Cyrus S. Eaton

Cyrus S. Eaton

Cyrus Stephen Eaton (December 27, 1883 – May 9, 1979) was a Canadian-born investment banker, businessman and philanthropist in the United States, with a career that spanned seventy years.

For decades one of the most powerful financiers in the American midwest, Cyrus Eaton was also a colorful and often-controversial figure. He was chiefly known for his longevity in business, for his opposition to the dominance of eastern financiers in the America of his day, for his occasionally ruthless financial manipulations, and for his outspoken criticism of America’s Cold War brinkmanship. He funded and helped organize the first Pugwash Conferences on World Peace, in 1955.

Nova Scotian youth

Cyrus Eaton was born on a farm near the village of Pugwash in Cumberland County, Nova Scotia, Canada, in 1883. [1] Besides the far, his father, Joseph Howe Eaton, ran a small general store and the district post office.

Eaton's ancestors had first come to North America ca. 1620, when John Eaton, a Puritan English farmer from Warwickshire in England arrived at Massachusetts Colony. David Eaton,[3] a direct descendant, left Connecticut circa 1760 to join the so-called New England Planters, who came to Nova Scotia to occupy farmlands left vacant after the expulsion of the Acadian French. On his mother’s side, Cyrus Eaton was a descendant of McPhersons, who were United Empire Loyalists and had chosen to remain faithful to the British Crown and leave New England after the American Revolution[4] for an uncertain future in Nova Scotia.

Education and a new start

Cyrus Eaton left Nova Scotia at sixteen for Woodstock College in Woodstock, Ontario, a preparatory school for the Baptist-affiliated McMaster University, which was then situated in Toronto. Intending to follow his mother's ambition for him and become a Baptist preacher, he enrolled at McMaster in 1901 where he with concentrated on philosophy and finance, and earned his Bachelor of Arts degree in 1905.

During his first summer vacation from McMaster, Cyrus went to work in a hotel in Cleveland, Ohio, where his popular, dedicated uncle, Rev. Charles Aubrey Eaton, led a congregation of the wealthy that included John D. Rockefeller. A meeting at a dinner party led to an invitation for Cyrus to work for the summer as the elderly businessman's assistant at his lakeside Cleveland estate, and the experience changed Eaton's direction in life away from a religious vocation toward a career in business. Rockefeller advised him to concentrate his efforts, as he himself had done, on the resource industries, and when Cyrus graduated from university his first job was with a Rockefeller affiliated company, the East Ohio Gas and Power Company, which was laying gas mains in Cleveland. After a period as a construction crew supervisor and troubleshooter for the public relations department, his negotiating skills earned him an opportunity to represent a syndicate of investors associated with Rockefeller who were buying up urban utility franchises in the American Midwest and the Prairie Provinces of Canada. This work led directly to his first substantial opportunity.

Brandon, Manitoba

One of their targets was the Canadian city of Brandon, Manitoba, which needed a reliable year-round source of power for street lighting because their current supply, from a hydroelectric facility, stalled each winter when the river froze. In October, 1907, on the same day that Eaton finalized arrangements with the mayor of Brandon for a franchise to supply the town with electric power from a steam generated power plant, a financial panic struck American banks, and for a brief period, American investment money was in such short supply, that the confidence of Eaton's backers was shaken. The City of Brandon, however, had issued a franchise, and wanted something done. Eaton seized the opportunity, and with the blessing of his previous backers, borrowed enough to take over the franchise himself. Within a year, the Brandon Gas and Power Company was generating power to light Brandon's streets, and also producing capital for Eaton’s next venture. He later sold the Canadian company for a considerable profit.

Rockefeller offered him employment with Standard Oil in New York. Cyrus declined the offer so that he could go into business for himself.

