Murder of Gary Matson and Winfield Mowder
Gary Matson (1949 - July 1, 1999) and Winfield Mowder (1959 - July 1, 1999) were a gay couple from Redding, California, who were murdered by white supremacist brothers Benjamin Matthew Williams and James Tyler Williams. The Williams brothers confessed killing the couple because they were gay.
- 1 Background
- 2 The discovery
- 3 The arrests
- 4 The murders
- 5 Motive
- 6 Aftermath
- 7 See also
- 8 References
- 9 External links
Gary Matson and Winfield Mowder
Matson, 50, earned a Master of Science degree in Environmental Horticulture from UC Davis in 1984. Afterwards, he and Mowder founded Matson Horticulture and Florabundance Nursery in Redding. Matson helped found a community garden to help feed the hungry (called the Redding Farmers Market), the Carter House Natural Science Museum (for children), and the Redding Arboretum.
He was divorced from his wife, Marcia Howe, who was also responsible for the founding of Carter House Natural Science Museum, which eventually evolved into Turtle Bay Exploration Park, and with whom he had a daughter, Clea.
Mowder, 40, held a Bachelor of Science degree in Anthropology and worked part-time as an associate in Orchard Hardware Supply's Garden Department, while also attending Chico State University. He frequently spoke at local high schools, serving as a source of knowledge and support for both gay and straight teens.
Together in 1997, Matson and Mowder founded Plantstogo.com, an online nursery specializing in plants for hot climates.
The Williams brothers
The Williams brothers, who were both known by their middle names, operated a landscaping and lawn service out of their parents' home in Palo Cedro, California. Neighbors said that the family was known for their fundamentalist Christianity, and that recordings of sermons and religious music were often heard from their house.
Prior to moving to Redding, the Williams lived in Gridley, California, a farming community in Butte County, California. According to neighbors, the family kept to themselves. They grew their own food, keeping chickens and an organic garden. The Williams boys, Matthew and Tyler, were homeschooled until they reached high school. The boys, both honor students, were not allowed to participate in extracurricular activities.
When the family moved to Redding, on what the father—Benjamin Williams—told neighbors were "God's orders"—mail from militia groups, addressed to the family, continued to arrive at their home. After the move, Matthew Williams briefly served in the Navy. While stationed in Bremerton, Washington, during his stint in the Navy, Matthew met and had a daughter with Kimberly Rodgers. Rodgers, however refused to marry Williams.
Matthew attended the University of Idaho in Moscow, Idaho. While there he joined the charismatic Christian church, Living Faith Fellowship, in Pullman, Washington. He also became interested in purification diets, and during a visit from his brother, coached Tyler in achieving the "perfect bowel movement" to cleanse his body.
After becoming disillusioned with Living Faith Fellowship, Matthew Williams became fascinated with white supremacist and antisemitic literature he read on the Internet. In January 1998, Williams was selling literature at a speech by Militia of Montana founder John Trochmann. By the time Matthew moved back to California, he had developed in interest in Christian Identity.
Matthew Williams was also a substitute teacher. He briefly taught bible class and science at a k-12 private Christian school. The students noted Matthew as extreme in his beliefs and socially awkward.
The Williams family attended a Baptist church in Palo Cedro, California, but left after their request to have a bi-racial couple kicked out of the church was denied.
Matson's and Mowder's bodies were discovered on July 1, 1999. The couple's nude bodies were found in their bed. Shell casings from a .22 caliber gun littered the floor, and the walls and ceiling were stained with blood. There was no sign of forced entry, and no apparent signs of robbery or anything being taken from the house. Matson's Toyota Tercel station wagon was gone, and police recovered it 50 miles south near Yuba City.
The couple had visited Matson's father—Oscar Matson—for dinner the previous evening. Troubled by a distressed-sounding message on the couple's answering machine, and a voice that did not sound like Matson's or Mowder's, Roger Matson went to the couple's house around 1:00 p.m.
Matthew and Tyler Williams were arrested after police found Matson's vehicle abandoned at the side of the road near Oroville, California. The brothers were arrested at about 4:30 p.m. on July 7, 1999, as they left a Yuba City shopping mall. Both carried handguns. Matthew wore a bulletproof vest.
Police were alerted by a phone call made two hours after Matson and Mowder were killed, to a company in Scottsdale, Arizona.The caller ordered ammunition and other equipment worth $2,276.09, and asked that the order be sent to a Yuba City private mailbox firm, care of Gary Matson. The order was paid for with Matson's credit card. Detectives traced the address and arrived just as the Williams brothers showed up.
