Talk:Aldi Talk: Difference between revisions
m Signing comment by H7 - "→Lemma of article and "term confusion": new section" |
|||
Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
== Lemma of article and "term confusion" == |
== Lemma of article and "term confusion" == |
||
In Germany, a reorientation of the article is currently taking place. Quote here: "Aldi Talk (also known as MEDIONmobile and ALDImobile [1]) is a mobile virtual network operator in Germany, Australia and the Netherlands." No, that's not correct! The article describes MEDIONmobile as an MVNO. It's not a "Aldi Talk" description!!! |
In Germany, a reorientation of the article is currently taking place. Quote here: "Aldi Talk (also known as MEDIONmobile and ALDImobile [1]) is a mobile virtual network operator in Germany, Australia and the Netherlands." No, that's not correct! The article describes MEDIONmobile as an MVNO. It's not a "Aldi Talk" description!!! Aldi is "only" the distribution partner and ALDImobile is nonsense in Germany, it's only the different brand name of Medion-hosted services in Australia so as Aldi Talk in GER and NL. |
||
The problem is: only one article per topic! But what's the topic? Here there are different sales brands per country. The article should decide in the future whether it describes either MEDIONmobile (as topic) in all countries (then the content could essentially remain), but then the first sentence is absolutely trash. |
The problem is: only one article per topic! But what's the topic? Here there are different sales brands per country. The article should decide in the future whether it describes either MEDIONmobile (as topic) in all countries (then the content could essentially remain), but then the first sentence is absolutely trash. |
Revision as of 10:24, 11 August 2019
This article is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.
Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.
Please add the quality rating to the {{WikiProject banner shell}} template instead of this project banner. See WP:PIQA for details.
|
Lemma of article and "term confusion"
In Germany, a reorientation of the article is currently taking place. Quote here: "Aldi Talk (also known as MEDIONmobile and ALDImobile [1]) is a mobile virtual network operator in Germany, Australia and the Netherlands." No, that's not correct! The article describes MEDIONmobile as an MVNO. It's not a "Aldi Talk" description!!! Aldi is "only" the distribution partner and ALDImobile is nonsense in Germany, it's only the different brand name of Medion-hosted services in Australia so as Aldi Talk in GER and NL.
The problem is: only one article per topic! But what's the topic? Here there are different sales brands per country. The article should decide in the future whether it describes either MEDIONmobile (as topic) in all countries (then the content could essentially remain), but then the first sentence is absolutely trash.
Alternatively, the sales brands would have to be dealt with in separate articles, because the mobile markets in the individual countries are so different that apart from the provider no further common ground exists.
The German article has decided to describe the sales brand in Germany and to outsource the brands in other countries to other articles. Here it should be decided whether this is done in the same way or whether it should remain a Medion article. Both are possible, but in the second case one must not confuse all terms! — Preceding unsigned comment added by H7 (talk • contribs) 10:21, 11 August 2019 (UTC)