Jump to content

Panzer ace

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by HansZwiller (talk | contribs) at 11:11, 25 December 2017 (See WP:PRESERVE. Consesus established when edits first introduced. WP:ONUS is distortion of intent. BRD-Not BRRD. "Instead of removing article content, consider cleaning up, formatting, or tagging as necessary." Use Talk page first.). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

For the Panzer Aces series, see Panzer Aces (book series).

"Panzer ace" ("tank ace") is a contemporary term used in English-speaking popular culture to describe highly decorated German tank ("Panzer") commanders and crews during World War II. While not prevalent in World War II within the Wehrmacht, it was common in the Waffen-SS to reward its most successful personnel, as the SS organisation was far more attuned to the propaganda imperatives of Nazi Germany. These commanders were credited with the destruction of large numbers of tanks and other armoured vehicles. The British and United States militaries did not recognise any of their tank commanders for "tank kills", though some were also responsible for destroying a large number of enemy tanks.

The term "Panzer ace" has become prominent in contemporary popular culture, especially in the United States or as part of the uncritical portrayal of the Waffen-SS in English-language militaria and popular history works. The term is featured prominently in English translations of the works by German author Franz Kurowski. His biographical Panzer Aces series focuses on highly-decorated tank commanders, such as Michael Wittmann and Franz Bäke.

In recent years, German historian Sönke Neitzel and American military historian Steven Zaloga, amongst others, have examined the combat performance of highly decorated German tank crews during the war. Zaloga concluded that "Panzer ace" is a romanticisation of reality, as it is neither possible to correctly determine "tank kills" in the heat of the battle nor to separate individual performance from technological or battlefield advantage, mixed with propaganda. In contrast, British historian Robert Kershaw argues that the large number of tanks destroyed by some German commanders can be attributed to the skills they gained through years of combat.

Wartime perceptions

During World War II the concept of "Panzer aces" received little attention. To the extent that the concept existed, it was mainly advanced by the Waffen-SS as part of its contributions to Nazi Germany's propaganda campaigns. In most German Army (Heer) units, tank crews and commanders generally received awards for mission performance rather than tank kills.[1]

A Tiger I tank during the Battle of Kursk in June 1943. Most of the successful German tank commanders served in units equipped with Tigers during this period.[1]

German highly-decorated tank commanders were most often soldiers who served in units equipped with Tiger I or Tiger II tanks between mid-1943 and mid-1944. The Allies did not have any tanks capable of easily defeating the Tigers during this period. Few soldiers who operated Panther tanks at this time received the same high decorations as these tanks were more vulnerable to Allied tanks and less mechanically reliable than the Tiger.[1] Historian Dennis Showalter has suggested that the confidence which the crews of Tigers and the operators of other relatively advanced weapons had in the capabilities of their equipment may have reinforced their ideological conditioning, and encouraged them to take risks in combat.[2]

The United States Army did not adopt the concept of "tank aces" during World War II, with proposals to do so being rejected,[citation needed] and neither did the British Army.[3] The Soviet Red Army did not regard destroying tanks as an act of particular heroism for its tank commanders.[citation needed] However, the Soviet Military Review magazine noted: "The tankmen's heroic deeds were popularised over the radio, in special orders of the day, in newspapers and leaflets, and in indivdual talks with servicemen. Some tank whose crews had distinguished themselves most in action, were given, by order of tank formation commanders, the name of Russian generals or of the heroes of the units, who had fallen fighting for their country."[4] The most successful award recipient of the Hero of the Soviet Union was published in accommodation of a portrait photo.[5] However, in June 1943 Stalin issued the Order No. 0387, that would award any "tank kill" with a steady monetary bonus of 500 rubles, and 1500 rubles for a tank crew.[6] Such a monetary bonus system already existed for "aircraft kills", (Order No. 299, August 1941) but the recipient were also honored with awards: The government would award the First decoration for 3 kills; the second decoration for the next 3 kills; and for 10 kills the award Hero of the Soviet Union.[7]

Overall, Allied Newspapers devoted a lot of space to aircraft and Naval tallies, human interest stories, and the Russian Front, but paid little attention to Tank combat.[8]

Contemporary use

Kershaw in his book "Tank Men" refers to a "Tank Ace" being the minority of tank commanders that accounted for the most amount of destroyed enemy armour, saying it is roughly analogous with Flying ace [9]

