Jump to content

Chasmosaurus: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
→‎Discovery and species: Campbell et al. 2019 consider AMNH 5402 and YPM 2016 distinct from C. belli and more closely related to Vagaceratops (which they refer to Chasmosaurus)
Line 28: Line 28:
In 1898, [[Lawrence Lambe|Lawrence Morris Lambe]] of the [[Geological Survey of Canada]] made at the [[Berry Creek]] the first discovery of ''Chasmosaurus'' remains, [[holotype]] '''NMC 491''', a [[parietal bone]] that was part of a neck frill.<ref name="ageofdinosaurschasmosaurus"/> Although recognizing that his find represented a new species, Lambe thought this could be placed in a previously-known short-frilled ceratopsian genus: ''[[Monoclonius]]''.<ref name="ageofdinosaurschasmosaurus"/> He erected the new species ''Monoclonius belli'' to describe his finding.<ref name="ageofdinosaurschasmosaurus"/> The [[specific name (zoology)|specific name]] honoured collector Walter Bell.<ref>Lambe, L.M., 1902, "New genera and species from the Belly River Series (mid-Cretaceous)", ''Geological Survey of Canada Contributions to Canadian Palaeontology'' '''3'''(2): 25-81</ref>
In 1898, [[Lawrence Lambe|Lawrence Morris Lambe]] of the [[Geological Survey of Canada]] made at the [[Berry Creek]] the first discovery of ''Chasmosaurus'' remains, [[holotype]] '''NMC 491''', a [[parietal bone]] that was part of a neck frill.<ref name="ageofdinosaurschasmosaurus"/> Although recognizing that his find represented a new species, Lambe thought this could be placed in a previously-known short-frilled ceratopsian genus: ''[[Monoclonius]]''.<ref name="ageofdinosaurschasmosaurus"/> He erected the new species ''Monoclonius belli'' to describe his finding.<ref name="ageofdinosaurschasmosaurus"/> The [[specific name (zoology)|specific name]] honoured collector Walter Bell.<ref>Lambe, L.M., 1902, "New genera and species from the Belly River Series (mid-Cretaceous)", ''Geological Survey of Canada Contributions to Canadian Palaeontology'' '''3'''(2): 25-81</ref>


