White savior narrative in film: Difference between revisions
m ←Blanked the page |
|||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
In film, the white savior narrative is a cinematic [[trope (literature)|trope]] in which a [[white people|white]] character rescues [[person of color|people of color]] from their plight. The white savior is portrayed as messianic and often learns something about themselves in the process of rescuing.<ref name="temple1" /> The trope reflects how media represents [[sociology of race and ethnic relations|race relations]] by racializing concepts like morality as identifiable with white people over nonwhite people.<ref name="temple2" /> White saviors are often male and are sometimes out of place in their own society until they lead minorities or foreigners. ''Screen Saviors: Hollywood Fictions of Whiteness'' labels the stories as fantasies that "are essentially grandiose, exhibitionistic, and narcissistic". Types of stories include white travels to "exotic" Asian locations, white defense against racism in the [[Southern United States|American South]], or white protagonists having "racially diverse" helpers.<ref name="vera" /> |
|||
David Sirota at ''[[Salon.com]]'' said, "These story lines insinuate that people of color have no ability to rescue themselves. This both makes white audiences feel good about themselves by portraying them as benevolent messiahs (rather than hegemonic conquerors), and also depicts people of color as helpless weaklings—all while wrapping such tripe in the cinematic argot of liberation."<ref name="sirota" /> Noah Berlatsky in ''[[The Atlantic]]'' said the narrative varies from film to film, though slavery films, including award-winning ones, lack range in theme. He wrote, "All of these critically acclaimed films use variations on a single narrative: Black people are oppressed by bad white people. They achieve freedom through the offices of good white people."<ref name="berlatsky" /> The white savior narrative is considered a cliché in [[cinema of the United States]]; the narrative is especially common in films about white teachers in [[inner cities]].<ref name="goff" /> |
|||
==List of films== |
|||
<!-- PLEASE ADD A FILM AND ITS CITATION IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER --> |
|||
{| class="sortable" border="1" cellpadding="5" cellspacing="5" style="border-collapse: collapse; border-style: hidden;" |
|||
|- |
|||
! scope="col" | Film |
|||
! scope="col" | Year |
|||
! scope="col" class="unsortable" style=white-space:nowrap | Description |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[12 Years a Slave (film)|12 Years a Slave]]'' || 2013 || In the historical film set in 1841 onward, free-born African American Solomon Northup (played by [[Chiwetel Ejiofor]]) is kidnapped and sold into slavery. In the film's denouement, a white Canadian (played by [[Brad Pitt]]) rescues Northup from enslavement.<ref name="goff" /> While ''12 Years a Slave'' focused mainly on Northup's resilience, and a Canadian did in reality rescue Northup, the film was identified as a cinematic representation of slavery that depicted a white savior.<ref name="berlatsky" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''{{sortname|The|Air Up There}}'' || 1994 || A disgraced white basketball coach (played by [[Kevin Bacon]]) travels to an African village in [[Kenya]] to recruit a prospect.<ref name="goff" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Amistad (film)|Amistad]]'' || 1997 || In the 1830s, a group of African slaves who commit mutiny are captured by the U.S. military, and a legal battle ensues in which the white lawyer [[John Quincy Adams]] defends their right to be freed.<ref name="berlatsky" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Avatar (2009 film)|Avatar]]'' || 2009 || In the science fiction film, a white former Marine (played by [[Sam Worthington]]) goes to another planet and becomes part of an alien tribe, ultimately leading them to victory against his people's military.<ref name="sirota" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''{{sortname|The|Blind Side|dab=film}}'' || 2009 || A white woman and football fan (played by [[Sandra Bullock]]) takes a black teenager (played by [[Quinton Aaron]]) into her home, and he plays football with her support through his high school and college years.<ref name="goff" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Blood Diamond (film)|Blood Diamond]]'' || 2006 || A racist white Rhodesian mercenary (played by [[Leonardo DiCaprio]]) rescues a black [[Sierra Leone|Sierra Leonese]] (played by [[Djimon Hounsou]]) and his son from black villains.