Continental Gas & Electric Corporation, Delaware

Eaton had become an investor and an operator in one of the fastest growing industries on the continent. From 1900 through 1920 the number of private electric systems in the U.S. grew from approximately 2,800 to 6,500. There were plenty of opportunities for imaginative entrepreneurs, and Eaton's next big opportunity came to him through the good offices of his father-in-law, Augustus F. House, a distinguished Cleveland physician and banker whose daughter Margaret had become Eaton's wife in 1909. Dr. House had profited, with Eaton's assistance, from the merger of Lakeshore Banking and Trust, a bank he founded, with Cleveland Trust.

As a result of this, and because of his success with Brandon Gas and Power, House introduced his son-in-law to an important Cleveland utility and traction magnate, George Taylor Bishop. Bishop took a personal liking to Cyrus, and invited him to join his office to learn more about the 'art' of financing electric utilities. Over the years, as he worked with Bishop on consolidations of utility holdings, the 'Eaton interests’ grew into controlling stakes in a significant number of utility operating companies.

The Eatons began a family with the birth of a daughter in 1909, the first of seven children, and in 1912, the year Cyrus Eaton became an American citizen, he and Bishop incorporated one of the country's first utility holding companies, Continental Gas and Electric, of the state of Delaware. The Eatons used part of their growing fortune to build a mansion on Euclid Avenue, and Cyrus purchased a country estate near his friend Bishop's, with a one hundred and fifty year old farmhouse and over 300 acres (1.2 km²) of farmland in Northfield, Ohio, south of Cleveland.

In 1916 became a partner in Otis and Company, a major investment banking firm with head office in Cleveland and branches in New York and Chicago.

Continental Shares Ltd.

Under the Eaton/Bishop management, Continental Gas and Electric grew eventually to be one of the largest utility holding companies in North America. But its success marked just the beginning of Eaton's ambitious plans. At that time he was most active, Cleveland was the center of the wealthiest industrial area in North America, yet it was, he felt, unfortunate that the financiers of Wall Street in New York controlled so much of the industrial decision making at the local level in Cleveland, and throughout the region. Eaton thought that local financiers had a better understanding of the local economy and could better respond to the region's economic development needs if they had a greater degree of autonomy. The expansion experienced by the post war American economy provided Eaton with the opportunity to realize his goals. His strategy was to use the investment trust to gain financial control from Wall Street.

With hundreds of thousands of new investors turning to American stock markets, an early form of the mutual fund, called the investment trust, was becoming a popular way for investment managers and investment bankers to attract and to absorb new pools of available capital. Investment trusts fed on investors who lacked expertise of their own, and were eager to place their money and confidence in the hands of managers with a reputation for success. The Eaton group certainly had that, and in 1921, Eaton ventured beyond Continental Gas and Electric, the utility holding company he and a group of other investors controlled, to create and sponsor an investment trust with a similar name, Continental Shares Ltd., listed on the New York Stock Exchange. The ultimate design was to use the power vested in him as Chairman of the Board and board member of many important corporations to challenge Wall Street's hegemony and exert his own control over financial decision making in the region.

Under the utility holding company format, a limited group of wealthy investors usually pooled resources to invest in operating utilities and other utility holding companies they could control and manipulate for their own profit. However, because of a history in America of abusing and mismanaging their prerogatives, from the public point of view, privately held utility company operators and utility holding company managers were facing increased competition from public sector power providers, and as well, the prospect of greater government regulation. Both factors were reducing the attractiveness of these investments in the eyes of the wider public, and promising to hamper their future profitability. The investment trust was founded on a wider mandate. It raised capital from investors no longer content with clipping railroad coupons or cashing predictable utilities dividend checks. It appealed to investors who were willing to risk some of their new affluence on a chance to participate in the booming profitability of the wider American business community in the enlarged postwar economy. It offered shares in a new form of holding company, and it managed that money on behalf of the investors by trading in a diversity of important new industries that would hopefully raise share values and pay dividends. By using 'other people's money,' the organizers and managers of these funds obtained positions of power and control in the market which was out of all proportion to the magnitude of their personal investments. As trusted managers who retained all decision making power, they could engineer stock market coups at minimal risk to their own capital, and derive day-to-day income from management fees. As well, it was usual for the investment bankers who sponsored these trusts to derive income from the banking and management sides.

