Legitimacy of the State of Israel

The phrase “delegitimization of Israel” characterizes the rhetorical demonization of Israel, holding Israel to a double-standard, and denying Israel’s right to defend itself, all in pursuit of discrediting Israel, damaging its reputation, and isolating it globally. It has been used as early as the 1970s. It is often used in contrast to 'criticism of israel'. Barack Obama, Joe Biden, Benjamin Netanyahu, Michael Oren, Mahmoud Abbas and others have used the term.

Etymology and Usage

Delegitimizers use myths and misinformation.

According to the Israeli Deputy Foreign Minister Danny Ayalon quoted on the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs website, delegitimization makes it difficult for either Israelis or Palestinians to live peacefully in present-day Israel, due to the consistent violence, religious intolerance, and political struggles. Thomas Friedman, writing in the New York Times, says “for 100 years, through violence and delegitimization, Israelis and Palestinians have made sure that the other was never allowed to really feel at home in Israel.

Anti-Semitism and Anti-Zionism

Natan Sharansky, head of the Jewish Agency, discussed a “3-D” test for determining new antisemitism. The third of the three D's is delegitimization. He explains "when Israel's fundamental right to exist is denied - alone among all peoples in the world - this too is anti-Semitism."

Canadian Foreign Minister John Baird has characterized Israel’s delegitimization as the new antisemitism.

Delegitimization and the BDS Movement

Though not synonymous, delegitimization is often part Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions campaigns.

United Nations Resolution 3379: Zionism is Racism

The United Nations and its subsidiaries have also been identified as participating in the delegitimization of Israel. In 1979, The UN passed Resolution 3379, in the United Nations General Assembly which determined that ‘Zionism is a form of racism.” United States ambassador to the UN, Daniel Patrick Moynihan likened the resolution to delegitimizaton.

George Will, writing about then US president George H.W. Bush, then Secretary of State James Baker, and UN Resolution 3379, said that this “resolution is integral to the UN's principal enterprise: the delegitimization of Israel.”

Durban Conference

The World Conference against Racism 2001, later known as Durban I, was a UN sponsored event to present an international front against racism, xenophobia and intolerance. Instead, with the encouragement of some NGOs, the conference became a source of basic delegitimization against Israel. Gerald Steinberg, president of NGO Monitor says that “The delegitimization of Israel by NGOs did not begin at Durban in September 2001, although that conference was doubtless a peak in the process.”

Steinberg also says that donors to non-governmental organizations and governments are “involved in the Durban strategy based on delegitimization campaigns targeting Israel.”

UN anti-Israel resolutions

According to Irwin Cotler, the lopsided number of anti-Israel resolutions passed by the UN is an example of delegitimization.

UN Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable rights of the Palestinian People

According to several members of the European Parliament, the UN Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People, “despite the neutrally sounding title of its conference, CEIRPP has a proven record of anti-Israel bias, spreading propaganda that presents only the Palestinian narrative, including the delegitimization of Israel - a UN member state.”

Use of violence and right to defend itself

Delegitimization of the adversary, among all the psychological themes, is “one of the major detrimental forces that turns a conflict to be vicious and violent, while preventing its peaceful resolution”

Some argued that demands for Israel to not enter into Gaza and defeat Hamas during Operation Pillar of Defense, is a “delegitimization of Israel's right to defend itself.”.

Tzipi Livni said that "the threat of delegitimization intensifies other threats facing Israel, and limits our ability to protect ourselves.”

Perspectives and Prevalence

United States

US President Barack Obama said in a May 2011 speech “for the Palestinians, efforts to delegitimize Israel will end in failure. Symbolic actions to isolate Israel at the United Nations in September won't create an independent state.”

Canada

Canadian Foreign Minister John Baird said that the “constant barrage of rhetorical demonization, double standards and delegitimization” of Israel is the new anti-Semitism.

Irwin Cotler, former Canadian Attorney General, said that delegitimization is “masked under the current discourse”. It is hidden in the anti-Israel resolutions passed by the UN, universal jurisdiction is “often abused” regarding Israel, it is “laundered under the cover of human rights”, and is hidden behind the use of accusations of racism and apartheid.

Israel

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, in discussing Israel's legitimacy, said, “we know that the attacks on Israel are threatening its existence, since we constantly hear people saying 'go back to Poland or Morocco'. They are essentially telling us to dismantle the Zionist enterprise."

Netanyahu said “the delegitimization of Israel in the face of attempts to destroy it is one of the great moral failures of our time.”

Israeli Ambassador to the United States, Michael Oren, said “increasingly the delegitimization campaign focuses not on Israel’s policy in the territories but on its essence as the Jewish national state.”

Amos Yadlin, former head of Israeli intelligence said that “delegitimization of Israel is a graver threat than war.”

Palestinian Authority

Palestinian Authoriy leader Mahmoud Abbas, said while speaking at the UN regarding Palestinian recognition, "We did not come here seeking to delegitimize a state established years ago, and that is Israel.”

Others

Abraham Foxman said that “if not for the continued Palestinian delegitimization of Israel, Mustafa Barghouthi's hope of a sovereign Palestinian state could have been realized years ago”.

Roger Cohen, writing in the New York Times, says "what Israel in turn must realize — before it is too late — is that the real threat it faces today is not one of destruction but of delegitimization. The armed conflict between Israel and Palestinian Terror entities has given anti-Israeli protesters much material for delegitimization. As a result, contradictory and one-sided accounts of Arab-Israeli events have become commonplace, particularly on western university campuses – where much delegitimization work has been focused.”

Israel is facing a global campaign of delegitimization, according to a report by the Reut Institute

MJ Rosenberg wrote that “Israel can't be delegitimized.” He argues that the Israel occupation of the West Bank leads to delegitimization, and that "the leading delegitimizer is Binyamin Netanyahu."

Combatting Delegitimization

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said, "the delegitimization [of Israel] must be delegitimized.”

The Israel-based Jewish Agency has 400 emissaries around the world fighting delegitimization.

US President Barack Obama has said, “whenever an effort is made to delegitimize the state of Israel, my administration has opposed them.”

US Vice President Joseph Biden said, regarding United States-Israeli Relations, that “to put it bluntly, there is only one nation -- only one nation in the world that has unequivocally, without hesitation and consistently confronted the efforts to delegitimize Israel.”

Canadian Prime Minister, Stephen Harper said "When Israel – the only country in the world whose very existence is under attack – is consistently and conspicuously singled out for condemnation, I believe we are morally obligated to take a stand," and that it is everyone's responsibility to stand up to the "'three D's – demonization, double standards and delegitimization-- of Israel."

See also

• Israel
• Zionism
• Anti-Zionism
• Timeline of Anti-Zionism
• New antisemitism
• Anti-globalization and antisemitism
• Arab Anti-Semitism
• Zionist entity