User talk:Bkissin

A page you started (Manon Blanchet) has been reviewed!

Thanks for creating Manon Blanchet, Bkissin!

Wikipedia editor MB298 just reviewed your page, and wrote this note for you:

Thanks for creating!

To reply, leave a comment on MB298's talk page.

Learn more about page curation.

Draft: Miss Avakin

Hi. i hope i am not being rude. but you declined my article and i have added references. I am new here so please don't delete simply decline again and i would keep on trying. Thank you

Thanks!! TristanNdianga (talk)

Maccabi USA Wikipedia Page

I cited CharityNavigator on the first paragraph and am still editing the rest of the page.

Talk hartilli

Declined Draft:Aqua Mail is up-dated. Please review it again.

Hi Bikissin,

I have added more reference sourses to the Aqua Mail draft page. Could you please review it again?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draft:Aqua_Mail

Best regards and thank you for your time,

Wiki The Author

16:36 18 September 2018

Declined Draft: Diane Giraud

Hi Bkissin,

My draft has been rejected for Copyright material but I don't see which content you refer to. Can you give me more details? Some content comes from official FB page of the Artist (which is copyright free content) and we got her approval for that anyway.

Thanks for your help, RA

Question regard Draft:John_Christopher_Muran

Hi Bkissin, I am a doctoral candidate working with Dr. Muran and trying to create a page for him. I have edited the page in response to the comments (i.e. paraphrasing, citation, & publication section). Would you mind take a look when you get a chance to see if it's better now? Thank you! -Di

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draft:John_Christopher_Muran

Your Reason for Declining Dawn Smith Jordan draft

You said, "Being a Miss America runner-up is not notability..." which seems inconsistent with existing pages on Wikipedia. For example, as I look at the list of other Miss South Carolina winners in Wikipedia, there a number of former winners with their own pages and most have their chief measure of notability as winning Miss South Carolina. Note that you have to win Miss South Carolina to even compete in Miss America, and Dawn Smith was a finalist in Miss America. A good specific example is Ali Rogers (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ali_Rogers). Ali Rogers has nothing more on her page other than winning beauty pageants, the most significant being Miss South Carolina and also was a finalist in Miss America. She did not sing in a Billy Graham crusade, hasn't recorded songs, written books, have an active ministry throughout the United States, and so forth. I intend to continue to add to the draft providing additional items of notability, but the above comment by itself is inconsistent with what I already see approved on Wikipedia. My assumption is it will eventually get approved as I document more, but I contend it should already be approved based on what I see on Ali Rogers' page.

Review

Hello, Bkission. I have seen your reviews about my draft. But in fact, I did not find the same topic with me and all of them pay attention to the whole information, which is not same as mine- use. Thank you

Hi

I believe my article should not have been rejected, I have cited as much as possible. I really need that page to be live for school. Lerato Kganyago or may you please guide me on where Im going wrong cause I dont see anything wrong with my article

Windsor Tablelands

Hi Bkissin,

I've made the changes now for the draft page for review: "Windsor Tablelands", and added a good lead section for the article. Hope this is sufficient! I was also just wanting to ask a question about changing the title of the page, upon greater investigation the geographical location is more commonly known as the 'Mount Windsor Tableland' as opposed to the 'Windsor Tablelands'.

Best Regards, Mcat963

Hi!

Thanks for viewing my article! I noticed that the article has been assessed to the start-class, and I had a look at the example article of start-class, I don't think my article is that bad : ). so, can you please give me some advice so that I can improve it. Many thanks!! (Architecture of Zimbabwe)=> name of my article

Best regards, Zimou Yuan

Nathaniel Phillips Submision Declined

Ok did not know thanks.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draft:Spiceheads