However, in 1913, [[Charles Hazelius Sternberg]] and his sons found several complete "M. belli" skulls in the middle [[Dinosaur Park Formation]] of [[Alberta]], [[Canada]].<ref name=ABS09/> In January 1914, Lambe named all these finds as a separate genus: ''Protorosaurus'', the name indicating an ancestry to ''[[Torosaurus]]''.<ref>Lambe, L.M., 1914, "On the forelimb of a carnivorous dinosaur from the Belly River Formation of Alberta, and a new genus of Ceratopsia from the same horizon, with remarks on the integument of some Cretaceous herbivorous dinosaurs", ''The Ottawa Naturalist'' '''27'''(10): 129-135</ref> However, this name quickly was shown to be preoccupied by a Permian reptile, ''[[Protorosaurus]]'', described by Meyer in 1836. Therefore, Lambe created the replacement name ''Chasmosaurus'' in February 1914.<ref name="ageofdinosaurschasmosaurus"/> It is derived from Greek χάσμα, ''khasma'', "opening" or "divide" and refers to the very large parietal fenestrae in the skull frill. Lambe now also assigned a [[paratype]], specimen NMC 2245 found by the Sternbergs in 1913 and consisting of a largely complete skeleton, including skin impressions.<ref>Lambe, L.M., 1914, "On ''Gryposaurus notabilis'', a new genus and species of trachodont dinosaur from the Belly River Formation of Alberta, with a description of the skull of ''Chasmosaurus belli''", ''The Ottawa Naturalist'' '''27''': 145-155</ref>
However, in 1913, [[Charles Hazelius Sternberg]] and his sons found several complete "M. belli" skulls in the middle [[Dinosaur Park Formation]] of [[Alberta]], [[Canada]].<ref name=ABS09/> Based on these finds, Lambe (1914) erected ''Protorosaurus'' ("before ''[[Torosaurus]]''),<ref>Lambe, L.M., 1914, "On the forelimb of a carnivorous dinosaur from the Belly River Formation of Alberta, and a new genus of Ceratopsia from the same horizon, with remarks on the integument of some Cretaceous herbivorous dinosaurs", ''The Ottawa Naturalist'' '''27'''(10): 129-135</ref> but that name was preoccupied by the Permian reptile ''[[Protorosaurus]]'', so he subsequently created the replacement name ''Chasmosaurus'' in February 1914. The name ''Chasmosaurus'' is derived from Greek χάσμα, ''khasma'', "opening" or "divide" and refers to the very large parietal fenestrae in the skull frill. Lambe now also assigned a [[paratype]], specimen NMC 2245 found by the Sternbergs in 1913 and consisting of a largely complete skeleton, including skin impressions.<ref>Lambe, L.M., 1914, "On ''Gryposaurus notabilis'', a new genus and species of trachodont dinosaur from the Belly River Formation of Alberta, with a description of the skull of ''Chasmosaurus belli''", ''The Ottawa Naturalist'' '''27''': 145-155</ref>
[[File:Royal Tyrell Chasmosaurus russelli.jpg|thumb|left|''C. russelli'', [[Royal Tyrrell Museum]]]]
[[File:Royal Tyrell Chasmosaurus russelli.jpg|thumb|left|''C. russelli'', [[Royal Tyrrell Museum]]]]
Since that date, more remains, including skulls, have been found that have been referred to ''Chasmosaurus'', and several additional [[species]] have been named within the genus.<ref name="ageofdinosaurschasmosaurus"/> Today some of these are considered to only reflect a morphological variation among the known sample of ''Chasmosaurus belli'' skulls;<ref name="ageofdinosaurschasmosaurus"/> others are seen as valid species of ''Chasmosaurus'' or as separate genera. In 1933 [[Barnum Brown]] named ''Chasmosaurus kaiseni'', honouring [[Peter Kaisen]] and based on skull AMNH 5401, differing from ''C. belli'' in having very long brow horns.<ref>Brown, B., 1933, "A new longhorned Belly River ceratopsian", ''American Museum Novitates'' '''669''': 1-3</ref> This form is perhaps related to ''Chasmosaurus canadensis'' ('from Canada') named by Thomas M. Lehman in 1990.<ref name="Lehman1990">T.M. Lehman, 1990, "The ceratopsian subfamily Chasmosaurinae: sexual dimorphism and systematics", In: K. Carpenter and P. J. Currie (eds.), ''Dinosaur Systematics: Perspectives and Approaches'', Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 211-229</ref> The latter species, originally'' Monoclonius canadensis'' Lambe 1902, had been described as ''[[Eoceratops]] canadensis'' by Lambe in 1915. ''Eoceratops'' and the long-horned ''Chasmosaurus kaiseni'' were thought to probably be exemplars of ''[[Mojoceratops]]'' by Nicholas Longrich,<ref name="Longrich2010">{{Cite journal|author=Nicholas R. Longrich|year=2010|title=''Mojoceratops perifania'', A New Chasmosaurine Ceratopsid from the Late Campanian of Western Canada|journal=Journal of Paleontology|volume=84|issue=4|pages=681–694|doi=10.1666/09-114.1}}</ref> although different teams of researchers have found ''Mojoceratops'' to be a synonym of ''Chasmosaurus russelli''. Campbell and colleagues, in their 2016 analysis of ''Chasmosaurus'' specimens found ''Eoceratops'' and ''C. kaiseni'' to be referable to ''Chasmosaurus'' sp. due to the lack of the parietal preserved in the holotypes of both.<ref name =Campbelletal2016>Campbell, J.A., Ryan, M.J., Holmes, R.B., and Schröder-Adams, C.J. (2016). [http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0145805 A Re-Evaluation of the chasmosaurine ceratopsid genus ''Chasmosaurus'' (Dinosauria: Ornithischia) from the Upper Cretaceous (Campanian) Dinosaur Park Formation of Western Canada.] ''PLoS ONE'', '''11'''(1): e0145805. {{doi|10.1371/journal.pone.0145805}}</ref> [[Richard Swann Lull]] in 1933 named an unusual, short-muzzled skull, specimen ROM 839 (earlier ROM 5436) collected in 1926, as ''Chasmosaurus brevirostris'', "with a short snout".<ref name="Lull1933">Lull, R.S., 1933, ''A revision of the Ceratopsia or horned dinosaurs''. Memoirs of the Peabody Museum of Natural History '''3'''(3): 1-175</ref> This has been seen as a [[junior synonym]] of ''C. belli''.<ref name="Lehman1990"/> [[Charles Mortram Sternberg]] added ''Chasmosaurus russelli'' in 1940, based on specimen NMC 8800 from southwestern Alberta (lower [[Dinosaur Park Formation]]). The specific name honours [[Loris Shano Russell]].<ref name=ABS09/><ref>Sternberg, C.M., 1940, "Ceratopsidae from Alberta", ''Journal of Paleontology'' '''14'''(5): 468-480</ref> Thomas Lehman described ''Chasmosaurus mariscalensis'' in 1989 from [[Texas]],<ref>Lehman, T.M., 1989, "''Chasmosaurus mariscalensis'', sp. nov., a new ceratopsian dinosaur from Texas", ''Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology'', '''9'''(2): 137-162</ref> which has now been renamed ''[[Agujaceratops]]''.<ref name="Lucas">{{Cite journal|vauthors=Lucas SG, Sullivan RM, Hunt AP |year=2006 |title=Re-evaluation of Pentaceratops and Chasmosaurus (Ornithischia: Ceratopsidae) in the Upper Cretaceous of the Western Interior |journal=New Mex Mus. Nat. Hist. Sci. Bull. |volume=35 |pages=367–370}}</ref> The most recently described species is ''Chasmosaurus irvinensis'' named in 2001,<ref>R.B. Holmes, [[Catherine Forster|C.A. Forster]], M.J. Ryan and K.M. Shepherd, 2001, "A new species of ''Chasmosaurus'' (Dinosauria: Ceratopsia) from the Dinosaur Park Formation of southern Alberta", ''Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences'' '''38''': 1423–1438</ref> which stems from the uppermost beds of the [[Dinosaur Park Formation]]. This species was given its own genus, ''[[Vagaceratops]]'', in 2010.<ref name="Sampson">{{Cite journal|author1=Scott D. Sampson |author2=Mark A. Loewen |author3=Andrew A. Farke |author4=Eric M. Roberts |author5=Catherine A. Forster |author6=Joshua A. Smith |author7=Alan L. Titus |year=2010 |title=New Horned Dinosaurs from Utah Provide Evidence for Intracontinental Dinosaur Endemism |journal=PLoS ONE |volume=5 |issue=9 |pages=e12292 |doi=10.1371/journal.pone.0012292 |pmid=20877459 |pmc=2929175 |url=http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0012292}}</ref>