<ref name="lacy" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[City of Joy (film)|City of Joy]]'' || 1992 || A white American doctor (played by [[Patrick Swayze]]) travels to India to find enlightenment. He sets up a free clinic to serve the poor, and though reluctant at first, he decides to stay with the people.<ref name="vera" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Conrack]]'' || 1974 || A white teacher (played by [[Jon Voight]]) is sent to an island off the coast of [[South Carolina]], where he teaches children of poor black families.<ref name="hughey" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Cool Runnings]]'' || 1993 || In the comedy film, black Jamaicans who want to form [[Jamaica national bobsleigh team|a national bobsled team]] are helped by a disgraced former bobsledder (played by [[John Candy]]).<ref name="goff" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Cry Freedom]]'' || 1987 || The film features white journalist [[Donald Woods]] (played by [[Kevin Kline]]) who learns to appreciate the [[Internal resistance to South African apartheid|anti-apartheid movement]] in [[South Africa]] and its black leader [[Steven Biko]] (played by [[Denzel Washington]]). Woods leaves the country to report the apartheid system to the world.<ref name="sirota" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Dances with Wolves]]'' || 1990 || In the 1860s, a white Union soldier (played by [[Kevin Costner]]) becomes part of the [[Sioux]], a [[Native American]] tribe. He leads the Sioux against their rivals the [[Pawnee people|Pawnee]] and later helps them escape the army he once served.<ref name="goff" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Dangerous Minds]]'' || 1995 || A white teacher (played by [[Michelle Pfeiffer]]) teaches African and Hispanic American teenagers at an [[inner city]] high school.<ref name="goff" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[District 9]]'' || 2009 || A white South African government official (played by [[Sharlto Copley]]) works to relocate extraterrestrials to a new internment camp. When he is infected by a fluid and gradually changes into an extraterrestrial himself, he fights against the transition and is motivated to free extraterrestrials so they can provide a cure for his condition.<ref name="sirota" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Django Unchained]]'' || 2012 || In 1858, black slave Django (played by [[Jamie Foxx]]) is freed by the white German bounty hunter Schultz (played by [[Christoph Waltz]]), and they work together to free Django's wife.<ref name="berlatsky" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Elysium (film)|Elysium]]'' || 2013 || In the science fiction film, a white assembly worker (played by [[Matt Damon]]) from a mostly nonwhite community travels to a space station to find a cure for radiation poisoning, sacrifices himself so medical devices could be used to heal people on Earth.<ref name="metz" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Finding Forrester]]'' || 2000 || A white reclusive writer (played by [[Sean Connery]]) sees potential writing skill in a black high school student and helps him with his writing.<ref name="barber" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Freedom Writers]]'' || 2007 || In the mid-1990s in [[Long Beach, California]], a white teacher (played by [[Hilary Swank]]) strives to educate nonwhite high school students despite their neighborhood conditions.<ref name="barone" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Glory (1989 film)|Glory]]'' || 1989 || During the [[American Civil War]], a regiment of black Union soldiers serve under the white Colonel Robert Gould Shaw. Through Shaw, they are able to fight back against slavery.<ref name="berlatsky" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Gran Torino]]'' || 2008 || A racist white Korean War veteran (played by [[Clint Eastwood]]) helps a [[Hmong American]] teenager and ultimately protects him and his family from a Hmong American gang.<ref name="sirota" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''{{sortname|The|Green Berets|dab=film}}'' || 1968 || The [[Vietnam War]] propaganda film depicts a white military commander (played by [[John Wayne]]) who fights for the [[South Vietnamese]].<ref name="vera" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Half Nelson (film)|Half Nelson]]'' || 2006 || A white teacher with a drug addiction (played by [[Ryan Gosling]]) teaches at an [[inner city]] middle school, and befriending a black student, learns to overcome his addiction.