Jump to content

Wikipedia:Featured article candidates/Moncton/archive1: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
→‎Moncton: oppose
m →‎Moncton: Support
Line 65: Line 65:
**A lot of the information is referenced to self-published sources. I think you should look for more newspaper and magazine articles to cover some of this.
**A lot of the information is referenced to self-published sources. I think you should look for more newspaper and magazine articles to cover some of this.
[[User:Karanacs|Karanacs]] ([[User talk:Karanacs|talk]]) 17:59, 14 February 2008 (UTC)
[[User:Karanacs|Karanacs]] ([[User talk:Karanacs|talk]]) 17:59, 14 February 2008 (UTC)

*'''Support''' This article is one of the best articles I have seen. -[[User:Flubeca|<span style="color:green;font-weight:bold;">Flubeca</span>]]<sup>[[User talk:Flubeca|<span style="color:blue;font-weight:bold;">Talk</span>]]</sup> 02:36, 15 February 2008 (UTC)

Revision as of 02:36, 15 February 2008

Moncton

Check external links

I'm nominating this article for featured article as I feel it meets all FA standards. Stu pendousmat (talk) 01:14, 6 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]

  • Nominate and Support. Stu pendousmat (talk) 01:14, 6 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]
  • Comment. I think this article has potential but it still needs quite a bit of work. I haven't read the entire article thoroughly but it seems that it is comprehensive and generally well-referenced. However, it is in dire need of much copyediting and formatting. The writing has too many very short paragraphs and some lists may be better as prose. There are grammar issues and the prose often reads more like a travel guide than a neutral encyclopedia article. I've been working on this a bit and will probably continue to do more, but others' input will also be needed. A fair number of references are not properly formatted. Other charts and lists should perhaps be re-thought. Finally, religion information (assuming it exists) should be added to the demographics section. Also not sure why the best image for the culture section is a church when the culture section talks exclusively about the arts (I liked the photo of the theater better). Calliopejen1 (talk) 17:09, 6 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]
I changed the picture back to the theater, as for the religion stuff the only data available at this moment is from the 2001 census, I was waiting for the new data from the 2006 census to be released (should be fairly soon) before updating that. As for the references, they arent really my strong suit, I made most of them, but Im not positive on proper formatting, so any help in that department would be appriciated. As for the table which are you talking about? The demographical ones, the sports team one, or the government one? Thanks for your help so far! Stu pendousmat (talk) 17:36, 6 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]


  • Oppose. The prose needs a lot of work to be compelling. There are grammatical errors and it could be tightened a good deal. There are also significant issues with statistics or claims not being cited. I think I've identified all the areas that should be cited, but the prose issues here are only a very tiny overview. Karanacs (talk) 17:59, 14 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]
    • Two paragraphs in the lead talk about shipbuilding and railroads. I think these two paragraphs should be combined.
    • "Although Moncton was traumatized twice" - the city was not traumatized; the economy might have been; this needs to be rephrased
    • In the history section, the sentences don't flow well within each paragraph. It is very choppy, and a good copyedit should help it to be more compelling.
    • Need a citation for the fact that the name of the initial settlement was "in reference to the sharp bend of the Petitcodiac River."
    • Need citation for "with him came eight immigrant Pennsylvania Deutsch families who were to re-establish the pre-existing farming community at Le Coude. This settlement was known as "The Bend of the Petitcodiac", or simply The Bend."
    • Need a citation for "Railway employment in Moncton peaked at nearly six thousand workers in the 1950s before starting a long slow decline."
    • Need citations for the paragraph about the Francophone-Anglophone tensions
    • "The sharp bend of the Petitcodiac River at Moncton has strongly influenced the names given to the community by the various succeeding inhabitants living in the area." is mentioned in both history and geography and not cited either place
    • Need citation for: "It is the longest remaining unspoiled barrier dune system on the mainland eastern seaboard of North America"
    • Need citation for: "This popular attraction "
    • Need citation for: "occupies a relatively large footprint for its size"
    • This is out of date: "it is scheduled for major renovation in 2007.["
    • Need citation for: "None of these buildings however are imposing enough to really help define the city"
    • Need a citation for "Irishtown Nature Park (one of the largest urban nature parks in Canada"
    • Need citation for "Since the previous national census in 2001 the metropolitan area has grown by 6.5%"
    • Need citation for "This rate of growth is within the top ten amongst major cities in Canada and Moncton has the fastest growth rate of any city east of Toronto."
    • You ought to also provide an official citation for the 2006 census data, so that people can easily verify the info (you never know what numbers a vandal might change it to)
    • There is a mixed Harvard style and footnote reference for the census 2001 info
    • Need a citation for " The local unemployment rate averages between 4-5%, which is below the national average" (that does not appear to be covered in the next reference)
    • Need citation for "The World Wine and Food Exposition — held every November, this is the largest event of its kind in eastern Canada"
    • There are a lot of lists in the article. Some of these should be converted to prose
    • Need a citation for "The "Magnetic Hill Illusion" remains a popular tourism draw "
    • There are two sentences that begin "Of the seven members of the Legislative Assembly that currently represent greater Moncton" They then have different numbers of people belonging to various parties. This information needs to be cleaned up, and a date needs to be added
    • Need a citation for " Moncton Flight College is one of Canada's oldest, largest, and most prestigious flight schools. "
    • Need a citation for "Skydive Moncton operates the province's only nationally certified sports parachute club out of this facility."
    • Need a citation for "such, all flights between the atlantic seaboard of North America and Europe pass through Moncton Centre airspace."
    • "The city is currently working to increase its annual ridership from 1.7 million to 2.8 million. To assist with this, the bus fleet will increase to 54 vehicles within the next two years' - there is no anchor date to let us know when this was added -- 2005, 2007, 2008?
    • Not all references have publishers listed
    • A lot of the information is referenced to self-published sources. I think you should look for more newspaper and magazine articles to cover some of this.

Karanacs (talk) 17:59, 14 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]