Jump to content

British Columbia carbon tax

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Phatmatt12188 (talk | contribs) at 20:12, 7 May 2024 (→Five-year review: Added a wikilink). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Petroleum product use in British Columbia declined after the implementation of the carbon tax in 2008.

The British Columbia carbon tax has been in place since 2008. It is a British Columbia policy that adds additional carbon taxes to fossil fuels burned for transportation, home heating, and electricity and reduces personal income taxes and corporate taxes by a roughly equal amount. The carbon tax is collected at the point of retail consumption (for example, at the pump for gasoline and diesel).

British Columbia's policy is unique in North America; only Quebec has a similar retail tax, but it is set at a much lower rate and does not include a matching tax shift.[1] Unlike most other governments, British Columbia's electricity portfolio largely consists of hydroelectric power, and its energy costs, even with the tax, are lower than in most countries.[2][3]

History

Public opinion polls in 2007 showed that the environment had replaced the economy and healthcare as the most important issue to a majority of respondents. The cultural change, which was brought about by greater media and political attention both inside and outside Canada, changed the political dynamic of British Columbia. Traditionally, the left-leaning BC New Democratic Party (NDP) had been seen as more green than the other of the two largest parties, the more free-market BC Liberal Party. However, in 2008, it was the Liberals that introduced the carbon tax and tax shift, which was thought to be a more market-friendly method of regulating carbon than the competing idea of cap-and-trade, which the NDP supported. During the 2009 British Columbia election, the NDP suggested replacing the tax with a cap-and-trade system, and the BC Conservatives also made repealing the carbon tax part of their platform, but the Liberals won another majority government.

In 2016, a similar measure was put on the ballot in neighbouring Washington State. Washington Initiative 732, like the British Columbia carbon tax, was to impose a steadily-rising tax on carbon emissions, while offsetting the state's sales tax and business tax/and to expand the state's tax credit for low-income families. The ballet initiative did not pass; however, another carbon tax plan, Washington Initiative 1631, has been proposed.[4]

Initial implementation

On 19 February 2008, British Columbia announced its intention to implement a carbon tax of $10 per tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e) emissions (2.41 cents per litre on gasoline) beginning 1 July 2008, the first North American jurisdiction to implement such a tax. The tax was to increase until 2012, reaching a final price of $30 per tonne (7.2 cents per litre at the pumps).[5][6] The tax was to be revenue neutral by reducing corporate and income taxes accordingly.[7] The government was to reduce other taxes by $481 million over three years.[5] In January 2010, the carbon tax was applied to biodiesel. Before the tax went into effect, the government of British Columbia sent out "rebate cheques" from expected revenues to all residents.[8] In January 2013, the tax was collecting about $1 billion/year, which was rebated.[9]

Unlike previous proposals, the legislation was to keep the pending carbon tax revenue neutral by reducing corporate and income taxes at an equivalent rate.[10] The government also planned to reduce taxes above and beyond the carbon tax offset by $481 million over three years.[5]

The tax was based on the following principles:

  • All revenue is recycled through tax reductions – The government was required to demonstrate how all carbon tax revenue was to be returned to taxpayers through tax reductions.[11]
  • The tax rate increased gradually – to give individuals and businesses time to make adjustments and respect decisions made prior to the announcement of the tax.[11]
  • Protect Low-income individuals and families – A refundable Low Income Climate Action Tax Credit helps offset the tax paid by low-income individuals and families.[11]
  • Broad base – Virtually all emissions from fuel combustion are taxed, with no exemptions except those required for integration with other climate actions.[11]
  • The tax would not, on its own, meet B.C.'s emission-reduction targets.[11]

Many Canadians concluded that the carbon tax generally benefitted the British Columbian economy, in large part because its revenue neutral feature reduced personal income taxes.[12] However some industries complained loudly that the tax had harmed them, notably cement manufacturers and farmers.[13] Nevertheless, the tax attracted attention in the United States and elsewhere from those seeking an economically efficient way of reducing the emission of greenhouse gases without hurting economic growth.[14]

2010 expansion

In January 2010, the carbon tax was applied to biodiesel. Before the tax actually went into effect, the BC government had sent out "rebate cheques" from expected revenues to all residents of British Columbia as of December 31, 2007.[15] In January 2013, the carbon tax was collecting about $1 billion each year, which was used to lower other taxes in British Columbia. BC Environment Minister Terry Lake said, "It makes sense, it's simple, it's well accepted."[16]