<ref name="hughey" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Hardball (film)|Hardball]]'' || 2001 || A white gambler (played by [[Keanu Reeves]]) is required to coach a baseball team of black children from Chicago's [[ABLA]] housing projects to pay off his gambling debts.<ref name="barone" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''{{sortname|The|Help|dab=film}}'' || 2011 || In 1963 in [[Jackson, Mississippi]], a young white woman (played by [[Emma Stone]]) strives for a career in journalism and encourages black maids to share their personal experiences despite the racism prevalent at the time.<ref name="goff" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| style=white-space:nowrap | ''[[Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom]]'' || 1984 || White archaeologist and adventurer [[Indiana Jones]] (played by [[Harrison Ford]]) rescues Indian peasants from a cult that sacrifices them.<ref name="vera" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''{{sortname|The|Last Samurai}}'' || 2003 || In the 1870s, a white former Union Army officer (played by [[Tom Cruise]]) travels to Japan and ultimately joins a group of [[samurai]], helping them to resist corrupt advisers to the Japanese Emperor.<ref name="goff" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Lawrence of Arabia (film)|Lawrence of Arabia]]'' || 1962 || The white [[British Army]] officer [[T. E. Lawrence]] (played by [[Peter O'Toole]]) leads Arabs in a revolt against the Turks.<ref name="gehlawat" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Lincoln (2012 film)|Lincoln]]'' || 2012 || The historical film focuses on the efforts of President [[Abraham Lincoln]] and other white figures to win the [[American Civil War]] and end slavery.<ref name="berlatsky" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Machine Gun Preacher]]'' || 2011 || A white ex-convict travels to [[South Sudan]] to rebuild homes and finds himself having to save its residents from soldiers involved in a civil war.<ref name="barone" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''{{sortname|The|Man Who Would Be King|dab=film}}'' || 1975 || Based on a story by [[Rudyard Kipling]], two white British adventurers (played by [[Sean Connery]] and [[Michael Caine]]) in the 1880s are crowned kings in a non-white country ([[Kafiristan]]). While the narrative is depicted as ironic, the natives are portrayed in a cliched manner.<ref name="vera" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''{{sortname|The|Matrix}}'' || 1999 || In the science fiction film, a white computer hacker (played by [[Keanu Reeves]]) is rescued from being plugged into a computer system and becomes a messiah figure who confronts all-white villains. Black characters serve him as disciples.<ref name="vera" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Mississippi Burning]]'' || 1988 || In 1964, two white FBI agents (played by [[Gene Hackman]] and [[Willem Dafoe]]) travel to [[Mississippi]] to investigate the murders of civil rights organizers, one of whom is black. They are depicted as heroes in the black struggle. Director Alan Parker said of the casting, "Because it’s a movie, I felt it ''had'' to be fictionalized. The two heroes in the story had to be white. That is a reflection of our society as much as of the film industry. At this point in time, it could not have been made in any other way."<ref name="sirota" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Music of the Heart]]'' || 1999 || A white music teacher teaches nonwhite students at an [[inner city]] school.<ref name="goff" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest (film)|One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest]]'' || 1975 || A white protagonist (played by [[Jack Nicholson]]) is in a mental hospital and confronts its cruel nurse, ultimately inspiring a Native American patient to escape the hospital.<ref name="vera" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''{{sortname|The|Principal}}'' || 1987 || A white teacher (played by [[James Belushi]]) teaches nonwhite students at an [[inner city]] school.<ref name="goff" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Radio (2003 film)|Radio]]'' || 2003 || A white high school football coach (played by [[Ed Harris]]) helps a mentally handicapped black football fan (played by [[Cuba Gooding Jr.]]) become more involved with the team.<ref name="barone" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''{{sortname|The|Ron Clark Story}}'' || 2006 || <ref name="kivel" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''{{sortname|The|Soloist}}'' || 2009 || A white man (played by [[Robert Downey Jr.]]) helps a black mentally handicapped and homeless man (played by [[Jamie Foxx]]) revive his passion and skill in music.