The German author Franz Kurowski covers "Panzer aces" in several of his hagiographic accounts. Published in the U.S. by J.J. Fedorowicz Publishing in the 1990s and by Stackpole Books in the 2010, his popular series Panzer Aces describes fictionalised careers of highly-decorated German soldiers during World War II.[10] A veteran of the Eastern front (as a member of a propaganda company), Kurowski is one of the authors who "have picked up and disseminated the myths of the Wehrmacht in a wide variety of popular publications that romanticize the German struggle in Russia", according to The Myth of the Eastern Front by historians Ronald Smelser and Edward Davies.[11]

The most famous German "Panzer ace", Michael Wittmann, is credited by Kurowski as having destroyed 60 tanks and nearly as many anti-tank guns in the course of a few days near Kiev in November 1943.[12] According to historian Steven Zaloga, Wittman was credited with about 135 tanks destroyed - although 120 of those were made on the Eastern Front from a virtually impregnable Tiger tank. After the war, Wittmann gained a cult status among admirers of the Wehrmacht, the Waffen-SS and tank warfare.[13] Kurowski's book also describes the actions of "Panzer ace" Franz Bäke in the Cherkassy Pocket. In Kurowski's retelling, after fighting unit after unit of the Red Army, Bäke is able to establish a corridor to the trapped German forces, and then "wipes out" the attacking Soviets. In another of Kurowski's accounts, while attempting to relieve the 6th Army encircled in Stalingrad, Bake destroys 32 enemy tanks in a single engagement.[14]

Analysis

The concept of what constitutes success in tank battles has received considerable attention in recent years.[1] The historian Sönke Neitzel questions the numbers of tanks destroyed attributed in popular culture to various tank commanders. According to Neitzel, numbers of successes by highly decorated soldiers should be approached with caution as it is rarely possible to determine reliably, in the heat of the battle, how many tanks were destroyed and by whom.[15] The Wehrmacht's intelligence service on the Eastern Front, the Fremde Heere Ost (FHO), routinely reduced the reported number of Soviet tanks being destroyed by 30 to 50 per cent[16] in their own statistics to make up for double counting and repairable vehicles.[1][16] Zaloga considers these numbers to be reasonably accurate tallies of actual Soviet tank losses.[17]

At the time of Operation Citadel and during the subsequent Soviet counteroffensives in the Summer of 1943, German combat units claimed 16,250 tanks and assault guns destroyed. According to Zetterling, the high command was a little too drastic with its 50% reduction, and a reduction of claims by 42% would have been more accurate.[18]

The historian Steven Zaloga opines that "tank kill claims during World War II on all sides should be taken with a grain of salt".[1] Zaloga uses the term "tank ace" in quotation marks in his 2015 work Armored Champion: The Top Tanks of World War II. He notes the "romantic nonsense" of the popular inclination to imagine a tank versus tank engagement as an "armoured joust" – two opponents facing each other – with the "more valiant or better-armed [one] the eventual victor". In reality, most tank to tank combat involved one tank ambushing the other, and the most successful tank commanders were generally "bushwhackers" with "a decided advantage in firepower or armour, and often both".[19]

The grave of "Panzer ace" Michael Wittmann and his tank crew in 2007

Zaloga uses Wittmann's career to illustrate the point of the battlefield advantage. He credits Wittmann with "about 135" tanks destroyed, but points out that Wittmann achieved 120 of these in 1943, operating a Tiger I tank on the Eastern Front. Having advantages both in firepower and in armour, Tiger I was "nearly invulnerable in a frontal engagement" against any of the Soviet tanks of that time. Wittmann thus could "kill its opponents long before they were close enough to inflict damage on his tank".[19] Zaloga concludes: "Most of the 'tank aces' of World War II were simply lucky enough to have an invulnerable tank with a powerful gun".[19] He has also written that "the considerable attention paid to German tank aces in recent years obscures the fact that they were an exception to the rule and that most of the anonymous young German tankers in late 1944 were thrown into combat with poor training".[1]

Historian John Buckley has also criticised accounts of Wittmann's career, arguing that "many historians through to today continue to repackage unquestioningly Nazi propaganda" by repeating false claims that Wittmann's tank single-handedly defeated a British offensive in Normandy. In reality, this tactical success was achieved by the entire unit Wittmann formed part of, but was attributed only to him as part of a propaganda campaign.[20]

In contrast to this, military historian Robert Kershaw says some tank aces like Wittmann encapsulate what cumulative skills from years of combat in multiple campaigns may achieve.[8]

