Joe Volpe

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
The Honourable
Giuseppe Volpe
PC
Volpe.jpg
Member of the Canadian Parliament
for Eglinton—Lawrence
In office
1988–2011
Preceded by Roland de Corneille
Succeeded by Joe Oliver
Personal details
Born Giuseppe Joseph Volpe
(1947-09-21) September 21, 1947 (age 66)
Monteleone di Puglia, Italy
Political party Liberal
Spouse(s) Mirella Volpe
Residence Toronto, Canada
Profession Educator, school principal, teacher, vice-principal
Religion Roman Catholic
This article is about the Canadian politician. For information about the opera manager, see Joseph Volpe (opera manager).

Giuseppe Joseph "Joe" Volpe, PC, (born September 21, 1947) was a Canadian politician. He was a Liberal member of the Canadian House of Commons from 1988 until the 2011, holding two senior positions in Prime Minister Paul Martin's Cabinet from 2003 to 2006, and serving as transportation critic when his party became the Official Opposition. In 2006, he was an unsuccessful candidate for the leadership of the Liberal Party. In the 2011 federal election, Volpe lost his seat to Joe Oliver.

Volpe was born in Monteleone, Puglia, Italy, and moved to Canada with his family in 1955.[1] He was raised in a working-class household and earned Bachelor of Arts (1970), Bachelor of Education (1971) and Master of Education (1980) degrees from the University of Toronto. As a teacher, he taught in Stoney Creek from 1971 to 1974, headed the history department of a secondary school in Etobicoke from 1974 to 1979, and was head of multicultural studies in a college in Weston, Ontario between 1979 and 1982. He worked as a mortgage development officer in 1982-83, and was vice-principal of the J.M. McGuigan Secondary School (which he helped found) between 1983 and 1988.[2]

He is married to Mirella and they have four children: Luciano, Flavio, Letizia and Massimo.

Early political career[edit]

Volpe first became involved with the Liberal Party in the 1968 federal election, when he worked on Charles Caccia's campaign in Davenport. He ran for the North York Board of Education in the 1974 municipal election as a separate school representative, but was defeated.[3] He later ran for the Ontario legislature in the 1981 provincial election and narrowly lost to New Democratic Party incumbent Odoardo Di Santo in Downsview. The following year, he supported David Peterson for the Ontario Liberal Party leadership.[4]

Volpe subsequently chaired the sponsoring group of an immigrant counseling agency called Alliance Community Services, which received a controversial $500,000 grant from the federal government in January 1984. Local municipal politicians Howard Moscoe and Maria Rizzo charged that the ACS was a partisan organization and that the grant was political patronage; Volpe and others rejected this charge. Maria Minna, the president of COSTI-IIAS Immigrant Services, opposed the grant on the grounds that the new organization would duplicate the work of her organization.[5] Employment and Immigration Minister John Roberts retracted the grant following criticism, but later reversed himself and allowed it to proceed.[6] The ACS dissolved in early 1985.

Volpe increased his profile in the mid-1980s by recruiting many new Liberal Party members from Toronto's Italian community. He helped influence several party nomination contests, including John Nunziata's 1984 victory over Paul Hellyer in York South—Weston.[7] Some questioned Volpe's methods and suggested that he was manipulating the system by signing up "instant party members", a charge that he denied. He endorsed John Roberts in the 1984 federal Liberal leadership convention, and threw his support to Jean Chrétien on the second ballot after Roberts withdrew from the contest.[8] The winning candidate was John Turner, who led the Liberal Party to defeat in the 1984 federal election.

Volpe unsuccessfully campaigned for the presidency of the Ontario Liberal Party in 1985 and 1986, against media speculation that leading figures in the party opposed his candidacy.[9] Despite Volpe's earlier support for Chrétien, he organized a pro-Turner slate for the Liberal Party's 1986 leadership review. Turner, who was faced with public and backroom challenges since 1984, received the necessary support to consolidate his leadership.[10] Volpe spoke out against the Meech Lake Accord the following year, while most of the Liberal leadership supported it.[11]

Member of Parliament[edit]

Nomination challenge[edit]

Volpe successfully challenged sitting Liberal Member of Parliament (MP) Rev. Roland de Corneille to win the party's nomination for Eglinton—Lawrence in the 1988 election. The contest was extremely divisive, with de Corneille alleging that Volpe was "trying to organize a group for his personal advantage" in recruiting new members from the riding's Italian community.[12]

After losing the nomination, de Corneille endorsed Progressive Conservative candidate Tony Abbott, who was himself a former Liberal cabinet minister.[13] Volpe defended his right to seek the nomination, arguing that Toronto's Italian residents were seeking to play a more active role in government.[14] He also sought a reconciliation with de Corneille's supporters, many of whom were from the riding's Jewish community.[15] Despite the divisions engendered by his nomination, Volpe won a convincing victory on election day.[16]

Opposition member, 1988–1993[edit]

The Progressive Conservatives were re-elected with a majority government in the 1988 election and Volpe sat as a member of the official opposition for the next five years, serving as his party's revenue critic for part of this time.[17] During the constitutional debates of the early 1990s, he suggested that the Parliament of Canada (as opposed to the executive branch of government) should assume responsibility for reformulating the terms of Canadian Confederation. He argued that parliament represented a strong cross-section of Canada's population, saying that parliamentary initiative on constitutional reform could save millions of dollars on "needless commissions".[18]

Volpe supported Paul Martin in the 1990 federal Liberal leadership convention, which was won by Jean Chrétien.[19] He subsequently opposed some of Chrétien's reforms to the Liberal Party constitution, including a change that allowed the leader to appoint candidates in selected ridings. Several Chrétien supporters defended this as necessary to prevent "instant party members" from taking over the party nomination process; many believe the change was directed against both Volpe and the Liberals for Life group affiliated with MP Tom Wappel.[20]

Volpe remained one of Martin's most prominent Toronto-area supporters after 1990. Many political observers believe this association kept him out of cabinet during Chrétien's tenure as prime minister, from 1993 to 2003.

Government backbencher[edit]

The Liberals won a majority government in the 1993 election, and Volpe sat as a government backbencher in the parliament that followed.[21] He was elected chair of the Ontario Liberal caucus following the election, but unexpectedly lost the position to a challenge from Sue Barnes in 1995.[22] On 23 February 1996, he was appointed parliamentary secretary to the Minister of National Health and Welfare. The ministry was renamed on 12 July 1996, and Volpe's position was restyled as parliamentary secretary to the Minister of Health, a position he held until 15 July 1998.