Searches of the brothers' residences yielded finds of literature from white supremacist organizations, including the World Church of the Creator (now known as the Creativity Movement). The World Church of the Creator was a pantheistic white separatist, anti-Christian religion. Investigators examined whether the case was part of a conspiracy of hate-crime violence by members of the World Church of the Creator. The Matson and Mowder murders took place just days before World Church of the Creator associate Benjamin Nathaniel Smith went on a shooting spree targeting racial and ethnic minorities in Illinois and Indiana. Unnamed federal resources were cited as having found a handwritten letter from Matthew Williams to National Alliance leader William Pierce.
Synagogue and clinic arsons
During searches of the brothers' homes and storage utilities, authorities also found a "hit list" of prominent Jewish civic leaders in the Sacramento, California area. The list was apparently compiled after the June 18, 1999 arson attacks against three synagogues in Sacramento -- Congregation B'nai Israel, Congregation Beth Shalom, and Knesset Israel Torah Center. The fires caused over $1 million in damage.
On March 17, the brothers were charged with setting the three synagogue fires and the July 2 fire at Country Club Medical Center, which housed an abortion clinic. The charges carried of up to 235 years in prison. Matthew Williams later admitted to reporters that he was one of eight or nine men who set fire to the synagogues and the clinic.
On the morning of July 1, Oscar Matson called his son, Gary, and heard a newly recorded outgoing answering machine message saying that the couple were both ill and were leaving to visit with a "specialist friend" of theirs in San Francisco for a week. Police said the man on the recording sounded distressed and seemed to be feigning illness. Detectives said they believed that the man in the recording was trying to send a message that a close acquaintance had forced him to make the recording.
Another male voice was heard in the background telling the man in the recording to "just calm down." Believing that the male voice did not sound like Matson or Mowder, Roger Matson drove to his brother's home and discovered the bodies.
Investigators said that, after being forced to make the recording, the couple was forced into their platform bed, which stood seven feet off the floor. The killers then stood on chairs at the foot of the bed and fired at the couple. Matson received five shots to the head and one to the back. Mowder was shot seven times in the head and once in the neck.
Tyler Williams' account
After the brothers' arrest, authorities said they believed the brothers were acquainted with Matson and Mowder through their involvement in the local landscaping industry. In a pre-sentencing interview with Shasta County deputy probation officer Gerald Salles, Tyler Williams recounted how he and his brother planned and carried out the murders.
Tyler Williams said he and his brother first talked about killing Matson and Mowder two weeks before the July 1, 1999 shootings, after Matthew Williams told Tyler that he'd met Matson and Mowder at the Redding Farmers Market. The couple, like Matthew Williams, had a booth. Ed Smith, who owned a Palo Cedro nursery where Matthew Williams worked for six months, also said Matthew Williams knew Matson and described them as friends.
Tyler Williams said he did not know how his brother decided to single out the couple, but that Matthew told him they were a homosexual couple. Olin Gordon, of Olinda—who had considered hiring the Williams brothers to do some landscaping—said that Matthew Williams had mentioned knowing Matson was homosexual.
According to Tyler, the brothers drove out to Happy Valley late on the night of June 30 or early on July 1, in a Toyota Corolla registered to their father. Matson and Mowder were asleep in their bed. He then said that Matthew Williams did the shooting, emptying a magazine from his .22 calibre semiautomatic handgun before reloading and firing five more shots. Other than labored breathing, Tyler Williams said the victims made no sound before or after the shootings. After the shooting, Matthew Williams drove away in Matson's Toyota Tercel while Tyler Williams returned to his parents' house and went to sleep.
Tyler Williams' account did not include an explanation for the newly recorded outgoing message on the answering machine, which investigators believed the couple had been forced to make, suggesting that they were awake at time of the shooting, and not asleep as Tyler Williams claimed.
In his account of the murders, Tyler Williams said that his brother did not consider the killing of Matson and Mowder to be murder, but a "judgment" instead.
In November 1999 Matthew Williams began giving interviews to various media outlets. In an interview with The Sacramento Bee, he admitted to the murders and said that when he killed Matson and Mowder he was "obeying the law of God." Williams said that he committed the murders because he believed their homosexuality violated God's laws, and he hoped his actions would incite more killings.