Since that date, more remains, including skulls, have been found that have been referred to ''Chasmosaurus'', and several additional [[species]] have been named within the genus.<ref name="ageofdinosaurschasmosaurus"/> Today some of these are considered to only reflect a morphological variation among the known sample of ''Chasmosaurus belli'' skulls;<ref name="ageofdinosaurschasmosaurus"/> others are seen as valid species of ''Chasmosaurus'' or as separate genera. In 1933 [[Barnum Brown]] named ''Chasmosaurus kaiseni'', honouring [[Peter Kaisen]] and based on skull AMNH 5401, differing from ''C. belli'' in having very long brow horns.<ref>Brown, B., 1933, "A new longhorned Belly River ceratopsian", ''American Museum Novitates'' '''669''': 1-3</ref> This form is perhaps related to ''Chasmosaurus canadensis'' ('from Canada') named by Thomas M. Lehman in 1990.<ref name="Lehman1990">T.M. Lehman, 1990, "The ceratopsian subfamily Chasmosaurinae: sexual dimorphism and systematics", In: K. Carpenter and P. J. Currie (eds.), ''Dinosaur Systematics: Perspectives and Approaches'', Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 211-229</ref> The latter species, originally'' Monoclonius canadensis'' Lambe 1902, had been described as ''[[Eoceratops]] canadensis'' by Lambe in 1915. ''Eoceratops'' and the long-horned ''Chasmosaurus kaiseni'' were thought to probably be exemplars of ''[[Mojoceratops]]'' by Nicholas Longrich,<ref name="Longrich2010">{{Cite journal|author=Nicholas R. Longrich|year=2010|title=''Mojoceratops perifania'', A New Chasmosaurine Ceratopsid from the Late Campanian of Western Canada|journal=Journal of Paleontology|volume=84|issue=4|pages=681–694|doi=10.1666/09-114.1}}</ref> although different teams of researchers have found ''Mojoceratops'' to be a synonym of ''Chasmosaurus russelli''. Campbell and colleagues, in their 2016 analysis of ''Chasmosaurus'' specimens found ''Eoceratops'' and ''C. kaiseni'' to be referable to ''Chasmosaurus'' sp. due to the lack of the parietal preserved in the holotypes of both.<ref name =Campbelletal2016>Campbell, J.A., Ryan, M.J., Holmes, R.B., and Schröder-Adams, C.J. (2016). [http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0145805 A Re-Evaluation of the chasmosaurine ceratopsid genus ''Chasmosaurus'' (Dinosauria: Ornithischia) from the Upper Cretaceous (Campanian) Dinosaur Park Formation of Western Canada.] ''PLoS ONE'', '''11'''(1): e0145805. {{doi|10.1371/journal.pone.0145805}}</ref> [[Richard Swann Lull]] in 1933 named an unusual, short-muzzled skull, specimen ROM 839 (earlier ROM 5436) collected in 1926, as ''Chasmosaurus brevirostris'', "with a short snout".<ref name="Lull1933">Lull, R.S., 1933, ''A revision of the Ceratopsia or horned dinosaurs''. Memoirs of the Peabody Museum of Natural History '''3'''(3): 1-175</ref> This has been seen as a [[junior synonym]] of ''C. belli''.<ref name="Lehman1990"/> [[Charles Mortram Sternberg]] added ''Chasmosaurus russelli'' in 1940, based on specimen NMC 8800 from southwestern Alberta (lower [[Dinosaur Park Formation]]). The specific name honours [[Loris Shano Russell]].<ref name=ABS09/><ref>Sternberg, C.M., 1940, "Ceratopsidae from Alberta", ''Journal of Paleontology'' '''14'''(5): 468-480</ref> Thomas Lehman described ''Chasmosaurus mariscalensis'' in 1989 from [[Texas]],<ref>Lehman, T.M., 1989, "''Chasmosaurus mariscalensis'', sp. nov., a new ceratopsian dinosaur from Texas", ''Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology'', '''9'''(2): 137-162</ref> which has now been renamed ''[[Agujaceratops]]''.<ref name="Lucas">{{Cite journal|vauthors=Lucas SG, Sullivan RM, Hunt AP |year=2006 |title=Re-evaluation of Pentaceratops and Chasmosaurus (Ornithischia: Ceratopsidae) in the Upper Cretaceous of the Western Interior |journal=New Mex Mus. Nat. Hist. Sci. Bull. |volume=35 |pages=367–370}}</ref> The most recently described species is ''Chasmosaurus irvinensis'' named in 2001,<ref>R.B. Holmes, [[Catherine Forster|C.A. Forster]], M.J. Ryan and K.M. Shepherd, 2001, "A new species of ''Chasmosaurus'' (Dinosauria: Ceratopsia) from the Dinosaur Park Formation of southern Alberta", ''Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences'' '''38''': 1423–1438</ref> which stems from the uppermost beds of the [[Dinosaur Park Formation]]. This species was given its own genus, ''[[Vagaceratops]]'', in 2010.<ref name="Sampson">{{Cite journal|author1=Scott D. Sampson |author2=Mark A. Loewen |author3=Andrew A. Farke |author4=Eric M. Roberts |author5=Catherine A. Forster |author6=Joshua A. Smith |author7=Alan L. Titus |year=2010 |title=New Horned Dinosaurs from Utah Provide Evidence for Intracontinental Dinosaur Endemism |journal=PLoS ONE |volume=5 |issue=9 |pages=e12292 |doi=10.1371/journal.pone.0012292 |pmid=20877459 |pmc=2929175 |url=http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0012292}}</ref> However, Campbell et al. (2019) referred ''Vagaceratops'' back to ''Chasmosaurus''.<ref name=Campbell19>James Alexander Campbell, Michael J. Ryan, Claudia J. Schroder-Adams, Robert B. Holmes & David C. Evans (2019)
Temporal range extension and evolution of the chasmosaurine ceratopsid 'Vagaceratops' irvinensis (Dinosauria: Ornithischia) in the Upper Cretaceous (Campanian) Dinosaur Park Formation of Alberta. ''Vertebrate Anatomy Morphology Palaeontology'' 7: 83-100 DOI: https://doi.org/10.18435/vamp29356 https://journals.library.ualberta.ca/vamp/index.php/VAMP/article/view/29356</ref>
[[File:ChasmosaurusBelli-Skull RoyalOntarioMuseum.png|thumb|Skull of ''C. belli'' ROM 5436, type of ''C.'' "brevirostris", on display at the [[Royal Ontario Museum]], Toronto]]
[[File:ChasmosaurusBelli-Skull RoyalOntarioMuseum.png|thumb|Skull of ''C. belli'' ROM 5436, type of ''C.'' "brevirostris", on display at the [[Royal Ontario Museum]], Toronto]]
In 1987, [[Gregory S. Paul]] renamed ''[[Pentaceratops]] sternbergii'' into ''Chasmosaurus sternbergi'',<ref>Paul, G.S., 1987, "The science and art of reconstructing the life appearance of dinosaurs and their relatives: a rigorous how-to guide", pp 4-49 in: ''Dinosaurs Past and Present Volume II'', Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County</ref> but this has found no acceptance. In 2000, George Olshevsky renamed ''Monoclonius recurvicornis'' Cope 1889 into ''Chasmosaurus recurvicornis'' as its fossil material is likely chasmosaurine;<ref>Olshevsky, G. 2000. ''An Annotated Checklist of Dinosaur Species by Continent''. George Olshevsky, Publications Requiring Research, San Diego, 157 pp</ref> this is a ''[[nomen dubium]]''.
In 1987, [[Gregory S. Paul]] renamed ''[[Pentaceratops]] sternbergii'' into ''Chasmosaurus sternbergi'',<ref>Paul, G.S., 1987, "The science and art of reconstructing the life appearance of dinosaurs and their relatives: a rigorous how-to guide", pp 4-49 in: ''Dinosaurs Past and Present Volume II'', Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County</ref> but this has found no acceptance. In 2000, George Olshevsky renamed ''Monoclonius recurvicornis'' Cope 1889 into ''Chasmosaurus recurvicornis'' as its fossil material is likely chasmosaurine;<ref>Olshevsky, G. 2000. ''An Annotated Checklist of Dinosaur Species by Continent''. George Olshevsky, Publications Requiring Research, San Diego, 157 pp</ref> this is a ''[[nomen dubium]]''.