<ref name="barone" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Stargate (film)|Stargate]]'' || 1994 || In the science fiction film, a white [[Egyptologist]] and linguist (played by [[James Spader]]) and a white military colonel (played by [[Kurt Russell]]) rescue a nonwhite population on an alien planet from their extraterrestrial slavers.<ref name="vera" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Sunset Park (film)|Sunset Park]]'' || 1996 || A white physical education teacher (played by [[Rhea Perlman]]) who coaches a basketball team of black players and succeeds in taking them to the city championships.<ref name="hughey" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Three Kings (1999 film)|Three Kings]]'' || 1999 || <ref name="vera" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[To Kill a Mockingbird (film)|To Kill a Mockingbird]]'' || 1962 || <ref name="barber" /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| ''[[Wildcats (film)|Wildcats]]'' || 1986 || <ref name="goff" /> |
|||
|} |
|||
==See also== |
|||
* [[Magical Negro]] |
|||
* [[List of Magical Negro occurrences in fiction]] |
|||
==References== |
|||
{{Reflist|30em|refs= |
|||
<ref name="barber">{{cite news | last=Barber | first=Mike | url=http://www.huffingtonpost.com/mike-barber/white-mans-burden-redux-t_b_378644.html | title=White Man's Burden Redux: The Movie! | work=[[The Huffington Post]] | date=December 3, 2009 | accessdate=May 14, 2014 }}</ref> |
|||
<ref name="barone">{{cite news | last=Barone | first=Matt | url=http://www.complex.com/pop-culture/2011/09/the-10-lamest-white-savior-movies/ | title=The 10 Lamest White Savior Movies | work=Complex.com | publisher=Complex Media | date=September 20, 2011 | accessdate=May 14, 2014 }}</ref> |
|||
<ref name="berlatsky">{{cite news | last=Berlatsky | first=Noah | url=http://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2014/01/-em-12-years-a-slave-em-yet-another-oscar-nominated-white-savior-story/283142/ | title=''12 Years a Slave'': Yet Another Oscar-Nominated 'White Savior' Story | work=[[The Atlantic]] | date=January 17, 2014 | accessdate=May 14, 2014 }}</ref> |
|||
<ref name="gehlawat">{{cite book | last=Gehlawat | first=Ajay | year=2013 | title=The Slumdog Phenomenon: A Critical Anthology | publisher=Anthem Press | isbn=978-0-85728-001-5 | page=83 }}</ref> |
|||
<ref name="goff">{{cite news | last=Goff | first=Keli | url=http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/05/04/can-belle-end-hollywood-s-obsession-with-the-white-savior.html | title=Can 'Belle' End Hollywood's Obsession with the White Savior? | work=[[The Daily Beast]] | date=May 4, 2014 | accessdate=May 14, 2014 }}</ref> |
|||
<ref name="hughey">{{cite journal | last=Hughey | first=Matthew W. |date=Summer 2010 | title=The White Savior Film and Reviewers' Reception | journal=Symbolic Interaction | volume=33 | issue=3 | pages=475–496 | doi=10.1525/si.2010.33.3.475}}</ref> |
|||
<ref name="lacy">{{cite book | last=Lacy | first=Michael G. | year=2011 | title=Critical Rhetorics of Race | publisher=[[New York University Press]] | isbn=978-0-8147-6529-6 | page=13 }}</ref> |
|||
<ref name="kivel">{{cite book | last=Kivel | first=Paul | year=2013 | title=Living in the Shadow of the Cross: Understanding and Resisting the Power and Privilege of Christian Hegemony | publisher=New Society Publishers | isbn=978-1-55092-541-8 }}</ref> |
|||
<ref name="metz">{{cite news | last=Metz | first=Jessie-Lane | url=http://bitchmagazine.org/post/a-future-without-me-matt-damon-is-the-great-white-hope-in-elysium-race-feminist-movie-review | title=A Future Without Me: Matt Damon is the Great White Hope in 'Elysium'| work=[[Bitch Magazine]] | date=August 21, 2013 | accessdate=August 24, 2014 }}</ref> |
|||
<ref name="sirota">{{cite news | last=Sirota | first=David | url=http://www.salon.com/2013/02/21/oscar_loves_a_white_savior/ | title=Oscar loves a white savior | work=[[Salon.com]] | date=February 21, 2013 | accessdate=May 14, 2014 }}</ref> |
|||
<ref name="temple1">{{cite web | url=http://www.temple.edu/tempress/titles/2263_reg.html | title=Matthew W. Hughey: The White Savior Film | work=temple.edu | publisher=[[Temple University]] | accessdate=October 1, 2014 }}</ref> |
|||
<ref name="temple2">{{cite web | url=http://www.temple.edu/tempress/authors/2263_qa.html | title=Interview with Matthew W. Hughey | work=temple.edu | publisher=[[Temple University]] | accessdate=October 1, 2014 }}</ref> |
|||
<ref name="vera">{{cite book | last1=Vera | first1=Hernán | last2=Gordon | first2=Andrew M. | year=2003 | chapter=The Beautiful White American: Sincere Fictions of the Savior | title=Screen Saviors: Hollywood Fictions of Whiteness | publisher=Rowman & Littlefield Publishers | isbn=978-1-4616-4286-2 | pages=32–33 }}</ref> |