Volpe was easily re-elected to parliament in the 1997 election. His closest opponent was Progressive Conservative candidate David Rotenberg, a former minister in the provincial government of Frank Miller. Volpe later endorsed Mel Lastman's bid to become Mayor of Toronto in 1997 municipal election.[23]

Volpe served as chair of the all-party Commons Health Committee after the 1997 election. He brought forward a report in late 1998 encouraging the sale of herbal medicines in Canada, and advocating their regulation in a category separate from foods and drugs. The following year, his committee produced a series of recommendations for improving Canada's organ donation system.[24]

Volpe was also given responsibility for overseeing Canada's investigation of a controversial vitamin-hormone cancer treatment run by Luigi di Bella in Italy. Some of Di Bella's supporters believed that his treatments actually cured cancer, and requested that their government investigate the possibility of assisting his research. Volpe led a delegation of Canadian doctors to Italy, arguing that they would either expose Di Bella as a fraud or establish the terms for assistance: they concluded there was no evidence to support the validity of his work. Volpe initially recommended that further research be conducted, arguing the doctor's treatment could lead to an improved quality of life for cancer patients even if it did not actually cure the disease.[25]

In 1999, Volpe argued that the government's proposed Citizenship Act was too restrictive and arbitrary, saying that it could result in reduced immigration to Canada. He and fellow MP Andrew Telegdi were particularly critical of a section of the bill which allowed cabinet ministers to override the judicial system in rejecting applications from immigrants.[26] He voted against the bill on its final reading in May 2000.[27]

Volpe was not promoted to cabinet in the August 1999 cabinet shuffle.[28] He served as chair of the Commons Standing Committee on Natural Resources in 2000, and developed a report for improving Canada's national highway system.[29] He also collaborated with Toronto-area MPs Derek Lee and John McKay to create a job placement and training program for at-risk youth in Toronto, called Workplace Connections.[30] He described as "unfortunate" Canada's decision to support an United Nations resolution critical of Israel in October 2000, and later argued that Canada should have abstained.[31] During the 2000 campaign, Volpe advocated tax breaks for parents who send their children to private religious schools.[32] He was re-elected without difficulty.

Volpe sought re-appointment as chair of the Natural Resources committee in 2001, but did not receive the position.[33] He became increasingly critical of the Chrétien government during the next two years, and made no secret of his support for Paul Martin to replace Chrétien as party leader. Volpe criticized the Chrétien government for moving too slowly to replace Canada's aging Sea King helicopters, and encouraged the government to purchase the EH-101 Cormorant helicopters recommended by the previous Progressive Conservative government of Brian Mulroney.[34] In November 2002, he called for the government to provide compensation for all victims of Hepatitis C who were infected through the national blood supply system, and criticized the Chrétien government's more restrictive settlement.[35] He also expressed skepticism about the Chrétien government's plans to decriminalize cannabis, saying "I believe it's a gateway drug. [...] It's going to be a pretty convincing argument to get me to vote for it."[36] He was an opponent of the government's plans to legalize same-sex marriage during this period, and voted to retain the traditional definition of marriage in 2003.[37]

Volpe worked openly for Paul Martin's bid to replace Chrétien as Liberal Party leader after June 2002, when Martin left Chrétien's cabinet under disputed circumstances. In June 2002, Volpe became one of the first sixteen Liberal MPs to publicly call for Chrétien to resign as prime minister.[38] During the same year, he became a founding member of the group Liberal Parliamentarians for Israel.[39]

Cabinet Minister[edit]

Minister of Human Resources and Skills Development[edit]

Paul Martin won an overwhelming victory in the 2003 federal Liberal leadership convention, and became Prime Minister of Canada on December 12, 2003. He appointed Volpe to cabinet as Minister of Human Resources and Skills Development, with responsibility for labour, homelessness, training, community economic development and federal student loans. He was also named as political minister for Ontario and the Greater Toronto Area, and was appointed to Martin's priorities and planning committee, known as the inner cabinet.[40] Soon after his appointment, Volpe announced that he would revamp the federal job skills and training programs to better meet the needs of employers.[41] He argued that Canada needed significant skill upgrading reforms in order to retain its long-term employment prospects.[42]

Volpe announced a new "Compassionate Care" benefit in January 2004, providing paid leave for Canadians who were forced to leave work to care for seriously ill family members.[43] In May of the same year, he introduced reforms to Canada's Employment Insurance laws making it easier for seasonal workers to apply for benefits.[44] Volpe promised a number of spending initiatives during the 2004 federal election, including $1 billion over five years for research, development and innovation in the automotive industry.[45]

The Liberals were reduced to a minority government in this election, although Volpe was re-elected by a comfortable margin in Eglinton—Lawrence. He was retained as Human Resources and Skills Development minister after the election.

In late 2004, Canadian Auditor General Sheila Fraser accused the federal government of violating the spirit of its laws by running a large surplus of Employment Insurance funds, arguing that the government was using money earmarked for the unemployed to fund separate programs. Volpe acknowledged there were problems with the EI system, but noted that rates were falling and would likely continue to fall in the future.[46]

During the same period, federal Minister of Citizenship and Immigration Judy Sgro was criticized for granting a temporary residency permit to Romanian exotic dancer who had worked on her election campaign. Sgro denied she had done anything wrong, and argued that she granted the permit on compassionate grounds. In the aftermath of the controversy, the Martin government eliminated a federal program that allowed foreign-born exotic dancers to enter the country. Volpe was given credit for this decision and was quoted as saying, "I didn't feel in the slightest bit comfortable with the program and I didn't think there was any justification for it".[47]

Minister of Citizenship and Immigration[edit]

Judy Sgro announced her resignation from cabinet on 14 January 2005, following accusations that she had offered to intervene in the immigration hearing of Harjit Singh in return for free food during the 2004 campaign (these accusations were later retracted and Sgro was cleared of any wrongdoing). Volpe was named as her successor. The Globe and Mail newspaper subsequently published an article which indicated that Sgro believed Volpe wanted her cabinet position, and further asserted that the two were rivals within the party.[48] Volpe denied that he had anything to do with Sgro's resignation and cast doubt on the veracity of the report, saying that Sgro had told him directly that she did not make the statement attributed to her.[49]

