University of Southern California athletics scandal
In the University of Southern California athletics scandal, the University of Southern California was investigated and punished for NCAA rules violations in the Trojan football, men's basketball and women's tennis programs.
Probes by both USC and the NCAA found that football star Reggie Bush, the 2005 Heisman Trophy winner, and basketball star O. J. Mayo had effectively forfeited their amateur status (in Mayo's case, before he ever played a game for USC) by accepting gifts from agents. In addition, the women's tennis team was cited in the report for unauthorized phone calls made by a former player. As a result of the ongoing investigation, which progressed well into the 2010-11 seasons for both USC and Reggie Bush's New Orleans Saints, Bush voluntarily gave up his 2005 Heisman Trophy, which the Heisman Trust decided to leave vacant.
As a result of sanctions issued by both USC and the NCAA, the Trojan athletic program received some of the harshest penalties ever meted out to a Division 1 program. The football team was forced to vacate the final two wins of its 2004 national championship season, as well as all of its wins in 2005. It was also banned from bowl games in both 2010 and 2011 and was docked 30 scholarships over three years. The basketball team gave up all of its wins from the 2007-08 season and sat out postseason play in 2010. The NCAA accepted USC's earlier elimination of its wins between November 2006 and May 2009 and did not sanction the team further.
Shortly after the NCAA handed out its penalties, the Football Writers Association of America announced it would no longer recognize the Trojans as its 2004 national champion. In June 2011, the Bowl Championship Series stripped the Trojans of the 2004 BCS title (leaving Ohio State as the only non-Southern school with a BCS title), though the Associated Press still recognizes the Trojans as its national champions for 2004.
Bush is the first person in the Heisman Trophy's history to give his trophy back to the Heisman Trust, and the 2005 season is the only one in the award's history for which there is no winner.
Criticism of sanctions
These sanctions have been criticized by some NCAA football writers, including ESPN’s Ted Miller, who wrote, “It's become an accepted fact among informed college football observers that the NCAA sanctions against USC were a travesty of justice, and the NCAA’s refusal to revisit that travesty are a massive act of cowardice on the part of the organization.”
ESPN's Ted Miller also suggested that the sanctions had more to do with objections to the football culture at USC than its alleged noncompliance with NCAA rules:
During a flight delay last year, I was cornered at an airport by an administrator from a major program outside the Pac-12. He made fun of me as a "USC fanboy" because of my rants against the NCAA ruling against the Trojans. But we started talking. Turned out he agreed with just about all my points. (He just didn't like USC.)
He told me, after some small talk and off-the-record, that "everybody" thought USC got screwed. He said that he thought the NCAA was trying to scare everyone with the ruling, but subsequent major violations cases put it in a pickle.
Then he told me that USC was punished for its "USC-ness," that while many teams had closed down access — to media, to fans, etc. — USC under Pete Carroll was completely open, and that was widely resented. There was a widespread belief the national media fawned on USC because of this. Further, more than a few schools thought that the presence of big-time celebrities, such as Snoop Dogg and Will Ferrell, at practices and at games constituted an unfair recruiting advantage for the Trojans.
It wasn't against the rules, but everyone hated it. This, as he assessed his own smell test, was a subtext of the so-called atmosphere of noncompliance that the NCAA referred to — an atmosphere that oddly yielded very few instances of noncompliance around the football program even after a four-year NCAA investigation.
In February 2014, in a talk on the campus of USC, former coach and recent Super Bowl winner Pete Carroll said about the sanctions, "I thought (the NCAA's investigation into USC) was dealt with poorly and very irrationally and done with way too much emotion instead of facts. I sat in the meetings. I listened to the people talk. I listened to the venom that they had for our program... They tried to make it out like it was something else. They made a terrible error."
Compared to subsequent scandals
Further criticism of the sanctions came during subsequent NCAA's investigations into other programs such as Ohio State, University of Miami, and University of Oregon for recruiting violations, all of which led to substantially more lenient punishment than USC's for arguably greater offenses. This has led many people to think that the NCAA's sanctions of USC were intended to make an example out of the school to other programs that the NCAA hasn't followed through on with other college programs.
Most notable of these scandals was that against Miami, because of the involvement of Paul Dee. Dee was the Committee on Infractions chairman for USC's NCAA investigation. It was Dee who announced the USC penalties and closed with the reminder that "high-profile athletes demand high-profile compliance." Accusations later came out that, under his tenure as athletic director, Miami had also been the center of major improper benefits, specifically that of university booster Nevin Shapiro from 2002 until 2010. Writers noted the hypocrisy of Miami's more lenient punishment (loss of nine scholarships and three years) compared to USC's, despite Miami committing more serious infractions through university employees over a longer timespan. One writer even stated that, "it seems only fair [Dee] should spend a day at USC's Heritage Hall wearing a sandwich board with the word "Hypocrite."
