User talk:Spidey104

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search


If you post to my talk page I will respond here, unless my response is requested on a previously started discussion page. If I posted to your talk page I have no preference if you respond on your talk page or on mine.

Movies and sets[edit]

Re your move, I am not at all familiar with WP film protocols and I have attachment to movies vs films, but am I wrong in thinking that as the name of the visitor centre would appear to be "Hobbiton Movie Set", that this move should either be reversed, or amended to "Hobbiton movie set"? Ben MacDui 12:50, 11 February 2015 (UTC)

If the location was in fact named "Hobbiton Movie Set" I believe that would be the correct name for the article, but based on this link the tour site is called "Hobbiton Tours" and they refer to it as "the Hobbiton movie set" but it is not named "Hobbiton Movie Set." It's a subtle difference, but for Wikipedia protocol it is important, because the Wikipedia standard is to call movies films. The Film WikiProject is the place to look for more information. If you disagree with my assessment of the situation I am more than willing to continue discussing it here. Cheers! Spidey104 21:43, 11 February 2015 (UTC)
Well the website is hobbitontours.com but just about the first thing on the home page is "Discover the real Middle-Earth at the Hobbiton™ Movie Set". I have a mini-guide book. Somewhat confusingly the front page says:
  • hobbiton movie set & farm tours
  • from the lord of the rings trilogy
  • Hobbiton Movie Set
The upper and lower cases above are per the document.Ben MacDui 18:38, 12 February 2015 (UTC)
You do have a point with the information you just posted, but I'm not an expert on naming conventions. I would suggest starting a move discussion on the talk page so other editors can post their opinions and come to a consensus that is in line with the naming conventions. Spidey104 19:51, 12 February 2015 (UTC)
Done. I will alert WikiProject Film too. Ben MacDui 19:33, 15 February 2015 (UTC)

Re: Spider-Man storyline list[edit]

If you feel it's ready then I am ok with you setting up as an article now. Definitely with all the work I am done. I am exhausted! Even if I feel it's ready I would be more comfortable if we cite all part of the list at one point. I usually feel more comfortable about the quality of the article that way. Feel free to fix any mistakes I might have done too. Happy editing!. Jhenderson 777 02:21, 25 April 2015 (UTC)