Jump to content

Henderson Brooks–Bhagat Report: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
Reorganised content
Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit
Rescuing 1 sources and tagging 0 as dead. #IABot (v1.3beta4)
Line 5: Line 5:
The report is said to be openly critical of the Indian political and military structure of the time, as well as of the execution of operations. According to Australian journalist [[Neville Maxwell]], the report says that the Indian government which was keen to recover territory, advocated a cautious policy; whilst the Army Headquarters dictated a policy that was militarily unsound.<ref>{{cite web|title=Henderson-Brooks report hold Bureaucracy for defeat in 1962 China War|url=http://news.biharprabha.com/2014/03/henderson-brooks-report-hold-bureaucracy-for-defeat-in-1962-china-war/|work=IANS|publisher=news.biharprabha.com|accessdate=18 March 2014}}</ref>
The report is said to be openly critical of the Indian political and military structure of the time, as well as of the execution of operations. According to Australian journalist [[Neville Maxwell]], the report says that the Indian government which was keen to recover territory, advocated a cautious policy; whilst the Army Headquarters dictated a policy that was militarily unsound.<ref>{{cite web|title=Henderson-Brooks report hold Bureaucracy for defeat in 1962 China War|url=http://news.biharprabha.com/2014/03/henderson-brooks-report-hold-bureaucracy-for-defeat-in-1962-china-war/|work=IANS|publisher=news.biharprabha.com|accessdate=18 March 2014}}</ref>


On 17 March 2014, Neville Maxwell posted Volume 1 of the two-volume report on his website.<ref name="unnithan">{{cite news |last=Unnithan |first=Sandeep|title=Henderson Brooks report lists the guilty men of 1962 |url=http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/the-guilty-men-of-1962-india-china-war-jawahar-lal-nehru-krishna-menon/1/350080.html |accessdate=8 April 2014 |newspaper=India Today |date=18 March 2014}}</ref> Maxwell had acquired a copy of the report and wrote his book ''India's China War'' based on it.<ref name="pandalai">{{cite news |last=Pandalai |first=Shruti |title=Burying Open Secrets: India's 1962 War and the Henderson-Brooks Report |url=http://southasia.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2014/04/02/burying_open_secrets_indias_1962_war_and_the_henderson_brooks_report |accessdate=8 April 2014 |newspaper=Foreign Policy |date=2 April 2014}}</ref> In an interview, Maxwell says he has never seen Volume 2, but understands it to be "mainly memos, written statements and other documents on which the authors based the report".<ref name="chowdhury">
On 17 March 2014, Neville Maxwell posted Volume 1 of the two-volume report on his website.<ref name="unnithan">{{cite news |last=Unnithan |first=Sandeep|title=Henderson Brooks report lists the guilty men of 1962 |url=http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/the-guilty-men-of-1962-india-china-war-jawahar-lal-nehru-krishna-menon/1/350080.html |accessdate=8 April 2014 |newspaper=India Today |date=18 March 2014}}</ref> Maxwell had acquired a copy of the report and wrote his book ''India's China War'' based on it.<ref name="pandalai">{{cite news|last=Pandalai |first=Shruti |title=Burying Open Secrets: India's 1962 War and the Henderson-Brooks Report |url=http://southasia.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2014/04/02/burying_open_secrets_indias_1962_war_and_the_henderson_brooks_report |accessdate=8 April 2014 |newspaper=Foreign Policy |date=2 April 2014 |deadurl=yes |archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20140408224604/http://southasia.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2014/04/02/burying_open_secrets_indias_1962_war_and_the_henderson_brooks_report |archivedate=8 April 2014 |df= }}</ref> In an interview, Maxwell says he has never seen Volume 2, but understands it to be "mainly memos, written statements and other documents on which the authors based the report".<ref name="chowdhury">
{{cite news
{{cite news
| title = Neville Maxwell interview: the full transcript
| title = Neville Maxwell interview: the full transcript

Revision as of 16:50, 31 March 2017

The Henderson Brooks-Bhagat report, also referred to as the Henderson Brooks report, is the report of an analysis (Operations Review) of the Sino-Indian War of 1962. Its authors are officers of the Indian armed forces. They are Lieutenant-General T.B. Henderson Brooks and Brigadier Premindra Singh Bhagat, commandant of the Indian Military Academy at the time.

More than 50 years after its creation, the report remains classified by the Indian government.[1] In April 2010, India's Defence Minister A.K. Antony told Parliament that the report could not be declassified because its contents “are not only extremely sensitive but are of current operational value.".[2] This statement was criticized by BJP leaders including Arun Jaitley who even penned a blog post on it . After May 2014, when BJP led government came to power ; the newly appointed Defence Minister Arun Jaitley refused to declassify the report. Jaitley removed his blog post and also agreed that the Brooks report could not be declassified.[3]

The report is said to be openly critical of the Indian political and military structure of the time, as well as of the execution of operations. According to Australian journalist Neville Maxwell, the report says that the Indian government which was keen to recover territory, advocated a cautious policy; whilst the Army Headquarters dictated a policy that was militarily unsound.[4]

On 17 March 2014, Neville Maxwell posted Volume 1 of the two-volume report on his website.[5] Maxwell had acquired a copy of the report and wrote his book India's China War based on it.[6] In an interview, Maxwell says he has never seen Volume 2, but understands it to be "mainly memos, written statements and other documents on which the authors based the report".[7]

Some analysts argue that continuing public controversy over the report indicates that many of the problems identified in the report continue today.[8]

On 15 November 2014, Congress leader Captain Amarinder Singh said the report should be made public by the Narendra Modi led administration.[9][10]

References

  1. ^ Declassification law on official documents needs review, says committee Murali Krishnan, Nerve News, [1]
  2. ^ The ghost of 1962, by Venkatesan Vembu, Daily News & Analysis, 2 May 2010, [2]
  3. ^ http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report-did-arun-jaitley-delete-his-blogpost-on-the-india-china-war-report-from-his-website-2000849
  4. ^ "Henderson-Brooks report hold Bureaucracy for defeat in 1962 China War". IANS. news.biharprabha.com. Retrieved 18 March 2014.
  5. ^ Unnithan, Sandeep (18 March 2014). "Henderson Brooks report lists the guilty men of 1962". India Today. Retrieved 8 April 2014.
  6. ^ Pandalai, Shruti (2 April 2014). "Burying Open Secrets: India's 1962 War and the Henderson-Brooks Report". Foreign Policy. Archived from the original on 8 April 2014. Retrieved 8 April 2014. {{cite news}}: Unknown parameter |deadurl= ignored (|url-status= suggested) (help)
  7. ^ Debasish Roy Chowdhury (2014-03-31). "Neville Maxwell interview: the full transcript". South China Morning Post. Retrieved 2014-03-31.
  8. ^ David Brewster. "Leaked 1962 report reveals India's still-unresolved military weaknesses, Lowy Interpreter, 2 April 2014. Retrieved 1 September 2014".
  9. ^ Amarinder Singh wants disclosure of Henderson Brooks Report on '62 War
  10. ^ Henderson Report should be made public: Amarinder
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Henderson_Brooks–Bhagat_Report&oldid=773150371"