Talk:Makonnen Wolde Mikael

This article is within the scope of WikiProject Biography, a collaborative effort to create, develop and organize Wikipedia's articles about people. All interested editors are invited to join the project and contribute to the discussion. For instructions on how to use this banner, please refer to the documentation.BiographyWikipedia:WikiProject BiographyTemplate:WikiProject Biographybiography articles

Ethiopia Mid‑importance

	This article is within the scope of WikiProject Ethiopia, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of Ethiopia on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.EthiopiaWikipedia:WikiProject EthiopiaTemplate:WikiProject EthiopiaEthiopia articles
Mid	This article has been rated as Mid-importance on the project's importance scale.

S

Vh TaBig's (talk) 02:02, 26 May 2020 (UTC)[reply]

unsubstantiated & falsification of history perpetuated on this page.

User talk:Drt1245 & User talk:Vif12vf

Stop edit warring on this page, you both are adding the name Gudessa & the place Sheno to this individual, without any sources to back it up. You will be called out for falsyfing history. You are making threats against me for calling you edit terrorist out. Substantiate your claims if you can. You want a inline citation from the Biography?

I will ask the assistance of experienced Wikipedia users, you will not get away with this. 2A02:A466:1107:1:8561:3D64:FBBE:D5BD (talk) 04:38, 16 March 2021 (UTC)[reply]

Which source

@User talk:2A02:6680:113B:11A4:458:FF36:DBA1:193F citing sources starts with putting the source book/journal etc between >> ^[1] even better if you use a Template:Cite book and add the ISBN and other information. Refrain from making anymore edits on this article, you could be blocked if you are reported.

What is the name of the source/book that you got info from about the Battle of Adwa? Dawit S Gondaria (talk) 00:45, 30 January 2022 (UTC)[reply]

References

^ source+page

Ancestry Discussion

I'm opening this section, since there's frequent edit warring about the paternal ancestry of Ras Makonnen Wolde Mikael. I'll be adding more sources here later, some of which were discussed at Talk:Haile Selassie some months ago, and were also included in this article. Dawit S Gondaria (talk) 18:29, 16 October 2022 (UTC)[reply]

I'm coming to this dispute late, but I am the person responsible for a lot of content about Ethiopia. And I want to make the following points:

One editor criticized Paul Henze as a source. I am responsible for citing him in a number of articles, & while I don't think he is the best source, because he worked for USAID in Ethiopia for some years he's not an entirely unreliable source. For factual details (e.g., X happened at Y date), I trust him completely; but as for his opinions & interpretations, I'll admit I don't always agree with him. (When in doubt, I'd rather go with the opinions of other experts such as Sven Rubenson or Dr. Bahri Zewde. To be honest, I'd rather cite the opinions of Ethiopians about their own country when it is possible.) And Henze's book, Layers of Time (2000), has an excellent bibliography for the time that provides any beginner a place to start research.
Ras Makonnen is a notable enough figure that it should not be hard to find reliable sources to identify his ancestors -- at least to determine whether his paternal grandmother's ethnicity.
It shouldn't be a surprise if a given Amhara or Tigrayan individual has an Oromo ancestor; Oromo individuals could be found throughout the historic Abyssinian region after 1600, as could Guragean & others. Marriages are made for political reasons as often as for love in every culture.
The only information I've been able to find about Haile Selassie's mother Yishimabet is Harold Marcus' comment that she was the "daughter of an obscure, petty nobleman from Wolo" (Haile Selassie I: The formative years, 1892–1936 [1996], p. 3) Anyone know the details of her ancestry? In his autobiography Haile Selassie provides almost no details about her, which is not surprising because she died when he was 2 years old.
Another issue which I learned years ago but have not included in the relevant articles, because I didn't want to fight about it when there was so much work needing to be done on Ethiopia-related articles, is that there is some doubt about if the rulers of Shewa were actually related to the Solomonic dynasty. One early explorer to the Horn of Africa -- Henry Salt -- fails to mention this relationship, although when Menelik II assumed the throne it was assumed to be proven fact.
I say that because genealogy is often politics: all royal genealogies -- regardless of the country -- tend to have dubious connections, created to emphasize the royal's claims to the throne. My fellow editors may accuse me of racism or condescension about this country -- which is not the case. I am simply trying to present the truth as best as I can, with as much respect as I can, & I admit some times I fail at this. -- llywrch (talk) 01:07, 17 October 2022 (UTC)[reply]

Saw your input way too late, great points made. I'll add my two cents later. Dawit S Gondaria (talk) 21:34, 23 October 2022 (UTC)[reply]

