Jump to content

Zapruder film

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Sm8900 (talk | contribs) at 04:28, 9 February 2016 (→Dispute over completeness). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Frame 150 from the Zapruder Film

The Zapruder film is a silent, color motion picture sequence shot by private citizen Abraham Zapruder with a home-movie camera, as U.S. President John F. Kennedy's motorcade passed through Dealey Plaza in Dallas, Texas on November 22, 1963, thereby unexpectedly capturing the President's assassination.

Although it is not the only film of the shooting, it has been called the most complete, giving a relatively clear view from a somewhat elevated position on the side from which the president's head wound is visible. It was an important part of the Warren Commission hearings and all subsequent investigations of the assassination, and is one of the most studied pieces of film in history. Of greatest notoriety is the film's capture of the fatal shot to President Kennedy's head when his presidential limousine was almost exactly in front of, and slightly below, Zapruder's position.

Creation

See also: Abraham Zapruder

Abraham Zapruder stood on a concrete pedestal along Elm Street in Dealey Plaza holding a high-end Model 414 PD Bell & Howell Zoomatic Director Series Camera. He filmed from the time the presidential limousine turned onto Elm Street [1] for a total of 26.6 seconds, exposing 486 frames of standard 8 mm Kodachrome II safety film, running at 18.3 frames/second.[2]

Frame 371 showing Jacqueline Kennedy reaching out across the back of the presidential limousine as Secret Service agent Clint Hill climbs aboard.

After Secret Service agent Forrest Sorrels promised Zapruder that the film would only be used for an official investigation, the two men sought to develop the footage as soon as possible. As television station WFAA's equipment was incompatible with the format, Eastman Kodak's Dallas film processing facility developed the film and Jamieson Film Company produced three copies. Zapruder gave two of the copies to the Secret Service.[1]

Media interest in the footage was great. In his 2001 book Tell Me A Story, CBS producer Don Hewitt said that he told a new correspondent, Dan Rather, to go to Zapruder's home to "sock him in the jaw", take the film, copy it, then return it and let the network's lawyers deal with the consequences.[3] According to Hewitt, he realized his mistake after ending their telephone conversation and immediately called Rather back to countermand the order.[3] In a 2015 interview on Opie with Jim Norton, Rather stated that the story was a myth.[4] On the morning of November 23, CBS lost the bidding for the footage to Life magazine's $150,000 offer.[5] Rather was the first to report on the footage on national television after seeing it, although the inaccuracies in his description would contribute to many conspiracy theories about the assassination.[1]

Frame 313 of the film depicts the fatal shot to the President's head. After having a nightmare in which he saw a sign in Times Square, New York City, read "See the President's head explode!", Zapruder insisted that frame 313 be excluded from publication.[1] The November 29, 1963 issue of Life—which featured the "LIFE" logo in a black box instead of the usual red box—published about 30 frames of the Zapruder film in black and white. Frames were also published in color in the December 6, 1963 special "John F. Kennedy Memorial Edition", and in issues dated October 2, 1964 (a special article on the film and the Warren Commission report), November 25, 1966, and November 24, 1967.

Zapruder was one of at least 32 people in Dealey Plaza known to have made film or still photographs at or around the time of the shooting.[6]

Subsequent history

The Zapruder frames used by the Warren Commission were published in black and white as Commission Exhibit 885 in volume XVIII of the Hearings and Exhibits.[7] Frames of the film have also been published in several magazines, and the film was featured in several movies. Copies of the complete film are available on the Internet.[8][9][10][11][12][13]

One of the first-generation Secret Service copies was lent to the Federal Bureau of Investigation in Washington, which made a second-generation copy on November 25. After study of that copy in January 1964, the Warren Commission judged the quality to be inadequate, and requested the original. Life brought the original to Washington in February for the Commission's viewing, and also made color 35mm slide enlargements from the relevant frames of the original film for the FBI. From those slides, the FBI made a series of black-and-white prints, which were given to the commission for its use.