Today, only two species are seen as valid: ''C. belli'' and ''C. russelli''. They show small differences in [[morphology (biology)|morphology]] and a difference in [[stratigraphy]], as ''C. russelli'' is found in the older lower Dinosaur Park Formation and ''C. belli'' in the middle Dinosaur Park Formation of the [[Campanian]],<ref name="Maidment2011">{{cite journal|last1=Maidment|first1=S.C.R.|last2=Barrett|first2=P.M.|year=2011|title=A new specimen of ''Chasmosaurus belli'' (Ornithischia: Ceratopsidae), a revision of the genus, and the utility of postcrania in the taxonomy and systematics of ceratopsid dinosaurs|journal=Zootaxa|volume=2963|pages=1-47}}</ref> together spanning a time period of 76.5 to 75.5 [[million years ago]].<ref name="ABS09">{{cite journal|last=[[Victoria Arbour|Arbour, V.M.]]|author2=Burns, M. E.|author3=Sissons, R. L.|date=|year=2009|title=A redescription of the ankylosaurid dinosaur ''Dyoplosaurus acutosquameus'' Parks, 1924 (Ornithischia: Ankylosauria) and a revision of the genus|url=|journal=Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology|volume=29|issue=4|pages=1117–1135|doi=10.1671/039.029.0405|via=}}</ref> Apart from the holotype and paratype several additional specimens of ''C. belli'' are known. These include AMNH 5422, AMNH 5402, ROM 843 (earlier ROM 5499) and NHMUK R4948, all (partial) skeletons with skull; and YPM 2016, a skull. Apart from its holotype ''C. russelli'' is known from its paratype CMN 8803, a skull frill; CMN 41933, a rear skull frill; RTMP 81.19.175, the right side of a skull and CMN 2280, a partial skeleton with skull found by the Sternbergs in 1914.
Today, only two species are seen as valid: ''C. belli'' and ''C. russelli''. They show small differences in [[morphology (biology)|morphology]] and a difference in [[stratigraphy]], as ''C. russelli'' is found in the older lower Dinosaur Park Formation and ''C. belli'' in the middle Dinosaur Park Formation of the [[Campanian]],<ref name="Maidment2011">{{cite journal|last1=Maidment|first1=S.C.R.|last2=Barrett|first2=P.M.|year=2011|title=A new specimen of ''Chasmosaurus belli'' (Ornithischia: Ceratopsidae), a revision of the genus, and the utility of postcrania in the taxonomy and systematics of ceratopsid dinosaurs|journal=Zootaxa|volume=2963|pages=1-47}}</ref> together spanning a time period of 76.5 to 75.5 [[million years ago]].<ref name="ABS09">{{cite journal|last=[[Victoria Arbour|Arbour, V.M.]]|author2=Burns, M. E.|author3=Sissons, R. L.|date=|year=2009|title=A redescription of the ankylosaurid dinosaur ''Dyoplosaurus acutosquameus'' Parks, 1924 (Ornithischia: Ankylosauria) and a revision of the genus|url=|journal=Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology|volume=29|issue=4|pages=1117–1135|doi=10.1671/039.029.0405|via=}}</ref> Apart from the holotype and paratype several additional specimens of ''C. belli'' are known. These include AMNH 5422, ROM 843 (earlier ROM 5499) and NHMUK R4948, all (partial) skeletons with skull. Apart from its holotype ''C. russelli'' is known from its paratype CMN 8803, a skull frill; CMN 41933, a rear skull frill; RTMP 81.19.175, the right side of a skull and CMN 2280, a partial skeleton with skull found by the Sternbergs in 1914. The skull YPM 2016 and the skull and skeleton AMNH 5402 were noted by Campbell et al. (2016) as differing from other ''C. belli'' referred specimens in having more epiparietals, although the authors interpreted them as individual variation, and Campbell et al. (2019) interpreted these specimens as an indeterminate ''Chasmosaurus'' species closely related to ''Vagaceratops''.<ref name=Campbell19/>