|||
}} |
|||
==Further reading== |
|||
*{{cite book | last=Hughey | first=Matthew | year=2014 | title=The White Savior Film: Content, Critics, and Consumption | publisher=Temple University Press | isbn=978-1-4399-1001-6 }} |
|||
==External links== |
|||
* [http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/WhiteMansBurden White Man's Burden] on [[TV Tropes]] with more examples in films and other works |
|||
[[Category:Films about race and ethnicity]] |
|||
[[Category:Lists of films by common content]] |
|||
[[Category:Sociology of culture]] |
Revision as of 08:58, 1 February 2015
In film, the white savior narrative is a cinematic trope in which a white character rescues people of color from their plight. The white savior is portrayed as messianic and often learns something about themselves in the process of rescuing.[1] The trope reflects how media represents race relations by racializing concepts like morality as identifiable with white people over nonwhite people.[2] White saviors are often male and are sometimes out of place in their own society until they lead minorities or foreigners. Screen Saviors: Hollywood Fictions of Whiteness labels the stories as fantasies that "are essentially grandiose, exhibitionistic, and narcissistic". Types of stories include white travels to "exotic" Asian locations, white defense against racism in the American South, or white protagonists having "racially diverse" helpers.[3]
David Sirota at Salon.com said, "These story lines insinuate that people of color have no ability to rescue themselves. This both makes white audiences feel good about themselves by portraying them as benevolent messiahs (rather than hegemonic conquerors), and also depicts people of color as helpless weaklings—all while wrapping such tripe in the cinematic argot of liberation."[4] Noah Berlatsky in The Atlantic said the narrative varies from film to film, though slavery films, including award-winning ones, lack range in theme. He wrote, "All of these critically acclaimed films use variations on a single narrative: Black people are oppressed by bad white people. They achieve freedom through the offices of good white people."[5] The white savior narrative is considered a cliché in cinema of the United States; the narrative is especially common in films about white teachers in inner cities.[6]
List of films
See also
References
- ^ "Matthew W. Hughey: The White Savior Film". temple.edu. Temple University. Retrieved October 1, 2014.
- ^ "Interview with Matthew W. Hughey". temple.edu. Temple University. Retrieved October 1, 2014.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i Vera, Hernán; Gordon, Andrew M. (2003). "The Beautiful White American: Sincere Fictions of the Savior". Screen Saviors: Hollywood Fictions of Whiteness. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. pp. 32–33. ISBN 978-1-4616-4286-2.
- ^ a b c d e f Sirota, David (February 21, 2013). "Oscar loves a white savior". Salon.com. Retrieved May 14, 2014.
- ^ a b c d e f Berlatsky, Noah (January 17, 2014). "12 Years a Slave: Yet Another Oscar-Nominated 'White Savior' Story". The Atlantic. Retrieved May 14, 2014.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l Goff, Keli (May 4, 2014). "Can 'Belle' End Hollywood's Obsession with the White Savior?". The Daily Beast. Retrieved May 14, 2014.
- ^ Lacy, Michael G. (2011). Critical Rhetorics of Race. New York University Press. p. 13. ISBN 978-0-8147-6529-6.
- ^ a b c Hughey, Matthew W. (Summer 2010). "The White Savior Film and Reviewers' Reception". Symbolic Interaction. 33 (3): 475–496. doi:10.1525/si.2010.33.3.475.
- ^ Metz, Jessie-Lane (August 21, 2013). "A Future Without Me: Matt Damon is the Great White Hope in 'Elysium'". Bitch Magazine. Retrieved August 24, 2014.
- ^ a b Barber, Mike (December 3, 2009). "White Man's Burden Redux: The Movie!". The Huffington Post. Retrieved May 14, 2014.
- ^ a b c d e Barone, Matt (September 20, 2011). "The 10 Lamest White Savior Movies". Complex.com. Complex Media. Retrieved May 14, 2014.
- ^ Gehlawat, Ajay (2013). The Slumdog Phenomenon: A Critical Anthology. Anthem Press. p. 83. ISBN 978-0-85728-001-5.
- ^ Kivel, Paul (2013). Living in the Shadow of the Cross: Understanding and Resisting the Power and Privilege of Christian Hegemony. New Society Publishers. ISBN 978-1-55092-541-8.
Further reading
- Hughey, Matthew (2014). The White Savior Film: Content, Critics, and Consumption. Temple University Press. ISBN 978-1-4399-1001-6.
External links
- White Man's Burden on TV Tropes with more examples in films and other works