Jump to content

Save Indian Family Foundation

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Durova (talk | contribs) at 04:44, 12 November 2006 (nominating for deletion). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

This article is being considered for deletion in accordance with Wikipedia's deletion policy.
Please share your thoughts on the matter at this article's entry on the Articles for deletion page.
Feel free to edit the article, but the article must not be blanked, and this notice must not be removed, until the discussion is closed. For more information, particularly on merging or moving the article during the discussion, read the guide to deletion.

Steps to list an article for deletion: {{subst:afd}} • Preloaded debate OR {{subst:afd2|pg=Save Indian Family Foundation|cat=|text=}} • {{subst:afd3|pg=Save Indian Family Foundation}} log

Save Indian Family (SIF) is an Indian social movement aimed at reducing abuse and intimate partner violence directed against men and their families. SIF consists of many men's & family rights organisations across various Indian cities and provinces. Each of these organisations operate independently and also under the umbrella of "Save Indian Family" to get united ideologically. SIF has free helpline telephone numbers for counselling men / husbands and their family members in distress in Bangalore, Delhi, Mumbai, Hyderabad, Nasik, Surat, Jaipur and Kolkatta.

The genesis of SIF is mainly due to large scale abuse of Indian "anti-dowry" law and cruelty/harassment laws by many unscrupulous Indian women. SIF is a Liberal Men's rights organisation. SIF has no links with any conservative religious or non-religious organisations. SIF is not about Saving Indian Marriages.

History

SIF was founded as a Yahoo! hosted d-list [1] on March 9, 2005 by the unification of a number of family's rights organisations across India. Many women (i.e. mothers and sisters of abused men) joined the organisation.

The Indian Men's & Family Rights Movement was started by Ram Prakash Chug in New Delhi in the early 80s soon after draconian laws were passed in favor of women by the Indian Parliament and women began to exploit these biased laws to perpetrate domestic violence against men, husbands, their parents, siblings and friends. Later on, in 1997, the Purush Hakka Saurakshan Samiti (Hindi for "Men's Rights Protection Committee") was formed in the city of Nasik to agitate against imprisonment of husbands and their families in false dowry cases.

In Bangalore, Sangyabalya was formed in 2003 and many women joined in as well to campaign against abuse of men by their wives. The founders of Sangyabalya were inspired by Dr. Warren Farrell and Christina Hoff Sommers. Many well paid Techies (Software Engineers) who faced false cases of dowry harassment by their wives joined in as well. In March 2005, Asha Kiran ("Rays of Hope") was formed in Bangalore with 13 founders including 7 techies. Most of them had by that time successfully won their cases against them.

As the movement started growing, it became difficult to coordinate and manage it. To this end, the SIF was formed in as an internet / blogosphere forum.

In 2005, the Pariwarik Suraksha Sanstha ("Family Protection Organization") was formed in New Delhi. Many expatriate Indians (Non-Resident Indians) from the US, UK, Middle East, etc. joined in.

The Indians in United States started a protest website 498.org [2] to create awareness and campaign against harassment of American green card-holders by India's biased laws.

Even though the SIF was begun as a men's movement, there are significant number of women also involved. In 2006, in order to meet a growing need, the SIF started providing free support (psychological and legal) for women in abusive relationships as well. This was initiated when a the mother of a victim committed suicide unable to bear the contant mental abuse inflicted by the victim's wife.

In March 2006, the NGO Protect Indian Family was founded in Bombay to better facilitate the work of the SIF.

SIF Concerns

Section 498a of IPC

Under Section 498a of the Indian Penal Code, inserted in 1983, a man, his parents, siblings and even friends can be arrested (totally and absolutely without any investigations or proof) if his wife complains of harassment and cruelty by him and his family. This law is non-bailable, non-compoundable and cognizable. That is, the accused persons can be jailed without a warrent and they can get bail only from a judge after the due process of bail argument. It takes 5 to 6 years for the trial to finish and to obtain acquittal.