==Classification==
==Classification==

Revision as of 14:04, 10 August 2019

Chasmosaurus
Temporal range: Late Cretaceous, 76.5–75.5 Ma
↓
C. belli skeleton, Royal Ontario Museum specimen 843
Scientific classification Edit this classification
Domain: Eukaryota
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Clade: Dinosauria
Clade: †Ornithischia
Clade: †Neornithischia
Clade: †Ceratopsia
Family: †Ceratopsidae
Subfamily: †Chasmosaurinae
Genus: †Chasmosaurus
Lambe, 1914
Species
Synonyms

Eoceratops? Lambe, 1915
Mojoceratops? Longrich, 2010

Chasmosaurus (/ˌkæzmoʊˈsɔːrəs/ KAZ-mo-SAWR-əs) is a genus of ceratopsid dinosaur from the Upper Cretaceous Period of North America. Its name means 'opening lizard', referring to the large openings (fenestrae) in its frill (Greek chasma meaning 'opening' or 'hollow' or 'gulf' and sauros meaning 'lizard'). With a length of 4.3–4.8 metres (14.1–15.7 ft) and a weight of 1.5–2 tonnes (1.7–2.2 short tons), Chasmosaurus was a ceratopsian of average size. Like all ceratopsians, it was purely herbivorous. It was initially to be called Protorosaurus, but this name had been previously published for another animal. All specimens of Chasmosaurus were collected from the Dinosaur Park Formation of the Dinosaur Provincial Park of Alberta, Canada. C. russelli comes from the lower beds of the formation while C. belli comes from middle and upper beds.[1]

Description

Size comparison of several members of Ceratopsidae with a human, Chasmosaurus in green

Chasmosaurus was a medium-size ceratopsid. In 2010 G.S. Paul estimated the length of C. belli at 4.8 metres, its weight at two tonnes; C. russelli would have been 4.3 metres long and weighed 1.5 tonnes.[2] The known differences between the two species mainly pertain to the horn and frill shape, as the postcrania of C. russelli are poorly known. Like many ceratopsians, Chasmosaurus had three main facial horns - one on the nose and two on the brow. In both species these horns are quite short, but with C. russelli they are somewhat longer, especially the brow horns, and more curved backwards. The frill of Chasmosaurus is very elongated and broader at the rear than at the front. It is hardly elevated from the plane of the snout. With C. belli the rear of the frill is V-shaped and its sides are straight. With C. russelli the rear edge is shaped as a shallow U, and the sides are more convex.[2] The sides were adorned by six to nine smaller skin ossifications (called episquamosals) or osteoderms, which attached to the squamosal bone. The corner of the frill featured two larger osteoderms on the parietal bone. With C. russelli the outer one was the largest, with C. belli the inner one. The remainder of the rear edge lacked osteoderms. The parietal bones of the frill were pierced by very large openings, after which the genus was named: the parietal fenestrae. These were not oval in shape, as with most relatives, but triangular, with one point orientated towards the frill corner.

