no better reference exists, you should delete the text. C679 20:00, 18 January 2014 (UTC)[reply]
  • Removed.
  • One additional point: "Noted as a "clutch" player, he was able to score key goals when the team most needed them. He scored five playoff overtime goals, third to Joe Sakic's eight and Maurice Richard's six. His 17 playoff game-winning goals are fifth all-time in NHL history.[3]" - the statement is not supported, the citation specifically denotes "at the time of his retirement", which should be worked into the sentence here. Further, the initial sentence about being a clutch player should be referenced or deleted.
  • Added reference. Changed the term clutch to money.
The lead still says clutch, reword or remove. C679 20:00, 18 January 2014 (UTC)[reply]
  • Fixed

The article isn't bad, but the prose has to be improved. Therefore I am placing the article on hold while the proposed changes are made . C679 20:58, 17 January 2014 (UTC)[reply]

  • Went back and checked and NHL.com has him listed as 6'1 and 190lbs, while hockeyDB has him listed as 5'11 and 175lbs. Which one should I use?
  • I went and checked a couple of GA about ice hockey biographies, and they all used the hockeydb height and weight instead of the NHL.com ones. I'm reverting it back to the previous ones.
  • Two more things:
  • "The issue has since been resolved" - wording is too close to the original
  • Hopefully fixed.
  • "This was not enough as Anderson also had to grant approval from the league." still doesn't make sense. Use "grant approval" properly. Almost finished here. C679 08:36, 19 January 2014 (UTC)[reply]
  • I changed grant approval to "obtain permission".
Good Article review progress box
Criteria: 1a. prose () 1b. MoS () 2a. ref layout () 2b. cites WP:RS () 2c. no WP:OR () 2d. no WP:CV ()
3a. broadness () 3b. focus () 4. neutral () 5. stable () 6a. free or tagged images () 6b. pics relevant ()
Note: this represents where the article stands relative to the Good Article criteria. Criteria marked are unassessed

I am closing the review, the article has passed and is now the holder of GA status. Well done. C679 20:16, 19 January 2014 (UTC)[reply]

Thank you for taking your time to do the review! Have a nice day. Heroman26 (talk) 20:18, 19 January 2014 (UTC)[reply]

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Glenn_Anderson/GA1&oldid=1144170848"