In this case, Eaton used his dominant position as Chairman of the Board of Continental Shares to capture banking business for Otis and Co., his investment bank, to include substantial fees for consulting and for underwriting the sale stock and bond issues.

United Light and Power

Cyrus Eaton’s Continental Shares, with its diversified portfolio of stocks in basic industries that stood to profit from the burgeoning auto industry, was at first extremely successful. In 1924, he parlayed its utility holdings derived from Continental Utilities into a major position in the large utility-traction conglomerate, United Light and Power.

Auto industry

By 1928, Eaton had begun to carry out the final stage in a campaign to become a dominating force in many of the major links in the auto industry’s chain of supply.

In addition to electrical power, his investment trust purchased dominant positions in the Cleveland-based paint company, Sherwin-Williams, the world's major supplier of auto coatings, and in Goodyear and Firestone, Ohio-based world leaders in the manufacture of tires and rubber.

His next major target was steel, and he was particularly interested in controlling companies that produced the strong, light steels used in auto manufacture. These plans led to a series of rapid purchases and mergers of several medium sized steel companies in Ohio and Pennsylvania, culminating in the merger that formed a new company, Republic Steel, at the time of its founding the third-largest steel producer in the United States.

The stock market crash of the 1930s caused Eaton a major, though temporary, setback, and the conditions that prevailed during the slow recovery of his and America's fortunes forced him to scale back his financial and industrial ambitions permanently. As well, it was during this period of the late 1920s and early 1930s that Eaton first gained a reputation in the English-speaking world for financial daring and for controversial decision making. In later years he would turn this reputation from celebrity to notoriety, and use it to assist him in focusing public attention on important issues, such as détente with Russia, nuclear disarmament and the dangers inherent in American militarism.

Eaton's many financial interests included organizing the mergers that formed Republic Steel Corporation and the Chessie System. He assumed the helm of the Chesapeake and Ohio Railway (C&O) in the mid-1950s when his colleague Robert Ralph Young of the Alleghany Corporation had to step down from the C&O to make a bid for the New York Central Railroad. Once the C&O had obtained control of the Baltimore and Ohio, and the Chessie System had been created, he largely retired to take care of his philanthropic interests.

The Pugwash Conferences

Eaton gained visibility outside the business community in the 1950s, when he became an ardent critic of the United States foreign and military policies during the Cold War. He became particularly controversial for engaging in personal diplomacy between the United States and communist countries in an effort to promote friendlier relations and more trade between the ideologically opposed segments of the world’s economy.

Eaton also gave personal and financial support to efforts to limit the nuclear arms race, and was involved in founding and financing the original Pugwash Conferences on Science and World Affairs, which took their name from Eaton’s hometown of Pugwash, Nova Scotia where the first meeting was held in July 1957 at his summer estate overlooking the Northumberland Strait.

The Pugwash Conferences were ultimately awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 1995. Eaton's 1950s efforts at rapprochement with the Soviet Union won him the 1960 Lenin Peace Prize. He was dubbed "the Kremlin's favorite capitalist". He was elected a Fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences in 1958.

Eaton had an estate in Blandford, Nova Scotia and create a wildlife reserve on the Aspotogan Peninsula.

Eaton died at his home in Northfield, Ohio at age 95.

In 1994, a residential developer bought Eaton's estate in Sagamore Hills, Ohio, a village 15 miles (24 km) southeast of Cleveland, Ohio and 20 miles (32 km) north of Akron, Ohio. The Eaton Estate had an area measuring approximately 200 acres (0.81 km²) and the developer constructed over 300 houses ranging in prices of $250,000 to about $500,000. Street names in the development called "Eaton Estates" include Pugwash, McMaster, and Republic as an homage to Cyrus Eaton.