Restoration of C. belli

The postcranium of C. belli is best preserved in the specimen known as NHMUK 4948. The first three cervical vertebrae are fused into a unit known as a syncervical, as in other neoceratopsians. There are five other cervicals preserved in this specimen, for a total of eight, which likely represents a complete neck. Cervicals four to eight are amphiplatian, wider than long, and roughly equal in length. The dorsal vertebrae are also amphiplatian. C. belli possesed a synsacrum, a compound unit composed of sacral, dorsal, and sometimes caudal vertebrae, depending on the specimen.[3]

The Chasmosaurus specimen NMC 2245 recovered by C.M. Sternberg was accompanied by skin impressions.[4] The area conserved, from the right hip region, measured about one by 0.5 metres. The skin appears to have had large scales in evenly spaced horizontal rows among smaller scales.[4] The larger scales had a diameter of up to fifty-five millimetres and were distanced from each other by five to ten centimetres. They were hexagonal or pentagonal, thus with five or six sides. Each of these sides touched somewhat smaller scales, forming a rosette. Small, non-overlapping convex scales of about one centimetre in diameter surrounded the whole. The larger scales were wrinkled due to straight grooves orientated perpendicular to their edges. From top to bottom, the large scale rows gradually declined in size.[5] Unfortunately, nothing can as yet be learned about the coloration of Chasmosaurus from the known fossil skin impression samples.

Discovery and species

G. F. Sternberg preparing a C. belli skull

In 1898, Lawrence Morris Lambe of the Geological Survey of Canada made at the Berry Creek the first discovery of Chasmosaurus remains, holotype NMC 491, a parietal bone that was part of a neck frill.[4] Although recognizing that his find represented a new species, Lambe thought this could be placed in a previously-known short-frilled ceratopsian genus: Monoclonius.[4] He erected the new species Monoclonius belli to describe his finding.[4] The specific name honoured collector Walter Bell.[6]

However, in 1913, Charles Hazelius Sternberg and his sons found several complete "M. belli" skulls in the middle Dinosaur Park Formation of Alberta, Canada.[7] Based on these finds, Lambe (1914) erected Protorosaurus ("before Torosaurus),[8] but that name was preoccupied by the Permian reptile Protorosaurus, so he subsequently created the replacement name Chasmosaurus in February 1914. The name Chasmosaurus is derived from Greek χάσμα, khasma, "opening" or "divide" and refers to the very large parietal fenestrae in the skull frill. Lambe now also assigned a paratype, specimen NMC 2245 found by the Sternbergs in 1913 and consisting of a largely complete skeleton, including skin impressions.[9]

C. russelli, Royal Tyrrell Museum

Since that date, more remains, including skulls, have been found that have been referred to Chasmosaurus, and several additional species have been named within the genus.[4] Today some of these are considered to only reflect a morphological variation among the known sample of Chasmosaurus belli skulls;[4] others are seen as valid species of Chasmosaurus or as separate genera. In 1933 Barnum Brown named Chasmosaurus kaiseni, honouring Peter Kaisen and based on skull AMNH 5401, differing from C. belli in having very long brow horns.[10] This form is perhaps related to Chasmosaurus canadensis ('from Canada') named by Thomas M. Lehman in 1990.[11] The latter species, originally Monoclonius canadensis Lambe 1902, had been described as Eoceratops canadensis by Lambe in 1915. Eoceratops and the long-horned Chasmosaurus kaiseni were thought to probably be exemplars of Mojoceratops by Nicholas Longrich,[12] although different teams of researchers have found Mojoceratops to be a synonym of Chasmosaurus russelli. Campbell and colleagues, in their 2016 analysis of Chasmosaurus specimens found Eoceratops and C. kaiseni to be referable to Chasmosaurus sp. due to the lack of the parietal preserved in the holotypes of both.[13] Richard Swann Lull in 1933 named an unusual, short-muzzled skull, specimen ROM 839 (earlier ROM 5436) collected in 1926, as Chasmosaurus brevirostris, "with a short snout".[14] This has been seen as a junior synonym of C. belli.[11] Charles Mortram Sternberg added Chasmosaurus russelli in 1940, based on specimen NMC 8800 from southwestern Alberta (lower Dinosaur Park Formation). The specific name honours Loris Shano Russell.[7][15] Thomas Lehman described Chasmosaurus mariscalensis in 1989 from Texas,[16] which has now been renamed Agujaceratops.[17] The most recently described species is Chasmosaurus irvinensis named in 2001,[18] which stems from the uppermost beds of the Dinosaur Park Formation. This species was given its own genus, Vagaceratops, in 2010.[19] However, Campbell et al. (2019) referred Vagaceratops back to Chasmosaurus.[20]

Skull of C. belli ROM 5436, type of C. "brevirostris", on display at the Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto

In 1987, Gregory S. Paul renamed Pentaceratops sternbergii into Chasmosaurus sternbergi,[21] but this has found no acceptance. In 2000, George Olshevsky renamed Monoclonius recurvicornis Cope 1889 into Chasmosaurus recurvicornis as its fossil material is likely chasmosaurine;[22] this is a nomen dubium.

