Talk:Border Security Force: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 20: | Line 20: | ||
== Unwarranted deletions by miscreants == |
== Unwarranted deletions by miscreants == |
||
The rank structure column has been defaced, with government pay grade information being removed, by motivated elements. Perhaps it is because these elements wanted to wrongly state that Asst Commandants are equivalents to Army captains which they are not. Assistant Commandants and Army Lieutenants are both in Pay Band III, Grade Pay 5400. They are NOT equivalent in ANY way to captains in the army. |
The rank structure column has been defaced, with government pay grade information being removed, by motivated elements. Perhaps it is because these elements wanted to wrongly state that Asst Commandants are equivalents to Army captains which they are not. Assistant Commandants and Army Lieutenants are both in Pay Band III, Grade Pay 5400. They are NOT equivalent in ANY way to captains in the army, who are in Pay Band III, Grade Pay 6100. There is no police or Paramilitary equivalent for the rank of captain in the Army. |
||
==Rank Structure== |
==Rank Structure== |
Revision as of 09:48, 3 October 2011
![]() | India C‑class Mid‑importance | |||||||||
|
![]() | Law Enforcement C‑class Mid‑importance | |||||||||
|
![]() | Military history: National / Asian / South Asia C‑class | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Unwarranted deletions by miscreants
The rank structure column has been defaced, with government pay grade information being removed, by motivated elements. Perhaps it is because these elements wanted to wrongly state that Asst Commandants are equivalents to Army captains which they are not. Assistant Commandants and Army Lieutenants are both in Pay Band III, Grade Pay 5400. They are NOT equivalent in ANY way to captains in the army, who are in Pay Band III, Grade Pay 6100. There is no police or Paramilitary equivalent for the rank of captain in the Army.
Rank Structure
I have edited the rank structure. There was a need to correct the numerous spelling, grammatical, and factual errors inherent in the section. I have added a column for the government pay grade that each officer rank is in, and each officer rank in the compared services is in, to make clear what the correct pay grade (and therefore rank) equivalence is, vis a vis police and defence services (Government equivalence between services is based on pay grade). Furthermore, I have added a few links to sources which authenticate this information. The portion of this section which dealt with below officer ranks contained no information at all, with just blank place holders. I have removed this section, as it was not adding any value to the article, due to its lack of information.
Fourth paragraph
The fourth paragraph in the article is highly misleading and is a produce of baseless thoughts. This paragraph very incorrectly states the reasons for the inception (yes, inception, rather than just induction) of BSF and the replacement of CRPF. The author has put forth erroneous and biased ideas while hiding the main reasons behind replacement of CRPF from Jammu and Kashmir, such as, the bulk of the CRPF being already committed to combating insurgency in Punjab and the North-Easter states, and unavailability of more manpower from CRPF. The experience and capabilities of the CRPF against Jihadis can be seen mentioned in the article meant for CRPF. Secondly, the BSF's greatest achievements surpass something like elimination of "Ghazi Baba" by great degrees. The author should be less biased, more factual, and even more specific - sticking strictly to the BSF, and mention factual and better instances regarding the achievements. Such as talking about those in the BSF who have/has been awarded the highly reputed Mahavir Chakra during Indo-Pak war.
To keep the article sound more specific, more factual and less erroneous, I am deleting the fourth misleading paragraph from this article.
- The first point about the accuracy and objectivity of the removed paragraph was valid, however the paragraph is still required to provide the context which led to the BSF, a border force, being deployed in counter-insurgency operations. Therefore, a more neutral, edited version of the paragraph has been inserted.
- Wrt the second point about the achievements of the BSF: historically speaking, the Indo-Pak war may indeed be considered more important. However, what is more relevant in recent times is the BSF's role in counter-insurgency. Also note that the existing article specifies the context wrt Ghazi Baba (prime success IN JAMMU AND KASHMIR). Given this, along with the fact that the December 13 suicide attack on the New Delhi parliament is viewed by many as comparable to 9/11 in terms of its gravity, the elimination of Ghazi Baba is an important point. Plucky77 22:43, 30 May 2006 (UTC)
Article Improvement Needed
I added tags for weasel words and unsourced content to this article. I will try and find some documentation to fill the gaps when I can, but an article this in-depth with no sources and various usages of weasel words is a far from optimal situation here. Anyone else who wants to work on the topic is welcome to. Please do NOT remove the tags until the changes are made. Thank you. Bullzeye (Ring for Service) 04:45, 3 December 2007 (UTC) You know my dad is in BSF,and I have seen how hard it is for them to gaurd the borders,especially when there is no border fencing,when the border is divided by a river! —Preceding unsigned comment added by 59.177.96.244 (talk) 19:26, 13 August 2009 (UTC)
Not A Global View
The references cited may not represent global view within Criticism section. An expert on India or Bangladesh or Both may resolve the issue. Hitro talk 18:25, 10 August 2009 (UTC)
- C-Class India articles
- Mid-importance India articles
- C-Class India articles of Mid-importance
- WikiProject India articles
- C-Class Law enforcement articles
- Mid-importance Law enforcement articles
- WikiProject Law Enforcement articles
- C-Class military history articles
- C-Class national militaries articles
- National militaries task force articles
- C-Class Asian military history articles
- Asian military history task force articles
- C-Class South Asian military history articles
- South Asian military history task force articles