The elementary school in Pugwash is named Cyrus Eaton Elementary School in honor of him.

Lee Eaton Elementary School in Northfield, Ohio was named after the daughter (Lee) of Cyrus Eaton who donated 12 acres (49,000 m²) of land for the school in memory of his daughter. In his dedication speech Mr. Eaton stated, “I hope the children of this school will make the most of their opportunity to know the best of both the country and the city”.

Politics, the Nuclear Threat and Cold War

As a citizen who frequently expressed his concerns and ideas about important economic and political issues, for Cyrus Eaton the major issue of the 1950's and 60's was the uncertainties caused by the invention and use of atomic weapons, particularly by their postwar proliferation in countries perceived as unfriendly by the United States. Despite dangerous differences between the United States and the Soviet Union which might otherwise have led to military conflict after WWII, the fear of mutual annihilation had resulted in a Cold War, characterized by tense international relations, by continued military build-ups that strained the budgets of both powers, and by military and diplomatic standoffs that threatened continually to turn into a hot war involving the exchange of nuclear weapons. This was particularly distressing for Cyrus Eaton, and he decided to join with others who wanted to do something about it. It led him to controversial acts of personal diplomacy aimed at keeping peace by trying to foster better relations between the United States and its enemies. He sought to do this in two major ways: 1) by financing and supporting international venues for friendly discussion about peace and nuclear disarmament, such as the Pugwash Conferences; and 2) by actively encouraging and promoting better trade relations between the United States and members of the Communist bloc. Though these efforts were in general well received by Communist leaders, Eaton's initiatives at first encountered major resistance at home. But his prestige as a businessman and his determination to influence public policy with his leadership earned him support and respect from important anti-war liberals such as Senator and House Majority Leader Mike Mansfield. At a time when the war in Vietnam was rousing such resistance in the United States as to become a major domestic problem, he was a tireless proponent of a negotiated peace, travelling frequently at his own expense between Washington, Moscow, Paris and Saigon to attend peace conferences and keep important back channels of communication open. By the time Richard Nixon became President, Cyrus Eaton and others had so influenced the political climate in the United States that not only did Nixon seek peace with North Vietnam, but laws and public policy resisting trade and cultural communications between American businessmen and Communistic countries were being changed in favour of detente, mutual cooperation on important international issues and an easing of military tensions. This was also a period when, despite rancour and setbacks, progress was being made in the objectives first established at Pugwash Conferences supported and financed by Cyrus Eaton, objectives such as mutual curtailments in nuclear weapons testing in the atmosphere and negotiations leading to the first agreements on nuclear disarmament and international teams of inspection. It was perfectly fitting that by the time Cyrus Eaton was an old man no longer able to work and travel there was real reason for him to hope that the world he had lived in for so long was returning to some semblance of peace and security. He died in 1979 at 95.

Awards

Eaton's 1950s efforts at rapprochement with the Soviet Union won him the 1960 Lenin Peace Prize. He was elected a Fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences in 1958, and was the recipient of several honourary degrees. The Pugwash Conferences and their Chairman, Joseph Rotblat, were awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 1995. [5]

Philanthropy

Besides financial support for The Pugwash Conferences, Cyrus Eaton gave a lot of money to support education in his home province, particularly to his home town and to Acadia University. He supported the establishment of a game sanctuary in Nova Scotia, and he donated 12 acres (49 hectares) of land in Northfield, Ohio, for the Lee Eaton Elementary School, which was named in memory of his daughter. He was also a financial supporter of McMaster University, the YWCA, the Cleveland Museum of Natural History and Case Western University.