In October 1964, the U.S. Government Printing Office released 26 volumes of testimony and evidence compiled by the Warren Commission. Volume 18 of the commission's hearings reproduced 158 frames of the Zapruder film in black and white. However, frames 208–211 were missing, a splice was visible in frames 207 and 212, frames 314 and 315 were switched, and frame 284 was a repeat of 283.[14] In reply to an inquiry, the FBI's J. Edgar Hoover wrote in 1965 that 314 and 315 were switched due to a printing error, and that the error did not exist in the original Warren Commission exhibits. In early 1967, Life released a statement that four frames of the camera original (208–211) had been accidentally destroyed, and the adjacent frames damaged, by a Life photo lab technician on November 23, 1963. Life released the missing frames from the first-generation copy it had received from Zapruder with the original.[15] (Of the Zapruder frames outside the section used in the commission's exhibits, frames 155–157 and 341 were also damaged and spliced out of the camera original, but are present in the first-generation copies.)

In 1966, assassination researcher Josiah Thompson, while working for Life, was allowed to examine a first-generation copy of the film and a set of color 35mm slides made from the original. He tried to negotiate with Life for the rights to print important individual frames in his book, Six Seconds in Dallas. Life refused to approve the use of any of the frames, even after Thompson offered to give all profits from the book sales to Life. When Thompson's book was published in 1967, it included very detailed charcoal drawings of important individual frames, plus photo reproductions of the four missing frames. Time Inc. filed a lawsuit against Thompson and his publishing company for copyright infringement. A U.S. District Court ruled in 1968 that the Time Inc. copyright of the Zapruder film had not been violated by invoking the doctrine of fair use. The court held that "there is a public interest in having the fullest information available on the murder of President Kennedy. Thompson did serious work on the subject and has a theory entitled to public consideration … [I]t has been found that the copying by defendants was fair and reasonable."[16]

In 1967, Life magazine hired a New Jersey film lab, Manhattan Effects, to make a 16 mm film copy of the original Zapruder film. Pleased with the results, they asked for a 35 mm internegative to be made. Mo Weitzman made several internegatives in 1968, giving the best to Life and retaining the test copies. Weitzman set up his own optical house and motion picture postproduction facility later that year. Employee and assassination buff Robert Groden, hired in 1969, used one of Weitzman's copies and an optical printer to make versions of the Zapruder film using close-ups and minimizing the camera's shakiness.

Before the 1969 trial of New Orleans businessman Clay Shaw for conspiracy in connection with the assassination, a copy of the film several generations from the original was subpoenaed from Time Inc. in 1967 by New Orleans District Attorney Jim Garrison for use at Shaw's grand jury hearing. Garrison unsuccessfully subpoenaed the original film in 1968. The courtroom showings of Garrison's copy in 1969 were the first time it had been shown in public as a film. Noted conspiracy theorist Mark Lane, author of Rush to Judgment, was in New Orleans at the time to assist Garrison in his investigation. Lane borrowed Garrison's copy of the Zapruder film and had several copies printed at a local lab. These low quality copies began circulating among assassination researchers and were known to many journalists as well. The underground circulation of these copies and the secret screenings to a select few who had the opportunity to see them added an additional aura of mystery to the film, enhancing the idea that there was a secret to be found in it that was being kept hidden from the general public.

The first broadcast of the Zapruder film was on the late-night television show Underground News with Chuck Collins, originating on WSNS-TV, Ch 44, Chicago in 1970. It was given to director Howie Samuelsohn by Penn Jones and later aired in syndication to Philadelphia, Detroit, Kansas City and St. Louis.[citation needed]

On March 6, 1975, on the ABC late-night television show Good Night America (hosted by Geraldo Rivera), assassination researchers Robert Groden and Dick Gregory presented the first-ever network television showing of the Zapruder home movie. The public's response and outrage to that television showing quickly led to the forming of the Hart-Schweiker investigation, contributed to the Church Committee Investigation on Intelligence Activities by the United States, and resulted in the House Select Committee on Assassinations investigation.[17]

In April 1975, in settlement of a royalties suit between Time Inc. and Zapruder's heirs that arose from the ABC showing, Time Inc. sold the original film and its copyright back to the Zapruder family for the token sum of $1. Time Inc. wanted to donate the film to the U.S. government. The Zapruder family initially refused to consent, but in 1978 the family transferred the film to the National Archives and Records Administration for appropriate preservation and safe-keeping, while still retaining ownership of the film and its copyright. Director Oliver Stone paid approximately $85,000 to the Zapruder family for use of the Zapruder film in his motion picture JFK (1991).