Please can you explain in lay mens English whats wrong with this? Spiceheads is the worlds leading brandname for information, help and advice to the public about NPS, that has sold many pix and videos to News agencys that have been published without accredication. It comes up hits 1,2 and 3 in Google and Bing when you serch the term Spiceheads and has provided cited information, advice and photographs to the Sunday Times. I just do not understand what is wrong, most of it refairs back to the cited main article in Vice and I have asked for help to connect up the citations, but no one has offered. I am both phisically and mentaly disabled, as you should be able to tell by my spelling and grammer. Instead of just rejecting it over and over, why will one of you intelegent accademics help an old guy with dementia? Is it because I am disabled that I am being treated in this way? Or is it the subject matter? All in all I am bewildered in a page that openly says that anyone, can publish or edit somthing, when clearly it is realy anyone with a degree in English that's part of the club. Not having a go at you personally, just very upset, almost suisidal that no one will halp me and I am being treated this way

Regarding outright Rejection to publish an article about a renowned Professor

Hi, Dear moderator Bkissin I have sent a small introduction about a scientist that you have rejected. In my opinion, this is a very and biased action. Rupesh Chaturvedi has contributed much in the medical field that is benefiting to the science community and it will give more benefit in the future. If you are writing an article about a person who has not given anything this world like (I can give you many examples) and at the same time declining a person who has a number of research articles/papers in the famous journal like PNAS, Cell, Nature, present on PubMed cited by approx 50000 times. Besides this as per I know He is the most cited scientist of India's Top Ranked Jawaharlal Nehru university, that you can see Rupesh Chaturvedi google scholar citation. He is also Director of R&D of JNU New Delhi that you can see on JNU website. Rupesh Chaturvedi is in USA Washington DC and already started a Big Startup project in the medical field. It was my first article and now it was last also. Public opinion that I have listened about the biases of Wikipedia, I got it to be correct. This is the respect what we as a researcher get from the common people for whom we worked for day and night.

Thank you very much, Mr. Bkissin Achyut Pandey Research scholar JNU New Delhi

Nathaniel Phillips Submision Resubmitted

He has made a senior appearance for VFB Stuttgart in the DFB Pokal so I have resubmitted the draft. and also added some references.
User:2A02:C7F:9616:2800:414F:2913:8C11:AF64 (talk) 10:52, 14 August 2019 (GMT)

Draft:In Chang-soo

Hi, When do you finish review of Draft:In Chang-soo He definately meets the WP:NFOOTY

Footwiks (talk)

Draft: Zain Ouadah

Hello Bkissin, how are you ?

I just want to tell you that I saw your comment on the :

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draft:Zain_Ouadah

Many boxers have and are still accepted despite these criteria. Several sources have been added in recent days. I really think this boxer is eligible for publication on Wikipedia. I registered on Wikipedia a few months ago and I hope you can review your decision, it would encourage me to create other pages.

Thank you

Andy12349 (talk)

Black Friday reviews

Hi Bkissin!

Sadly, there doesn't seem to be a single reliable review of the show to put on the black friday page, and I know a lot of people want the page to be up as fast as possible... Any suggestions as to where I could look to find reviews? Google search doesn't help me

---GuestYT (talk) 03:14, 7 March 2020 (UTC)

Page Mover

I would suggest that you request the Page Mover privilege to be able to deal with redirects that interfere with acceptance of articles. Robert McClenon (talk) 04:33, 16 March 2020 (UTC)

Arsenal Hvar article

Hi, I found that Bkissin has accepted an article for Arsenal Hvar ("This article was accepted from this draft on 19 February 2020 by reviewer Bkissin"). I wanted to ask, the article is not indexed in google searches, why is that? Thanks a lot in advance for your help.

link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hvar_Arsenal — Preceding unsigned comment added by RDam94 (talk • contribs) 11:52, 16 March 2020 (UTC)

Review for UNHCR Zakat

thank you for reviewing UNHCR Refugee Zakat Fund, however, i dont think this can used and merged with UNHCR page, as it is a detailed topic and has a more spiritual and humanitarian involvement regarding one specific action. Do you think we can reconsider that, and resubmit to go live? — Preceding unsigned comment added by Cynaj (talk • contribs) 12:14, 16 March 2020 (UTC)