Rates

Here are selected carbon tax rates by fuel:[17]

In April 2019, the carbon tax increased to $40 /t CO2e, which is translated below into different fuel types. The carbon tax increased by units of $5/t until 2022, when the annual increase was raised to $15/t. As of April 2024, the carbon tax is $80/t.[18]

Type of Fuel Unit Tax Rate: July 1, 2012 Tax Rate: 2019[19] Tax Rate: 2024
Gasoline ¢/litre 6.67 8.89 17.61
Diesel (light fuel oil) ¢/litre 7.67 10.23 20.74
Jet fuel ¢/litre 7.83 10.44 19.59
Natural gas ¢/cubic metre 5.70 7.6 15.25
Propane ¢/litre 4.62 6.16 12.38
Coal - high heat value $/tonne 62.31 83.08 141.80
Coal - low heat value $/tonne 53.31 71.08 178.48

Effects

According to the World Bank, British Columbia's carbon tax policy has been very effective in spurring fuel efficiency gains. Further, the resulting decreases in fuel consumption did not harm economic growth. On the contrary, the province has outperformed the rest of Canada since 2008.[20]

Five-year review

A July 2013 report by Sustainable Prosperity, BC's Carbon Tax Shift After Five Years: An Environmental (and Economic) Success Story, suggested that the policy had been a major success. Since the tax had been in place, fossil fuel consumption had dropped 17.4% per capita and fallen by 18.8% relative to the rest of Canada. Those reductions occurred across all the fuel types covered by the tax, not just vehicle fuel. BC's rate of economic growth (measured as GDP) had kept pace with the rest of Canada's over that time. The tax shift enabled BC to have one of Canada's lowest income tax rates, as of 2012. The aggregate effect of the tax shift was positive of taxpayers as a whole, in that cuts to income and other taxes exceeded carbon tax revenues by $500 million from 2008 to 2012.[21]

The report was released to coincide with an internal review of the policy by the BC government, which ultimately decided to freeze the tax at 2012 levels for five years.[22] It was also aimed to influence energy policy discussion as the First Ministers met at Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario. Critics of the report debated its findings in media. Jock Finlayson of the BC Business Council pointed out that the drop in fuel consumption might be due to cross-border shopping, as many BC residents are able to drive into Washington or Alberta to fuel their cars and trucks, as well as to a much larger gasoline levy implemented in Greater Vancouver (accounting for much of BC's population) to fund public transit development (TransLink) and that businesses were receiving fewer tax advantages from the plan than individuals.[23] Aldyen Donnelly of WDA Consulting suggested that the success of the tax in reducing fuel consumption would cannibalize the potential revenue that it could generate, creating a tax waste, and that it fell more on the middle and lower-middle classes than on the most wealthy which made it a regressive tax.[24] The supporter Mark Jaccard of Simon Fraser University defended the tax by saying that BC's aviation fuel usage, which is not subject to the carbon tax, "did not diverge from the Canadian pattern, supporting the argument that the carbon tax really did have an effect. And BC's disconnect from the rest of the country was evident for all taxed fuels, not just gasoline; so the argument that BC's divergence is caused by increased cross-border shopping for gasoline is not supported." Also, statistical analysis can factor out things like weather, background economic conditions, and other policies.[25]

Although fossil fuel consumption initially dropped rapidly, the recession in 2008 was also involved in lower consumption globally. A report in 2015 suggested an 8.5% reduction to date in greenhouse gas emissions, which may also be affected by cross border purchases of vehicle fuel.[26] Stats Canada reports that between 2007 and 2018 fuel consumption of gasoline in British Columbia has increased by 5.2%, while consumption in Canada as a whole increased 9.8%, suggesting the possibility that British Columbia's fuel consumption rose less than the rest of Canada's due to behavioral changes stemming from the tax, as the policy intended.[27]

Later analyses

The program has seen continued success. From the program’s start in 2007 to 2018, British Columbia’s gasoline consumption increased from 4,629,896 m3 to 5,590,356 m3 (20.7%)[28] and diesel consumption increased from 1,796,661 m3 to 1,963,507 m3 (9.3%).[29] However, during this same period, British Columbia’s real GDP (inflation-adjusted using chained 2017 Canadian dollars) increased from $229,376,000,000 to $292,182,000,000 (27.4%).[30] Considering only gasoline and diesel, this indicates that emissions from these sources made up a smaller percentage of the overall economy a decade into the program than when it began, though this is an incomplete and ultimately correlational, rather than causal, analysis, since it does not account for the counterfactual.[31]

