1987 Whittier Narrows earthquake
|Date||1 October 1987|
|Origin time||14:42 (UTC) |
|Magnitude||5.9 ML |
|Depth||14 km (8.7 mi) |
|Areas affected||Southern California
|Total damage||$358 million |
|Max. intensity||VIII (Destructive) |
|Peak acceleration||.63g at 7215 Bright Ave., Whittier |
|Aftershocks||5.3 ML October 4 at 10:59 UTC |
|Casualties||8 killed |
The 1987 Whittier Narrows earthquake occurred in the southern San Gabriel Valley and surrounding communities of southern California at 7:42 a.m. PDT on October 1. The moderate 5.9 magnitude blind thrust earthquake was centered several miles north of Whittier in the town of Rosemead, had a relatively shallow depth, and was felt throughout southern California and southern Nevada. A large number of homes and businesses were impacted, along with roadway disruptions, mainly in Los Angeles and Orange counties. Damage totals amounted to $358 million USD, with many injuries, three directly-related deaths, and five additional fatalities that were associated with the event.
Mercalli Intensity values for the greater Los Angeles area varied with ranges from VI (Strong) to VII (Very Strong). Only Whittier experienced a level of VIII (Destructive), the highest experienced during the event, with the historic uptown area suffering the greatest damage. A separate M5.3 strike-slip aftershock occurred three days later and several kilometers to the northwest that also caused damage and one additional death. Because of the earthquake activity in the Los Angeles Metropolitan area, buildings and other public structures had been equipped with accelerometers, and both the mainshock and the primary aftershock provided additional data for seismologists to analyze and compare with other southern California events.
Beginning with the 1983 Coalinga earthquake, a blind thrust event in the central coast ranges of California, a change in perspective was brought about regarding these types of (concealed) faults. The October 1987 shock occurred on a previously unrecognized blind thrust fault that is now known as the Puente Hills thrust system. The fault was delineated by the mainshock and aftershock focal mechanisms, fault plane reflection studies, and high resolution seismic profiles, which also revealed that the fault runs from downtown Los Angeles to near Puente Hills. The system is considered a one of the highest risk faults in the United States due to its moderate dip and its location under a large metropolitan area.
The main shock occurred near the northwestern border of the Puente Hills 3 kilometers (1.9 mi) north of the Whittier Narrows at a depth of 14 kilometers (8.7 mi). First motion polarities, along with modelling of teleseismic P and S-waves, established that the thrust fault responsible for the shock strikes east-west with a dip of 25° dip to the north. The shock was located adjacent to the west-northwest striking Whittier fault, which is primarily a strike-slip fault, but also has a minor thrust component.
Although most of the Los Angeles metropolitan area saw shaking in line with Mercalli Intensity values of VI (Strong) or VII (Very Strong), Whittier experienced effects consistent with MMI values of VIII (Destructive). The old commercial district saw the worst damage, as these were the oldest buildings, and were also heavily damaged in the 1929 Whittier earthquake, a shock may have been a result of movement on the Norwalk Fault.
The 7:42 a.m. shock was the strongest in the Los Angeles area since the 1971 San Fernando earthquake and was felt as far as San Diego and San Luis Obispo, California and Las Vegas, Nevada. Communication systems and local media were temporarily impaired and power was cut, leaving numerous early morning workers stranded in disabled elevators. Other minor disruptions included a number of water and gas main breaks, shattered windows and some ceiling collapses. Like the San Fernando earthquake, transportation systems were again affected, but this time it was only the Santa Ana Freeway and San Gabriel River Freeways that were closed near Santa Fe Springs after pieces of concrete were dislodged and cracks were observed in the roadway. Los Angeles County+USC Medical Center took a large number of the injured, whose injuries were summarized by an emergency room spokesman as very bad to minor, and three people died as a direct result.