On October 26, 1992, President George H. W. Bush signed into law the John F. Kennedy Records Collection Act of 1992 (the "JFK Act"), which sought to preserve for historical and governmental purposes all records related to the assassination of President Kennedy. The Act created the President John F. Kennedy Assassination Records Collection at the National Archives. The Zapruder film was automatically designated an "assassination record" and therefore became official property of the United States government. When the Zapruder family demanded the return of the original film in 1993 and 1994, National Archives officials refused to comply.

On April 24, 1997, the Assassination Records Review Board, which was created by the JFK Act, announced a "Statement of Policy and Intent with Regard to the Zapruder Film". The ARRB re-affirmed that the Zapruder Film is an "assassination record" within the meaning of the JFK Act and directed it to be transferred on August 1, 1998 from its present location in NARA's film collection to the John F. Kennedy Assassination Records Collection maintained by NARA.[fn 1] As required by law for such a seizure under eminent domain, payment to Zapruder's heirs was attempted. Because the film is unique, the film's value was difficult to ascertain; eventually, following arbitration with the Zapruder heirs, the government purchased the film in 1999 for $16 million.

The Zapruder family retained copyright to the film, which was not seized. In 1997, the film was digitally replicated and restored under license of the Zapruder family. The 1998 documentary Image of an Assassination: A New Look at the Zapruder Film shows the history of the film, as well as various versions of the restored film.

In December 1999, the Zapruder family donated the film's copyright to The Sixth Floor Museum, in the Texas School Book Depository building at Dealey Plaza, along with one of the first-generation copies made on November 22, 1963, and other copies of the film and frame enlargements once held by Life magazine, which had been since returned.[18] The Zapruder family no longer retains any commercial rights to the film, which are now entirely controlled by the museum.

The relevant history of the film is covered in a book by David Wrone called The Zapruder Film: Reframing JFK's Assassination (2003). Wrone is a professor of history who tracks the "chain of evidence" for the film.

Authenticity

Zapruder testified before the Warren Commission[19] that the frames published in Commission Exhibit 885 were from the film that he took. Some researchers of the assassination have claimed that three other films of part of the assassination (the Orville Nix, and Marie Muchmore films), together with numerous still photographs, are inconsistent with the Zapruder film, suggesting that they are fraudulent; some researchers of the assassination have claimed that the extant Zapruder film is not authentic.[20][21][22][23] These claims[which?] have been countered.[24][25]

Abraham Zapruder's Bell & Howell Zoomatic movie camera, in the collection of the US National Archives

The House Select Committee on Assassinations described the Zapruder film as "the best available photographic evidence of the number and timing of the shots that struck the occupants of the Presidential limousine."[26] The Assassination Records Review Board said it "is perhaps the single most important assassination record."[27] According to Vincent Bugliosi, the film was "originally touted by the vast majority of conspiracy theorists as incontrovertible proof of [a] conspiracy" but is now believed by many assassination researchers to be a "sophisticated forgery".[28] Among those who believe the Zapruder film has been altered are John Costella,[28] James H. Fetzer,[28] David Lifton,[28] David Mantik,[28] Jack White,[28] Noel Twyman,[29] and Harrison Livingstone, who has called it "the biggest hoax of the twentieth century".[28] In 1996 Roland Zavada, a former product engineer for Kodak who led the team that invented Kodachrome II, was requested by the Assassination Records Review Board to undertake a thorough technical study of the Zapruder Film.[30] Zavada concluded that there was no detectable evidence of manipulation or image alteration on the Zapruder in-camera original. He concluded that any alleged alterations were not feasible.[31][32] Zavada said that copying Zapruder's film would leave visible artifacts of "image structure constraints of grain; [and] contrast and modulation transfer function losses.…It has no evidence of optical effects or matte work including granularity, edge effects or fringing, [or] contrast buildup."[33]

David Lifton wrote that the Zapruder film was in the possession of the CIA's National Photographic Interpretation Center, the night of the assassination.[34][35] Jack White, researcher and photographic consultant to the House Select Committee on Assassinations, claimed that there are anomalies in the Zapruder film, including an "unnatural jerkiness of movement or change of focus ... in certain frame sequences."[36]

