The Meeting Place Cannot Be Changed: Difference between revisions
m Reverted 1 edit by 208.54.70.205 (talk) to last revision by Drmies. (TW) |
|||
Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
|writer = [[Vayner brothers]]<br>(novel & screenplay) |
|writer = [[Vayner brothers]]<br>(novel & screenplay) |
||
|narrator = |
|narrator = |
||
|starring = [[Vladimir Vysotsky]]<br>[[Vladimir Konkin]]<br>[[Zinovy Gerdt]]<br>[[Armen Dzhigarkhanyan]] |
|starring = [[Vladimir Vysotsky]]<br>[[:ru:Конкин, Владимир Алексеевич|Vladimir Konkin]]<br>[[Zinovy Gerdt]]<br>[[Armen Dzhigarkhanyan]] |
||
|music = [[Yevgeni Gevorgyan]] |
|music = [[Yevgeni Gevorgyan]] |
||
|cinematography = [[Leonid Burlaka]] |
|cinematography = [[Leonid Burlaka]] |
||
Line 21: | Line 21: | ||
|gross = |
|gross = |
||
}} |
}} |
||
'''''The Meeting Place Cannot Be Changed''''' ({{lang-ru|Место встречи изменить нельзя}}, {{translit|''Mesto vstrechi izmenit nelzya''}}) is a 1979 [[Soviet Union|Soviet]] 5-part television [[miniseries]] directed by [[Stanislav Govorukhin]]. It achieved the status of a [[cult film]] in the USSR, and along with ''[[Seventeen Moments of Spring]]'' became a part of popular culture with several generations of [[russophone]] TV viewers. The series star the famed [[singer-songwriter]] [[Vladimir Vysotsky]] in one of his final screen appearances |
'''''The Meeting Place Cannot Be Changed''''' ({{lang-ru|Место встречи изменить нельзя}}, {{translit|''Mesto vstrechi izmenit nelzya''}}) is a 1979 [[Soviet Union|Soviet]] 5-part television [[miniseries]] directed by [[Stanislav Govorukhin]]. It achieved the status of a [[cult film]] in the USSR, and along with ''[[Seventeen Moments of Spring]]'' it became a part of popular culture with several generations of [[russophone]] TV viewers. The series star the famed [[singer-songwriter]] [[Vladimir Vysotsky]] in one of his final screen appearances (his [[Vladimir Vysotsky#Death|death]] at the age of 42 came less than a year after the film's release). Soviet screen and stage legends [[Sergey Yursky]], [[Armen Dzhigarkhanyan]], [[Zinovy Gerdt]], [[Yevgeniy Yevstigneyev]] and [[Leonid Kuravlev]] also appear in the film. |
||
The film was released in the West as ''The Age of Mercy'', the title of the novel by the writing duo of brothers Arkadiy Vayner and Georgiy Vayner, on which the film |
The film was released in the West as ''The Age of Mercy'', the title of the novel by the writing duo of brothers Arkadiy Vayner and Georgiy Vayner, on which the film was based. |
||
The film follows a [[police procedural]] storyline enriched with elements of [[drama]], powerful message on [[human rights]] in a [[totalitarian]] law enforcement environment,<ref>The main protagonists are formally members of the notoriously repressive [[NKVD]] during [[Joseph Stalin]] rule, although it is never directly mentioned in the film.</ref> and rich sociocultural background of the post-[[World War II]] [[Moscow]]. |
|||
==Plot== |
==Plot== |
||
The film is set in post-[[World War II|WWII]] Moscow. |
The film is set in post-[[World War II|WWII]] [[Moscow]]. Vladimir Sharapov (Vladimir Konkin) is a young [[reconnaissance]] officer who has just returned from the war and is assigned for peacetime duty at the famous MUR (Moscow Department of Criminal Investigations). There he becomes part of an elite team led by the brilliant, tough, no-nonsense homicide detective Gleb Zheglov (Vysotsky). The duo becomes embroiled in two seemingly separate investigations: that of the murder of young aspiring actress Larisa Gruzdeva, and the hunt for a vicious gang of armed robbers that calls itself "Black Cat" and constantly manages to evade capture. While suspicion in Gruzdeva's murder initially falls on her estranged husband Dr Gruzdev (Yursky), it gradually becomes apparent that the two cases are connected, as a Black Cat mobster known as Fox is implicated in the murder. As a result of Zheglov's successful high-stakes operation to capture Fox, Sharapov inadvertently finds himself undercover at the Black Cat hideout, sparring with the gang's menacing leader The Hunchback (Dzhigarkhanyan). What ensues is arguably one of Soviet television's most memorable and suspenseful finales. |
||
