Jump to content

Wikipedia:Picture peer review/9/11 Victim Montage

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I was moved by this image, and it's historically significant not only because of the attacks but because of its use in evidence at trial. That's all I have to say; if others more familiar with featured-picture selection agree that this should be featured, let them proceed with it. There are two versions; I assume that if it's accepted, one of them would be chosen on technical grounds. 207.176.159.90 01:09, 31 August 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Comments:

  • I can see why this could move you and appeal to you. Unfortunately when viewed at smaller sizes (for example as it would be displayed on the Wikipedia mainpage) it probably looks more like a piece of carpet than anything else. The fact that it's so unappealing at the smaller sizes would personally put me off, but others may disagree. There also seem to be some technical issues such as not being straight (look at the inconsistent borders on the image). The second version appears to be blurry, or at least very unsharp. Thanks for pointing it out though. --jjron 09:09, 31 August 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Seconder: