Jump to content

Doctor of Education: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
Included para for Singapore
Exactbird (talk | contribs)
16 edits
There are two conflicting views about the status. The first (positive) one has a direct quote with the name, while the second does not. Bringing in hidden reference does not equate the quality of the references, so the latter is deleted.
Tag: references removed
Line 3: Line 3:


==Differences between an Ed.D. and a Ph.D. in Education==
==Differences between an Ed.D. and a Ph.D. in Education==
The Ed.D. is recognized by the [[National Science Foundation]] as a research degree, and is recognized by the U.S. Department of Education as being equivalent to a Ph.D.<ref>http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/nsf10309/content.cfm?pub_id=3996&id=10#taba2</ref><ref>http://www.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ous/international/usnei/us/edlite-structure-us.html "Research Doctorate Degrees"</ref> However, some universities describe their Ed.D. programs as professional degree programs, particularly those that focus on educational leadership and administration.<ref>http://www.edb.utexas.edu/education/departments/khe/AcadProg/grad/hed/about/doctoral/edd/</ref><ref>http://education.washington.edu/degrees/edd.html</ref><ref>http://www.uu.edu/academics/graduate/edd/</ref><ref>http://curry.virginia.edu/academics/degrees/doctor-of-education/ed.d.-in-gifted-education</ref><ref>http://www.catalogs.umn.edu/grad/gen/edd.html</ref> Several studies have concluded that the Ed.D. has the same level of academic rigor as the Ph.D. in education.<ref>Nelson, J.K. & Coorough, C. (1994). Content analysis of the Ph.D. versus the Ed.D. dissertation. Journal of Experimental Education. 62.</ref><ref>Redden, E. (2007, April 10). Envisioning a New Ed.D. Inside Higher Ed.</ref><ref>Addams, A. N. (2008). Doctorate Recipients from United States Universities: Summary Report 2004 http://www.aacu.org/ocww/volume35_1/data.cfm</ref> Through a 5-year Carnegie Foundation project launched in 2001, Shulman et al. found that, "In reality, the distinctions between the [Ed.D. and Ph.D.] programs are minimal, and the required experiences (curriculum) and performances (dissertation) strikingly similar" (p.&nbsp;26).<ref>Shulman, L.S., Golde, C.M., Conklin Bueschel, & A., Garabedian, K. J. (2006). Reclaiming education's doctorates: A critique and a proposal. Educational Researcher, 35(3).</ref><ref>Clifford, C.J. & Guthrie, J.W. (1988). Ed school: A brief for professional education. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.</ref><ref>http://www.usc.edu/dept/chepa/pdf/ASHE_townsend.pdf</ref><ref>University of Minnesota, College of Education and Human Development http://www.cehd.umn.edu/edpa/EdAd/EdDandPhD.html</ref><ref>Indiana University, School of Education, Graduate Academic Bulletin http://www.indiana.edu/~bulletin/iu/educ_grad/2008-2010/doctoral.shtml#info</ref><ref>University of Liverpool http://www.edd.ohecampus.com/index.php?mod=dcp&act=navigationindex&navigationid=3774</ref> However, other researchers claim the Ed.D. does not have the same status as the Ph.D. within academe.<ref>Clifford, C.J. & Guthrie, J.W. (1988). Ed school: A brief for professional education. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.</ref><ref>http://www.usc.edu/dept/chepa/pdf/ASHE_townsend.pdf</ref> Furthermore, some universities claim that the Ed.D. emphasizes a broad scope of knowledge and skills related to the practice of education whereas the Ph.D. emphasizes more breadth and depth in theory and research methodology than does the Ed.D.<ref>University of Minnesota, College of Education and Human Development http://www.cehd.umn.edu/edpa/EdAd/EdDandPhD.html</ref><ref>Indiana University, School of Education, Graduate Academic Bulletin http://www.indiana.edu/~bulletin/iu/educ_grad/2008-2010/doctoral.shtml#info</ref><ref>University of Liverpool http://www.edd.ohecampus.com/index.php?mod=dcp&act=navigationindex&navigationid=3774</ref>
The Ed.D. is recognized by the [[National Science Foundation]] as a research degree, and is recognized by the U.S. Department of Education as being equivalent to a Ph.D.<ref>http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/nsf10309/content.cfm?pub_id=3996&id=10#taba2</ref><ref>http://www.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ous/international/usnei/us/edlite-structure-us.html "Research Doctorate Degrees"</ref> However, some universities describe their Ed.D. programs as professional degree programs, particularly those that focus on educational leadership and administration.<ref>http://www.edb.utexas.edu/education/departments/khe/AcadProg/grad/hed/about/doctoral/edd/</ref><ref>http://education.washington.edu/degrees/edd.html</ref><ref>http://www.uu.edu/academics/graduate/edd/</ref><ref>http://curry.virginia.edu/academics/degrees/doctor-of-education/ed.d.-in-gifted-education</ref><ref>http://www.catalogs.umn.edu/grad/gen/edd.html</ref> Several studies have concluded that the Ed.D. has the same level of academic rigor as the Ph.D. in education.<ref>Nelson, J.K. & Coorough, C. (1994). Content analysis of the Ph.D. versus the Ed.D. dissertation. Journal of Experimental Education. 62.</ref><ref>Redden, E. (2007, April 10). Envisioning a New Ed.D. Inside Higher Ed.</ref><ref>Addams, A. N. (2008). Doctorate Recipients from United States Universities: Summary Report 2004 http://www.aacu.org/ocww/volume35_1/data.cfm</ref> Through a 5-year Carnegie Foundation project launched in 2001, Shulman et al. found that, "In reality, the distinctions between the [Ed.D. and Ph.D.] programs are minimal, and the required experiences (curriculum) and performances (dissertation) strikingly similar" (p.&nbsp;26).<ref>Shulman, L.S., Golde, C.M., Conklin Bueschel, & A., Garabedian, K. J. (2006). Reclaiming education's doctorates: A critique and a proposal. Educational Researcher, 35(3).</ref><ref>Clifford, C.J. & Guthrie, J.W. (1988). Ed school: A brief for professional education. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.</ref><ref>http://www.usc.edu/dept/chepa/pdf/ASHE_townsend.pdf</ref><ref>University of Minnesota, College of Education and Human Development http://www.cehd.umn.edu/edpa/EdAd/EdDandPhD.html</ref><ref>Indiana University, School of Education, Graduate Academic Bulletin http://www.indiana.edu/~bulletin/iu/educ_grad/2008-2010/doctoral.shtml#info</ref><ref>University of Liverpool http://www.edd.ohecampus.com/index.php?mod=dcp&act=navigationindex&navigationid=3774</ref>