Today, only two species are seen as valid: C. belli and C. russelli. They show small differences in morphology and a difference in stratigraphy, as C. russelli is found in the older lower Dinosaur Park Formation and C. belli in the middle Dinosaur Park Formation of the Campanian,[3] together spanning a time period of 76.5 to 75.5 million years ago.[7] Apart from the holotype and paratype several additional specimens of C. belli are known. These include AMNH 5422, ROM 843 (earlier ROM 5499) and NHMUK R4948, all (partial) skeletons with skull. Apart from its holotype C. russelli is known from its paratype CMN 8803, a skull frill; CMN 41933, a rear skull frill; RTMP 81.19.175, the right side of a skull and CMN 2280, a partial skeleton with skull found by the Sternbergs in 1914. The skull YPM 2016 and the skull and skeleton AMNH 5402 were noted by Campbell et al. (2016) as differing from other C. belli referred specimens in having more epiparietals, although the authors interpreted them as individual variation, and Campbell et al. (2019) interpreted these specimens as an indeterminate Chasmosaurus species closely related to Vagaceratops.[20]

Classification

Skeletal restorations of the two valid species, C. belli (top) and C. russelli (bottom). The restorations share the postcrania
Holotype of C. kaiseni, which has also been considered a specimen of Mojoceratops

Chasmosaurus was in 1915 by Lambe within the Ceratopsia assigned to the Chasmosaurinae.[23] The Chasmosaurinae usually have long frills, like Chasmosaurus itself, whereas their sister-group the Centrosaurinae typically have shorter frills. Most cladistic analyses show that Chasmosaurus has a basal position in the Chasmosaurinae.

The following cladogram shows the phylogeny of Chasmosaurus according to a study by Scott Sampson e.a. in 2010.[19]

Ceratopsidae 

Paleobiology

Depiction of the mega-herbivores in the Dinosaur Park Formation, C. belli on the left

Chasmosaurus shared its habitat, the east coast of Laramidia, with successive species of Centrosaurus. A certain niche partitioning is suggested by the fact that Chasmosaurus had a longer snout and jaws and might have been more selective about the plants it ate.

The function of the frill and horns is problematic. The horns are rather short and the frill had such large fenestrae that it could not have offered much functional defense. Paul suggested that the beak was the main defensive weapon.[2] It is possible that the frill was simply used to appear imposing or conceivably for thermoregulation. The frill may also have been brightly colored, to draw attention to its size or as part of a mating display. However, it is difficult to prove any sexual dimorphism. In 1933, Lull suggested that C. kaiseni, which bore long brow horns, was in fact the male of C. belli of which the females would have short ones.[14] In 1927 C.M. Sternberg concluded that of the two skeletons he had mounted in the Canadian Museum of Nature, the smaller one, NMC 2245, was the male and the larger, NMC 2280, the female.[24] However, today the two are referred to different species.

Juvenile UALVP 52613

A juvenile Chasmosaurus belli found in Alberta, Canada by Phil Currie et al., reveals that Chasmosaurus may have cared for its young, like its relative, Triceratops, is hypothesized to have done. The juvenile measured five feet long and was estimated to be three years of age and had similar limb and frill proportions to the adult Chasmosaurus. This indicates that Chasmosaurus was not fast moving, and that juveniles did not need to be fast moving either to keep pace with adults. The fossil was complete save for its missing front limbs, which had fallen into a sinkhole before the specimen was uncovered. Skin impressions were also uncovered beneath the skeleton and evidence from the matrix that it was buried in indicated that the juvenile ceratopsian drowned during a possible river crossing.[25] Further study of the specimen revealed that juvenile chasmosaurs had a frill that was narrower in the back than that of adults, as well as being proportionately shorter in relation to the skull.[26]