Two days after his appointment, Volpe pledged to tighten Canada's refugee system and to accelerate the processing time for individual claimants.[50] He also promised to give illegal immigrant workers the means and opportunity to attain legal status in Canada, although rejecting the option of a blanket amnesty, and pledged to promote regional immigration outside of Canada's major cities.[51] In mid-February 2005, he announced that spouses and common-law partners living in Canada without legal status would be eligible to apply under the family class sponsorship program.[52] In the same period, Volpe asked his department to work on building cases to revoke the citizenship of five suspected Nazi war criminals living in Canada.[53]

In April 2005, Volpe announced that the Martin government would fast-track the admission of 110,000 wage earning immigrants into Canada. He also announced that Canada would try to cut the waiting time for citizenship applications from 18 to 12 months, and that the Martin government would triple the number of parents and grandparents eligible to enter Canada.[54]

In late 2005, Volpe announced that his government would seek a 35% increase in immigration over five years. He noted that there was a pressing need for more skilled immigrants throughout all parts of the country, and suggested that trade skills be emphasized over university education in determining the success of individual applications.[55] Some within the Liberal Party criticized his proposal, arguing that it would be more appropriate to fix current backlogs in the immigration system.[56] Volpe also proposed legislation to make foreign-born adopted children automatic citizens of Canada.[57] After a serious earthquake struck Pakistan in October 2005, Volpe announced that the Canadian government would take steps to expedite the reunification of families affected by the tragedy.[58]

In November 2005, Volpe released a strategic plan for a national immigration policy following consultation with provincial and territorial leaders. The plan included improved recognition of immigrants with professional skills, such as doctors.[59]

Also in November, the House of Commons Immigration Committee voted 6-5 along party lines to block $168 million in new money for immigration programs. Volpe criticized the opposition committee members for voting down the funding, arguing that their decision would jeopardize several previously announced reforms. Some opposition members argued that Volpe had not adequately justified his department's spending.[60]

One of Volpe's last major acts as Immigration Minister was to announce a $920 million immigration settlement deal with the Government of Ontario on 21 November 2005. Under the terms of the deal, the money was to be earmarked to help immigrants settle, integrate, and become proficient in the English language.[61] In the same week, Volpe also announced the creation of an "in-Canada" economic class of immigrants, making it easier for people on temporary work permits to apply for citizenship. Volpe's department argued that the change would match immigrants with skill shortages, which addressing backlogs in the immigration system.[62]

Minister responsible for Ontario and for the Greater Toronto Area[edit]

In March 2004, Volpe announced the addition of nearly $8 million for existing crime prevention programs in Ontario.[63] In May of the same year, he announced that the federal government would provide $1 billion in funding for GO Transit.[64]

Also in May 2004, Volpe wrote an official letter to Toronto Mayor David Miller, promising that the federal government would not order the construction of a bridge to the Toronto City Centre Airport against the wishes of Toronto City Council. Miller had been elected in the 2003 municipal election on a promise to cancel the bridge, and had previously expressed concern that the federal Toronto Port Authority might authorize its construction even after the city withdrew support.[65] Volpe later expressed concerns about the continued viability of the Toronto Waterfront Revitalization Corp., and emerged as a prominent critic of Miller's plans for waterfront management.[66]

In May 2005, Volpe announced that the federal government would pay $35 million to the Toronto Port Authority to in compensation for the cancellation of the Toronto Island Airport Bridge.[67] In September of the same year, he announced that a 1.4-acre (5,700 m2) piece of waterfront property at Yonge St. and Queen's Quay would remain in public hands. Many regard this property as essential for any future strategy involving comprehensive waterfront renewal.[68]

Volpe remained active with issues of interest to the Italian community in Toronto, and was a prominent supporter of RAI International's bid to receive a television licence in Canada.[69]

Views and controversies[edit]

Volpe reconsidered his position on same-sex marriage in 2004, and voted with the rest of cabinet to grant legal status to same-sex marriages in 2005. Critics accused him of opportunism for changing his position. Volpe responded by arguing that he had played a contributory role in creating balanced legislation that protects the rights of both minority groups and religious institutions.[70]

In May 2005, two Conservative MPs were photographed posing with a poster from the Western Standard with the title "The Liberano$", comparing the Liberal Party to the mafia television show The Sopranos. The poster was sparked by accusations made against the Liberal Party during the federal sponsorship scandal of 2004-05. Volpe argued that the poster was offensive to Canadians of Italian heritage, and commented "These are the same Conservatives who think that every immigrant is a potential terrorist and criminal and everything else", and "Notwithstanding that they don't have their cowl and their cape, the Klan looks like they're still very much alive." The Conservative Party demanded an apology from Volpe, who acknowledged that his words "might have been a little intemperate" because of what he interpreted as a "racial slur".[71]

In September 2005, it was reported that Volpe had claimed $10,891.15 in meal and transportation expenses over an eleven-month period.[72] Opposition MPs argued that this figure was excessive, and noted that Volpe's meal expenses were more than three times higher than his predecessor as Immigration Minister, Judy Sgro, during the same period a year earlier. Volpe argued that his schedule was extremely busy, and that he had to meet with "many stakeholders" in the course of his ministerial duties. There was at least one instance of Volpe charging for two separate meals on the same night. His staff argued that he had made arrangements to meet with two groups of people on the same night, and could not cancel either meeting.[73] In March 2006, the Canadian Taxpayers Federation awarded Volpe with its 8th annual "Teddy" award as the previous year's worst offender in federal government overspending.[74]

Opposition member, 2006–2011[edit]

The three opposition parties united to bring down the Liberal government in late 2005, and a new election was called for January 2006. During the campaign, Volpe and Paul Martin announced that, if re-elected, their government would waive the $975 landing fee charged to immigrants.[75] The Liberals were defeated, however, and the Conservative Party came to office with a minority government. Volpe was again re-elected without difficulty in his own riding. Following the election, he was named as official opposition critic to the President of the Treasury Board.[76]

In early September 2006, Volpe announced that he would break with his party's official position and support a softwood lumber deal negotiated by the Conservative government with the United States of America.[77] In November of the same year, Volpe was one of fifteen Liberal MPs who voted against a resolution from Prime Minister Stephen Harper that recognized the Québécois as a nation within Canada.[78]

Leadership candidate[edit]

Joe Volpe speaking to the press at the 2006 Liberal leadership convention.

