Talk:Turlough McHenry O'Neill: Difference between revisions
Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
:@[[User:Johannes Schade]] Thanks for the notification and the compliment :-) The article had the wrong name for a start so I moved it. Turlough as grandson of Hugh O'Neill was a member of the clan ''derbfine'' [those eligible for the kingship]. It consisted of three generations from one who had been chief, with the sons of a chiefs daughters having as much a claim as the eldest son of a chief. Hugh O'Neill had been chief of Tyrone, thus Turlough McHenry was an eligible successor in Gaelic law if he could muster enough support. In English law he was quite far down the line of succession for the earldom. [[User:Mabuska|Mabuska]] <sup>[[User_talk:Mabuska|(talk)]]</sup> 20:22, 14 November 2022 (UTC) |
:@[[User:Johannes Schade]] Thanks for the notification and the compliment :-) The article had the wrong name for a start so I moved it. Turlough as grandson of Hugh O'Neill was a member of the clan ''derbfine'' [those eligible for the kingship]. It consisted of three generations from one who had been chief, with the sons of a chiefs daughters having as much a claim as the eldest son of a chief. Hugh O'Neill had been chief of Tyrone, thus Turlough McHenry was an eligible successor in Gaelic law if he could muster enough support. In English law he was quite far down the line of succession for the earldom. [[User:Mabuska|Mabuska]] <sup>[[User_talk:Mabuska|(talk)]]</sup> 20:22, 14 November 2022 (UTC) |
||
::Dear [[User:Mabuska|Mabuska]]. Thanks for your intervention and especially for correcting the name and for explaining ''derbfine'' to me. I had seen that word being thrown around but had not understood until now. However, I would not think that being a member of the derbfine gives notability. With [[Hugh O'Neill, Earl of Tyrone]] having been married at least four times, there must have been a big number of people in his derbfine (which might also include his illegitimate children). It seems [[Shane O'Neill (Irish exile)]], called "El Conde de Tyrone", followed him as 3rd earl (ignoring the attainder). But who followed him as The O'Neill? Perhaps it does not matter. I still think notability is not demonstrated. With many thanks and best regards, [[User:Johannes Schade|Johannes Schade]] ([[User talk:Johannes Schade|talk]]) 10:09, 16 November 2022 (UTC) |
::Dear [[User:Mabuska|Mabuska]]. Thanks for your intervention and especially for correcting the name and for explaining ''derbfine'' to me. I had seen that word being thrown around but had not understood until now. However, I would not think that being a member of the derbfine gives notability. With [[Hugh O'Neill, Earl of Tyrone]] having been married at least four times, there must have been a big number of people in his derbfine (which might also include his illegitimate children). It seems [[Shane O'Neill (Irish exile)]], called "El Conde de Tyrone", followed him as 3rd earl (ignoring the attainder). But who followed him as The O'Neill? Perhaps it does not matter. I still think notability is not demonstrated. With many thanks and best regards, [[User:Johannes Schade|Johannes Schade]] ([[User talk:Johannes Schade|talk]]) 10:09, 16 November 2022 (UTC) |
||
:::It also included illegitimate children. Why do you think there were so many dynastic wars in Gaelic culture with so many claimnants lol? Unofficial 3rd Earl as the title was forfeited with Hugh's attainder. I don't know who successed that Shane as The O'Neill, but it's now held by Portugese descendants of the Clandeboy branch according to [https: |
:::It also included illegitimate children. Why do you think there were so many dynastic wars in Gaelic culture with so many claimnants lol? Unofficial 3rd Earl as the title was forfeited with Hugh's attainder. I don't know who successed that Shane as The O'Neill, but it's now held by Portugese descendants of the Clandeboy branch according to [https://www.bhsportugal.org%2Fuploads%2Ffotos_artigos%2Ffiles%2FONeills_in_Portugal2.pdf&usg=AOvVaw3MTZ7Y9KqgHg1zkW64yAZh this pdf] on the Portugese O'Neill's. Ironically it was the British College of Arms they applied to and got granted their petition to be head of all the O'Neill's, not Gaelic law. |
||
:::In regards to actual notability, there isn't much on this guy is there? He died in battle and was the father of the 1641 rebellion leader Phelim O'Neill and that seems to be it. However, where else would this information be collected too out of curiousity? [[User:Mabuska|Mabuska]] <sup>[[User_talk:Mabuska|(talk)]]</sup> 18:11, 18 November 2022 (UTC) |
:::In regards to actual notability, there isn't much on this guy is there? He died in battle and was the father of the 1641 rebellion leader Phelim O'Neill and that seems to be it. However, where else would this information be collected too out of curiousity? [[User:Mabuska|Mabuska]] <sup>[[User_talk:Mabuska|(talk)]]</sup> 18:11, 18 November 2022 (UTC) |
Revision as of 18:11, 18 November 2022
![]() | This article is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.
Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.
Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.
|
Change of citation style
Dear eminent wikipedian Lord Cornwallis. You are the creator of the article and the only person who has added citations (a single one) before I came along. That single citation reads "<ref>Casway, Jerrold. Owen Roe O'Neill and the Struggle for Catholic Ireland, pg. 60. University of Pennsylvania Press, 1984.</ref>" and fixes the citation style to the category "inline citations using ref tags" (WP:FOOTCITE) and perhaps more precisely to the variant "not using templates". You are therefore the owner of the citation style. I would like to change the citation style to use short citations (WP:SFN) where "short" descriptions in the text using ({{Sfn}}) are combined with source descriptions using citation templates (e.g. {{Cite book}}) in a list of sources like in the recent FA Frederick the Great. I have in fact added such a citation, which demonstrates what I want to do. You can easily revert it. As prescribed in WP:CITEVAR, I formally ask your permission.
In hope of further good collaboration, with thanks and best regards, Johannes Schade (talk) 15:47, 19 July 2022 (UTC)
Possible deletion for lack of notability
@User:Lord Cornwallis (creator), @User:Mabuska (subject matter expert). As the article stands now, notability is not demonstrated. Turlough, father of the famous Sir Felim, was no peer, did not sit in parliament, has no monograph written on him, he did not even own the land around Kinard, which beloinged to his father. It is possible that the intended biographical subject was not Felim;'s father, but Turlough, 4th son of Shane O'Neill. As a fourth son he had no claim to his grandfather Conn O'Neill, 1st Earl of Tyrone's earldom. What do you think? With thanks and best regards, Johannes Schade (talk) 20:48, 30 October 2022 (UTC)
- @User:Johannes Schade Thanks for the notification and the compliment :-) The article had the wrong name for a start so I moved it. Turlough as grandson of Hugh O'Neill was a member of the clan derbfine [those eligible for the kingship]. It consisted of three generations from one who had been chief, with the sons of a chiefs daughters having as much a claim as the eldest son of a chief. Hugh O'Neill had been chief of Tyrone, thus Turlough McHenry was an eligible successor in Gaelic law if he could muster enough support. In English law he was quite far down the line of succession for the earldom. Mabuska (talk) 20:22, 14 November 2022 (UTC)
- Dear Mabuska. Thanks for your intervention and especially for correcting the name and for explaining derbfine to me. I had seen that word being thrown around but had not understood until now. However, I would not think that being a member of the derbfine gives notability. With Hugh O'Neill, Earl of Tyrone having been married at least four times, there must have been a big number of people in his derbfine (which might also include his illegitimate children). It seems Shane O'Neill (Irish exile), called "El Conde de Tyrone", followed him as 3rd earl (ignoring the attainder). But who followed him as The O'Neill? Perhaps it does not matter. I still think notability is not demonstrated. With many thanks and best regards, Johannes Schade (talk) 10:09, 16 November 2022 (UTC)
- It also included illegitimate children. Why do you think there were so many dynastic wars in Gaelic culture with so many claimnants lol? Unofficial 3rd Earl as the title was forfeited with Hugh's attainder. I don't know who successed that Shane as The O'Neill, but it's now held by Portugese descendants of the Clandeboy branch according to this pdf on the Portugese O'Neill's. Ironically it was the British College of Arms they applied to and got granted their petition to be head of all the O'Neill's, not Gaelic law.
- In regards to actual notability, there isn't much on this guy is there? He died in battle and was the father of the 1641 rebellion leader Phelim O'Neill and that seems to be it. However, where else would this information be collected too out of curiousity? Mabuska (talk) 18:11, 18 November 2022 (UTC)
- Dear Mabuska. Thanks for your intervention and especially for correcting the name and for explaining derbfine to me. I had seen that word being thrown around but had not understood until now. However, I would not think that being a member of the derbfine gives notability. With Hugh O'Neill, Earl of Tyrone having been married at least four times, there must have been a big number of people in his derbfine (which might also include his illegitimate children). It seems Shane O'Neill (Irish exile), called "El Conde de Tyrone", followed him as 3rd earl (ignoring the attainder). But who followed him as The O'Neill? Perhaps it does not matter. I still think notability is not demonstrated. With many thanks and best regards, Johannes Schade (talk) 10:09, 16 November 2022 (UTC)
- Stub-Class Ireland articles
- Low-importance Ireland articles
- Stub-Class Ireland articles of Low-importance
- Ireland articles needing infoboxes
- All WikiProject Ireland pages
- Stub-Class Northern Ireland-related articles
- Unknown-importance Northern Ireland-related articles
- All WikiProject Northern Ireland pages
- Stub-Class biography articles
- Biography articles without infoboxes
- WikiProject Biography articles