⚫ | Much of the series revolves around the relationship between Zheglov and Sharapov. While the two become close friends and roommates, they also clash throughout the film. The source of the conflict is Sharapov's disagreement with Zheglov's "ends justify the means" approach to law enforcement. Zheglov thinks that "a thief's place is in prison, and the public couldn't care less how I put him there". To that end, Zheglov thinks nothing of using dubious tactics such as planting evidence to justify the arrest of a known pickpocket. Sharapov, on the other hand, considers that law is a higher value for its own sake and cannot be used merely as a tool. A tense conflict also arises when, in order to mislead Fox, Zheglov elects to continue to hold Dr Gruzdev under arrest even after it becomes clear that the man is innocent. |
||
While suspicion in Gruzdeva's murder initially falls on her estranged husband ''Dr. Gruzdev'' (Yursky), it gradually becomes apparent that the two cases are connected, as a Black Cat mobster and [[Thief in law|Thief in Law]] ''Foks'' (Belyavskiy) is implicated in the murder. As a result of Zheglov's successful high-stakes operation to capture Foks, Sharapov inadvertently finds himself [[Covert operation|undercover]] at the Black Cat hideout, sparring with the gang's menacing leader ''Hunchback'' (Dzhigarkhanyan). What ensues is arguably one of Soviet television's most memorable and suspenseful finales. |
|||
==Other information== |
|||
⚫ | Much of the series revolves around the relationship between Zheglov and Sharapov. While the two become close friends and roommates, they also clash throughout the film. The source of the conflict is Sharapov's disagreement with Zheglov's "ends justify the means" approach to law enforcement. Zheglov thinks that "a thief's place is in prison, and the public couldn't care less how I put him there". To that end, Zheglov thinks nothing of using dubious tactics such as |
||
⚫ | * The film's title is a reference to the finale, where Sharapov's botched attempt to get away after making contact with the gang forces Zheglov to follow a previously discarded plan for an undercover operation. Hoping that Sharapov will lure the bandits to the scene of a prior robbery as they have previously rehearsed, Zheglov utters: "The place and time of the operation cannot be changed." |
||
* Actors [[Sergey Yursky]], [[Zinovy Gerdt]], [[Yevgeniy Yevstigneyev]] and [[Leonid Kuravlev]] star in the series. Years earlier, all four appeared together in the smash hit comedy [[The Little Golden Calf (film)|''The Golden Calf'']] based on the novel by [[Ilf and Petrov]], with Yursky leading the cast as the venerable con artist [[Ostap Bender]]. |
|||
⚫ | |||
⚫ | *According to<ref>{{cite web|url=http://gorod.tomsk.ru/index-1290498039.php |title=Место встречи изменить нельзя,, - Город.томск.ру |language={{ru icon}} |publisher=Gorod.tomsk.ru |date=2010-03-22 |accessdate=2012-09-08}}</ref> Vysotsky played a major creative role in the making of the series. He conceived the idea of turning the novel into a movie after receiving an advance copy of the book from the Vayner brothers, and he actively campaigned for the part of Zheglov despite the fact that the character in the novel was a much younger man. During the making of the film, he frequently substituted for [[Stanislav Govorukhin|Govorukhin]] as director, including directing the entire scene of Dr Gruzdev's interrogation, and he also invented the comical attributes of the character of Kostya "The Brick" Saprykin (a good-natured thief with a speech impediment). |
||
⚫ | *Sharapov's love interest patrolwoman Varya Sinichkina dies at the end of the novel. The ending was altered in the movie because the studio administrator thought it was too depressing. The Vayner brothers later admitted that they liked the new happy ending better.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.newsru.co.il/rest/08jan2007/vainer_int_print.html |title=NEWSru.co.il |publisher=NEWSru.co.il |date= |accessdate=2012-09-08}}</ref> |
||
==In popular culture== |
|||
==Selected cast== |
|||
* The popular song "Atas" by the Russian group [[Lyubeh]] is based on the characters of the film. |
|||
*[[Vladimir Vysotsky]] — ''Gleb Zheglov'' |
|||
