Jump to content

Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation/October 2013 Backlog Elimination Drive/Pratyya Ghosh

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

< Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation | October 2013 Backlog Elimination Drive

(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/The Real Stella From Winx Club's Information And Facebook Profile
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Rightware
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Tradekompass.com
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/greatdeas4us world gpt forum
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Chirag Walia
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Michael DiNardo
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Zrínyi Ilona Grammar School
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/microhard software solutions
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/The Elephant Journal
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Holiday Inn Presidential Hotel
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/iSpeak Reviews
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/CybrSys
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Charlton Rovers AFC
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Marisa Micallef
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Recruitment in Africa
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/NURSEN BERIK WORST TEA IN HISTORY
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Pipe Freezing
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/www.thecelebully.com
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Bush Hawg
(Declined) User:Nicestuff2003/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/fundamental rights and duties
(Declined) User:Newcontent/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/XHMVS-FM
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Buymore Limited
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Shoppe N Smile
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Totalview
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Pusateri's Fine Foods
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Quaryl
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Global Watch Brokers
(Declined) User:Joystx/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Qatar Scientific Club
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Punitha Ganesan
(Accepted) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Bangladeshi Cyclists
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/KEC42
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Lawrence Grassi
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Bangladesh Civil Service Administration Cadre
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Dr. Horrible
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Nurazzaman Mondal
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Field Mellows
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Henry Timeyo Bichi Uteka
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Kingdom of Bahrain Guards Training School (GTS)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Deadman Records
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Canadian Golf Magazine
(Declined) Wikipedia:Articles for creation/BuzzSpice
(Declined) User:Ablaze786/sandbox
(Declined) User:Crestrideac/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Out of Screen! 3D
(Declined) User:Michael R Simms/sandbox
(Declined) User:RahulSantu/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/du Quenoy Family
(Declined) User:Burubuchems/Barreno
(Declined) User:Burrenview/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Rahashya
(Declined) User:Kazi shamim ahmed/sandbox
(Declined) User:Gustav2013/sandbox
(Declined) User:Andyprintmedia/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/SchoolWise
(Declined) User:Sss889/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Hymns of the US Armed Forces
(Declined) User:Kyawkyawmyint/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Project 99
(Declined) User:Mastercraftsmen9317/sandbox
(Declined) User:Ayo.ayoola/sandbox
(Declined) User:Umiimu/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Charlotte Biggs, Author of A Residence In France During The Years 1792-1795
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Bennett Coughlin
(Declined) User:LostEarBuds/sandbox
(Declined) User:Markkalt65/sandbox
(Declined) User:LilPatthehookking/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Real Talk with Robert Simmons
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Gerard Masselin
(Declined) User:Aaryapagadala/sandbox
(Declined) User:Siddharthyit/श्री घनश्याम तिवाड़ी
(Declined) User:Presidentmarian/sandbox
(Declined) User:Raphsade/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Mandra Punjab Pakistan
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Pain is Living
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Juspreet Singh Walia
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Australian Motor Museum, Gippsland Vehicle Collection, Maffra, Victoria
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Frequency stability
(Accepted) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Pocket Trains
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Data Consulting Group
(Declined) User:Highlander1998/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Hi-Tec Sports
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/The Aleph Institute
(Declined) User:Erimichlom/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Community Farm of Ann Arbor
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/bulging fissure sign
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Frank V. Benincaso
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Mayfest
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/CJRP TRAVEL
(Declined) User:Edu amandeep/Scrum body of knowledge
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Meehyun Chung
(Declined) User:Hiperbaric HPP/sandbox
(Declined) User:Duncan Elsey/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Ben Mattes
(Declined) User:PIYUSH PATNAIK/sandbox
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Richland Academy
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/High Fidelity Pure Audio
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/illume OS
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/MyriamF Jewelry
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/CJ CLUE
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Disco Orange
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Crossgar Police station, Northern Ireland
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Tommy Lilja
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Methods for Handling of Trapped or Injured Birds
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Ostasiatischer Verein e. V., German Asia-Pacific Business Association, OAV
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Aaron Marks
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/The origin and prevalence of the Theravada Buddhism
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Anajak Tours & Travel
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Chain Gang (1950 film)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Andreas Moritz
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Jaffer Ali (writer)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Karl Tombak
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Lauren Jauregui
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Uzeyir Khanbayov (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) User:Thom W Blair III/sandbox (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Ed Englefield (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/james bks (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/koli dance (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Bureau UK (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Charles Chansa Kanyanta (Kay Charles) (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Wikipedia:Articles for creation/NIRGAM (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Ain't nobody got time for dat (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/System integrator of Electronics Security Equipments (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Anchalika Jana Seva Anusthan (AJSA) (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Groundfeel Universe Ltd. (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Intellipaat Software Solutions Pvt Ltd (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Ben's Cat (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Centre for Contemporary Art Ujazdowski Castle (Deleted Revision)
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/trey hinchey (Deleted Revision)

