User:Elovell9/Global Warming Hoax of 1874

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The "Global Warming Hoax of 1874" was a journalistic hoax that occurred as the result of an article submitted to the editor of the Kansas City Times of Kansas City, Missouri by L.B. Legendre.[1] and published in this major midwestern newspaper. The column, titled "A Scientific Sensation", claimed that Giovanni Donati, a 19th century astronomer, had discovered that the laying of the first transatlantic telegraph cable was causing the Earth to be pulled towards the Sun and issued a warning that in twelve years--that is, in 1886--there would be a dramatic increase in temperature, resultin a climate crisis due to global warming that would cause the extinction of all life on Earth.

Legendra's Claims[edit]

The column states that a friend of Legendre who was in Italy at the time, wrote to Legendre to inform him of the discovery made by Donati. His friend says, "Donati... had been a victim, not to disease or to time,... but to nervous excitement or fright, caused by a discovery which he had made of great and even agonizing importance to the human race".[2] Legendre says Donati had been calculating and recording the location of the Earth in orbit as well as the Earth's distance from the Sun using instruments Donati had constructed himself, but that "he was not universally credited by his scientific colleagues".[3] Through his meticulous measurements, Donati noticed a change in the distance from the Sun when the transatlantic telegraph cable was laid in 1858, and that, "every month after that... its distance was perceptibly lessened". [4] Legendre's friend said that the cable brought the Earth closer to the Sun due to a relationship between gravitation and magnetism. Donati said, "That in twelve years the climate of Europe would become tropical, if not unfit for human existence, and that in a few more years this globe... would be precipitated into the Sun."[5] After his failed attempt to receive help from the government, Donati took it upon himself to solve the issue. He brought together "several wealthy Italians... (and)... chartered a brig and expensive machinery"[6] in order to cut the transatlantic cable. Donati found that the distance had returned to normal, but shortly after the cable was repaired, causing the Earth to again move towards the Sun. Legendre says this caused Donati to fall ill, and eventually die.

Reality[edit]

While it contains some verifiable details, most of the article is a work of fiction. Giovanni Donati was a real astronomer who did die in 1873. However he did not die from the stress caused by his fear of the Earth hurtling towards the Sun but due to health complications from contracting cholera[7]. The article claims that Donati and the scientists caused the first break in the transatlantic cable[8], but this never occurred. The first break in the cable occurred in 1858 shortly after the cable was laid, but it was never cut by vandals seeking to save the Earth from destruction.[9]

Reception[edit]

The article that appeared in the Kansas City Times was reprinted in a few other newspapers shortly after it appeared, but didn't receive much traction. Hoaxes such as this were becoming more common place in the 19th century, as there was rise in media and journalistic hoaxes.[10] Some newspapers even made jokes about Donati's death and the cause of it. The Northern Ohio Journal ran a column on L.B. Legendre's article titled, "A Cheerful Bit of News", that read "This will be discouraging news to the insurance companies" and "Such a disaster is about the only thing that could beat the Chicago fire".[11]

Similar Hoaxes[edit]

The Global Warming Hoax of 1874 was a journalistic/media hoax, which is when a fictitous story is purposefully written and published so as to appear as if it were real and factual when it is not.[12]. In the 19th century, hoaxes appeared often in newspapers and magazines. However, they can now be found in any type of media. Some examples of other journalistic/media hoaxes around the same time are:

More recent journalistic hoaxes would include:

External Links[edit]

Notes[edit]

  1. ^ Legendre 1874, p. 1
  2. ^ Legendre 1874, ln. 6-21
  3. ^ Legendre 1874, ln. 32-34
  4. ^ Legendre 1874, ln. 42-44
  5. ^ Legendre 1874, ln. 57-63
  6. ^ Legendre 1874, ln. 79-82
  7. ^ Hetherington 1973, p. 462.
  8. ^ Legendre 1874, ln. 84-85
  9. ^ Schwartz 2008, p. 46.
  10. ^ Young 2017, p. 7
  11. ^ "A Cheerful Bit of News" 1874, p. 4
  12. ^ Patrick 2005

References[edit]

  • “A Cheerful Bit of News.” Nothern Ohio Journal, 18 Apr. 1874, pp. 4–4, Accessed 29 Apr. 2022.
  • Hetherington, B. "Giovanni Battista Donati, 1826-1873." Journal of the British Astronomical Association 83 (1973): 461-462.
  • Legendre, L. B. “The Scientific Sensation.” The Wichita City Eagle, 12 Feb. 1874. Chronicling America, Accessed 28 Apr. 2022.
  • Patrick Boyle. “Hoaxes: How They Work.” The Hoax Project, Philip Merrill College of Journalism, University of Maryland, College Park, 2005, https://www.jclass.umd.edu
  • Schwartz, Mischa, and Jeremiah Hayes. "A history of transatlantic cables." IEEE Communications Magazine 46.9 (2008): 42-48.
  • Young, Kevin. Bunk: The rise of hoaxes, humbug, plagiarists, phonies, post-facts, and fake news. Graywolf Press, 2017.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Elovell9/Global_Warming_Hoax_of_1874&oldid=1086534084"