Causal impact studies have also been published, however, with evidence generally showing that the tax has caused a decrease in emissions, albeit not to the scale that the province has hoped to achieved given, for example, Canada's signing of the 2015 Paris Climate Agreement. A 2015 review of preceding academic literature on the program concludes in the abstract that “[e]mpirical and simulation models suggest that the tax has reduced emissions in the province by between 5% and 15% since being implemented” and that “polling data shows that the tax was initially opposed by the majority of the public, but that three years post-implementation, the public generally supported the carbon tax.”[32] A 2019 academic research paper that looked only at diesel consumption found that the tax caused a statistically significant decrease in diesel consumption and diesel-generated emissions.[33] A 2021 counterfactual analysis showed “no significant negative impacts on GDP” and that the pass-through of the carbon tax into energy prices was complete.[34] The authors conclude, as stated in the abstract, that “implementing revenue-neutral carbon taxation contributes to lowering harmful greenhouse gases into the atmosphere without hurting the economy.”[34] A 2022 study using machine-learning-based difference-in-differences, synthetic control, and a break-detection approach showed that the policy “has reduced transportation emissions but not ‘yet’ led to large statistically significant reductions in aggregate CO2 emissions” because the “existing carbon taxes (and prices) are likely too low to be effective in the time frame since their introduction,” indicating that the carbon tax rate needs to increase in order to identify effects on economy-wide CO2 emissions with statistical significance, even if transportation-based CO2 emissions can be seen to decrease with statistical significance.[35] Beyond emissions and overall GDP, a 2017 paper found that “the BC carbon tax generated, on average, a small but statistically significant 0.74 percent annual increases in employment over the 2007–2013 period,” providing evidence that a revenue-neutral carbon tax may actually encourage, rather than adversely affect, employment, as critics of the policy had previously asserted.[36]