Paul Martin resigned the Liberal leadership after the election, and a new leadership contest was scheduled for late 2006. Volpe announced his candidacy on April 21, 2006. During his campaign launch, he said, "We don't need to re-invent the Party. We just need to give it back to the people who are its rightful owners. We need to take it back from the backroom players who hide behind new faces."[79] He highlighted education and training issues, and said that Canada should be more accommodating to new immigrants. Volpe also argued that Canada should return to a peacekeeping ethos in foreign affairs, rather than primarily engaging in combat missions.[80] After the party's first all-candidates debate, he accused frontrunner Michael Ignatieff of echoing the foreign policy vision of Conservative Prime Minister Stephen Harper.[81]

At the start of his campaign, Volpe was supported by Liberal MPs Jim Karygiannis, Wajid Khan, Yasmin Ratansi, Joe Comuzzi, Sukh Dhaliwal, Massimo Pacetti, and Lui Temelkovski, and former MPs Nick Discepola and Bob Speller.[82] Dhaliwal, Karygiannis and Ratansi later withdrew their support.[83]

Apotex donations[edit]

Volpe's campaign was hindered by controversy. In May 2006, the Canadian media reported that he had received $108,000 in donations from current and former executives of the drug company Apotex Inc., and each of their spouses and children. All of the donations were for $5,400, the maximum allowed for individual donations under the law, while five cheques were in the names of children under eighteen years of age. Companies are banned from donating money to a federal leadership campaign and individuals are prohibited from donating money on behalf of someone else, although donations from minors are not illegal. Critics charged that the Apotex contributions may have been an attempt to sidestep Canada's laws on corporate donations. NDP MP Pat Martin accused Volpe of deliberately orchestrating fraudulent donations and asked the Elections Commissioner to investigate whether "individuals may be trying to circumvent campaign fundraising limits". After Volpe threatened a libel suit, Martin said that his initial accusation was an overstatement but maintained that his call for an investigation was justified. While other parties criticized the donations, Liberal national director Steven MacKinnon stated that the party would not launch an investigation, arguing that it was the responsibility of Elections Canada to regulate donations.[84][85] The donations were parodied by a website called "YouthForVolpe.ca".[86]

Volpe responded by promising to return any donations that contravened the letter or spirit of the law. He returned the five cheques from minors after extensive media criticism, and denied that any laws had been broken. The controversy nonetheless damaged his candidacy.[87][88][89] Sukh Dhaliwal withdrew his support from Volpe after the controversy broke, saying "I think this thing should not happen in any campaign".[90] Other Liberals requested that Volpe withdraw from the contest due to negative publicity, but he said that this was not an option he was considering.[91] In July 2006, Volpe argued that the Federal Accountability Act should be amended to prevent persons under eighteen from contributing to political campaigns.[92]

On December 5, 2006, Elections Canada stated that Volpe had not violated election financing law in accepting the contributions.[93]

Other controversies[edit]

Jim Karygiannis, who had been Volpe's campaign chair, left the campaign on 21 July 2006 after disagreements over Volpe's staunch pro-Israel stance in the 2006 Israel-Lebanon conflict. Soon after his abrupt departure, Karygiannis called the police to prevent a Volpe official from removing computers at the campaign's Scarborough headquarters, which had been leased in Karygiannis's name. No charges were filed. There was speculation that Karygiannis's recruits were more loyal to him than to Volpe, and that his departure would create serious difficulties for Volpe's candidacy.[94]

On October 15, 2006, the Toronto Star reported that the Career Foundation, a federally funded charity serving the unemployed, had paid seven of its clients to work on Volpe's leadership campaign. The Foundation is headquartered in Volpe's Eglinton—Lawrence riding and fell under his purview during his tenure as Minister of Human Resources and Skills Development. The Star article indicated that three Foundation managers objected to paying workers in a partisan political campaign, on the grounds that it was an inappropriate use of taxpayer funds and incompatible with the foundation's charitable status.[95] The Foundation's executive director, Colin Morrison, was quoted as saying that the assignment of clients served a "higher purpose" of "help[ing] unemployed people. Volpe described the Star's report as "a total fiction", and the latest in a series of attempts to derail his campaign.[96]

Fine and appeal[edit]

On September 23, 2006, the Liberal Party investigated Volpe's campaign on suspicion of questionable recruitment tactics in Quebec. Volpe had signed up 4,000 new members in the province, more than any other candidate. Several new party members in Montreal were reported as having been improperly registered, and at least nine members were signed up by the Volpe camp without their knowledge or without paying the $10 fee. In two of the cases, the signed-up members were deceased.[97] There was speculation that Volpe would withdraw from the contest after these allegations but he declined to do so, saying that his campaign was not aware of any wrongdoing.[98] Some of Volpe's supporters suggested that Michael Ignatieff's team was running a smear campaign against him.[99] Volpe also argued that his ethnicity may have been a factor in the accusations, suggesting that they came from those who believed he was "not Canadian enough". A similar sentiment was echoed by former Public Works minister Alfonso Gagliano, banned from the party for being implicated in the Sponsorship scandal, who urged Volpe to stay in the race and fight the allegations.[100][101][102] Some prominent Liberals, including Scott Reid, were strongly critical of Volpe's response.[103]

The Liberal Party imposed a $20,000 fine on Volpe's campaign in late September, having determined that it provided membership forms to cultural groups without ensuring that new members paid their own fees. The panel found no that evidence Volpe or his senior officials knew about the problems. Volpe appealed the decision, arguing the fine was imposed "without due process" and was "designed to inflict as much damage as possible on my campaign immediately prior to the delegate selection meetings."[100]

On October 31, a Liberal Party appeals committee exonerated Volpe of improper membership sales, and withdrew the fine imposed the previous month. He was found guilty of a minor breach of the leadership candidates' code of conduct, and given a nominal fine of $1,000. Volpe accepted the ruling as vindication, and repeated his charge that the previous ruling had a prejudicial effect on delegate selection.[104] He told reporters, "I can't say I'm ecstatic because the damage has already been done".[105] Volpe's reputation in the Liberal Party, damaged by earlier controversies, recovered to some extent after the appeal.[106]

Results[edit]

Volpe fared poorly in the delegate selection meetings, and knew going into the convention that he could not win the leadership. He threw his support behind former Ontario Premier Bob Rae during the convention's "speech night", only moments after the final speech from Michael Ignatieff.[107] This decision did not affect the first ballot of voting, which took place as the speeches were being delivered. Volpe received 156 votes from the convention delegates, finishing in seventh place.