The study of the film

The Zapruder film frames have been put together into a panoramic movie. Each object that appears during the film has its starting position equal to where it appears first in Zapruder's frames. The objects' positions are updated during visibility in Zapruder's frames and stay unmoved as soon as each object moves out of the frames.[37]

The Nix film had the same technology applied to it. The Nix film and the Zapruder film were then combined into a direct simultaneous comparison movie.[38]

Between November 1963 and January 1964, the FBI examined a copy of the Zapruder film, noting that the camera recorded at 18.3 frames per second. It is not clear from the Zapruder film itself when the first and second shots occurred. It is apparent that by frame 225 the President is reacting to his throat wound. However, no wound or blood is seen on either President Kennedy or Governor Connally prior to frame 313. The fatal shot to the President occurred at frame 313 [39] with the visible effects of the shot to the head.

There is also a stabilized high-definition version of the Zapruder film that is synchronized with the Dallas Police Department audio recording. The version of the Zapruder film used here is the first-generation copy that went to France. The video also shows the immediate aftermath at Dealey Plaza and the press conference of JFK's assistant press secretary Malcolm Kilduff.[40]

Dispute over completeness

The Zapruder film has often been believed as capturing the shooting from start to finish and has been called a "complete record of the Kennedy assassination".[according to whom?] This view is, however, challenged by Max Holland, author of The Kennedy Assassination Tapes, and the professional photographer Johann Rush in a joint editorial piece published by The New York Times on November 22, 2007.[41] Holland and Rush point out that Zapruder temporarily stopped filming at frame 132, when only police motorcycles were visible. When he resumed filming, frame 133 already shows the presidential motorcade in view. This pause could have great significance for the interpretation of the assassination, Holland and Rush suggest.

One of the sources of controversy with the Warren Report has been its difficulty in satisfactorily accounting for the sequencing of the assassination. A specific mystery concerns what happened to the one shot that missed (and how Oswald came to miss at what was assumed to be close range). Holland and Rush argue that the break in the Zapruder film might conceal a first shot earlier than analysts have hitherto assumed, and point out that in this case a horizontal traffic mast would temporarily have obstructed Oswald's view of his target. In the authors' words, "The film, we realize, does not depict an assassination about to commence. It shows one that had already started." [42]


The evidence offered by Holland and Rush to support their theory was challenged in a series of 2007–08 articles by computer animator Dale K. Myers and assassination researcher Todd W. Vaughan, who defended the prevailing belief that Zapruder's film captured the entire shooting sequence.[43]

Cultural effect

In 1994, the Zapruder film footage was deemed "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant" by the United States Library of Congress and was selected for permanent preservation in the National Film Registry.

The film's 1975 broadcast on Good Night America ignited widespread public distrust in the findings of the Warren Commission. Perhaps the most controversial effect was the suggestion that an assassin or assassins other than Oswald were involved.[citation needed]

Author J. G. Ballard focuses on Kennedy and the Zapruder film in a number of his works, such as The Atrocity Exhibition.

Actor Freddie Prinze was fascinated by the Zapruder film, and watched it frequently in the time leading up to his 1977 suicide.[44]

Some critics have stated that the violence and shock of this home movie led to a new way of representing violence in 1970s American cinema, both in mainstream films, and particularly in indie and underground horror movies.[45][46]

The film has been featured in films or other media, such as the Oliver Stone film JFK, which used the clearest copy of the film available to the public before the late 1990s. For example, after the fatal shot, Jacqueline Kennedy can be seen mouthing what appears to be the words, "Oh, my God!" A closeup from the portion of the film showing the fatal shot to Kennedy's head is also shown in the Clint Eastwood film In the Line of Fire.

The film was pastiched by the American television show Seinfeld in the two-part episode of Season 3 titled The Boyfriend

Zapruder is also mentioned in the 1994 Manic Street Preachers' song "Ifwhiteamericatoldthetruthforonedayit'sworldwouldfallapart", a track from the album The Holy Bible.

In the Don DeLillo novel Underworld, there is a screening of a bootleg copy of Zapruder film, at which the film is played over and over on multiple televisions at varying speeds.

In the 2004 revival of Stephen Sondheim's musical Assassins, the film was projected onto Lee Harvey Oswald's white shirt during the climax of the show.