See also

References

  1. ^ Ryan, M.J.; Evans, D.C. (2005). "Ornithischian dinosaurs". In Currie, P.J.; Koppelhus, E.B. (eds.). Dinosaur Provincial Park: A Spectacular Ecosystem Revealed. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. pp. 312–348. {{cite book}}: Unknown parameter |last-author-amp= ignored (|name-list-style= suggested) (help)
  2. ^ a b c Paul, G.S., 2010, The Princeton Field Guide to Dinosaurs, Princeton University Press p. 269-270
  3. ^ a b Maidment, S.C.R.; Barrett, P.M. (2011). "A new specimen of Chasmosaurus belli (Ornithischia: Ceratopsidae), a revision of the genus, and the utility of postcrania in the taxonomy and systematics of ceratopsid dinosaurs". Zootaxa. 2963: 1–47.
  4. ^ a b c d e f g Dodson, Peter; et al. "Chasmosaurus". The Age of Dinosaurs. Publications International. pp. 110–111. ISBN 0-7853-0443-6.
  5. ^ Sternberg, C.M., 1925, "Integument of Chasmosaurus belli", Canadian Field-Naturalist 39: 108-110
  6. ^ Lambe, L.M., 1902, "New genera and species from the Belly River Series (mid-Cretaceous)", Geological Survey of Canada Contributions to Canadian Palaeontology 3(2): 25-81
  7. ^ a b c Arbour, V.M.; Burns, M. E.; Sissons, R. L. (2009). "A redescription of the ankylosaurid dinosaur Dyoplosaurus acutosquameus Parks, 1924 (Ornithischia: Ankylosauria) and a revision of the genus". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 29 (4): 1117–1135. doi:10.1671/039.029.0405.
  8. ^ Lambe, L.M., 1914, "On the forelimb of a carnivorous dinosaur from the Belly River Formation of Alberta, and a new genus of Ceratopsia from the same horizon, with remarks on the integument of some Cretaceous herbivorous dinosaurs", The Ottawa Naturalist 27(10): 129-135
  9. ^ Lambe, L.M., 1914, "On Gryposaurus notabilis, a new genus and species of trachodont dinosaur from the Belly River Formation of Alberta, with a description of the skull of Chasmosaurus belli", The Ottawa Naturalist 27: 145-155
  10. ^ Brown, B., 1933, "A new longhorned Belly River ceratopsian", American Museum Novitates 669: 1-3
  11. ^ a b T.M. Lehman, 1990, "The ceratopsian subfamily Chasmosaurinae: sexual dimorphism and systematics", In: K. Carpenter and P. J. Currie (eds.), Dinosaur Systematics: Perspectives and Approaches, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 211-229
  12. ^ Nicholas R. Longrich (2010). "Mojoceratops perifania, A New Chasmosaurine Ceratopsid from the Late Campanian of Western Canada". Journal of Paleontology. 84 (4): 681–694. doi:10.1666/09-114.1.
  13. ^ Campbell, J.A., Ryan, M.J., Holmes, R.B., and Schröder-Adams, C.J. (2016). A Re-Evaluation of the chasmosaurine ceratopsid genus Chasmosaurus (Dinosauria: Ornithischia) from the Upper Cretaceous (Campanian) Dinosaur Park Formation of Western Canada. PLoS ONE, 11(1): e0145805. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0145805
  14. ^ a b Lull, R.S., 1933, A revision of the Ceratopsia or horned dinosaurs. Memoirs of the Peabody Museum of Natural History 3(3): 1-175
  15. ^ Sternberg, C.M., 1940, "Ceratopsidae from Alberta", Journal of Paleontology 14(5): 468-480
  16. ^ Lehman, T.M., 1989, "Chasmosaurus mariscalensis, sp. nov., a new ceratopsian dinosaur from Texas", Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 9(2): 137-162
  17. ^ Lucas SG, Sullivan RM, Hunt AP (2006). "Re-evaluation of Pentaceratops and Chasmosaurus (Ornithischia: Ceratopsidae) in the Upper Cretaceous of the Western Interior". New Mex Mus. Nat. Hist. Sci. Bull. 35: 367–370.
  18. ^ R.B. Holmes, C.A. Forster, M.J. Ryan and K.M. Shepherd, 2001, "A new species of Chasmosaurus (Dinosauria: Ceratopsia) from the Dinosaur Park Formation of southern Alberta", Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 38: 1423–1438
  19. ^ a b Scott D. Sampson; Mark A. Loewen; Andrew A. Farke; Eric M. Roberts; Catherine A. Forster; Joshua A. Smith; Alan L. Titus (2010). "New Horned Dinosaurs from Utah Provide Evidence for Intracontinental Dinosaur Endemism". PLoS ONE. 5 (9): e12292. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012292. PMC 2929175. PMID 20877459.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: unflagged free DOI (link)
  20. ^ a b James Alexander Campbell, Michael J. Ryan, Claudia J. Schroder-Adams, Robert B. Holmes & David C. Evans (2019) Temporal range extension and evolution of the chasmosaurine ceratopsid 'Vagaceratops' irvinensis (Dinosauria: Ornithischia) in the Upper Cretaceous (Campanian) Dinosaur Park Formation of Alberta. Vertebrate Anatomy Morphology Palaeontology 7: 83-100 DOI: https://doi.org/10.18435/vamp29356 https://journals.library.ualberta.ca/vamp/index.php/VAMP/article/view/29356
  21. ^ Paul, G.S., 1987, "The science and art of reconstructing the life appearance of dinosaurs and their relatives: a rigorous how-to guide", pp 4-49 in: Dinosaurs Past and Present Volume II, Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County
  22. ^ Olshevsky, G. 2000. An Annotated Checklist of Dinosaur Species by Continent. George Olshevsky, Publications Requiring Research, San Diego, 157 pp
  23. ^ L.M. Lambe, 1915, "On Eoceratops canadensis, gen. nov., with remarks on other genera of Cretaceous horned dinosaurs", Canada Geological Survey Museum Bulletin 12, Geological Series 24: 1-49
  24. ^ Sternberg, C.M., 1927, "Horned dinosaur group in the National Museum of Canada", Canadian Field-Naturalist 41: 67-73
  25. ^ http://www.nbcnews.com/science/rare-baby-dinosaur-skeleton-unearthed-canada-2D11650637
  26. ^ https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/01/160114113643.htm
Wikispecies has information related to Chasmosaurus.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Chasmosaurus&oldid=910216731"