Jump to content

Misnomer: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Idnwiki (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Idnwiki (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Line 76: Line 76:
* While [[dry cleaning]] does not involve water, the process does involve the use of liquid solvents.
* While [[dry cleaning]] does not involve water, the process does involve the use of liquid solvents.
* A [[radiator]] usually transfers more energy by [[convection]] than by radiation.
* A [[radiator]] usually transfers more energy by [[convection]] than by radiation.
* The [[polarized light]] does not contain any poles. The term was introduced before the theory of luminous undulations was accepted by the scientific world and it "was intended at the time of its adoption to express certain fancied affections, analogous to the polarities of a magnet, conceived to exist in the material emanations which, according to Newton, constituted the essence of light." <ref>W.H.C. Bartlett, "Elements of Natural Philosophy, II-Acoustics, III-Optics", 4th Ed (New York, 1866) p. 323.</ref>.
* The [[polarized light]] does not contain any poles. The term was introduced before the theory of luminous undulations was accepted by the scientific world and it "was intended at the time of its adoption to express certain fancied affections, analogous to the polarities of a magnet, conceived to exist in the material emanations which, according to Newton, constituted the essence of light. It would be better were it replaced by some other term more expressive of the actual condition of the light; but at present this seems to be impossible, owing to its very general acceptation, and it is accordingly retained" <ref>W.H.C. Bartlett, "Elements of Natural Philosophy, II-Acoustics, III-Optics", 4th Ed (New York, 1866) p. 323.</ref>.
* The "funny bone" is not a [[bone]] &mdash; the phrase refers to the [[ulnar nerve]].
* The "funny bone" is not a [[bone]] &mdash; the phrase refers to the [[ulnar nerve]].
* A [[parkway]] is a type of street or road where parking is generally prohibited, whereas a residential [[driveway]] is intended for parking.
* A [[parkway]] is a type of street or road where parking is generally prohibited, whereas a residential [[driveway]] is intended for parking.

Revision as of 02:43, 29 April 2010

A misnomer is a term which suggests an interpretation that is known to be untrue. Such incorrect terms sometimes derived their names because of the form, action, or origin of the subject becoming named popularly or widely referenced—long before their true natures were known.

Sources of misnomers

Some of the sources of misnomers are:

  • An older name being retained as the thing named evolved (e.g. pencil lead, tin can, fixed income market, mince meat pie, steamroller, tin foil, radio, clothes iron, most music genre titles). This is essentially a metaphorical extension with the older item standing for anything filling its role.
  • Transference of a well-known product brand name into a genericized trademark (e.g. Xerox for photocopy, Kleenex for tissue or Jell-o for gelatin dessert).
  • An older name being retained even in the face of newer information (e.g. Chinese checkers, Arabic numerals).
  • Pars pro toto, or a name being applied to something which only covers part of a region. The name Holland is often used to refer to the Netherlands while it only designates a part of that country; sometimes people refer to the suburbs of a metropolis with the name of the biggest city in the metropolis.
  • A name being based on a similarity in a particular aspect (e.g. shooting stars (Meteors) look like stars from Earth, Greenland is icy and Iceland is greener)
  • A difference between popular and technical meanings of a term. For example, a koala "bear" (see below) looks and acts much like a bear, but from a zoologist's point of view it is quite distinct and unrelated. Similarly, fireflies fly like flies, ladybugs look and act like bugs. Botanically, peanuts look and taste like nuts and palm trees are classified scientifically as related to grass. The technical sense is often cited as the "correct" sense, but this is a matter of context.
  • Ambiguity (e.g. a parkway is generally a road with park-like landscaping, not a place to park). Such a term may confuse those unfamiliar.
  • Association of a thing with a place other than one might assume. For example, Panama hats are made in Ecuador, but came to be associated with the building of the Panama Canal.
  • Naming peculiar to the originator's world view.
  • An unfamiliar name (generally foreign) or technical term being re-analyzed as something more familiar.
  • Anachronisms, terms being applied to things that belong to another time, especially much later, such as the Dendera light interpretation of a mural from the Hathor Temple of Ancient Egypt.
  • Dispute of criteria on naming. For instance, freeways are generally divided highways with no at-grade intersections or private access, and expressways have no private access but select crossroads. However, two-lane freeway often refers to 2-lane roads without private access but sometimes have at-grade intersections.

Examples

Older name retained

  • The lead in pencils is made of graphite and clay, not lead; graphite was originally believed to be lead ore but this is now known not to be the case. The graphite and clay mix is known as plumbum, meaning "lead ore" in Latin, and is still known as "black lead" in Keswick, Cumbria and elsewhere.
  • Blackboards can be black, green, red or blue. And the sticks of chalk are no longer made of chalk, but of gypsum.
  • Tin foil is almost always actually aluminum, whereas "tin cans" made for the storage of food products are made from steel plated in a thin layer of tin. In both cases, tin was the original metal.
  • Telephone numbers are sometimes referred to as being dialed despite the fact that rotary phones are now rare.
  • When a computer program is electronically transferred from disk to memory, this is referred to as loading the program. "Load" is a holdover term from the mid-20th century, when programs were created on punched cards and then loaded into a hopper for automated processing.
  • In golf, the clubs commonly referred to as woods are usually made of metal. The club heads for "woods" were formerly made predominantly of wood.

Similarity

Difference between common and technical meanings

  • Fermat's last theorem from 1637 was not correctly proven until 1995, and was therefore, until then, not a theorem, but a conjecture. 'Last' also refers to it being the last to be proved, not the last formulated.
  • Koala "bears" are marsupials not closely related to the Ursid family of bears. The name "koala" is preferred in Australia, where koalas are native.
  • Jellyfish are not fish (but they do have a gelatinous structure similar to jelly).
  • A peanut is not a true nut in the botanical sense, but a legume. Similarly, a coconut is not a true botanical nut.
  • Tear gas is not a gas, but a (solid) crystalline substance.[1]

Association with place other than one might assume

Naming peculiar to the originator's world view

  • The term "American" is frequently used to mean a citizen of the United States of America, despite the fact that anyone who is a citizen of any country in the Americas is technically an "American".

Reanalysis

  • In logic, begging the question is a type of fallacy occurring in deductive reasoning in which the proposition to be proved is assumed implicitly or explicitly in one of the premises. However, more recently, "begs the question" has been used as a synonym for "raises the question".
  • A quantum leap is properly an instantaneous change, which may be either large or small. In physics, it is the smallest possible changes that are of particular interest. In vernacular usage, however, the term is often taken to imply an abrupt large change.

Other

  • While dry cleaning does not involve water, the process does involve the use of liquid solvents.
  • A radiator usually transfers more energy by convection than by radiation.
  • The polarized light does not contain any poles. The term was introduced before the theory of luminous undulations was accepted by the scientific world and it "was intended at the time of its adoption to express certain fancied affections, analogous to the polarities of a magnet, conceived to exist in the material emanations which, according to Newton, constituted the essence of light. It would be better were it replaced by some other term more expressive of the actual condition of the light; but at present this seems to be impossible, owing to its very general acceptation, and it is accordingly retained" [2].
  • The "funny bone" is not a bone — the phrase refers to the ulnar nerve.
  • A parkway is a type of street or road where parking is generally prohibited, whereas a residential driveway is intended for parking.

See also

References

  1. ^ Modern Marvels:Non-lethal Weapons. The History Channel.
  2. ^ W.H.C. Bartlett, "Elements of Natural Philosophy, II-Acoustics, III-Optics", 4th Ed (New York, 1866) p. 323.