Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Northern Inuit Dog: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
Angelatomato (talk | contribs) |
Angelatomato (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
*'''Keep''' The content of the page could be improved, but this breed of dog is now relatively famous since their appearance on TV, notably in [[Game of Thrones]] - the HBO series. I actually came to this page to learn more about them after I saw them on the show. The "promotion" is questionable bc there are a number of societies and breeders that have the dog or similar dogs (see the talk page - where there is also a lot of fighting...which needs to be resolved). Dog breeders (who may have initiated the article) may not be the best encyclopedia writers or willing to learn or navigate all of the WP rules (one proclaims "stop editing my page" for example)... but with more time, many others can improve this article (and the original editors can learn how WP works). A lot of people have looked at it in a short period of time (28 rated it - and only a small % of people rate articles)...plus there are dozens of questions about this breed of dog on yahoo answers, etc. People are very curious about it since it appeared on TV. It should be improved though...and the Utonagan and the Tamaskan breeders need to resolve their differences w/ this dog breed. [[User:Angelatomato|Angelatomato]] ([[User talk:Angelatomato|talk]]) 22:56, 12 December 2012 (UTC) |
*'''Keep''' The content of the page could be improved (and Tikuko already improved it since my initial post), but this breed of dog is now relatively famous since their appearance on TV, notably in [[Game of Thrones]] - the HBO series. I actually came to this page to learn more about them after I saw them on the show. The "promotion" is questionable bc there are a number of societies and breeders that have the dog or similar dogs (see the talk page - where there is also a lot of fighting...which needs to be resolved). Dog breeders (who may have initiated the article) may not be the best encyclopedia writers or willing to learn or navigate all of the WP rules (one proclaims "stop editing my page" for example)... but with more time, many others can improve this article (and the original editors can learn how WP works). A lot of people have looked at it in a short period of time (28 rated it - and only a small % of people rate articles)...plus there are dozens of questions about this breed of dog on yahoo answers, etc. People are very curious about it since it appeared on TV. It should be improved though...and the Utonagan and the Tamaskan breeders need to resolve their differences w/ this dog breed. [[User:Angelatomato|Angelatomato]] ([[User talk:Angelatomato|talk]]) 22:56, 12 December 2012 (UTC) |
||
*<s>'''Delete'''</s> Essentially the same breed as Tamaskan and Utonagan with minor unimportant differences that consist of "my wolf-looking dog is better than your wolf-looking dog." Also see discussion [[Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Dogs#Tamaskan_Dog_dispute|here]]. --'''[[User:Tikuko|<font color="black">Ti</font><font color="orange">ku</font><font color="gray">ko</font>]]''' 17:28, 13 December 2012 (UTC) |
*<s>'''Delete'''</s> Essentially the same breed as Tamaskan and Utonagan with minor unimportant differences that consist of "my wolf-looking dog is better than your wolf-looking dog." Also see discussion [[Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Dogs#Tamaskan_Dog_dispute|here]]. --'''[[User:Tikuko|<font color="black">Ti</font><font color="orange">ku</font><font color="gray">ko</font>]]''' 17:28, 13 December 2012 (UTC) |
||
Revision as of 05:41, 17 December 2012
- Northern Inuit Dog (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views) – (View log · Stats)
- (Find sources: Google (books · news · scholar · free images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL)
- Not notable;
- Unrecognized by all major dog associations;
- Promotional/advertisement - the only external link is to unofficial 'breed society';
- No references despite 'citations needed' template since March 2008.
There has been a brief discussion here about this article, also Utonagan and Tamaskan Dog. Utonagan is already at AfD and I'm also tagging Tamaskan Dog now. SagaciousPhil - Chat 10:03, 12 December 2012 (UTC)
- Note: This debate has been included in the list of Organisms-related deletion discussions. SagaciousPhil - Chat 13:10, 12 December 2012 (UTC)
- Keep The content of the page could be improved (and Tikuko already improved it since my initial post), but this breed of dog is now relatively famous since their appearance on TV, notably in Game of Thrones - the HBO series. I actually came to this page to learn more about them after I saw them on the show. The "promotion" is questionable bc there are a number of societies and breeders that have the dog or similar dogs (see the talk page - where there is also a lot of fighting...which needs to be resolved). Dog breeders (who may have initiated the article) may not be the best encyclopedia writers or willing to learn or navigate all of the WP rules (one proclaims "stop editing my page" for example)... but with more time, many others can improve this article (and the original editors can learn how WP works). A lot of people have looked at it in a short period of time (28 rated it - and only a small % of people rate articles)...plus there are dozens of questions about this breed of dog on yahoo answers, etc. People are very curious about it since it appeared on TV. It should be improved though...and the Utonagan and the Tamaskan breeders need to resolve their differences w/ this dog breed. Angelatomato (talk) 22:56, 12 December 2012 (UTC)
DeleteEssentially the same breed as Tamaskan and Utonagan with minor unimportant differences that consist of "my wolf-looking dog is better than your wolf-looking dog." Also see discussion here. --Tikuko 17:28, 13 December 2012 (UTC)
- Soft keep, the breed was in fact featured as a major component of an extremely notable TV show. --Tikuko 10:26, 14 December 2012 (UTC)