In 2014, USC's sanctions once again became a talking point because of the Penn State child sex abuse scandal. Sanctions against Penn State, who had been hit with sanctions that included a four year bowl ban and forty lost scholarships, were significantly reduced after two years. After hearing this decision, USC petitioned the NCAA requesting similar leniency, but was denied, saying the situations weren't comparable. This incident led to further outcry over the inconsistency of punishment by the NCAA and the bias the organization seemed to have against USC.
Todd McNair lawsuit against the NCAA
Todd McNair, a running backs assistant coach at USC, sued the NCAA in June 2011, claiming that the NCAA's investigation was one-sided and his future earnings were impaired by its report on the scandal that led to sanctions against USC. The NCAA determined McNair lied about knowing about some of the gifts to Bush's family.
On November 21, 2012, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Frederick Shaller ruled that the NCAA was "malicious" in its investigation of McNair. In his ruling, the Judge stated that e-mails between an investigative committee member, an NCAA worker, and a person who works in the agency's appeals division "tend to show ill will or hatred" toward McNair. In an e-mail, one staffer called McNair "a lying morally bankrupt criminal, in my view, and a hypocrite of the highest order." Judge Shaller said he would unseal the entire inquiry into McNair in December. "I understand [why] the NCAA wants to keep this quiet," the Judge said. "But I'm not going to seal the record... I know you guys are going to appeal it but from my part.. There's no reason to seal it. I think the public has a right to know."
However, on 19 December 2012, the NCAA requested and was granted a stay of Judge Shaller's order to unseal the files, much of which contain e-mails from NCAA staff personnel and committee members to one another. As a result of the stay, files regarding the NCAA's investigation into USC remained sealed until the California Appellate Court ruled on the NCAA's appeal.
In February 2015, the California appellate court ruled that the NCAA cannot seal the estimated 400 pages of material regarding McNair's defamation lawsuit. The NCAA may petition the appellate court for a rehearing as well as take the matter to the California Supreme Court.
- NCAA hits USC with big punishments, Associated Press, June 11, 2010, accessed December 7, 2012.
- "ESPN Los Angeles: Reggie Bush gives up 2005 Heisman Trophy" <http://sports.espn.go.com/los-angeles/ncf/news/story?id=5572827>.
- "Reggie Bush gives up Heisman, Admitting "mistakes" and blames "persistent media speculation" <http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2010/09/14/reggie-bush-gives-up-heisman-blames-persistent-media-speculation-admits-mistakes/>.
- "Heisman Trust leaves 2005 award vacant" <http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2010/sep/15/heisman-trust-says-2005-award-will-remain-vacant/?page=all>.
- "USC Trojans Stripped of 2004 Grantland Rice Trophy - ESPN Los Angeles." ESPN: The Worldwide Leader In Sports. 26 Aug. 2010. Web. 31 Jan. 2011." <http://sports.espn.go.com/los-angeles/ncf/news/story?id=5500128>.
- Jay Bilas, "Anyone know what NCAA's standards are?", ESPN.com, July 1, 2010.
- Bryant Gumbel, "Student/Athlete Behavior", Real Sports with Bryant Gumbel, September 21, 2010.
- Bryan Fischer, " Trojans never stood a chance after taking NCAA's best shot", CBSSports.com, May 26, 2011.
- Pete Fiutak, "USC paying for NCAA's inconsistency?", FoxSports.com, May 26, 2011.
- Stewart Mandel, "What USC's sanctions mean for Ohio State", SportsIllustrated.com, April 27, 2011.
- Miller, Ted (December 23, 2011) "Mailbag: Ohio State fan holiday wishes." ESPN.com.
- ESPN News Services (February 27, 2014) "Pete Carroll criticizes USC sanctions." ESPN News Services. (Retrieved 2027-2014.)
- "Tattoogate (January 10,2012)", Marquette University Law School, January 10, 2011.
- "NCAA puts Oregon football on probation for recruiting violations", June 22, 2013.
- Stewart Mandel, ", LATimes.com, October 22, 2013.
- Mandel, Stewart (August 17, 2011) "Credibility of NCAA enforcement will be tested by Miami allegations."
- Robinson, Charles (2011-08-16). "Renegade Miami football booster spells out illicit benefits to players". Yahoo Sports (Yahoo). Retrieved 2011-08-17.
- Chris Fuhrmeister, ", SBnation.com, September 13, 2013.
- Alicia de Artola, ", ReignofTroy.com, September 6, 2014.
- Editors (November 21, 2012) "USC investigation: Judge calls NCAA report on Todd McNair 'malicious'." Sporting News. (Retrieved 12-6-12.)
- Sports XChange (November 28, 2012) "Report: Three violated NCAA ethics code in USC appeal." Yahoo Sports. (Retrieved 12-6-12.)
- Weber, Dan (December 20, 2012) "McNair-NCAA file stays sealed." USCFootball.com.
- Fenno, Nathan (February 6, 2015) "Court rules NCAA can't seal Todd McNair documents." Los Angeles Times. (Retrieved 2-7-2015.)