British expert George Forty advocates that some German tanks (in particular the Tiger 1) were often better armoured and armed than their allied counterparts, which often helped the survivability of crews, enabling them to either win engagements or at least survive encounters so as to be able to fight again.[21] However, like Kershaw, Forty notes that the expertise and bravery of tank aces who had achieved high numbers of "kills", like for instance Michael Wittmann, was also a factor. [22]. Forty also points out that there were tank commanders, like Buck Kite and Laffeyete Pool, who still had success in their tanks despite them being inferior to the tanks they opposed. [23]

Contributing Factors to Success

There are numerous factors established by writers in the field, that contribute to the success of a tank ace (and tank crews generally), though not all of them agree. Training was one issue, with writers establishing the difference in quality of training depending on the country. George Forty concludes that German tank training had the edge on other nation's training, at least partially because they had started training programs before the other countries, though he notes they still had their problems. [24]. In comparison, he notes that Russian training was seen by some as inadequate, as it was too short.[25]. He noted that for instance, Russian crews drove on the peaks of hills to avoid rough terrain, however this made them more visible targets. They continued to do this throughout the war, with no training or experience correcting this. [26]

The difference in armour and firepower is undeniably a factor. Though at times the Germans found themselves to be at a disadvantage (initially against the Matilda II in North Africa and against the T-34 in 1941 in Russia) [27] the introduction of the Tiger 1, and the advantages it had over over other tanks it commonly engaged, meant that Panzer aces had an advantage over many allied tanks, eg Russian T-34s. [19] , [28]. The Tiger 1 had an advantage over many tanks it encountered, in terms of both armour and firepower. It held that advantage up until the end of the war, when the heavier US M26 Pershing, British Comet (tank) and the Russian Joseph Stalin (IS-2) were introduced. [29]. Successful German tank aces were often in Tigers, including Kummel[30], Wittman [31] Strachwitz [32] and Otto Carius [33][33] Johannese Bolter and Martin Shroif [34]. The Panther and Tiger cause consternation in Allied tank crews, and the 75mm gun of the early model Sherman tank was seen as inadequate against these tanks. [35]. However, Kershaw points out that having a technical advantage over the enemy in terms of armour isn't absolutley decisive. The French had superior tanks in terms of armour and firepower to the Germans at the start of the war, however the training and doctrine of the French armoured forces was inferior and patchy compared to the Germans. [36]

Both British and German veterans also noted that a good crew working together, helped success in tank combat [37]. Panzer ace Michael Wittmann noted the importance of a good crew as being necessary for an effective tank. In particular, he noted the importance of the gunner, and when he was honoured with the knights Cross award for tank combat, he said he would only accept it if his gunner, Bobby Woll, was also honoured in the same manner. [38]

Notable Panzer Aces

Michael Wittman

Was a high profile tank Ace, and while his performance by some is put down to the technical superiority of his tank over his adversaries, [19] [39], other writers establish that it was also his skill, or a combination of both that enabled him to achieve such success in terms of successfully destroying large amounts of enemy tanks and vehicles[40]. His success as a panzer ace saw multiple websites and even merchandise dedicated to him, in particular he was noted for his action at Villers Bocage, where he destroyed around 21 tanks and armoured vehicles in the space of 15 minutes. [41]. [42].By the time of his death, he claimed a total war tally of 138 tanks, 132 anti tank guns, and numerous other soft skinned vehicles.[43]