At most colleges and universities in the United States that offer doctorates in education, the college or university chooses to offer an Ed.D. (doctor of education), a Ph.D. (doctor of philosophy) in education, or both. Several of the top schools of education in the United States only offer their doctorates in education as Ed.D.s (e.g., Harvard University), whereas other top schools of education only offer their doctorates in education as Ph.D.s (e.g. Stanford University), and yet other top schools of education choose to offer Ed.D.s for degrees in applied research and Ph.D.s for theoretical research (e.g. UCLA, University of Oregon, University of Pennsylvania, etc.). At Teachers College Columbia University and at the Institute of Education, London, both Ed.D. and Ph.D. are research-oriented and the difference in designation merely originates from whether Arts and Science Departments can coordinate particular sub-fields of educational studies (e.g. economics of education vs. second language education). Finally, in rare circumstances, a school of education may offer both degrees with an Ed.D. being project-based and a Ph.D. being research-based (e.g. St. Louis University).
At most colleges and universities in the United States that offer doctorates in education, the college or university chooses to offer the Ed.D. (doctor of education), the Ph.D. (doctor of philosophy) in education, or both. Several of the top schools of education in the United States only offer their doctorates in education as Ed.D.s (e.g., Harvard University), whereas other top schools of education only offer their doctorates in education as Ph.D.s (e.g. Stanford University), and yet other top schools of education choose to offer Ed.D.s for degrees in applied research and Ph.D.s for theoretical research (e.g. UCLA, University of Oregon, University of Pennsylvania, etc.). At Teachers College Columbia University and at the Institute of Education, London, both the Ed.D. and the Ph.D. are research-oriented and the difference in designation merely originates from whether Arts and Science Departments can coordinate particular sub-fields of educational studies (e.g. economics of education vs. second language education). Finally, in rare circumstances, a school of education may offer both degrees with the Ed.D. being project-based and the Ph.D. being research-based (e.g. St. Louis University).


==Professional prospects==
==Professional prospects==

Revision as of 00:00, 14 September 2011

The Doctor of Education degree (Ed.D. or D.Ed.), in Latin, Doctor Educationis, is a discipline-based doctorate that prepares the student for academic, administrative, clinical or research positions in education, civil service, and private organizations.

Differences between an Ed.D. and a Ph.D. in Education

The Ed.D. is recognized by the National Science Foundation as a research degree, and is recognized by the U.S. Department of Education as being equivalent to a Ph.D.[1][2] However, some universities describe their Ed.D. programs as professional degree programs, particularly those that focus on educational leadership and administration.[3][4][5][6][7] Several studies have concluded that the Ed.D. has the same level of academic rigor as the Ph.D. in education.[8][9][10] Through a 5-year Carnegie Foundation project launched in 2001, Shulman et al. found that, "In reality, the distinctions between the [Ed.D. and Ph.D.] programs are minimal, and the required experiences (curriculum) and performances (dissertation) strikingly similar" (p. 26).[11][12][13][14][15][16]

At most colleges and universities in the United States that offer doctorates in education, the college or university chooses to offer the Ed.D. (doctor of education), the Ph.D. (doctor of philosophy) in education, or both. Several of the top schools of education in the United States only offer their doctorates in education as Ed.D.s (e.g., Harvard University), whereas other top schools of education only offer their doctorates in education as Ph.D.s (e.g. Stanford University), and yet other top schools of education choose to offer Ed.D.s for degrees in applied research and Ph.D.s for theoretical research (e.g. UCLA, University of Oregon, University of Pennsylvania, etc.). At Teachers College Columbia University and at the Institute of Education, London, both the Ed.D. and the Ph.D. are research-oriented and the difference in designation merely originates from whether Arts and Science Departments can coordinate particular sub-fields of educational studies (e.g. economics of education vs. second language education). Finally, in rare circumstances, a school of education may offer both degrees with the Ed.D. being project-based and the Ph.D. being research-based (e.g. St. Louis University).

Professional prospects

In the United States, the Ed.D. and the Ph.D. in education are both recognized for appointment as a lecturer or professor in a university. It may also be recognized as training for administrative positions in education, such as superintendent of schools, human resource director, or principal.

The effect on a future career will depend on the area of study. In an ESRC-funded report[17] by Professor Ingrid Lunt of the Institute of Education compared the Eng.D., the Ed.D. and the DBA (Doctor of Business Administration). She concluded that:

"The impact of the development of professional knowledge on employment culture varied considerably; for Eng.D. participants there was a major impact, whereas for those on the DBA, the impact was often more personal, developing and enhancing individual consultancy skills; for Ed.D. participants, there appeared to be little impact on employment, though frequently considerable impact for the individuals themselves."

The EdD is generally presented as an opportunity to prepare for academic, administrative or specialised positions in education, favourably placing the graduates for promotion and leadership responsibilities, or high-level professional positions in a range of locations in the broad Education industry. In the UK and Ireland both the EdD and PhD are recognised for the purposes of appointment as a lecturer or professor in universities.

History

When research universities were established in the late 19th century in the United States, they primarily awarded doctorates in the sciences and later the arts. By the early 20th century, these universities began to offer doctoral degrees in the social sciences, which included education. From the very beginning there were divisions between those universities that offered an Ed.D. and a Ph.D. in education.[18]

The first Ph.D. in education was granted at Teachers College, Columbia University in 1893.[19] The first Ed.D. degree was introduced in the United States at Harvard University in 1920. The Ed.D. was added by Teachers College in 1934.[20]

Not long after the creation of doctorates in education, some scholars considered whether doctoral studies should be for professional training, as well as for the preparation of researchers.[21] In light of the controversy, many institutions opted to offer the Ed.D. as the exclusive doctorate within their schools of education, including Harvard University that has created the degree and continues to offer the Ed.D. as a research doctorate comparable to a Ph.D.[22]

In the United Kingdom, the Ph.D. in education was introduced in the 1920s. The first Ed.D. was awarded in England in 1992, at the University of Bristol. Six years later, 29 British universities were offering Ed.D. programs.