Rae released his delegates after being eliminated on the third ballot. Volpe moved to the camp of Stéphane Dion, who defeated Michael Ignatieff on the fourth ballot to win the party leadership.[108] Volpe and four other MPs who contested the Liberal leadership were named to the frontbench of the Official Opposition in parliament.[1][109]

Offices held[edit]

27th Ministry – Cabinet of Paul Martin
Cabinet Posts (2)
Predecessor Office Successor
Judy Sgro Minister of Citizenship and Immigration
2005–2006
Monte Solberg
position created in 2003 Minister of State
2003–2005
styled as Minister of Human Resources and Skills Development
Lucienne Robillard

Electoral record[edit]

Canadian federal election, 2011
Party Candidate Votes % ±pp Expenditures
Conservative Joe Oliver 22,652 46.81 +7.56
Liberal Joe Volpe 18,590 38.42 -5.57
New Democratic Justin Chatwin 5,613 11.60 +3.18
Green Paul Baker 1,534 3.17 -5.17
Total valid votes 48,389 100.00
Total rejected ballots 302 0.62 +0.12
Turnout 48,691 68.02 +8.27

Source: Elections Canada

Canadian federal election, 2008
Party Candidate Votes % ±pp Expenditures
Liberal Joe Volpe 19,133 43.99 -8.90 $46,582
Conservative Joe Oliver 17,073 39.25 +9.00 $82,193
New Democratic Justin Chatwin 3,663 8.42 -3.07 $4,729
Green Andrew James 3,629 8.34 +3.22 $6,136
Total valid votes/Expense limit 43,498 100.00 $82,294
Total rejected ballots 219 0.50
Turnout 43,717 59.75
     Liberal hold Swing -9.0


Canadian federal election, 2006: Eglinton—Lawrence
Party Candidate Votes % ±pp Expenditures
Liberal Joe Volpe 26,044 52.89 -7.35 $66,769
     Conservative Peter Coy 14,897 30.25 +5.20 $59,382
     New Democratic Party Maurganne Mooney 5,660 11.49 +1.11 $7,722
Green Patrick Metzger 2,520 5.12 +1.03 $1,338
     N/A (Communist League) John Steele 123 0.25 $369
Total valid votes 49,244 100.00
Total rejected ballots 245
Turnout 49,489 67.61 +3.84
Electors on the lists 73,201
Sources: Official Results, Elections Canada and Financial Returns, Elections Canada.


Canadian federal election, 2004: Eglinton—Lawrence
Party Candidate Votes % ±pp Expenditures
Liberal Joe Volpe 28,360 60.24 +1.07 $72,089
     Conservative Bernie Tanz 11,792 25.05 -6.88 $71,823
     New Democratic Party Max Silverman 4,886 10.38 +3.93 $8,534
Green Shel Goldstein 1,924 4.09 $2,377
     Canadian Action Corrinne Prévost 115 0.24 $0
Total valid votes 47,077 100.00
Total rejected ballots 284
Turnout 47,361 63.77
Electors on the lists 74,266
Percentage change figures are factored for redistribution. Conservative Party percentages are contrasted with the combined Canadian Alliance and Progressive Conservative percentages from 2000.
Sources: Official Results, Elections Canada and Financial Returns, Elections Canada.


Canadian federal election, 2000: Eglinton—Lawrence
Party Candidate Votes % ±pp Expenditures
Liberal Joe Volpe 25,161 60.68 +1.44 $53,652
     Progressive Conservative Louise Sankey 7,156 17.26 -5.49 $16,232
     Canadian Alliance Joel Etienne 5,497 13.26 +5.17 $18,685
     New Democratic Party Simon Rowland 2,663 6.42 -2.60 $1,577
Green Doug Howat 688 1.66 $579
Marxist–Leninist Frank Chilelli 164 0.40 $8
     Natural Law Matthew Macleod 133 0.32 -0.59 $0
Total valid votes 41,462 100.00
Total rejected ballots 263
Turnout 41,725 57.58 -9.42
Electors on the lists 72,463
Sources: Official Results, Elections Canada and Financial Returns, Elections Canada.


Canadian federal election, 1997: Eglinton—Lawrence
Party Candidate Votes % ±pp Expenditures
Liberal Joe Volpe 25,985 59.24 -4.07 $49,531
     Progressive Conservative David Rotenberg 9,977 22.75 +5.11 $34,874
     New Democratic Party Sam Savona 3,955 9.02 +4.36 $14,088
     Reform Charles Van Tuinen 3,547 8.09 -3.65 $10,529
     Natural Law Robyn Brandon 397 0.91 $0
Total valid votes 43,861 100.00
Total rejected ballots 320
Turnout 44,181 67.00
Electors on the lists 65,945
Percentage change figures are factored for redistribution.
Sources: Official Results, Elections Canada and Financial Returns, Elections Canada.


Canadian federal election, 1993: Eglinton—Lawrence
Party Candidate Votes % ±pp Expenditures
Liberal Joe Volpe 28,634 71.62 +20.60 $38,419
     Reform Charles Van Tuinen 4,347 10.87 $13,413
     Progressive Conservative Marc Monson 4,262 10.66 -20.28 $19,954
     New Democratic Party Gael Hepworth 2,091 5.23 -10.34 $12,165
     Natural Law Debbie Weberg 384 0.96 $0
Marxist–Leninist Jeanne Gatley 138 0.35 $105
     Abolitionist Linda Kruschel 124 0.31 $0
Total valid votes 39,980 100.00
Total rejected ballots 480
Turnout 40,460 68.28 -6.48
Electors on the lists 59,254
Source: Thirty-fifth General Election, 1993: Official Voting Results, Published by the Chief Electoral Officer of Canada. Financial figures taken from official contributions and expenses provided by Elections Canada.


Canadian federal election, 1988: Eglinton—Lawrence
Party Candidate Votes % ±pp Expenditures
Liberal Joe Volpe 20,446 51.02 +8.04 $33,611
     Progressive Conservative Tony Abbott 12,400 30.94 -9.35 $26,187
     New Democratic Party Vittoria Levi 6,241 15.57 +0.68 $16,036
     Libertarian Sandor L. Hegedus 538 1.34 +0.51 $0
     Communist Geoffrey da Silva 208 0.52 +0.02 $357
     N/A (Revolutionary
Workers League
)
Margaret Manwaring 123 0.31 $776
     Commonwealth James Felicioni 122 0.30 $67
Total valid votes 40,078 100.00
Total rejected ballots 565
Turnout 40,643 74.76
Electors on the lists 54,362


Ontario general election, 1981: Downsview
Party Candidate Votes % Expenditures
     New Democratic Party Odoardo Di Santo 8,644 39.10 $14,984
Liberal Joe Volpe 7,991 36.14 $17,106
     Progressive Conservative Ross Charles 5,475 24.76 $15,229
Total valid votes 22,110 100.00
Total rejected ballots 185
Turnout 22,295 58.54
Electors on the lists 38,086


1974 Toronto municipal election, North York Board of Education, Separate School Representative (Area One)edit
Candidate Total votes  % of total votes
Peter Caruso 2,393 38.77
(x)William Higgins 1,919 31.09
Joe Volpe 1,860 30.14
Total valid votes 6,172 100.00

All federal electoral information is taken from Elections Canada. Italicized expenditures from elections after 1997 refer to submitted totals, and are presented when the final reviewed totals are not available. Expenditures from 1997 refer to submitted totals.

