Wikipedia:Peer review/Fly to the Sky/archive2
Fly to the Sky[edit]
- Previous Peer Review:Wikipedia:Peer review/Fly to the Sky/archive1
I already listed the article for peer review, but received no comments. Eventually, however, Fly to the Sky did manage to climb to GA status, but now I want to make it FA. Please point out any flaws!! mirageinred 07:25, 5 November 2006 (UTC)
- Overall, this seemed like a well written article. There were two things that concerned me, however. Throughout the article, there are times when the wording just seems odd in English. I realize the primary editors for this article probably are not native English speakers. You might want to find someone who is to run through and edit some of these areas. Also, there are times throughout the article where you reference a song, and give only the Korean name. Consider putting the English title of the song as well. For example "However, it did not hurt the duo as the album collected decent sales and made their single 가슴 아파도 (English title here), the theme song of the show, an unexpected hit." -- Pepsi2786 07:37, 5 November 2006 (UTC)
- I put the English titles to the Korean songs referenced in the article. I'll try to fix the wording as much as I can. mirageinred 17:06, 5 November 2006 (UTC)
- Overall, it looks great and I think it's about ready for a FAC. If you haven't already, check out the guidelines at WP:MUSTARD.
- Albums should be italicized, song titles should not
- Song titles should be in quotes, album titles should not
- If something is in a foreign language or is given as a translation of a foreign language, it should be italicized (even if it's a song title)
- Don't use album covers in the discography section
- Fair use images need more info on their image pages. See this page for more.
- Use {{Template:Cite web}} for references
- That's all I see at the moment.