The music video for Lana Del Rey's single "National Anthem" is a partial re-creation of the Zapruder film.

The earliest three days of the original film's life, including its actual filming, developing, copying, premiere viewing by Zapruder, government agents and reporters, and sale to Life Magazine are portrayed in the 2013 docudrama Parkland, in which Abraham Zapruder is played by Paul Giamatti.

Abraham Zapruder is sometimes presented as a forefather of all citizen journalists.[47]

The Zapruder film, long classified and kept from public viewing for years, has evolved into one of the most viewed films in history, now available on the internet for public access.

Footnotes

  1. ^ The film's physical location remained the same, only its record classification changed.

See also

References

  1. ^ a b c d Pasternack, Alex (2012-11-23). "The Other Shooter: The Saddest and Most Expensive 26 Seconds of Amateur Film Ever Made". Vice. Retrieved November 26, 2012.
  2. ^ The Model 414 PD held a reel of 16mm film which was first run in one direction, with half of the width of the film being exposed. The reel would then be removed from the camera (a process which could take place in subdued light), the feed and take-up reels swapped and reloaded so that the other half of the film could be exposed in a process analogous to half-track audio tape. The FBI later tested Zapruder's camera and found that it filmed an average of 18.3 frames/second (slightly deviating from the camera's standard frame rate of 16 frame/s). Richard B. Trask, Photographic Memory: The Kennedy Assassination, November 22, 1963, Dallas: Sixth Floor Museum, 1996, p. 5. While earlier 8 mm cameras had used a 16 frame/s rate, the 8 mm standard was moving to 18 frame/s by the 1960s, and that was the frame rate adopted by the Super 8 format in 1966.
  3. ^ a b Hewitt, Don (2002) [2001]. "New Frontiers". Tell Me A Story: 50 Years and 60 Minutes in Television. New York: PublicAffairs. p. 81. ISBN 9781586489656.
  4. ^ Gregg Hughes and Jim Norton (October 30, 2015). "Dan Rather Seeing the Zapruder Film". www.youtube.com (Podcast). Opie Radio. Event occurs at 3:28-4:04. Retrieved November 17, 2015.
  5. ^ "Kennedy's Assassination: How LIFE Brought the Zapruder Film to Light". LIFE.com. October 24, 2013. Retrieved 2013-11-14.
  6. ^ Vincent Bugliosi, Reclaiming History: The Assassination of President John F. Kennedy. W.W. Norton, 2007, endnotes, p. 291.
  7. ^ Warren Commission Hearings and Exhibits, Vol. XVIII. Online version at the History Matters Archive.
  8. ^ Zapruder Film of JFK Assassination on YouTube. Requires Flash Player.
  9. ^ Stabilized Version of the Zapruder Film on YouTube. Requires Flash Player.
  10. ^ Stabilized versions of the Zapruder film. Research quality. Based on the “Costella 2006” frames. Large file sizes. Requires QuickTime viewer from apple.com. Entire film is covered in six “fixed camera” video clips, plus one “stabilized pan” video clip. Full speed.
  11. ^ JFK Kennedy shooting, Zapruder audiovideo on YouTube. Licenza Creative Commons Attribuzione. The Zapruder film has been added to the sound recorded by police in Dallas.
  12. ^ All 486 frames of the Zapruder film. The “Costella 2006” frames. Research quality. Does not require special viewers, but not shown in movie form.
  13. ^ John P. Costella, "The New Zapruder Film", Assassination Research, Vol.2 No.2 (2003) Stabilized version which allows frame-by-frame easy forward.
  14. ^ Frames 207 and 212, frames 283 and 284 (actually 283), frame 314 (actually 315), and frame 315 (actually 314).
  15. ^ "Life To Release Today Part of Kennedy Film", New York Times, January 30, 1967, p. 22;
  16. ^ Time Inc. v. Bernard Geis Associates, 293 F.Supp. 130, 146 (D.C.N.Y. 1968).