While total casualties amounted to eight, the destruction of homes was significant. Throughout Los Angeles, Orange, and Ventura counties, 123 homes and 1,347 apartments were destroyed, and an additional 513 homes and 2,040 apartments were damaged. An inspection of a highway bridge on Interstate 605 revealed that there were fractures on the support columns, which resulted in a temporary closure, and minor damage affected 28 other bridges. Other typical failures included more than 1,000 gas leaks, with many resulting in fire, ceramic elements on high-voltage substation equipment breaking, and phone systems becoming overwhelmed.
Caltech scientists recorded the events on a cluster of twelve strong motion sensors that were placed throughout the region with a total of 87 channels of recorded data. Nine of these instruments were located on the Caltech campus, two were at the nine story Jet Propulsion Laboratory building 180 (ten miles northwest of the campus) and the final device was placed on a hillside 5 km to the west. Investigation of the accelerograms from these units revealed the strongest shaking lasted 4–5 seconds. The vertical accelerations were considered relatively high and early analysis (pre-digitilization) indicated that the mainshock was complex, with a double train of P-waves arriving with a 1.4–1.8 second interval.
The National Strong-Motion Instrumentation Network (NSMIN) (a cooperative effort including the United States Geological Survey and other organizations) also monitored a set of 52 strong motion stations in the Los Angeles area. Most of the stations successfully captured the event, and the closest unit to the mainshock, a rock site at Garvey Reservoir, recorded a peak horizontal acceleration of .47g. A twelve-story steel frame building in Alhambra was outfitted with accelerographs in the basement, at mid-level, and at the top of the structure. The top floor instruments recorded a peak acceleration of .18g during the 1971 San Fernando earthquake and instruments on the sixth floor recorded a peak acceleration of .47g at the time of the Whittier mainshock. A ten-story reinforced concrete building in Whittier (7215 Bright Ave.) saw a peak horizontal reading of .63g in the basement.
|5.3 ML||Oct 4, 1987 at 10:59||VII|
|4.7 ML||Feb 11, 1988 at 15:25||VI|
|Stover & Coffman 1993, pp. 98, 178–180|
A magnitude 5.3 aftershock occurred three days later on October 4, causing additional damage in Alhambra, Pico Rivera, Los Angeles, and Whittier. The shock's effects were assessed at VII (Very Strong) on the Mercalli Intensity Scale with damaged chimneys, broken windows, and the collapse of two bell towers at the San Gabriel Civic Auditorium. This event was also responsible several injuries and one additional death. On February 11 of the following year another small aftershock again damaged chimneys, broke windows, cracked drywall and some homes' foundations in Pico Rivera, Pasadena, and Whittier.
The October 4 aftershock struck 3 kilometers (1.9 mi) to the northwest of the mainshock, and was primarily a strike-slip event on a steeply dipping, northwest-striking fault. The origin of faulting for this event was at a depth of 12 km (7.5 mi), which places it within the hanging wall of the thrust fault that was responsible for the main shock.
This aftershock was recorded on thirty of the NSMIN stations at distances of up to 57 kilometers (35 mi). The majority of the stations were located in buildings, but nine were located at dams or reservoirs, and four were at Veterans Administration buildings. Lighter accelerations were observed than the main shock, with peak accelerations in the range of .15g–.33g, all occurring at six stations that were within 12 kilometers (7.5 mi) of the epicenter.
The 1929 Whittier earthquake occurred on July 8 with a local magnitude of 4.7 and maximum perceived intensity of VII (Very Strong) on the Mercalli Intensity scale. The shock occurred at a depth of 13 kilometers (8.1 mi) and was most intense to the southwest of the city, where a school and two homes were heavily damaged and other homes sustained chimney collapses. In Santa Fe Springs, oil towers were damaged and some short cracks appeared in the ground. This earthquake was felt from Mount Wilson to Santa Ana, and from Hermosa Beach to Riverside. Numerous aftershocks occurred in the first several hours and persisted through early 1931.