Williams insisted that his actions did not constitute murder and claimed that he expected to receive a fairly light sentence even if found guilty, ignoring the fact that he was on trial for first-degree murder and would face either the death penalty or life in prison without the possibility of parole under California law if convicted. Because the Bible holds that homosexuality is a sin that must be punished by death, he claimed, the responsibility lies with the victims. Williams expressed regret that more "people who claim to be Christians" didn't "have the guts" to act as he had. Admitting the possibility of his future execution, he said he hoped to become a "Christian martyr" whose death would inspire others to lash out against Jews, homosexuals, and other minorities.
Matthew Williams' sexuality questioned
In interviews with media, two friends from Matthew Williams' past recounted incidents concerning questions about his sexual orientation.
Todd Bethel served in the Navy with Williams, and claimed to have been his best friend during that period. He briefly rented an apartment with Williams when they were both assigned to a ship in Bremerton, Washington. Bethel, who reportedly tried to sell a videotape and photographs of Williams, said that he and others thought Williams acted too "prissy" and "sat too close to other men." Bethel asked Williams if he was gay, and said Williams denied it but seemed disturbed by the idea that he might be perceived as such.
In August 1999 Dan Martin, Williams' best friend from his time in the Living Faith Fellowship, gave an interview to The Advocate, which described their relationship as a romantic friendship. According to Martin, the two shared poetry, skinny-dipped, and traded stories over campfires in the Idaho mountains. When Williams left the church to drift into the white supremacist movement, Martin went on to become a gay rights activist.
According to Martin, shortly before the murders Williams called a mutual friend looking for Martin's home number in Moscow, Idaho. When he was told that Martin identified as openly gay and was coordinator of an HIV prevention group, Williams began to sob uncontrollably. Martin said he thought the revelation may have triggered the murders of Matson and Mowder.
In September 2001, the brothers pleaded guilty to their 1999 arson attacks against synagogues and clinics. In December 2001, the brothers were sentenced for the arsons—Matthew Williams to 30 years, and Tyler Williams to 21 years, and were ordered to pay more than $1 million in restitution.
Congratulations Reverend Williams
In June 2000, Matthew Williams' court-appointed attorney paid for an advertisement that appeared in the June 18 edition of The Redding Record Searchlight, congratulating Williams on being ordained as a minister by the Christ's Covenant Church. The two-column-by-four-inch advertisement depicted a dove bearing an olive branch, and was labeled as having been placed by "the family and friends of Benjamin Matthew Williams."
The ad, which appeared on Father's Day, read "Rev. Williams: May your knowledge and faith continue to grow during your current persecutions and trials." William's attorney, Frank J. O'Connor, placed the ad and paid the $107.70 bill to The Redding Record Searchlight. O'Connor and the Williams family refused to comment on the ad. The newspaper said that the advertising representative did not focus on Williams' name when the order was placed, and that the ad would not have been printed had the paper been aware of its content.
Matthew Williams' suicide
On June 22, 2002, Matthew Williams and another inmate attacked prison guard Timothy Renault with a homemade hatchet. Renault suffered a skull fracture and a broken jaw. Matthew Williams was kept in a segregation unit following the attack.
At 6:30 a.m. on November 17, 2002, Matthew Williams was found dead in his cell, an apparent suicide. It is believed that he killed himself sometime late the previous night, November 16, or early in the morning on the 17th. Williams jammed his cell door with a piece of cardboard, and then spread a blanket between his cell toilet and the wall, so that he would not be seen by his jailers. He bled to death from multiple self-inflicted slash wounds to his arms, legs, and neck from a disposable jail-issue razor he had modified to expose the blade, attached to a handle fashioned from a ballpoint pen, and fastened to his wrist with dental floss.
Around his neck he wore an amulet fashioned from dental floss and aluminum foil, containing various items, including two Bible verses. Officials did not say which Bible verses the amulet held, but in Williams' cell a Bible was open to Psalms 22 and 23.
He was scheduled to be sentenced on December 2.
After Matthew Williams' suicide, it was reported that the Shasta County jail had been ordered by the court to make sure that Williams had no narcotics in his system, so he could be drug-free for a brain scan his attorneys had arranged. Williams was to be weaned off his medications, but Shasta County jail staff stopped Williams' medication abruptly.
Two days prior to committing suicide, Matthew Williams mailed a signed confession to his brother's attorney, taking full responsibility for the murders of Matson and Mowder. In the one-page letter, Williams wrote that it was an "accepted fact" that he killed Matson and Mowder, whom he referred to as "the 2 perverts." He expressed concern about poisoning a jury against his brother, whose innocence he maintained. Tyler Williams' attorney turned the letter over the court for review on the case. While he later attempted to use this document to dismiss the charges against his client, the court rejected this approach, stating that the "confession" had no legal value and that they would neither dismiss any charges against Tyler nor consider any leniency in a plea bargain as a result of it.