  17. ^ Vincent Bugliosi (2007). Reclaiming history: the assassination of President John F. Kennedy. W. W. Norton & Company. p. 371. ISBN 978-0-393-04525-3. Retrieved 5 March 2011.
  18. ^ Zapruder Film Press Release, January 18, 2000. The Sixth Floor Museum at Dealey Plaza.
  19. ^ Warren Commission Hearings and Exhibits, Vol. VII, pp. 569–576. Online version at the History Matters Archive.
  20. ^ Noel Twyman, Bloody Treason, (Laurel Publishing, Rancho Sante Fe, California, 1997).
  21. ^ Fetzer, James H. (ed.), Assassination Science (Open Court/Catfeet Press, Chicago, 1998).
  22. ^ Fetzer, James H. (ed.), Murder in Dealey Plaza (Open Court/Catfeet Press, Chicago, 2000).
  23. ^ Fetzer, James H. (ed.), The Great Zapruder Film Hoax (Open Court/Catfeet Press, Chicago, 2003).
  24. ^ Roland J. Zavada, Analysis of Selected Motion Picture Photographic Evidence, Kodak Technical Report #318420P, Imaging Science Division (September 25, 1998).
  25. ^ David R. Wrone, The Zapruder Film: Reframing JFK's Assassination (University Press of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas, 2003).
  26. ^ "I.A.". Report of the Select Committee on Assassinations of the U.S. House of Representatives. Washington, D.C.: United States Government Printing Office. 1979. p. 45. {{cite book}}: External link in |chapterurl= (help); Unknown parameter |chapterurl= ignored (|chapter-url= suggested) (help)
  27. ^ "Chapter Six, Part II: Clarifying the Federal Record". Final Report of the Assassination Records Review Board (PDF). Washington, D.C.: United States Government Printing Office. September 30, 1998. p. 124. {{cite book}}: External link in |chapterurl= (help); Unknown parameter |chapterurl= ignored (|chapter-url= suggested) (help)
  28. ^ a b c d e f g Bugliosi 2007, pp. 504–512.
  29. ^ Twyman, Noel. Bloody Treason: On Solving History's Greatest Murder Mystery, (Rancho Santa Fe: Laurel Publishing, 1997), ISBN 0-9654399-0-9
  30. ^ Assassination Records Review Board Report Sept 1998 Ch 6, Pt II, C.3 https://fas.org/sgp/advisory/arrb98/part09.htm accessed 11 August 2012
  31. ^ Roland J. Zavada, Analysis of Selected Motion Picture Photographic Evidence, 1998.
  32. ^ Roland Zavada. 'Analysis of Selected Motion Picture Photographic Evidence Sept 7 1998 study I.
  33. ^ Rollie Zavada, "Request for Response to Z-film Hoax extracts", 2003.
  34. ^ Lifton, David. Best Evidence: Disguise and Deception in the Assassination of John F. Kennedy, (New York: Carroll & Graf Publishers, 1988), pp. 555-557.
  35. ^ Fetzer, James. Assassination Science, (Chicago: Catfeet Press, 1998), pp. 209, 224. ISBN 0-8126-9366-3
  36. ^ Fetzer, James. Assassination Science, (Chicago: Catfeet Press, 1998), pp. 213–14. ISBN 0-8126-9366-3
  37. ^ JFK Assassination Zapruder Stabilized Motion Panorama HD plus SloMo - 50th anniversary on YouTube
  38. ^ JFK Assassination Stabilized Motion Panorama HD Nix v Zapruder - 50th anniversary (HD) on YouTube
  39. ^ Frame 313 Costella Combined Edit
  40. ^ Zapruder Version 2012 . JFK on YouTube
  41. ^ Holland, Max; Rush, Johann (November 22, 2007). "J.F.K.'s Death, Re-Framed". The New York Times.
  42. ^ The Truth Behind JFK's Asssasination, by Max Holland, Newsweek, November 20, 2014.
  43. ^ Max Holland's 11 Seconds in Dallas; Holland Deja Vu; Cherry-Picking Evidence of the First Shot
  44. ^ "SUICIDES: Freddie Prinze: Too Much, Too Soon". Time. February 7, 1977.
  45. ^ World Archipelago. "Wallflower Press" (PDF).
  46. ^ Template:Fr icon 26 secondes: L'Amérique éclaboussée.
  47. ^ http://www.ecrans.fr/La-mort-de-JFK-dans-le-viseur-de,1957.html (in French) La mort de JFK dans le viseur de Zapruder
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Zapruder_film&oldid=704042760"