List of high scoring tank commanders

Name Country Rank Unit Tank Number of tanks credited with Notes
Kurt Knispel  Germany Feldwebel 503rd Heavy Panzer Battalion, 12th Panzer Division Tiger I 168 Destroyed 168 tanks, the highest number of tanks destroyed by any tank ace. [44] [45]. [46] Knispel was the top tank ace of World War II [47]
Otto Carius  Germany Oberleutnant 502nd Heavy Panzer Battalion Tiger I / Jagdtiger 150+ Published post-war memoirs Tigers in the Mud; described as a "Panzer ace" in his English-language obituary[48]
Johannes Bölter  Germany Hauptmann 502nd Heavy Panzer Battalion Tiger I 139 Destroyed 139 enemy tanks. Referenced in Wolfgang Schneider's "Tigers in Combat, Volume 1" [49] [50]
Michael Wittmann  Germany SS-Hauptsturmführer 101st SS Heavy Panzer Battalion StuG III / Tiger I 139 Destroyed 138 tanks. [51]
Karl Körner  Germany Hauptscharführer 503rd Heavy Panzer Battalion Tiger II 102 [52]
Ernst Barkmann  Germany Oberscharführer SS-Panzer-Regiment 2 Panzer III / Panther tank 82 Destroyed 82 tanks. His action was referenced in Christer Bergstrom's "The Ardennes, 1944-1945" [53]
Willi Fey  Germany Oberscharführer Schwere SS-Panzer-Abteilung 502 Tiger I 80+ [54]
Emil Siebold  Germany Leutnant 2nd SS Panzer Division Das Reich
1st Panzer Division (Wehrmacht)		 T-34 69 Though German, Siebold's unit was equipped with captured Russian T-34s. He used one to destroy 69 enemy tanks[55] [56][57]
Dmitry Lavrinenko  Soviet Union Senior Leutnant 1st Guards Tank Brigade T-34 58 Most successful Russian and allied tank ace in WWII. [58]
Gerhard Brehmer  Germany Oberfeldwebel 1st Company, Panzer Battalion 52 Panther 51 [59]
Kurt Ohler  Germany Unter-Offizier StuGAbt. 270 StuG III 47 [60]
Weerts Johann  Germany Obersturmfuhrer 4./SS-Panzer-Regiment - 5. SS-Panzer Division "Wiking StuG III 39+ Had destroyed 39 tanks by the time he was awarded German Gold cross in 1944, likely his total tally was more by end of war. [61]
Wolfgang von Bostell  Germany Feldwebel Panzerjäger-Sturmgeschütz-Kompanie 1023
Panzerjäger-Abteilung 205		 Tiger I 28 [62]
Zvika Greengold  Israel Captain 188th Armor Brigade Centurion (tank) 20 Personally claimed 20 enemy tanks destroyed, but others credited him with up to 60. [63]

[64]

Sydney Valpy Radley-Walters  Canada Brigadier General Sherbrooke Fusilier Regiment Sherman Firefly 18 [65]