Checked reviews

(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/The Real Stella From Winx Club's Information And Facebook Profile
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Rightware
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Tradekompass.com
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/greatdeas4us world gpt forum
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Chirag Walia
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Michael DiNardo
Pass - You could have used "bio" here, but "v" is still acceptable. Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Zrínyi Ilona Grammar School
Pass - Yes, Grammar Schools are notable- it is lack of independent sourcing that is the issue, not notability Rankersbo
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Ed Englefield
Fail - If claims in were credible he would be notable, but they aren't. Obvious hoax. Rankersbo
(Declined) User:Newcontent/sandbox
Pass - Could also have failed for context 78.26
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Henry Timeyo Bichi Uteka
Pass - Exactly right 78.26
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Hymns of the US Armed Forces
Fail - This is an attempt to create a template, not an article, so sources aren't applicable. Not your usual AfC. 78.26
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/The Real Stella From Winx Club's Information And Facebook Profile
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Rightware
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Tradekompass.com
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/greatdeas4us world gpt forum
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Chirag Walia
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Michael DiNardo
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Zrínyi Ilona Grammar School
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Ed Englefield
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/microhard software solutions
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/The Elephant Journal
Pass - You should have done “web” for this, but I’ll accept it anyway. :) Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Holiday Inn Presidential Hotel
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/iSpeak Reviews
Pass - npov is ok, but I would have gone with “web” here. Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/CybrSys
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Charlton Rovers AFC
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Marisa Micallef
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Recruitment in Africa
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/NURSEN BERIK WORST TEA IN HISTORY
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Pipe Freezing
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) User:Siddharthyit/श्री घनश्याम तिवाड़ी
Pass - Funny, my phone displays the entire article as a bunch of grey squares. Sending them to the Hindi wiki was a good idea. Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Chirag Walia
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Michael DiNardo
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Andreas Moritz
Pass - Absolutely it was blank. No question. Rankersbo
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Karl Tombak
Fail - True, there are no sources, but should be declined as bio because notability not shown. Rankersbo
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Lauren Jauregui
Fail - True, there are no sources, but should be declined as music because notability not shown. Rankersbo
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Charlotte Biggs, Author of A Residence In France During The Years 1792-1795
Pass - Improperly referenced. Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Bennett Coughlin
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) User:LostEarBuds/sandbox
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) User:Markkalt65/sandbox
Pass - Er... a bit of a weird submission. Numbermaniac
(Declined) User:LilPatthehookking/sandbox
Pass - Numbermaniac
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Gerard Masselin
Pass - Agree. Notability not verified. Anne Delong
(Declined) User:Aaryapagadala/sandbox
Pass - Agree. Non-notable. Anne Delong
(Declined) User:Siddharthyit/श्री घनश्याम तिवाड़ी
Pass - I agree. Not English. Anne Delong
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/System integrator of Electronics Security Equipments
Fail - Missed copyvio Anne Delong

Fail - Support Anne Rankersbo
(Declined) User:Presidentmarian/sandbox
Pass - Yes. - test Anne Delong
(Declined) User:Raphsade/sandbox
Fail - These are quotes from the bible; suitability is the issue rather than notability. Decline with "What Wikipedia is not" and cite WP:NOTREPOSITORY. Anne Delong
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Mandra Punjab Pakistan
Fail - Towns, and a few other topics, are considered "Inherently notable" (seeWP:GEOLAND. The issue here is lack of sources for verification. Anne Delong

Pass - Although a town may be inherently notable, everything needs to be verified in reliable sources first, so the decline message tells the submitter the right thing Ritchie333

Pass - Yes- towns inheritably notable, so you failed on sources rather than notability Rankersbo
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Pain is Living
Pass - Yup, looks like a typical WP:GARAGE Ritchie333
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Juspreet Singh Walia
Pass - Right. Anne Delong
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Australian Motor Museum, Gippsland Vehicle Collection, Maffra, Victoria
Pass - Reluctant pass. You should have taken time to add a note about the lack of reliable sources. Anne Delong
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Frequency stability
Fail - There is already an article, Frequency stability, in the encyclopedia. Anne Delong
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/CJRP TRAVEL
Fail - While there is some promotions here, the issue of lack of demonstrated notability is much more important. Anne Delong
(Declined) User:Edu amandeep/Scrum body of knowledge
Fail - Missed copyvio from http://www.prweb.com/releases/2013/10/prweb11177611.htm andhttp://www.scrumstudy.com/overview-of-sbok.asp Anne Delong

Fail - Support Anne Rankersbo
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/High Fidelity Pure Audio
Pass - There may be overlap between this article and Olivier Robert-Murphy Ritchie333
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/illume OS
Pass - Agreed, submission is going nowhere. Creator will probably give up, and it will be G13d. Ritchie333
(Declined) Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Chain Gang (1950 film)
Pass - Probably is notable, but IMDB is inherently unreliable and an entry in TCM is not enough. Also mostly a plot summary - article should mention production details, commercial and critical reception etc Ritchie333
Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Community Farm of Ann Arbor
Pass - Lack of references to establish notability. Aggie80
Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/bulging fissure sign
Pass - Lack of references to establish notability. Aggie80
Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Frank V. Benincaso
Pass - Lack of references to establish notability. Aggie80
Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/Mayfest
Pass - Lack of references to establish notability. Aggie80
Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/CJRP TRAVEL
Pass - Lack of references to establish notability. Aggie80
Wikipedia:Articles for creation/NIRGAM
Fail - You failed this for lack of reliable sources, which was true enough. However, there was a more serious issue: It was a copyright violation of http://nirgam-v2.googlecode.com/svn/trunk/NIRGAM_manual.pdf . I replaced the content with {{afc cleared|csd}}, it should be deleted shortly. Davidwr

Fail - Rankersbo
Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/The origin and prevalence of the Theravada Buddhism
Pass - Davidwr

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:WikiProject_Articles_for_creation/October_2013_Backlog_Elimination_Drive/Pratyya_Ghosh&oldid=579646568"