See also

References

  1. ^ Sustainable Prosperity, p. 5
  2. ^ "Overview of Electricity Sector - PeoplePowerPlanet". PeoplePowerPlanet. Archived from the original on 2018-03-18. Retrieved 2017-09-07.
  3. ^ Mines, Ministry of Energy and. "B.C.'s Electricity Rates - Province of British Columbia". www2.gov.bc.ca. Archived from the original on 2017-09-08. Retrieved 2017-09-07.
  4. ^ Bauman, Yoram; Ryan, Joe (26 April 2018). "Will Washington voters warm to a new carbon tax initiative?". Seattle Times. Retrieved 20 July 2018.
  5. ^ a b c "B.C. introduces carbon tax". CanWest MediaWorks Publications. 22 February 2008. Archived from the original on 10 November 2012. Retrieved 9 January 2013.
  6. ^ "British Columbia Carbon Tax" (PDF). Ministry of Small Business and Revenue. February 2008. Archived from the original (PDF) on 13 May 2013.
  7. ^ "B.C.'s Revenue-neutral Carbon Tax". Balanced Budget 2008 Backgrounder. Province of British Columbia. 1 July 2008. Archived from the original on 20 May 2008. Retrieved 5 May 2011.
  8. ^ "B.C. tax rebate cheques due out this week". CTV British Columbia News. 23 June 2008. Archived from the original on 3 March 2016. Retrieved 9 January 2013.
  9. ^ Ahearn, Ashley (7 January 2013). "Talk Of A Carbon Tax In The Northwest". EarthFix · Oregon Public Broadcasting. Archived from the original on 16 January 2013. Retrieved 9 January 2013. "It makes sense, it's simple, it's well accepted," says Terry Lake, the minister of the environment of British Columbia.
  10. ^ "B.C.'s Revenue-neutral Carbon Tax". Balanced Budget 2008 Backgrounder. Province of British Columbia. 1 July 2008. Retrieved 5 May 2011.
  11. ^ a b c d e "What is a Carbon Tax?". Government of British Columbia. Archived from the original on 8 April 2010. Retrieved 27 October 2014.
  12. ^ Beaty, Ross; Lipsey, Richard; Elgie, Stewart (9 July 2014). "The shocking truth about B.C.'s carbon tax: It works". The Globe and Mail. Toronto, Ontario. Archived from the original on 11 December 2015. Retrieved 10 December 2015.
  13. ^ "British Columbia's carbon tax; The evidence mounts". The Economist. 31 July 2014. Archived from the original on 9 December 2015. Retrieved 10 December 2015.
  14. ^ Halstead, Ted (16 November 2015). "The Republican Solution for Climate Change; Republicans have the ability to offer a market-based solution to climate change, so why aren't they doing it?". The Atlantic. Washington, D.C. Archived from the original on 25 August 2018. Retrieved 10 December 2015.
  15. ^ CTV News (23 June 2008). "B.C. tax rebate cheques due out this week". CTV British Columbia News. Retrieved 9 January 2013.
  16. ^ Ahearn, Ashley (7 January 2013). "Talk Of A Carbon Tax In The Northwest". EarthFix · Oregon Public Broadcasting. Archived from the original on 2013-01-16. Retrieved 9 January 2013. "It makes sense, it's simple, it's well accepted," says Terry Lake, the minister of the environment of British Columbia.
  17. ^ "British Columbia's Carbon Tax". Province of British Columbia. Retrieved 14 July 2018.
  18. ^ Government of British Columbia, Ministry of Environment and Climate Change (April 29, 2024). "Carbon Tax Rates by Fuel Type". www2.gov.bc.ca. Retrieved 2024-05-02.
  19. ^ "Ministry of Finance Tax Bulletin Revised April 2019" (PDF). Retrieved April 25, 2019.
  20. ^ Elgie, Stewart; Beaty, Ross; Lipsey, Richard. "British Columbia's carbon tax shift: An environmental and economic success". worldbank.org. The World Bank. Retrieved 1 September 2016.
  21. ^ "BC's Carbon Tax Shift After Five Years".
  22. ^ "Province of British Columbia".
  23. ^ Finlayson, Jock. "B.C.'s carbon tax hurting businesses".
  24. ^ Donnelly, Aldyen. "Fantasy carbon-tax modelling overcomes arithmetic".
  25. ^ "BC's carbon tax after 5 years - Talking Sustainability - Simon Fraser University". Archived from the original on 2017-02-23. Retrieved 2017-08-25.
  26. ^ https://nicholasinstitute.duke.edu/sites/default/files/publications/ni_wp_15-04_full.pdf pg 8
  27. ^ "Add/Remove data - Sales of fuel used for road motor vehicles, annual". 28 September 2020.
  28. ^ "Supply and disposition of refined petroleum products, monthly". 4 September 2020.
  29. ^ "Sales of fuel used for road motor vehicles, annual". 28 September 2020.
  30. ^ Statistics Canada. "Table 36-10-0222-01 Gross domestic product, expenditure-based, provincial and territorial, annual (x 1,000,000)". doi:10.25318/3610022201-eng. Retrieved 2024-03-26.
  31. ^ Wooldridge, Jeffrey M (2010). Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data. MIT press.
  32. ^ Murray, Brian & Rivers, Nicholas (2015). "British Columbia's revenue-neutral carbon tax: A review of the latest "grand experiment" in environmental policy". Energy Policy. 86: 674–683. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2015.08.011. Retrieved 2024-03-26.
  33. ^ Bernard, Jean-Thomas & Kichian, Maral (2019). "The long and short run effects of British Columbia's carbon tax on diesel demand". Energy Policy. 131: 380–389. doi:10.1016/j.enpol.2019.04.021. Retrieved 2024-03-26.
  34. ^ a b Bernard, Jean-Thomas & Kichian, Maral (2021). "The Impact of a Revenue-Neutral Carbon Tax on GDP Dynamics: The Case of British Columbia". The Energy Journal. 42 (3): 205–224. doi:10.5547/01956574.42.3.jber. Retrieved 2024-03-26.
  35. ^ Petris, Felix (2022). "Does a Carbon Tax Reduce CO2 Emissions? Evidence from British Columbia". Environmental and Resource Economics. 83: 115–144. doi:10.1007/s10640-022-00679-w. Retrieved 2024-03-26.
  36. ^ Yamazaki, Akio (2017). "Jobs and climate policy: Evidence from British Columbia's revenue-neutral carbon tax". Journal of Environmental Economics and Management. 83: 197–216. doi:10.1016/j.jeem.2017.03.003. Retrieved 2024-03-26.

Government of British Columbia:

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=British_Columbia_carbon_tax&oldid=1222768992"