What makes this legislation even more invidious is the exception provided to this provision from the general principle of law that every person is innocent in the eyes of the law and the courts until proven guilty. Therefore, in effect, every accused is treated as guilty and is obliged to prove his or her innocence before the law at his or her own cost and suffer imprisonment until proven innocent.

Often, some unscrupulous Indian women complain of cruelty and harassment by filing a complaint under section 498a, so that they can claim for an exorbitant amount of alimony and get a out of court settlement to withdraw the case. Thousands of innocent old and sick people were arrested and imprisoned even when there is no evidence of dowry demand or cruelty towards the woman. Even children below 7 years of age are not spared. Many innocent men and their parents have committed suicide after failing to fight these costly lawsuits.

On 20th July, 2005, Indian Supreme Court bench presided by Justice Arijit Pasayat and Justice H.K. Seema declared Section 498a to be 'constitutional', but warned against its misuse while expressing concern that it can lead to "legal terrorism". They also stated, "Dowry Law is a shield, not an assassin's weapon". As a matter of fact, with the support and assistance of the judicial system, sexual harrasment laws, section 498a & now the 'Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act' empowers unscrupulous women to use them precisely as assassin's weapons, in order to perpetrate state-sponsored and abetted terrorism.

SIF demands that the provisions be made non-cognizable, bailable and compoundable.

Does the Indian Law 498a IPC protects the Indian family values? No. Once the 498a is used the marriage will only led to separation. Even the Local News paper does not even anlysis the truth, before the court gives the judgement they start writing about the mens family only based on the womens compliant.

Male Suicide

The male suicides specially that of married men are increasing at the rate of 4% per year as per the National Crime Bureau. Based on the analysis of the study done by professor K Nagaraj of Madras institute of Development Studies every year 22000 to 23000 married men can be said to have been driven to sucide by wives.

There are no suitably trained counselling available for men. All the sucide counselling seems to be form a pattern of trying for men to be in service objects of women .

Social Concerns

In India, the law enforcement system is highly corrupt and inefficient. So, it is not un-natural for a criminal law being used as a tool of blackmail. But, the number of innocent old and sick getting arrested under section 498a is a matter of grave concern.

SIF members point out that a large number of innocent women and even minors have been arrested and jailed due to misuse of the law section 498a (which was orginaly meant to protect women from abuse). So, they demand the law Section 498a to be made bailable and compoundable and non-cognizable.So the power of arrest goes to magistrate level from a petty junior police officer like sub-inspector.

In year 2005, about 58,200 lawsuits were filed under Section 498a of IPC. SIF activits claim that more than 80% of them are false. They argue that the real female victims of intimate partner violence mostly do not seek police help. The conviction rate of 498A cases is below 2%.

Criticism of SIF

SIF faces criticism by feminists and feminist organizations for being vocal and allegedly anti-feminist. The critiques allege that SIF members lose sympathy (whose?) due to its alleged anti-feminist stand, and they fear that the SIF can offset the women's movement in India.

Feminists point to the approximate 7000 "reported" deaths of women every year allegedly due to dowry demands.

SIF's stand is that pain and pleasure are equally applicable for both men and women, and that inflicting pain to men for the pleasure of women is sadistic.

The Indian State claims that "domestic violence" is endemic, and that only men are perpetrators and only their wives are victims. The Indian State then goes on to admit that, being unable to address this alleged malaise, it seeks to compensate by creating a new class of victims, men, their parents, siblings and friends, whom the 'law' robs of their human dignity and rights by negating the basic and fundamental principle that every person, regardless of sex or other criteria, is innocent until proven guilty.

Feminists attack organizations such as the SIF for attacking this crime that they have inveigled into the statute-book, and for demanding universal and indiscriminate justice and equality for all before the law.

News articles

  • Feminist Journalist Chandrima S. Bhattacharya wonders in The Telegraph about the possible reasons that led Indian men to allegedly launch the SIF as a protest platform in the wake of the biased domestic violence act by Indian parliament, when, in fact, the SIF was founded long before the enactment of this crime.

External links

Footnotes

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Save_Indian_Family_Foundation&oldid=87277090"