See also

References

Citations

  1. ^ a b c d e f g Zaloga 2008, p. 38.
  2. ^ Showalter 2002, p. 142.
  3. ^ Perrett 2012.
  4. ^ Soviet Military Review, Issue 4, April 1972, p. 34. Moscow: Krasnaya Zvezda Publishing House
  5. ^ Soviet Military Review, Issue 4, April 1972, p. 35. Moscow: Krasnaya Zvezda Publishing House
  6. ^ Order of the People's Commissar of Defense of the USSR, Order No. 0387 of June 24, 1943 in Russian
  7. ^ Order of the People's Commissar of Defense of the USSR, Order No. 299 of 19 August 1941 in English
  8. ^ a b Kershaw, Robert "Tank Men: the Human Story of Tanks at War" Hodder p 331
  9. ^ Kershaw, Robert "Tank Men: the Human Story of Tanks at War" Hodder p 332
  10. ^ Smelser & Davies 2008, pp. 175–176, 251.
  11. ^ Smelser & Davies 2008, pp. 5, 159.
  12. ^ Smelser & Davies 2008, pp. 179.
  13. ^ Zaloga 2015, pp. 3.
  14. ^ Smelser & Davies 2008, pp. 176.
  15. ^ Neitzel 2002, p. 413.
  16. ^ a b Zaloga 2015, p. 312.
  17. ^ Zaloga 2015, p. 134.
  18. ^ Zetterling, Niklas; Frankson, Anders (2000). Kursk 1943: A Statistical Analysis. London: Frank Cass. p. 126.
  19. ^ a b c d e Zaloga 2015, pp. 3–4.
  20. ^ Buckley 2013, p. 70.
  21. ^ Forty, George "Tanks Aces: Bliztkrieg to the gulf war" Sutton Publishing p 84,
  22. ^ Forty, George "Tanks Aces: Blitzkrieg to the Gulf War" Sutton Publishing p viii
  23. ^ Forty, George "Tanks Aces: Blitzkrieg to the Gulf War" Sutton Publishing p viii
  24. ^ Forty, George "Tank Warfare In World War Two" Magpie Books 1998, page 48
  25. ^ Forty, George "Tank Warfare In World War Two" Magpie Books 1998, page 50
  26. ^ Forty, George "Tank Warfare In World War Two" Magpie Books 1998, page 50
  27. ^ Showalter, Dennis "Hitler's Panzers: The lightning Attacks that revolutised Warfare" Berekely Caliber, 2009 p 165
  28. ^ Forty, George "Tanks Aces: Bliztkrieg to the gulf war" Sutton Publishing p 84,
  29. ^ Forty, George "Tanks Aces: Blitzkrieg to the Gulf War" Sutton Publishing p 84
  30. ^ Forty, George "Tanks Aces: Blitzkrieg to the Gulf War" Sutton Publishing p 97
  31. ^ Forty, George "Tanks Aces: Blitzkrieg to the Gulf War" Sutton Publishing p 104
  32. ^ Forty, George "Tanks Aces: Blitzkrieg to the Gulf War" Sutton Publishing p 95
  33. ^ a b "Otto Carius". The Times. 12 February 2015. Retrieved 12 June 2015.
  34. ^ Tucker-Jones, Jones "Tiger I and Tiger II" Pen and Sword Military, 1988, page 9
  35. ^ Prods, John "Normandy Crucible: The Decisive Battle that shaped World War II in Europe" p 81
  36. ^ Kershaw, Robert "Tank Man" Hodder, 2009 p 95
  37. ^ Forty, George "Tank Warfare In World War Two" Magpie Books 1998, page 133, 135
  38. ^ Forty, George "Tank Warfare In World War Two" Magpie Books 1998, page 106
  39. ^ Forty, George "Tanks Aces: Bliztkrieg to the gulf war" Sutton Publishing p 84,
  40. ^ Forty, George "Tanks Aces: Bliztkrieg to the gulf war" Sutton Publishing p 84,
  41. ^ Showalter, Dennis "Hitler's Panzers: The lightning Attacks that revolutised Warfare" Berekely Caliber, 2009 p 165
  42. ^ Forty, George "Tanks Aces: Bliztkrieg to the gulf war" Sutton Publishing p 107
  43. ^ Forty, George "Tanks Aces: Bliztkrieg to the gulf war" Sutton Publishing p 108
  44. ^ Clodfelter, Micheal. "Warfare and Armed Conflicts: A Statistical Encyclopedia of Casualty" McFarland, 2017 p 456
  45. ^ Ganz, A. Harding "Ghost Division: The 11th "Gespenster" Panzer Division and the German Armored" 2016 p 183
  46. ^ Szambever, Norbert "Waffen SS Armour in Normandy" Helion and Co, 2012 p 187
  47. ^ Clodfelter, Micheal. "Warfare and Armed Conflicts: A Statistical Encyclopedia of Casualty" McFarland, 2017 p 456
  48. ^ German World War II Panzer Ace Otto Carius Dies at 92, Mercury News
  49. ^ Wolfgang Schneider "Tigers in Combat, Volume 1" 2004
  50. ^ Szambever, Norbert "Waffen SS Armour in Normandy" Helion and Co, 2012 p 187
  51. ^ Forty, GeorgeTank Aces Sutton Publishing, 1977 p 108
  52. ^ Tucker-Jones, Anthony "Tiger I and Tiger II" Pen and Sword Military 2012 p 150
  53. ^ Christer Bergstrom's "The Ardennes, 1944-1945" Casemate 2014
  54. ^ Carruthers, Bob (2013). Tiger I in Combat. Barnsley, England: Pen and Sword. pp. 74, 76.
  55. ^ Fowler, William "Kursk: The Vital 24 Hours", Spellmount, 2005 p 62
  56. ^ Massimiliano Afiero "Zitadelle: L'SS Panzer-Korps all'attacco" Luglio 1943
  57. ^ Anthony Tucker-Jones "Hitler's Great Panzer Heist: Germany's Foreign Armour in Action 1939-45" Pen & Sword Military, 2007 p 75
  58. ^ Smirnov, Aleksandr (2002). Танковый ас Дмитрий Лавриненко [Tank Ace Dmitry Lavrinenko]. Танкомастер (in Russian). 3: 6–9. Retrieved 2014-11-11.
  59. ^ Forczyk, Robert A. "Panther vs T-34 Ukraine 1943" 2007
  60. ^ Gunter, Goerg "Die deutschen Skijäger von den Anfängen bis 1945" Dörfler Verlag GmbH; Auflage: 1, 2005
  61. ^ Mark C. Yerger "German Cross in Gold, Holder of the SS and Police: Volume 8" Bender Publishing Pgs 305-307. 2013
  62. ^ Mitcham, Samuel W. Jr, “The German Defeat in the East, 1944-45” 2001 p 139
  63. ^ Lappin, Yaakov (September 21, 2015), "I was willing to die to stop the Syrian Advance", Jerusalem Post, retrieved 1 October 2017
  64. ^ Rabinovich, Abraham "The Yom Kippur War: The Epic Encounter That Transformed the Middle East" Schocken Books, New York 2004 p 164
  65. ^ Rose, Larry "Tank Ace began stellar career at Normandy; ‘General Rad’ took out 18 German tanks and was the ‘most respected battlefield commander in the Canadian Armoured Corps’ The Globe and Mail (Breaking News) 23 April 2015

Bibliography

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Panzer_ace&oldid=817006980"