* A sculpture of Zheglov and Sharapov ([http://www.geolocation.ws/v/P/53971215/---/en picture]) is installed outside the Internal Affairs Ministry building in [[Kiev]], Ukraine |
|||
*[[Vladimir Konkin]] — ''Volodya Sharapov'' |
|||
*[[Sergei Yursky]] — ''Dr. Gruzdev'' |
|||
*[[Viktor Pavlov]] — ''Levchenko'' |
|||
*[[Leonid Kuravlyov]] — ''Kopchyony'' |
|||
*[[Alexander Borisovich Belyavsky|Aleksandr Belyavskiy]] — ''Yevgeniy "Foks"'', Thief-in-Law |
|||
*[[Evgeni Evstigneev]] — ''Petya "Ruchechnik" Ruchnikov'', Thief-in-Law |
|||
*[[Armen Dzhigarkhanyan]] — ''Hunchback'', Thief-in-Law |
|||
*[[Larisa Udovichenko]] — ''Manka Obligatsiya'' |
|||
*[[Stanislav Sadalskiy]] — ''Kostya "Kirpich" Saprykin'' |
|||
*[[Valeriya Zaklunnaya]] - ''Hunchback Girlfriend '' |
|||
*[[Zinoviy Gerdt]] — ''Mikhail Mikhaylovich'' |
|||
*[[Aleksandr Abdulov]] — ''Gang Driver'' |
|||
*[[Yekaterina Gradova]] — ''Woman with "Ruchechnik"'' |
|||
*[[Ivan Bortnik]] — ''Promokashka'' |
|||
==Production== |
|||
⚫ | The film's title is a reference to the finale, where Sharapov's botched attempt to |
||
The series' historical and cultural accuracy regarding police work is explained by immediate life experience of its creators. On one hand, both screenwriting Vayner brothers received legal education; the elder brother, Arkadiy, was an actual Moscow militsiya detective before becoming a professional writer. Elements of several actual criminal cases were used in the plot.<ref>[http://www.ogoniok.com/archive/2003/4784/05-50-52/ НАСТОЯЩАЯ «ЧЁРНАЯ КОШКА»] 2008 article in ''[[Ogoniok]]'' {{ru icon}}</ref> |
|||
⚫ | |||
Young supporting actor [http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0097550/ Ivan Bortnik] (a close friend of Vysotsky) was appraised for his vivid and accurate portrayal of underdog gang member ''Promokashka'' - the role that dominated his further film acting career. Currently perceived as a stereotypical Russian criminal, Bortnik is coming from a Moscow academic family who never submerged into underworld. He created his iconic part only by recollecting his occasional street contacts with young criminal wannabes. |
|||
Authors of the 1979 series attempted to portray 1940s Moscow with the use of historical neighborhoods in Moscow and [[Odessa]] as well as extensive resources of the [[Odessa Film Studio]]. There were, however, visible inconsistencies such as Sharapov's walking past a railway line with modern [[Electrichka]] and refrigerator train cars moving along it. |
|||
In 1998, Russian TV star [[Leonid Parfyonov]] made a commemorative [[documentary film|documentary]] "Место встречи. 20 лет спустя" (''Meeting Place, Past 20 Years''),<ref>[http://www.ntv.ru/corp/video/View.jsp?vid=73 Место встречи. 20 лет спустя] {{ru icon}}</ref> putting history of the series' creation in the wider social context of both the plot and the production eras. Parfyonov interviewed members and acquaintances of the cast and crew as well as actual police detectives and criminals of the 1970s. |
|||
⚫ | Sharapov's love interest patrolwoman Varya Sinichkina dies at the end of the novel. The ending was altered in the movie because the studio administrator thought it was too depressing. The Vayner brothers later admitted that they liked the new happy ending better.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.newsru.co.il/rest/08jan2007/vainer_int_print.html |title=NEWSru.co.il |publisher=NEWSru.co.il |date= |accessdate=2012-09-08}}</ref> |
||
⚫ | The series were originally intended to have 7 parts, but the Soviet broadcast authorities ordered to trim them down to 5. As a result, many scenes were left out of the final cut, with creators struggling to maintain the flow of the narrative<ref>[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v= |
||
==Cultural impact== |
|||
The film's massive popularity made its texts and messages a major source for the Soviet and post-Soviet culture. |
|||
*For instance, "The Meeting Place Cannot Be Changed" was the first mention of the [[Thief in law|Thief in Law]] [[organized crime]] phenomena in Soviet cinema and television, although it is a background plot element. |
|||