In order to gather funds to help the rebuilding effort, the city of Whittier approved the establishment of a 521-acre earthquake recovery redevelopment area. Through this initiative, property tax revenue is directed to the city rather than to the county and schools, the originally designated recipients. The arrangement will remain in effect until the year 2037.
A nonprofit organization called the Whittier Conservancy was formed shortly after the Whittier Narrows earthquake. The group aids in the preservation of the city's historical style of construction. During the earthquake, several notable buildings were destroyed, including the Harvey Apartments. They were built with bricks that appeared to have been made by hand during the 19th century; the mud used to make them came from the San Gabriel River. The Conservancy felt that these bricks were worth saving, not only for the historical value, but also for their aesthetics.
Some effort was made to save and use the bricks for rebuilding the historic apartment on the corner of Greenleaf Avenue and Hadley Street. They spent $15,000 to prevent the usable bricks from being taken during the final demolition of the building. The bricks were then cleaned, then stored until they could be used in the rebuilding of the apartment. The Whittier Conservancy also collaborated in the rezoning of the Hadley neighborhood and was able to help control the rate of new multiple-family dwelling construction.
- Stover & Coffman 1993, p. 98
- Stover & Coffman 1993, pp. 178–180
- Etheredge, E. C.; Porcella, R. L. (1987), Strong-motion data from the October 1, 1987 Whittier Narrows earthquake, Geological Survey Open-File Report OSMS 87-616, United States Geological Survey, pp. 1, 3
- Yeats, Robert (2012), Active Faults of the World, Cambridge University Press, pp. 110, 111, ISBN 978-0521190855
- Hauksson, E.; Jones, L. M.; Davis, T. L.; Hutton, L. K.; Williams, P.; Bent, A. L.; Brady, A. G.; Reasenberg, P. A.; Michael, A. J.; Yerkes, R. F.; Etheredge, E.; Porcella, R. L.; Johnston, M. J.S.; Reagor, G.; Stover, C. W. (1988), "The 1987 Whittier Narrows Earthquake in the Los Angeles Metropolitan Area, California", Science (American Association for the Advancement of Science) 239 (4846): 1409,1410, doi:10.1126/science.239.4846.1409
- Eric Malnic (October 1, 1987). "6.0 Quake Rocks L.A. : At Least 3 Dead, Scores Hurt, Buildings Damaged : Woman Dies at Cal Man Trapped in Tunnel". Los Angeles Times.
- Levine, M. P.; Beck, J. L.; Iwan, W. D.; Jennings, P. C.; Relles, R. (1988), Accelerograms recorded at Caltech during the Whittier Narrows earthquakes of October 1 and 4, 1987: a preliminary report, EERL 88-01, California Institute of Technology, pp. 3, 5, 6
- Etheredge, E. C.; Porcella, R. L. (1988), Strong-motion data from the Whittier Narrows aftershock of October 4, 1987, Geological Survey Open-File Report OSMS 88-38, United States Geological Survey, p. 1
- Stover & Coffman 1993, pp. 77, 128
- Wood, H. O.; Richter, C. F. (1931), "Recent earthquakes near Whittier, California", Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America (Seismological Society of America) 21 (3): 183–203
- Sandra T. Molina (September 28, 2007). "Whittier's Big One: 2 decades later". Whittier Daily News.
- Tina Daunt (August 31, 1989). "Whittier Conservancy Fights for 100-Year-Old Bricks". Los Angeles Times.
- Los Angeles Times (May 24, 1995). "Whittier : Conservancy Honored for Preservation Work". Los Angeles Times.
- Stover, C. W.; Coffman, J. L. (1993), Seismicity of the United States, 1568-1989 (Revised), U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1527, United States Government Printing Office
- Whittier Narrows earthquake – Southern California Earthquake Center
- Whittier Narrows, California - 1987 October 01 UTC 14:42 - Magnitude 5.9 – USGS
- Whittier Narrows, California - 1987 October 04 10:59:38 UTC - Magnitude 5.6 – USGS