All provincial election information is taken from Elections Ontario.

The 1974 municipal result is taken from the Toronto Star, 3 December 1974, A11. The final official result was not significantly different.

Footnotes[edit]

  1. ^ "Luciano Volpe aided son's Commons bid", Toronto Star, 13 May 1989, A8; Jane Taber, "Volpe to make an Italian homecoming", Globe and Mail, 6 November 2004, A7; Carol Goar, "The insurrection at Monteleone", Toronto Star, 10 November 2004, A30. Several of his relatives played leading roles in a local citizen's rebellion against Benito Mussolini's fascist government in 1942, the first such rebellion anywhere in Italy. See Jane Taber, "Volpe to make an Italian homecoming", Globe and Mail, 6 November 2004, A7; Carol Goar, "The insurrection at Monteleone", Toronto Star, 10 November 2004, A30.
  2. ^ In The Eighties (circa 1987) He was on staff at Brother Edmund Rice Catholic Secondary School The Federal Election: Riding Profiles, Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, 1997.
  3. ^ See Toronto Star, 30 November 1974, p. A16 for one of his campaign advertisements.
  4. ^ Joe O'Donnell, "Drop support for accord Peterson being urged", Toronto Star, 1 June 1987, A1.
  5. ^ Geoffrey York, "$500,000 grant to immigrant body is termed political", Globe and Mail, 6 January 1984. Local MP Roland de Corneille was also critical of the grant.
  6. ^ Geoffrey York, "Roberts stands by grant to disputed Italian agency", Globe and Mail, 11 April 1984, M2.
  7. ^ James Rusk and Ross Howard, "Fleming quits, infighting starts in riding", Globe and Mail, 17 July 1984, P5.
  8. ^ Richard Cleroux, "Roberts favored by Liberal block", Globe and Mail, 11 May 1984, P5; Joe O'Donnell, "Ontario Liberals choose lawyer as new president", Toronto Star, 24 March 1986, A15.
  9. ^ Ross Howard, "Spirits flag as fortunes sag for federal Grits", Globe and Mail, 22 June 1985, P5; Joe O'Donnell, "Ontario Liberals choose lawyer as new president", Toronto Star, 24 May 1986, A15.
  10. ^ Joe O'Donnell, "Turner wins 6 of 7 delegates in York North", Toronto Star, 22 October 1986, A7.
  11. ^ Joe O'Donnell, "Trudeau will keep up fight over accord Liberals say", Toronto Star, 7 June 1987, A01.
  12. ^ Ross Howard, "Liberal MP urges party to protect incumbents", Globe and Mail, 2 December 1987, A3; Dan Smith, "De Corneille in nomination showdown as Liberals fight over Eglinton-Lawrence", Toronto Star, 26 April 1988, A16.
  13. ^ Dan Smith, "Former Liberal minister seeks Tory nomination", Toronto Star, 6 October 1988, A20.
  14. ^ Linda McQuaig, "Minorities learn to win numbers game", Globe and Mail, 16 August 1988, A5.
  15. ^ Murray Campbell, "Nomination scars Liberals in Eglinton-Lawrence", Globe and Mail, 3 November 1988, A15. Volpe's nominator was Les Scheininger, who became president of the Canadian Jewish Congress in 1989. See John Allemang, "New CJC head seeks better relations with Israel", Globe and Mail, 7 April 1989, A13.
  16. ^ Paul Hoy, "'True Grit' the big winner in battle marred by dissent", Toronto Star, 29 November 1988, N12.
  17. ^ Sally Ritchie, "Small firm severely harassed owner says", Toronto Star, 18 July 1992, A10.
  18. ^ Joe Volpe, "How Commons could be used to unify country", Toronto Star, 13 May 1991, A17; Carol Goar, "MP's faith in Parliament not shared by public", Toronto Star, 14 May 1991, A17.
  19. ^ Colin Vaughan, "The City Grit Expectations", Globe and Mail, 27 April 1990, P21.
  20. ^ David Vienneau, "Eggleton stands fast in riding flap", Toronto Star, 14 November 1992, A4.
  21. ^ Tim Harper, "Silent majority GTA backbenchers have been conspicuous by their absence from parliamentary debate", Toronto Star, 30 December 1995, B1.
  22. ^ David Vienneau, "Ontario backbench revolts", Toronto Star, 22 February 1995, A19.
  23. ^ Murray Campbell, "How style closed gap in megacity mayoral race", Globe and Mail, 8 November 1997.
  24. ^ Tim Harper, "Labels urged for alternate medicines", Toronto Star, 25 March 1998, A11; Dennis Bueckert, "Door opened on herbal medicines", Hamilton Spectator, 5 November 1998, D2; Tim Harper, "Baby awaiting heart shows flaws in donor system", Toronto Star, 23 March 1999, p. 1; Tim Harper, "Network could end organ shortage in Canada", Kitchener-Waterloo Record, 23 April 1999, A01.
  25. ^ Carolyn Abraham, "Cancer-cure hysteria sweeps Italy", Globe and Mail, 28 March 1998, A1; Rebecca Bragg, "Ottawa offers help for Di Bella therapy", Toronto Star, 6 June 1998, A13; Paula Arab, "Cancer doctor says he had proof that treatment works, but no one asked", Hamilton Spectator, 11 June 1998, D3.
  26. ^ Brian Laghi, "Coalition slams citizenship proposals", Globe and Mail, 15 April 1999, A2; Philip Jalsevac, "Citizenship bill divides Liberals", Kitchener-Waterloo Record, 16 July 1999, A03.
  27. ^ Brian Caldwell, "Telegdi loses gamble, resigns as parliamentary secretary", Kitchener-Waterloo Record, 17 May 2000, A02.
  28. ^ William Walker, "When loyalty's unrewarded", Toronto Star, 5 August 1999, p. 1.
  29. ^ Allan Thompson, "Report defends forest industry", Toronto Star, 28 June 2000, p. 1; "Name: Joe Volpe", Toronto Star, 24 June 2000, p. 1.
  30. ^ William Walker, "Ottawa set to unveil job project for youth", Toronto Star, 13 July 2000, p. 1.