*[[Armen Dzhigarkhanyan]] lampooned his own performance as The Hunchback, in a 1998 installment of a popular Armenian sketch comedy series ''Our Backyard''.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://armeniantube.net/armenian-video/mer-bake/mer-bake-2-video_081d841b4.html |title=Mer Bake - Mer Bake 2 |publisher=Armeniantube.net |date= |accessdate=2012-09-08}}</ref> |
*[[Armen Dzhigarkhanyan]] lampooned his own performance as The Hunchback, in a 1998 installment of a popular Armenian sketch comedy series ''Our Backyard''.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://armeniantube.net/armenian-video/mer-bake/mer-bake-2-video_081d841b4.html |title=Mer Bake - Mer Bake 2 |publisher=Armeniantube.net |date= |accessdate=2012-09-08}}</ref> |
||
*In 2010, Russian Prime Minister [[Vladimir Putin]] used Zheglov's famous "a thief's place is in prison" line in widely criticized remarks against the jailed tycoon [[Mikhail Khodorkovsky]].<ref>{{cite web|author=Cassandra The World in 2012 |url=http://www.economist.com/blogs/theworldin2011/2010/12/khodorkovsky_trial_underlines_putins_power_2011 |title=The Khodorkovsky trial underlines Putin's power in 2011: "A thief should sit in jail..." |publisher=The Economist |date= |accessdate=2012-09-08}}</ref> |
*In 2010, Russian Prime Minister [[Vladimir Putin]] used Zheglov's famous "a thief's place is in prison" line in widely criticized remarks against the jailed tycoon [[Mikhail Khodorkovsky]].<ref>{{cite web|author=Cassandra The World in 2012 |url=http://www.economist.com/blogs/theworldin2011/2010/12/khodorkovsky_trial_underlines_putins_power_2011 |title=The Khodorkovsky trial underlines Putin's power in 2011: "A thief should sit in jail..." |publisher=The Economist |date= |accessdate=2012-09-08}}</ref> |
||
* A sculpture featuring Vysotsky and Konkin (as Zheglov and Sharapov) is installed outside the Internal Affairs Ministry building in [[Kiev]], Ukraine<ref>[http://kiyany.obozrevatel.com/news/2009/4/14/53464.htm В Киеве открыли памятник Жеглову и Шарапову] {{uk icon}}</ref> |
|||
==References== |
==References== |
||
{{Reflist}} |
{{Reflist}} |
||
{{wikiquote|ru:Место встречи изменить нельзя}} |
|||
==External links== |
==External links== |
||
*{{Amg movie|160395}} |
*{{Amg movie|160395}} |
||
*{{imdb title|0078655}} |
*{{imdb title|0078655}} |
||
*"МЕСТО ВСТРЕЧИ. 20 ЛЕТ СПУСТЯ" - [[Leonid Parfyonov]]'s documentary {{ru icon}}: |
|||
**{{YouTube|id=Ox87xIuQDwc|title=Part 1|accessdate=April 23, 2013}} |
|||
**{{YouTube|id=fzOakxS1TZo|title=Part 2|accessdate=April 23, 2013}} |
|||
{{DEFAULTSORT:Meeting Place Cannot Be Changed, The}} |
{{DEFAULTSORT:Meeting Place Cannot Be Changed, The}} |
||
Line 96: | Line 59: | ||
[[Category:Films about organized crime in Russia]] |
[[Category:Films about organized crime in Russia]] |
||
[[Category:Films directed by Stanislav Govorukhin]] |
[[Category:Films directed by Stanislav Govorukhin]] |
||
[[Category:Films set in Moscow]] |
|||
[[Category:Crime drama films]] |
|||
[[Category:Police procedural television series]] |
Revision as of 22:36, 4 August 2013
The Meeting Place Cannot Be Changed | |
---|---|
Directed by | Stanislav Govorukhin |
Written by | Vayner brothers (novel & screenplay) |
Starring | Vladimir Vysotsky Vladimir Konkin Zinovy Gerdt Armen Dzhigarkhanyan |
Cinematography | Leonid Burlaka |
Edited by | Valentina Olejnik |
Music by | Yevgeni Gevorgyan |
Production company | |
Release date | 1979 |
Running time | 359 minutes |
Country | Soviet Union |
Language | Russian |
The Meeting Place Cannot Be Changed (Russian: Место встречи изменить нельзя, [Mesto vstrechi izmenit nelzya] Error: {{Transliteration}}: missing language / script code (help)) is a 1979 Soviet 5-part television miniseries directed by Stanislav Govorukhin. It achieved the status of a cult film in the USSR, and along with Seventeen Moments of Spring it became a part of popular culture with several generations of russophone TV viewers. The series star the famed singer-songwriter Vladimir Vysotsky in one of his final screen appearances (his death at the age of 42 came less than a year after the film's release). Soviet screen and stage legends Sergey Yursky, Armen Dzhigarkhanyan, Zinovy Gerdt, Yevgeniy Yevstigneyev and Leonid Kuravlev also appear in the film.
The film was released in the West as The Age of Mercy, the title of the novel by the writing duo of brothers Arkadiy Vayner and Georgiy Vayner, on which the film was based.
