1993 Big Bayou Canot train wreck
|1993 Big Bayou Canot train wreck|
The wreck of the Sunset Limited at Big Bayou Canot
|Date||September 22, 1993|
|Rail line||CSX Transportation|
|Type of incident||Derailment|
|Cause||Barge collision with bridge / wrong design |
The 1993 Big Bayou Canot train wreck was the derailing of an Amtrak train on the CSXT Big Bayou Canot bridge in northeast Mobile, Alabama, USA, on September 22, 1993. It was caused by displacement of a span and deformation of the rails when a formation of heavy barges had collided with the bridge eight minutes earlier. Casualties were 47 killed and 103 injured. To date it is the deadliest train wreck in Amtrak's history and at the time the worst rail disaster in the United States since the 1958 Newark Bay, New Jersey rail accident in which 48 lives were lost.
The CSX Transportation unfinished swing bridge over the Big Bayou Canot in southwestern Alabama (about 10 miles northeast of Mobile) was struck at approximately 2:45 a.m. by a barge being pushed by the towboat Mauvilla (owned and operated by Warrior and Gulf Navigation of Chickasaw, Alabama), whose pilot had become disoriented in heavy fog. The collision forced the unsecured end of a bridge span approximately three feet out of alignment, into the path of an oncoming train, and severely kinked the track.
At approximately 2:53 a.m., Amtrak's Sunset Limited train, powered by three locomotives (one GE Genesis P40DC number 819 in the front, and two EMD F40PHs, numbers 262 and 312) en route from Los Angeles, California to Miami, Florida with 220 passengers and crew aboard, crossed the bridge at a high speed and derailed at the kink. The first of its three locomotives slammed into the displaced span, causing that part of the bridge to collapse into the water beneath. The lead locomotive embedded itself nose-first into the canal bank and exploded, and the other locomotives, together with the baggage car, dormitory car and two of the six passenger cars, plunged into the water. The locomotives' fuel tanks, each of which held several thousand gallons of diesel fuel, ruptured upon impact, resulting in a massive fuel spill and a fire. Forty-seven people, 42 of whom were passengers, were killed, many by drowning, others by fire/smoke inhalation. Another 103 were injured. The towboat's four crew members were not injured.
Immediately prior to the accident, the Mauvilla had made a wrong turn and entered an un-navigable channel of water heading to the bridge. The towboat's pilot, Willie Odom, was not properly trained on how to read his radar and thus, owing to the very poor visibility in the fog and his lack of experience, did not realize that he was off course. The boat also lacked a compass and a chart of the waters. Odom believed that he was still on the Mobile River and had identified the bridge in the radar as another tug boat. He was not found to be criminally liable for the accident.
The bridge span had actually been designed to rotate so it could be converted to a swing bridge by adding suitable equipment. No such conversion had ever been performed, but the span had not been adequately secured against unintended movement. Despite the displacement of the bridge, the continuously welded rails did not break. As a result, the track circuit controlling the bridge approach block signals remained closed (intact) and the nearest signal continued to display a clear (green) aspect. Had one of the rails been severed by the bridge's displacement, the track circuit would have opened, causing the approach signal to display a stop (red) aspect and the preceding signal an amber approach indication. This might have given the Amtrak engineer sufficient time to stop his train or at least reduce speed in an effort to minimize the severity of the accident.
An episode of the National Geographic Channel documentary series Seconds from Disaster examined the accident. In addition to corroborating findings of the official accident report, the program noted that the train had been delayed in New Orleans, Louisiana, by repairs to an air conditioner unit. This had put the train a half-hour behind schedule. If not for the delay, the Sunset Limited would have passed over the Big Bayou Canot bridge 20 minutes before it was struck by the barge.
As a result of its investigation of this accident, the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) made a comprehensive series of recommendations, on September 19, 1994, to the U.S. Department of Transportation, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the U.S. Coast Guard, the National Railroad Passenger Corporation (Amtrak), the Federal Emergency Management Agency, The American Waterways Operators, Inc., the Warrior & Gulf Navigation Company, the Association of American Railroads, and the American Short Line Railroad Association.
Following a recommendation to maintain a record of onboard passenger numbers, Amtrak now records passenger lists electronically.
Comparable bridge accidents
- The 1953 Tangiwai Bridge disaster in New Zealand, in which 151 passengers and crew died when a bridge over the Whangaehu River collapsed under the force of a volcanic lahar. Sensors now put the signals to red if a lahar is detected.
- The 1975 Tasman Bridge disaster in Hobart, the capital city of Australia's island state of Tasmania, when a bridge was hit by a 7,000-ton bulk carrier, causing a 400 foot section of roadway to fall 120 feet into the river below. Seven of the ship's crew and five car occupants were killed.
- The 1977 Granville train disaster in Sydney, Australia, which involved the collapse of a bridge after its support pylons were struck by a train. The concrete road overpass fell on to carriages of the train, crushing them. 83 died and more than 210 were injured.
- The Sunshine Skyway Bridge disaster in Tampa Bay, Florida. The southbound span of the original bridge, built in the late sixties, was destroyed on May 9, 1980, when the freighter MV Summit Venture collided with a pier (support column) during a storm, sending over 1200 feet (366m) of the bridge plummeting into Tampa Bay. The collision caused six automobiles and a Greyhound bus to fall 150 feet (46 m), killing 35 people.
- The Eschede train disaster of 1998 involved a high-speed train which derailed, and rear carriages hit a nearby motorway bridge. 101 died and a similar number were injured.
- The I-40 bridge disaster of 2002 was caused by a barge hitting the I-40 bridge over the Arkansas River, which collapsed, causing numerous cars to fall in the river. There were 14 fatalities.
- The Eggner Ferry Bridge partially collapsed on January 26, 2012, when the MV Delta Mariner struck the bridge after traveling through the recreational channel in the Tennessee River on Kentucky Lake. No injuries were reported
- U.S. National Transportation Safety Board Railroad-Marine Accident Report 94-1, 19 September 1994
- Wreck of the Sunset Limited episode of 'Seconds from Disaster', at IMDb, 10 August 2004
- Labaton, Stephen (June 22, 1994). "Barge Pilot Blamed in Fatal Amtrak Wreck". The New York Times. Retrieved July 17, 2014.
- "No Criminal Liability Is Found in Amtrak Bayou Derailment". Los Angeles Times. March 26, 1994. Retrieved July 17, 2014.
- Holloway, David Mobile Press-Register 200th Anniversary: Sunset Limited train wreck memories not diminished by passing years at al.com, 1 July 2013. Retrieved 3 June 2014
- Sproul, R. C. Train Wreck Eyewitness account of aftermath, at Ligonier Ministries blog. Retrieved 3 June 2014
- Summary and photos at Trainweb.org. Retrieved 3 June 2014
- Graphical re-enactment of accident cause at TMBA Inc Animation Studio, New York. Retrieved 3 June 2014
- U.S. Coast Guard: The short film Aerial and Boat Views of Amtrak Train Derailment, Mobile, Alabama (1993) is available for free download at the Internet Archive [more]