Talk:Sin Rumbo

Article to redirect

@Richhoncho: I understand (and agree with) your rationale but... what criteria are you using to pinpoint to Entrañas and not Arca (album)? First appearance? Then I could argue that most people know this song for being part of the latter's tracklist... It's so ambiguous to choose one, that's why I think it should redirect to a more general article. 7szz (talk) 15:15, 19 May 2022 (UTC)[reply]

tbf I didn't know it was on more than one album, but as Entrañas predates Arca, then I would suggest Entrañas is the correct target (as per discography entry too). I am not sure there is any benefit to readers to create redirects, certainly not unnecesary redirects. The search engine at WP is pretty good. I also thought Spanish language songs weren't capitalised... Perhaps you would care to add WPSongs to the talk pages and save me the work of adding it to songs (not unnecessary redirects etc). Cheers. --Richhoncho (talk) 15:57, 19 May 2022 (UTC)[reply]

@Richhoncho:

1) Yes, it appears on two albums, that's why I asked you to read my previous edit summary. And yes, it was released as a single for Entrañas, but I can argue that most people know it for Arca, so I don't think Entrañas is a good target.

2) In my opinion, redirects are useful and current unnecessary redirects, too; I create the latter to avoid these things.

3) Spanish-language song titles use sentence case, that's true, but this is enwiki and they can adapt to English-language rules (title case). At least that's what happens with English-language song titles on eswiki. I am not aware of any rule here on enwiki regarding this, are you?

4) I will add WPSongs, thanks for your help. 7szz (talk) 18:22, 19 May 2022 (UTC)[reply]