Talk:Midnight Train (album)/GA1
GA Review
[edit]The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.
| GA toolbox |
|---|
| Reviewing |
Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
Nominator: Versace1608 (talk · contribs) 14:17, 12 April 2024 (UTC)
Reviewer: Cambalachero (talk · contribs) 17:46, 23 July 2024 (UTC)
- Images
- File:Sauti Sol - Midnight Train album cover.jpg
(non-free image, with rationale)
Done
- Infobox and lead
- The image has no caption
- Done
- "...who commended Sauti Sol for pushing the envelope..." try to avoid idioms and use phrases with no double-meanings.
- Done. Reworded sentence in the lede
- Background and recording
- Replace generic link with COVID-19 pandemic in Kenya
- Done. Included a pipe link in the article
- "Otieno told OkayAfrica that their personal experiences and what they go through as men and husbands inspired the album's music" Written just after the mention of COVID suggests that he's talking about their personal experiences with it, when in the reference it's about their personal experiences in general.
- I'm not sure how you were able to tie COVID to this particular sentence when it isn't about the virus. The sentence related to COVID is completely separate from this particular sentence.
- "...the second version was made available at some point in 2020" sounds way too imprecise
- Done. Simplified it to just 2020
- Promotion
- Seems fine
- Music and lyrics
- "Recorded in English, Swahili, and Luhya, Midnight Train explores..." Hit the brakes. How do you record a song in three languages? Does it jump from one language to the other, or does it have three distinct versions?
- "The percussive track "Wake Up" evokes the need to dance" People does not "need" to dance. Perhaps it's the "desire" to dance?
- Done. Replaced the word "need" with "desire".
- Singles
- Why does the Kenya Film Classification Board rate songs? Isn't it for films?
- Critical reception
- Seems fine
- Personnel
- I'm not sure if Spotify can count as a source. What about music databases like Allmusic?
Those are the issues I have noticed so far. Cambalachero (talk) 17:46, 23 July 2024 (UTC)
- Hi Camblachero, thanks for reviewing the article. I am going to address some of your concerns here. With regards to the Personnel section, the credits listed on Spotify are consistent with the credits on All Music. There is no valid reason why it cannot be used. With regards to the Singles section, the source cited in the article did not state that KFCB rated the song. It only states that KFCB investigated the claim about the song promoting incest and concluded that it doesn't. This info is vital to the article and should not be removed. With regards to the Music and lyrics section, Midnight Train (the album) was recorded in English, Swahili, and Luhya per this source. I don't know how you deduced that I was referring to the title track. To answer your question, a song can be recorded in multiple languages. There are tons of bilingual and multilingual songs out there. Even on Midnight Train, the tracks "Feel My Love" and "Brighter Days" are bilingual songs. Versace1608 Wanna Talk? 15:22, 24 July 2024 (UTC)
- The problem with Spotify is that it is the artists themselves who edit their own artist page on Spotify, so it would count as a self-published source. Cambalachero (talk) 16:33, 25 July 2024 (UTC)
- @Cambalachero: I disagree with you about Spotify. Per this source, the credits on Spotify are taken from the metadata info published by the record label. Do you have a reliable source to support the statement you made about artists editing their own page on Spotify? I have addressed all of your concerns related to this GAN and like I said earlier, there is nothing wrong with using Spotify as a source in regards to the album credits. Versace1608 Wanna Talk? 19:07, 27 July 2024 (UTC)
- Very well, let's say we accepted Spotify as a valid source. Where exactly, does it say what the reference implies it says? I can see the cover, album name, number of songs and total time, each song that I can click and listen, other albums, user interface options... and that's it. Yes, surely Sauti Sol worked on performing and production, Bienaimé Baraza as writer, and so on... but where does Spotify say any of that? Cambalachero (talk) 05:02, 28 July 2024 (UTC)
- The credits on Spotify can be seen by clicking on the three dots to the right of each song. A pop-up screen will appear when you click on the three dots. From the pop-up screen, you will scrow down until you see "View credits". Once you clicked on it, another pop-up screen will appear; there, you will see the performance, writing, production, and source credits for each song. Hope that answers your question. Click on this link and follow the instructions stated above, and you will see the credits. I'm glad you conceded to the point I raised since you could not provide me with a reliable source to support your statement about artists having the ability to edit their own pages on Spotify. Versace1608 Wanna Talk? 21:01, 28 July 2024 (UTC)
- Artists can edit things on their Spotify pages, there's a whole official page for that. I still thnk it' not a valid source, but I'm willing to let a third user decide. I will place the article on second opinion. Cambalachero (talk) 02:31, 31 July 2024 (UTC)
- I'm not sure why you're choosing to delay this GA review. The track list credits for this particular album were provided by the record label per the info on Spotify. It was not provided by "artists who edit their own Spotify pages". There is no evidence that Sauti Sol were the ones who added the credits to Spotify. When I get to a computer, I am going to change the reference from Spotify to AllMusic. I previously pointed out that the credits on AllMusic are exactly the same as this one. There's only a minor difference in the wording. For instance, featured acts are considered "primary artist" and/or "performers", whereas writers are considered "composers".
- You seem overly concerned about album credits like they are some sort of yardstick for GA. I'm sure I can find albums (lacking track list credits) that have passed the good article criteria. The notion that primary sources cannot be used in Wikipedia is completely false. Wikipedia doesn't forbid the use of primary sources; it favors secondary sources for notability purposes. Album credits do not determine the notability of an album. Notability is determined by the album being discussed in reliable sources. Versace1608 Wanna Talk? 23:43, 31 July 2024 (UTC)
- Update: @Cambalachero: I have updated the credits section and added the AllMusic source. The album credits are good to go. If you do not have any other objections, I think you should close this GA and promote the article. Versace1608 Wanna Talk? 15:38, 3 August 2024 (UTC)
- Artists can edit things on their Spotify pages, there's a whole official page for that. I still thnk it' not a valid source, but I'm willing to let a third user decide. I will place the article on second opinion. Cambalachero (talk) 02:31, 31 July 2024 (UTC)
- The credits on Spotify can be seen by clicking on the three dots to the right of each song. A pop-up screen will appear when you click on the three dots. From the pop-up screen, you will scrow down until you see "View credits". Once you clicked on it, another pop-up screen will appear; there, you will see the performance, writing, production, and source credits for each song. Hope that answers your question. Click on this link and follow the instructions stated above, and you will see the credits. I'm glad you conceded to the point I raised since you could not provide me with a reliable source to support your statement about artists having the ability to edit their own pages on Spotify. Versace1608 Wanna Talk? 21:01, 28 July 2024 (UTC)
- Very well, let's say we accepted Spotify as a valid source. Where exactly, does it say what the reference implies it says? I can see the cover, album name, number of songs and total time, each song that I can click and listen, other albums, user interface options... and that's it. Yes, surely Sauti Sol worked on performing and production, Bienaimé Baraza as writer, and so on... but where does Spotify say any of that? Cambalachero (talk) 05:02, 28 July 2024 (UTC)
- @Cambalachero: I disagree with you about Spotify. Per this source, the credits on Spotify are taken from the metadata info published by the record label. Do you have a reliable source to support the statement you made about artists editing their own page on Spotify? I have addressed all of your concerns related to this GAN and like I said earlier, there is nothing wrong with using Spotify as a source in regards to the album credits. Versace1608 Wanna Talk? 19:07, 27 July 2024 (UTC)
- The problem with Spotify is that it is the artists themselves who edit their own artist page on Spotify, so it would count as a self-published source. Cambalachero (talk) 16:33, 25 July 2024 (UTC)
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.