I'll like to add one thing though, for all the speculation and claims foreigners made about Makonnen's ethnicity, they always tend to leave out the language the said individual spoke. There's no credible historical evidence that Makonnen Wolde Mikael spoke Oromo or Tigrinya languages ever, no sources to support that. Ethnicity is a fluid matter in Ethiopia, but language is a key factor. I can find a dozen sources Makonnen spoke Amharic. Dawit S Gondaria (talk) 21:34, 23 October 2022 (UTC)[reply]

Sources

Quote: Haile Selassie's direct male line originated from the Amhara people. But he also had Oromo, Tigray and Gurage roots.^[1]

Quote: His father, Ras Makonnen Welde Michael, claimed a link to the Amhara royal line through his paternal grandmother. [...] Tafari primarily identified himself with his father's Amhara roots because it was politically expendient to do so.^[2]

Quote: it fell - and , Ras Makonnen Harar when he entered it is the very first ( to ) Harar who came Christian tribe - indeed the Amhara.^[3]

Quote: "Makonnen's father, Wolde Mikael, was a nobleman from eastern Tigray. Haile Selassie's ancestry thus included Tigrayan, Oromo and Amhara antecedents, the three principal ethnic strains of Ethiopia, and Muslims as well as Christians, the two principal religions."^[4]

Quote: "To take one striking example: Emperor Haile Selassie's father's father was Oromo; his father's mother was Amhara: his mother's father was Oromo, and his mother's mother was Gurage. In a patrilineal society he would have been classed as Oromo, in a matrilineal one as Gurage; but to all intents and purposes he was Amhara, and it was his descent from his father's mother, a member of the Shoan royal house, that provided the genealogical basis for his claim to the Imperial throne."^[5]

References

^ Bridgette, Kasuka (2012). Prominent African Leaders Since Independence. p. 19. ISBN 9781470043582.
^ McVety, Amanda Kay (2015). Enlightened Aid: U. S. Development As Foreign Policy in Ethiopia. Oxford University Press. p. 62. ISBN 9780190257781.
^ Leslau, Wolf (1965). "Ethiopians Speak: Studies in Cultural Background". University of California Press. 1: 69.
^ Henze, Paul B (2001). Layers of time a history of Ethiopia. New York: Palgrave. p. 189.
^ Woodward, Peter (1994), Conflict and Peace in the Horn of Africa: federalism and its alternatives. Dartmouth Pub. Co. ISBN 1-85521486-5, p. 29.

Recent changes

@Socialwave597, the quote on Borelli is inaccurate, Makonnen ignored pillaging by his troops thats what Borelli states, he didnt "fear rebellion". This is corroborated by the source of Norman which you removed, it states Makonnen actively provoked a rebellion to provide an excuse to take over civil power" [1]. The statement by Charles Michel is not relevant to the page, who are Abyssinian chiefs he is talking about? The article should be about Ras Makonnen himself not others, the citation should be discussing him alone. The massacre committed by Makonnen is a major event in Harar hence the points I mention here shouldnt be removed. Make a draft about the wording concerns. When you add new content, do not remove citations and other content in the article. Magherbin (talk) 19:16, 18 December 2023 (UTC)[reply]

I will send you a draft later tomorrow. Socialwave597 (talk) 19:41, 18 December 2023 (UTC)[reply]

@Magherbin where in the source does it say that the residents where massacred? The only thing I could find about a massacre in Harar was in 1916 when Balcha Safo massacred the Somali residents of the town for their support of Lij Iyasu. Socialwave597 (talk) 20:34, 19 December 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Its in the book I own titled "Leadership in Eastern Africa Six Political Biographies", on p.29 following his suspected provocation for Hararis to revolt, they did which then "Makonnen marched into town with his troops, cowed the population, and imprisoned the civil governor, who was sent in chains to Menilek. Once in the town, the troops went wild, demolished and looted homes, tyrannized the population, and killed several people" [2]. Magherbin (talk) 21:24, 19 December 2023 (UTC)[reply]

[1] source+page

[2] Bridgette, Kasuka (2012). Prominent African Leaders Since Independence. p. 19. ISBN 9781470043582.

[3] McVety, Amanda Kay (2015). Enlightened Aid: U. S. Development As Foreign Policy in Ethiopia. Oxford University Press. p. 62. ISBN 9780190257781.

[4] Leslau, Wolf (1965). "Ethiopians Speak: Studies in Cultural Background". University of California Press. 1: 69.

[5] Henze, Paul B (2001). Layers of time a history of Ethiopia. New York: Palgrave. p. 189.

[Woodward-6] Woodward, Peter (1994), Conflict and Peace in the Horn of Africa: federalism and its alternatives. Dartmouth Pub. Co. ISBN 1-85521486-5, p. 29.

[1]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]