United States

In the United States, the Ed.D. tends to be granted by the school of education of universities and is a terminal degree in education. A typical doctorate of education in the United States usually requires several years of course work as a doctoral student achieving generally 15 courses beyond a masters degree, a comprehensive exam, and at its conclusion a dissertation. The dissertation presents the doctoral candidate's research and findings and is submitted for defense to the candidate's dissertation committee (including an advisor/first, second, and third reader and usually limited to five - although varies by institution). Majors within the Ed.D. may include: counseling, curriculum and instruction/curriculum and teaching, educational administration, educational leadership, education policy, educational psychology, educational technology, higher education, or language/linguistics.

Argentina

In the Latin American docta, to get into a Ph.D. program of Education, candidates are required to have a Licentiate or Master's degree in Education.[23]

Australia

In Australia entry requirements for the Ed.D. are similar to the Ph.D. except that the former requires a number of the years professional experience in education or academic life.

Canada

In Canada, the Ed.D. tends to be granted by faculties of education at universities and is a terminal degree in education. Much like the United States and Great Britain, some universities offer the Ed.D. (Simon Fraser University), others offer a Ph.D. in education (McGill University, Queen's University, University of British Columbia), and yet others offer both (University of Toronto, University of Alberta, University of Calgary).

Singapore

In Singapore, the National Institute of Education (Nanyang Technological University), is the sole university that awards the Ed.D. degree. The Ed.D. programme has the rigour and expectations of a PhD, but with a professional focus[24].

South Africa

In South Africa, following a convention of using Latin in academic designations, the doctorate in education is called Doctor Educationis (D.Ed.) and, like other doctoral degrees in that country, it is entirely a research-based qualification.

United Kingdom and Ireland

In the United Kingdom, the Ed.D. differs from a Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.) in Education in that it allows the study of a greater variety of education-related subjects in the first stages of study, focusing on a single topic only at the end. However, both the Ed.D. and Ph.D. are research based degrees demanding the same level of academic rigor. A typical Ph.D. in the United Kingdom usually requires the submission of an approximately 80,000 word thesis; the entire study period would be spent researching the topic and writing the thesis. For an Ed.D., a student might be required to research various topics in the first two years, preparing a 5,000-6,000-word report for each. The last two years would be spent on the thesis, which might be 45,000-50,000 words working out at about the same amount of words overall as a PhD.[25] A key difference between the two forms of doctorate is that the Ph.D. student tends to work alone while the Ed.D. student will initially be part of a learning community although increasingly Ph.D. students are now required to take courses on research methods similar to those taken by EdD students.

In Ireland Ed.D. programs have only recently been introduced and they tend to follow the UK model of initial research modules followed by longer research papers and thesis.

Research by Scott, Lunt, Browne and Thorne (2002) has found that the difference between an Ed.D. and a Ph.D. can be somewhat overstated as students of both tend to follow similar courses of study and to research similar topics.

Suggested reforms

Numerous scholars have suggested future reforms for both the Ed.D. and Ph.D. in education. Shulman et al. argued for a new doctorate for the professional practice of education, which might be called the Professional Practice Doctorate (P.P.D.). This doctoral degree would be for principals, superintendents, policy coordinators, curriculum coordinators, classroom educators, etc. The Ph.D. in education and the Ed.D. are now so closely intertwined, Shulman et al. argued that after the creation of the P.P.D., universities will be able to move forward on improving the research and scholarly components of the Ed.D. and Ph.D. in education.[26]

Arthur Levine argued that the current Ed.D. should be re-tooled into a new professional master's degree, parallel in many ways to the MBA.[27]

David Imig described reforms to the Ed.D. as including more collaborative work involving the analysis of data collected by others. Rather than generating their own data and hypothesis-testing, as Ph.D. students would, a group of Ed.D. students would analyze a specific pool of data from a number of different angles, each writing an individual dissertation on a specific aspect of the data which, when pooled together with the other dissertations, would combine to offer a comprehensive solution to a real-world problem.[28]

Notable people with Ed.D. degrees

  • Michael Apple - leading critical educational theorist, writer, and professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
  • Bill Ayers - American elementary education theorist, activist, and professor at the University of Illinois at Chicago
  • Jill Biden - the wife of the Vice-President of the United States, Joe Biden
  • Bill Cosby - American entertainer, educator, and activist
  • Linda Darling-Hammond - writer, researcher, education adviser to Barack Obama, and professor at Stanford University
  • Lisa Delpit - American educator, author, and professor at Florida International University.
  • Sonia Nieto - leading author and teacher in the field of multiculturalism.
  • Thomas Payzant - former superintendent of Boston Public Schools, former U.S. Assistant Secretary for Education, and professor at Harvard University
  • Neil Postman - American author, media theorist and cultural critic
  • Jonas Soltis - Professor Emeritus of Philosophy and Education, Teachers College, Columbia University
  • Betty Shabazz - American educator and civil rights advocate and wife of Malcolm X.
  • Ruth "Dr. Ruth" Westheimer - American sex therapist, media personality, and author