Hyperlinks

1. ^ www.nseaton.org: Cyrus Stephen Eaton, 1883-1979 2. ^ www.nseaton.org: John Eaton 1590-1668 3. ^ www.nseaton.org: David Eaton 1729-1803 4. ^ www.nseaton.org: Amos Eaton 1785-1862 5. ^ "Book of Members, 1780-2010: Chapter E". American Academy of Arts and Sciences. http://www.amacad.org/publications/BookofMembers/ChapterE.pdf. Retrieved 7 April 2011

Bibliography

Beautiful Upon the Mountain by M. Allen Gibson, Lancelot Press, Windsor, Nova Scotia, 1977

Bootstraps: The Autobiography of Tom A Girdler by Tom M. Girdler, New York, Scribner's, 1943

Business At Bay: Critics and Heretics of American Business by Irving S. Michelman, Augustus M. Kelley, Publisher, New York, 1969

Investment Banking in America by Vincent Carosso, Harvard Studies in Business, 1970; pp. 431-457.

Cleveland: The Best Kept Secret by George E. Condon, Doubleday and Company, New York, 1967; pp. 294-315

Cyrus S. Eaton: Capitalist Manipulator by Jamie Maria Phillips, A Masters Degree Thesis, Arizona State University, 1989; 149 pages

Edmonton: Stories from the River City by Tony Cashman, University of Alberta Press, 2002; pp. 113-116

Henry J. Kaiser, The Western Colossus: An Insider's View by Albert P. Heiner, Halo Books, San Francisco, 1991; pp. 232-239

Investment Trusts Gone Wrong by John T. Flynn, New Republic, New York, 1930; pp. 146-157

John L. Lewis:A Biography by Melvyn Dubovsky and Warren Van Tine, Quadrangle Books, New York, 1977; pp. 509-510

“Just Call Me Hays”: Recollections, reactions and reflections on 42 years of railroading by Hays T. Watkins, Jr., REB Communications and Publishing Inc., Jacksonville, Florida, 2001; pp. 52-64; 95-106

My Life in Steel: From CIO to CEO by Harold J. Ruttenburg, Word Association Publishers, Tarentum, Pennsylvania, 2001; pp. 98-129

Promises of Power: a political autobiography by Carl B. Stokes, Simon and Schuster, New York, 1973; pp. 9-21. This book is available in its entirety online at http://www.clevelandmemory.org/ebooks/stokes/

Red Carpet by Joseph Finder, New Republic/Holt, Rinehart & Winston, New York, 1983; pp. 93-112; 152-171; 219-233

Robert R. Young, The Populist of Wall Street by Joseph Borkin, Harper and Row, New York, 1969; pp. 52-61; 78-99

Steep Rock: The Men and the Mines by Bruce W. Taylor, Quetico Publishing, Atikokan, 1978; pp. 31-44

The Great Crash 1929 by John Kenneth Galbraith, Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston, 1988

The Old Lady of Vine Street: The Valiant Fight for the Cincinnati Enquirer by Richard K. Mastain, iUniverse Inc., New York, 2006; pp. 194-274

The World of Cyrus Eaton by Marcus Gleiser, Kent State University Press, 2010; a biography, first published in 1966

The articles that deal with the life, interests, activities and business career of Cyrus Eaton are too numerous to mention. The archives of New York Times are the best source of newspaper information about his daily business career. There are also many articles of general interest in the archives of Time Magazine. A portrait of Eaton appeared on the cover of Time for Feb. 24, 1930. Two other articles of particular interest are the following:

"Profile of American businessman Cyrus Eaton" by E.J. Kahn, The New Yorker, in two parts: 10/10/77, Vol 53, Issue 34, p. 49, and 10/17/77, Vol 53, Issue 35, p. 54.

"The Strange Romance Between John L. Lewis and Cyrus Eaton" by Nathaniel Caldwell and Gene S. Graham, Harper's Magazine, Dec., 1961; pp. 25-32; this article arose out of a Pulitzer Prize winning exposé by the same writers published over a six-year period in The Nashville Tennessean.

External links

• Bio at the Cyrus Eaton Foundation
• Cyrus Eaton interviewed by Mike Wallace on The Mike Wallace Interview