Template talk:UKRDA

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Romsey Town Rollerbillies[edit]

Wikipedia:Article Incubator/Romsey Town Rollerbillies now has seventeen sources, a logo, several ELs, and clearly passes Wikipedia:Notability (sports)#Basic criteria requirements for multiple published, non-trivial, reliable, intellectually and otherwise independent secondary sources, and is pending a move back to userspace by any editor who has not yet edited it per WP:GRADUATION. Dualus (talk) 15:03, 27 October 2011 (UTC)

Missing one link?[edit]

Since the Romsey Town Rollerbillies article was deleted, its link has been deleted from this template - perfectly sensible. Unfortunately, some editors have wanted to remove any mention of it from the article, citing an essay as justification. This might make sense if there were numerous topics in this group without articles, but to miss out just one seems excessively confusing - any reasonable observer would assume that all the members are listed, not all but one. Warofdreams talk 18:15, 4 November 2011 (UTC)

If you want a policy here's WP:NAVBOX: 'Navigation templates—sometimes called "navboxes"—are boxes containing links to a group of related articles' . As such a navbox with a list of links does not indicate the links are all the members: a navbox lists all the articles of a class (even if that class is very poorly defined), not all the members based on some other criterium. To list all UKRDA members do it in an article: then it can be made clear what the list is, it can be properly sourced, it can be updated without filling the template with red links or further unlinked text, etc.--JohnBlackburnewordsdeeds 19:03, 4 November 2011 (UTC)