See also

References

  1. ^ http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/nsf10309/content.cfm?pub_id=3996&id=10#taba2
  2. ^ http://www.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ous/international/usnei/us/edlite-structure-us.html "Research Doctorate Degrees"
  3. ^ http://www.edb.utexas.edu/education/departments/khe/AcadProg/grad/hed/about/doctoral/edd/
  4. ^ http://education.washington.edu/degrees/edd.html
  5. ^ http://www.uu.edu/academics/graduate/edd/
  6. ^ http://curry.virginia.edu/academics/degrees/doctor-of-education/ed.d.-in-gifted-education
  7. ^ http://www.catalogs.umn.edu/grad/gen/edd.html
  8. ^ Nelson, J.K. & Coorough, C. (1994). Content analysis of the Ph.D. versus the Ed.D. dissertation. Journal of Experimental Education. 62.
  9. ^ Redden, E. (2007, April 10). Envisioning a New Ed.D. Inside Higher Ed.
  10. ^ Addams, A. N. (2008). Doctorate Recipients from United States Universities: Summary Report 2004 http://www.aacu.org/ocww/volume35_1/data.cfm
  11. ^ Shulman, L.S., Golde, C.M., Conklin Bueschel, & A., Garabedian, K. J. (2006). Reclaiming education's doctorates: A critique and a proposal. Educational Researcher, 35(3).
  12. ^ Clifford, C.J. & Guthrie, J.W. (1988). Ed school: A brief for professional education. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
  13. ^ http://www.usc.edu/dept/chepa/pdf/ASHE_townsend.pdf
  14. ^ University of Minnesota, College of Education and Human Development http://www.cehd.umn.edu/edpa/EdAd/EdDandPhD.html
  15. ^ Indiana University, School of Education, Graduate Academic Bulletin http://www.indiana.edu/~bulletin/iu/educ_grad/2008-2010/doctoral.shtml#info
  16. ^ University of Liverpool http://www.edd.ohecampus.com/index.php?mod=dcp&act=navigationindex&navigationid=3774
  17. ^ "Professional Doctorates and their Contribution to Professional Development and Careers"
  18. ^ Douglas, T. J. (2002). Legitimacy, differentiation, and the promise of the Ed.D. in higher education. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Association for the Study of Higher Education.
  19. ^ Shulman, L.S., Golde, C.M., Conklin Bueschel, A., Garabedian, K. J. (2006). Reclaiming education's doctorates: A critique and a proposal. Educational Researcher, 35(3).
  20. ^ Douglas, T. J. (2002). Legitimacy, differentiation, and the promise of the Ed.D. in higher education. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Association for the Study of Higher Education.
  21. ^ Brubacher, J., & Rudy, W. (1968). Higher education in transition. New York: Harper and Row.
  22. ^ Nelson, J. K. & Coorough, C. (1994)e. Content analysis of the PhD versus EdD dissertation. Journal of Experimental Education. 62(2). HGSE website, http://www.gse.harvard.edu/admissions/faq/degree_info.html
  23. ^ http://spuweb.siu.edu.ar/studyinargentina/pages/study1603.php Doctorates, Masters and Licentiates degrees in Argentina
  24. ^ http://www.nie.edu.sg/edd "Doctor in Education homepage"
  25. ^ http://www.esrcsocietytoday.ac.uk/ESRCInfoCentre/Images/recognition_of_professional_doctorates_(appendix%25202)_tcm6-9063.pdf "Recognition of Professional Doctorates" in 'ESRC Guidelines'
  26. ^ Shulman, L.S., Golde, C.M., Conklin Bueschel, & A., Garabedian, K. J. (2006). Reclaiming education's doctorates: A critique and a proposal. Educational Researcher, 35(3).
  27. ^ Levine,A (2005). Educating School Leaders. New York: Education Schools Project.
  28. ^ Redden, E. (2007). Envisioning a New Ed.D. Inside Higher Ed. http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2007/04/10/education.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Doctor_of_Education&oldid=450384674"