Tricky question

I don't think she's notable because almost everything is a name drop. But I am probably the wrong person to ask about anything Thiru related at this point. As a side note, what Bearcat said in the first AFD (specifically the unsuccessful run) is spot on, especially when you look at Maryland, particularly Baltimore's political scene. As an example, Baltimore's mayoral race up until a week ago had 25 candidates. This is important because running for office here is basically what everyone who is over 18 does eventually and few are actually notable. I don't see any changes locally or nationally in terms of coverage of her and based on the draft, I'm not sure what the claim of notability is aside from trying to WP:COATRACK the position under Michelle Obama. Praxidicae (talk) 18:29, 17 March 2020 (UTC)

Thanks Praxidicae, that's basically what I thought as well. I didn't want to suggest possible PAID or anything like that from a campaign or connected office. She wouldn't meet WP:NPOL, and that hasn't changed. Whether her role as head of Lutheran Refugee Services is notable (provided that the article is trimmed of all self-promotion), is highly debateable. Thanks for your expertise! I moved from College Park down into the District back in June, so I figured I would let a native handle this one! Bkissin (talk) 16:11, 18 March 2020 (UTC)

resubmit "Polynesian Paralysis" page on March 13

I have edited the Polynesian Paralysis page and added more print references and submitted the page for review on March 13. Thanks for your previous comments and I hope the revised page will be accepted. Jim JimGaston (talk) 16:56, 23 March 2020 (UTC)

Article for Samora Smallwood

Hello,

I have submitted an article for the actor and activist Samora Smallwood and it was declined. I am resubmitting and also have the photographer's explicit information to use a photograph (he had given me permission via email before but not in the format required by Wikipedia). Please let me know what I am doing wrong?

Thank you,

Karen — Preceding unsigned comment added by Samdal35ton (talk • contribs) 04:52, 24 March 2020 (UTC)

RE: Draft:Rose Leiman Goldemberg

Bkissin-

Hello! I am trying to get the page approved for Rose Leiman Goldemberg. You stated the following: "Don't use Wikipedia as a source, and Amazon isn't normally considered a reliable source either. After that is taken care of, if MurielMary thinks it's OK, then I'll accept."

That sounds completely fair to me. Thank you for giving me specific instructions. I have made these changes on my personal copy of the page but I am not seeing an edit tab on the draft page anymore: https://en.wikiredia.com/wiki/Draft:Rose_Leiman_Goldemberg Also, it looks like the heading for the references dropped off for some reason. Is the webpage damaged?

Please get back to me as soon as you can. Rose is 91 and ailing. Her son is beside himself, and I am trying to do something nice for the family.

-Rick

RDHolland (talk) 14:59, 24 March 2020 (UTC)

NEWS, RE: Draft:Rose Leiman Goldemberg

Update to my last message:

I have successfully created the edits that you specified, namely, I am no longer using Wikipedia or Amazon as sources, and have replaced them with better sources where necessary.

Please review the page when you get a chance. Rose is 91 and ailing. I would love for her to see this in time!

RDHolland (talk) 14:58, 24 March 2020 (UTC)

Thank you so much for reviewing and approving the page!! It means so much to us! RDHolland (talk) 21:42, 24 March 2020 (UTC)

Cardano

Cardano article Draft:Cardano (cryptocurrency platform) is well developed now. I added new contents with 3 sources from Forbes and Yahoo finance, I think its ready for Wikipedia. All the best Spada II ♪♫ (talk) 06:03, 27 March 2020 (UTC)

Coronavirus: The Movie

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draft:Coronavirus:_The_Movie

Hi you declined the above movie, please can you help re-writing it not as advertisement, because I did include some negative reviews too. Also this film was never mentioned as a passing comment, it has been covered significantly in news. You can see all the dozens of articles here: https://www.google.com/search?q=coronavirus+blake+ridder&sxsrf=ALeKk008IBI0u5N__I1rnFQz6at1d7ZA6A:1585400538561&source=lnms&tbm=nws&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiwxbWfnb3oAhXEnFwKHRILDA0Q_AUoAnoECAsQBA&biw=2560&bih=1338