  31. ^ Jeff Sallot, "Backbenchers criticize Grits for signing UN resolution", Globe and Mail, 12 October 2000, A13; Louise Brown, "Mideast turmoil touches North Toronto riding", Toronto Star, 22 November 2000, p. 1.
  32. ^ Election 2000 coverage, Toronto Star, 22 November 2000, p. 1.
  33. ^ Jane Taber, "Manning phones Rock's wife post-op", National Post, 17 February 2001, A06.
  34. ^ Mike Blatchfield, "Grit MP joins helicopter backlash", National Post, 11 February 2002, A04. Volpe repeated his criticisms in May 2003. See Bill Curry, "Backbencher blasts PM for helicopter deal delay", National Post, 22 May 2003, A14.
  35. ^ John Ibbitson, "MPs ready to vote their hearts", Globe and Mail, 22 November 2002, A6.
  36. ^ Kim Lunman and Brian Laghi, "Ottawa set to preach evils of pot", Globe and Mail, 27 May 2003, A1.
  37. ^ Anne Dawson and John Ivison, "Martin says duty comes before faith", National Post, 31 July 2003, A5; Joe Volpe, "We're for due process, not against gay rights", Globe and Mail, 12 August 2003, A13.
  38. ^ Anne Dawson, "16 Liberal MPs willing to declare PM should resign", National Post, 25 July 2002, A01.
  39. ^ "Opposition and government", Joe Volpe official website, accessed 21 October 2007.
  40. ^ "New PM names 15 to inner circle", National Post, 13 December 2003, A4; Susan Delacourt, "A funny thing happened on the way to the swearing-in", Toronto Star, 20 December 2003, H03
  41. ^ Wallace Immen, "Ottawa's New Year resolutions", Globe and Mail, 19 December 2003, B22.
  42. ^ Simon Tuck, "Federal minister urges big upgrade in workers' skills", Globe and Mail, 18 March 2004, B3.
  43. ^ Darren Yourk, "Ottawa unveils compassionate-care plan", Globe and Mail, 6 January 2004.
  44. ^ Simon Tuck, "Ottawa to implement changes to EI benefits", Globe and Mail, 11 May 2004, A10.
  45. ^ "Federal Liberals vow to fuel auto industry with $500 million in subsidies", Canadian Press, 14 June 2004, 14:47 report.
  46. ^ Simon Tuck, "Auditor-General slams Ottawa for running massive EI surplus", Globe and Mail, 24 November 2004, B5.
  47. ^ "Canada ends permit program for foreign strippers", Reuters News, 1 December 2004, 16:27 report.
  48. ^ Michael Den Tandt and Maria Jimenez, "Downfall politically motivated, minister says", Globe and Mail, 15 January 2005, p. 1.
  49. ^ "Interview with Joe Volpe", Question Period, 16 January 2005; http://sympaticomsn.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/1105686456318_27?hub=topstories
  50. ^ "Canada's new immigration minister appears to be hitting the ground running", Broadcast News, 16 January 2005, 03:09 report.
  51. ^ Nicholas Keung, "Volpe says he will smooth pathway for illegal workers", Toronto Star, 5 February 2005, F08. Volpe initially intended to include a proposal for legalizing undocumented workers in a late 2005 legislative package, but later withdrew the measure. See Anne Dawson, "Liberals set to boost immigrant numbers", National Post, 27 October 2005, A12.
  52. ^ Nicholas Keung, "New rule lets spouses with no status stay", Toronto Star, 19 February 2005, A21.
  53. ^ Brian Laghi, "Volpe moves against Nazi war-crimes suspects, sources say", Globe and Mail, 11 June 2005, A8.
  54. ^ "Immigration minister reveals plan to fast-track 110,000 applicants", Canadian Press, 17 April 2005, 15:16 report; Randall Palmer, "Policy initiatives raise Canadian election fever", Reuters News, 18 April 2005, 16:38 report; Catherine Solyom, "Ottawa triples number of parents who can immigrate", National Post, 19 April 2005, A8.
  55. ^ Alexander Pannetta, "Ottawa to unveil plan to attract 40 per cent more immigration to Canada", Canadian Press, 23 September 2005, 15:49 report; Campbell Clark, "Ottawa set to announce immigration overhaul", Globe and Mail, 24 September 2005, A7; Elizabeth Thompson, "Immigrant job skill criteria needs 'fix'", Calgary Herald, 8 October 2005, A3.
  56. ^ Anne Dawson, "PM's immigration pledge draws fire", Calgary Herald, 2 October 2005.
  57. ^ Alexander Pannetta, "Feds plan changes to make adopted babies instant citizens", Canadian Press, 3 October 2005, 16:38 report.
  58. ^ "Canada speeds up immigration for Pakistan's quake affected", Hindustan Times, 13 October 2005.
  59. ^ "Immigration ministers agree on national plan", Winnipeg Free Press, 5 November 2005, A13.
  60. ^ Bruce Campion-Smith, "Immigration pledge at risk", Kitchener-Waterloo Record, 3 November 2005, A1; Elizabeth Thompson, "Immigration plan in limbo after committee defeat", Montreal Gazette, 3 November 2005.
  61. ^ Steve Erwin, "Ontario, Ottawa sign $920-million immigration settlement deal", Canadian Press, 21 November 2005, 14:52 report.
  62. ^ Bruce Campion-Smith, "Becoming Canadian to be easier for skilled", Toronto Star, 24 November 2005, A08; "Liberals announce $700-million plan to clear immigration backlog", Broadcast News, 24 November 2005, 11:26 report.
  63. ^ "Ontario crime-prevention projects get nearly $8 million in federal funding", Canadian Press, 4 March 2004, 11:00 report.
  64. ^ Kevin McGran, "GO Transit gets $1B boost", Toronto Star, 8 May 2004, E01.
  65. ^ Martin Patriquin, "Miller glad to get bridge promise in writing", National Post, 25 May 2004, A19.
  66. ^ Christopher Home, "Waterfront is a quagmire", Toronto Star, 2 November 2004, B05; Royson James, "Waterfront job is suddenly a prize", Toronto Star, 22 November 2004, B04. The TWRC is managed by the federal, provincial and municipal levels of government.