In March 2003 Tyler Williams pleaded guilty to the murders of Matson and Mowder. Under a plea agreement, Williams was sentenced to 29 years to life, to be served after a 21-year sentence in the synagogue and clinic arsons. If he had gone to trial, Williams could have received the death penalty.
- "Fremontia Special Issue - Vernal Pools" (PDF). California Native Plant Society. January 2000. pp. 71–72. Retrieved 2007-08-05.
- "Brothers charged in gay slaying". The Portsmouth Herald. Associated Press. 1999-07-10. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- Stanton, Sam; Gary Delsohn (1999-10-09). "Poster boys for the summer of hate". Salon.Com. Archived from the original on 2008-05-17. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- Sanchez, Rene (1999-07-12). "Path of Calif. Hate Crimes Leads to Strictly Reared Brothers". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on 2004-08-21. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- "Suspects in slayings, fires were former honor students". The Lubbock Avalanche-Journal. Associated Press. 1999-07-13. Archived from the original on 2007-09-27. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- Hazle, Maline (1999-07-22). "Williams' sexuality questioned". Record Searchlight. Archived from the original on 2007-12-04. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- Bolander, Kimberly (1999-08-25). "Victim may have been forced to make message". Record Searchlight. Archived from the original on June 5, 2006. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- "Yuba city police arrest brothers in shooting deaths of gay couple". Lubbock Avalanche-Journal. 1999-07-10. Archived from the original on 2007-09-27. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- Breitler, Alex; Maline Hazle (1999-07-09). "2 arrested in killings - Palo Cedro brothers held in murders of Gary Matson, Winfield Mowder". Record Searchlight. Archived from the original on June 5, 2006. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- "Link cited in slayings, arson cases". The Lubbock Avalanche-Journal. 1999-07-11. Archived from the original on 2007-09-27. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- "CA Suspects Plead Not Guilty". The Advocate. PlanetOut.Com. 1999-07-30. Archived from the original on December 19, 2005. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- "California: Hate-Crime Guilty Pleas". The New York Times. 2001-09-08. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- "Williams brothers charged with arson". The Gay People's Chronicle. 2000-03-24. Retrieved 2007-08-06.[dead link]
- "Brothers Accused of Synagogue Arsons". GFN. Associated Press. 2000-03-22. Archived from the original on 2007-10-06. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- Stanton, Sam; Gary Delsohn (2000-03-18). "Indictments issued in Sacramento synagogue arsons". Salon.Com. Archived from the original on 2007-02-07. Retrieved 2007-08-06. He also claimed that his brother Tyler had not been involved.
- Hazle, Maline (2003-03-30). "Williams describes events leading to murders". Record Searchlight. Archived from the original on June 5, 2006. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- "Williams admits killing couple; says he 'obeyed God's law'". The Gay People's Chronicle. 1999-11-12. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- Delsohn, Gary; Sam Stanton (1999-11-08). "I'm guilty of obeying the laws of the creator". Salon.Com. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- Bull, Chris (1999-08-31). "Connect the dots - same-sex romance linked to white supremacist group". The Advocate. Archived from the original on 2005-04-09. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- Hazle, Maline (2001-12-01). "Brothers sentenced to prison - Judge hands down long terms for series of arsons". Record Searchlight. Archived from the original on June 5, 2006. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- ""Reverend" Williams Congratulated". The Advocate News & Politics. PlanetOut. 2000-06-21. Archived from the original on January 25, 2005. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- Hazle, Maline (2002-06-20). "'Rev. Williams' ad stokes furor". Record Searchlight. Retrieved 2007-08-06.[dead link]
- Hecht, Peter (2002-11-18). "Arsonist Williams dies in jail". The Sacramento Bee. Archived from the original on 2009-10-22. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- Hazle, Maline (2003-04-26). "Williams' test result released by coroner". Record Spotlight. Archived from the original on 2009-10-22. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- Hazle, Maline (2003-02-23). "Williams was taken off medication before suicide". Redding Spotlight. Archived from the original on June 5, 2006. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- Hazle, Maline (2003-06-20). "Killer's last letter unsealed". Record Searchlight. Archived from the original on June 24, 2006. Retrieved 2007-08-06.
- "Sentence in Killings of Gay Men". The New York Times. 2003-03-29. Retrieved 2007-08-06.