Plot
The film is set in post-WWII Moscow. Vladimir Sharapov (Vladimir Konkin) is a young reconnaissance officer who has just returned from the war and is assigned for peacetime duty at the famous MUR (Moscow Department of Criminal Investigations). There he becomes part of an elite team led by the brilliant, tough, no-nonsense homicide detective Gleb Zheglov (Vysotsky). The duo becomes embroiled in two seemingly separate investigations: that of the murder of young aspiring actress Larisa Gruzdeva, and the hunt for a vicious gang of armed robbers that calls itself "Black Cat" and constantly manages to evade capture. While suspicion in Gruzdeva's murder initially falls on her estranged husband Dr Gruzdev (Yursky), it gradually becomes apparent that the two cases are connected, as a Black Cat mobster known as Fox is implicated in the murder. As a result of Zheglov's successful high-stakes operation to capture Fox, Sharapov inadvertently finds himself undercover at the Black Cat hideout, sparring with the gang's menacing leader The Hunchback (Dzhigarkhanyan). What ensues is arguably one of Soviet television's most memorable and suspenseful finales.
Much of the series revolves around the relationship between Zheglov and Sharapov. While the two become close friends and roommates, they also clash throughout the film. The source of the conflict is Sharapov's disagreement with Zheglov's "ends justify the means" approach to law enforcement. Zheglov thinks that "a thief's place is in prison, and the public couldn't care less how I put him there". To that end, Zheglov thinks nothing of using dubious tactics such as planting evidence to justify the arrest of a known pickpocket. Sharapov, on the other hand, considers that law is a higher value for its own sake and cannot be used merely as a tool. A tense conflict also arises when, in order to mislead Fox, Zheglov elects to continue to hold Dr Gruzdev under arrest even after it becomes clear that the man is innocent.
Other information
- The film's title is a reference to the finale, where Sharapov's botched attempt to get away after making contact with the gang forces Zheglov to follow a previously discarded plan for an undercover operation. Hoping that Sharapov will lure the bandits to the scene of a prior robbery as they have previously rehearsed, Zheglov utters: "The place and time of the operation cannot be changed."
- Actors Sergey Yursky, Zinovy Gerdt, Yevgeniy Yevstigneyev and Leonid Kuravlev star in the series. Years earlier, all four appeared together in the smash hit comedy The Golden Calf based on the novel by Ilf and Petrov, with Yursky leading the cast as the venerable con artist Ostap Bender.
- The series were originally intended to have 7 parts, but the Soviet broadcast authorities ordered to trim them down to 5. As a result, many scenes were left out of the final cut, with creators struggling to maintain the flow of the narrative[1]
- According to[2] Vysotsky played a major creative role in the making of the series. He conceived the idea of turning the novel into a movie after receiving an advance copy of the book from the Vayner brothers, and he actively campaigned for the part of Zheglov despite the fact that the character in the novel was a much younger man. During the making of the film, he frequently substituted for Govorukhin as director, including directing the entire scene of Dr Gruzdev's interrogation, and he also invented the comical attributes of the character of Kostya "The Brick" Saprykin (a good-natured thief with a speech impediment).
- Sharapov's love interest patrolwoman Varya Sinichkina dies at the end of the novel. The ending was altered in the movie because the studio administrator thought it was too depressing. The Vayner brothers later admitted that they liked the new happy ending better.[3]
In popular culture
- The popular song "Atas" by the Russian group Lyubeh is based on the characters of the film.
- A sculpture of Zheglov and Sharapov (picture) is installed outside the Internal Affairs Ministry building in Kiev, Ukraine
- Armen Dzhigarkhanyan lampooned his own performance as The Hunchback, in a 1998 installment of a popular Armenian sketch comedy series Our Backyard.[4]
- In 2010, Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin used Zheglov's famous "a thief's place is in prison" line in widely criticized remarks against the jailed tycoon Mikhail Khodorkovsky.[5]
References
- ^ [1]
- ^ "Место встречи изменить нельзя,, - Город.томск.ру" (in Template:Ru icon). Gorod.tomsk.ru. 2010-03-22. Retrieved 2012-09-08.
{{cite web}}
: CS1 maint: unrecognized language (link) - ^ "NEWSru.co.il". NEWSru.co.il. Retrieved 2012-09-08.
- ^ "Mer Bake - Mer Bake 2". Armeniantube.net. Retrieved 2012-09-08.
- ^ Cassandra The World in 2012. "The Khodorkovsky trial underlines Putin's power in 2011: "A thief should sit in jail..."". The Economist. Retrieved 2012-09-08.
{{cite web}}
: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)