  67. ^ Hicham Safieddine and Royson James, "Bridge battle finally over", Toronto Star, 4 May 2005, B01.
  68. ^ Kerry Gillespie, "Piece of the puzzle falls into place at lakefront", Toronto Star, 13 September 2005, A02.
  69. ^ Mary Gordon, "Italy to lobby over TV channel", Toronto Star, 15 October 2004, A08.
  70. ^ Sue Bailey and Joan Bryden, "Liberal Party officially endorses gay marriage as protest heats up", Canadian Press, 5 March 2005, 17:09 report.
  71. ^ "Joe Volpe lashed out at the Conservatives", CTV News, 3 May 2005; "Angry Canadian minister rueful after Klan outburst", Reuters News, 4 May 2005, 13:08 report.
  72. ^ http://cnews.canoe.ca/CNEWS/Politics/2006/01/17/pf-1398259.html "Volpe's $1G limo ride", 17 January 2006, Alan Findlay
  73. ^ "Argy-bargy sends MPs in search of dictionaries", Edmonton Journal, 1 October 2005, A14, Daniel LeBlanc, "Volpe blasted over pricey dinners", Globe and Mail, 21 September 2005, A4; "Volpe bills taxpayers almost $7,000 for 31 meals", CTV, 21 September 2005, 6:40 report.
  74. ^ Terry Pedwell, "Former federal minister, Manitoba among winners of dubious taxpayers award", Canadian Press, 1 March 2006, 11:55 report.
  75. ^ Allan Woods, "Liberals woo new Canadians", National Post, 4 January 2006, A5.
  76. ^ Juliet O'Neill, "Liberals name a critic and a spare", National Post, 23 February 2006, A8.
  77. ^ "Most Liberals are expected to vote against Canada-U.S. softwood deal", Canadian Press, 8 September 2006, 15:23 report.
  78. ^ Allan Woods and Mike De Souza, "Tory resigns over 'nation'", National Post, 28 November 2006, A1.
  79. ^ Terry Weber, Allison Dunfield & Scott Deveau, "Liberal leadership candidates", Globe and Mail, 8 May 2006.
  80. ^ John Ivison, "Rae wants early end to Afghan mission: Liberals at odds", National Post, 8 June 2006, A1.
  81. ^ Susan Delacourt, "Volpe attack jolts Liberal race", Toronto Star, 18 June 2006, A02.
  82. ^ Campbell Clark, "The Liberal Contenders", Globe and Mail, 27 April 2006, A4; Campbell Clark, "Colleagues to present Volpe as a contender", Globe and Mail, 21 April 2006, A6.
  83. ^ The departures of Dhaliwal and Karygiannis are mentioned elsewhere in this article. For Ratansi, see "Yasmin Ratansi joins Prominent Liberal Women to Support Michael Ignatieff", Ignatieff campaign press release, 22 August 2006, accessed 10 September 2006.
  84. ^ FED -Liberals refuse to investigate Volpe donations 31 May 2006
  85. ^ "Volpe returns controversial campaign donations". CTV.ca. 2006-06-02. Retrieved 2008-08-05. 
  86. ^ John Ibbitson, "Mr. V, the kiddies and Liberal woes", Globe and Mail, 2 June 2006, A4.
  87. ^ Juliet O'Neill, "Campaign cash from kids returned", Montreal Gazette, 2 June 2006, A10.
  88. ^ "NDP wants Volpe leadership donations probed", CTV news, 30 May 2006, 6:38 report; Campbell Clark, "Executives' donations to Volpe draw fire", Globe and Mail, A1.
  89. ^ Joan Bryden, "Volpe vows to return donations if they violate spirit of law", Canadian Press, 31 May 2006, 18:19 report.
  90. ^ Peter O'Neil, "B.C. MP withdraws support of Volpe", Vancouver Sun, 7 June 2006, A6.
  91. ^ Les Whittington, "Volpe pressured to quit race", Toronto Star, 9 June 2006, A01; Juliet O'Neill, "Volpe damaged reputation of Liberals, Ignatieff charges", Ottawa Citizen, 10 June 2006, A10; Carolyn Bennett, "Liberal leadership race: There's an elephant in the room", Globe and Mail, 14 July 2006, A15.
  92. ^ Daniel LeBlanc, "Volpe seeks tighter restrictions on donations", Globe and Mail, 4 July 2006, A4.
  93. ^ "Back to work for Liberal MP after leadership bid", Town Crier Online, January 8, 2007
  94. ^ Linda Diebel, "Tempers flare in Volpe camp dispute", Toronto Star, 26 July 2006, A1.
  95. ^ "Was taxpayer money used improperly?", Toronto Star, October 15, 2006
  96. ^ "Volpe faces fresh campaign allegations", CBC.ca, October 16, 2006
  97. ^ "Volpe to respond to controversy on Monday", CTV News, 23 September 2006, 11:18 report.
  98. ^ "Volpe won't let allegations stop his leadership bid". CBC News, 25 September 2006.
  99. ^ "Volpe vows to keep running despite allegations", CTV.ca, 25 September 2006
  100. ^ a b "Liberal party fines Volpe $20,000". CBC News, 29 September 2006.
  101. ^ Joanne Chianello, "Stop playing the culture card" [editorial], Ottawa Citizen, 28 September 2006, A13.
  102. ^ "Volpe victim of racism", CanWest News Service
  103. ^ "Liberals", CTV News, 30 September 2006. Reid was quoted as saying that the second-tier candidates in the Liberal leadership race "can all find something to be proud of with the exception of Joe Volpe whose campaign has not covered himself or this party in glory."
  104. ^ Campbell Clark, "Liberals back off $20,000 fine against Volpe", Globe and Mail, 2 November 2006, A14.
  105. ^ Norma Greenaway, "Volpe fine cancelled, but 'damage done'", Ottawa Citizen, 2 November 2006, A4.
  106. ^ "Volpe now everybody's friend", Kitchener-Waterloo Record, 1 December 2006, A3.
  107. ^ "Volpe crosses floor to join Rae, Toronto Star, 1 December 2006, accessed 8 December 2006.
  108. ^ Kevin Dougherty and Andy Riga, "Losing candidates ponder future", Montreal Gazette, 3 December 2006, A2.
  109. ^ Juliet O'Neill, "Dion gathers his ex-rivals for attack", Montreal Gazette, 5 December 2006, A4.

External links[edit]