Beit HaShalom: Difference between revisions

Coordinates: 31°31′36.17″N 35°6′47.62″E / 31.5267139°N 35.1132278°E / 31.5267139; 35.1132278
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
→‎Legal battle for ownership: Copyedit (major); merge sections
→‎Court rulings: Copyedit (major)
Line 44: Line 44:


=== Court rulings ===
=== Court rulings ===
In September 2012, the Jerusalem District Court ruled that the purchase was valid and the house must return to the settlers within a month. It dismissed the claim that the purchase agreement had been annulled before it was finalized. However, the judge stressed that he was not ordering the Civil Administration to pursue legal measures that would give the settlers authorization to live in the house.<ref>[http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4281348,00.html ''Court: Settlers purchased Hebron house legally''] Itamar Fleishman, Ynet, 13 September 2012</ref> The Court held that the original vendors had turned a blind eye to the fact that the buyer was a strawman working for a Jewish group.<ref name=Pals_lose_appeal /> Nachi Eyal, Director of the [[Legal Forum for the Land of Israel]], commented that “The Minister of Defense and representatives of the State Prosecutor need to apologize and compensate the owners in Hebron.”<ref>[http://www.jewishpress.com/news/breaking-news/hebrons-beit-hashalom-to-return-to-its-jewish-owners/2012/09/14/ Hebron’s Beit HaShalom to Return to its Jewish Owners]</ref>
In September 2012, the Jerusalem District Court ruled that the purchase was valid and the house must return to the settlers within a month.<ref name=Haaretz_court_rules /><ref name=Ynet /> It dismissed the claim that the purchase agreement had been annulled before it was finalized. However, the judge stressed that he was not ordering the Civil Administration to pursue legal measures that would give the settlers authorization to live in the house.<ref name=Ynet>[http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4281348,00.html ''Court: Settlers purchased Hebron house legally''] Itamar Fleishman, Ynet, 13 September 2012</ref> Nachi Eyal, Director of the [[Legal Forum for the Land of Israel]], commented that “The Minister of Defense and representatives of the State Prosecutor need to apologize and compensate the owners in Hebron.”<ref name=Haaretz_court_rules />


In March 2014 the Israel Supreme Court ruled that Beit ha Shalom had been purchased by Morris Abraham, a Jew from Brooklyn.<ref>Tovah Lazaroff,[http://www.jpost.com/Diplomacy-and-Politics/Yaalon-Settlers-can-move-into-Hebron-house-348388 'Ya'alon. Settlers can move into Hebron house,'] [[Jerusalem Post]] 13 April, 2014.</ref><ref>[http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4509910,00.html 'Ya'alon allows settlers to return to disputed Hebron house,'] [[Ynet]], 14 April 2014.</ref> Additionally with this ruling, all appeals by the Palestinian owners, who regard the deal as fraudulent, have been exhausted, and no further hearings will be held. [[NGO]] [[Peace Now]] has warned Jewish residence there will require the IDF to employ extra resources to secure the area.<ref>Tovah Lazaroff, [http://www.jpost.com/National-News/HJC-authenticates-Jewish-purchase-of-Beit-HaShalom-in-Hebron-345049 'HJC authenticates Jewish purchase of Beit HaShalom in Hebron,'] [[Jerusalem Post]],11 March 2014.</ref> The court also ruled that the purchasers still owed the vendor $217,000, and could not reoccupy the dwelling until the remaining sum had been paid.<ref name=Pals_lose_appeal />
On 11 March 2014, the Supreme Court affirmed the ruling of the Jerusalem District Court regarding the ownership.<ref>[http://www.jpost.com/National-News/HJC-authenticates-Jewish-purchase-of-Beit-HaShalom-in-Hebron-345049 ''HJC authenticates Jewish purchase of Beit HaShalom in Hebron'']. Tovah Lazaroff, Jerusalem Post, 11 March 2014.</ref> The Court held that the original vendors had turned a blind eye to the fact that the buyer was a strawman working for a Jewish group.<ref name=Pals_lose_appeal /> The Court determined that the property only should be handed over after an approval of the Minister of Defense to register the property in the name of the settlers. The ruling also did not oblige the Government to register the settler’s rights.<ref name=PeaceNow_Disaster>[http://peacenow.org.il/eng/HebronContentionHouse ''A Disaster-in-the-Making: The (Potential) New Settlements in Hebron'']. Peace Now, 12 March 2014</ref> The court ruled that the purchasers still owed the vendor $217,000, and could not reoccupy the dwelling until the remaining sum had been paid.<ref name=Pals_lose_appeal /> [[Peace Now]] called the potential new settlement "a disaster-in-the-Making".<ref name=PeaceNow_Disaster />


=== Approval of the Defense minister ===
A family subsequently took up residence in the building in mid April, 2014.<ref>[http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4509910,00.html 'Ya'alon allows settlers to return to disputed Hebron house,'] [[Ynet]], 14 April 2014.</ref>
Defense Minister Moshe Ya’alon was quick to respond to the Court's decision; two days later, he gave the green light for the settlers to move into the building.<ref name=JP_move>Tovah Lazaroff,[http://www.jpost.com/Diplomacy-and-Politics/Yaalon-Settlers-can-move-into-Hebron-house-348388 Ya'alon. ''Settlers can move into Hebron house'']. Jerusalem Post, 13 April 2014.</ref><ref name=>[http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4509910,00.html ''Ya'alon allows settlers to return to disputed Hebron house'']. AFP, 14 April 2014</ref>


==See also==
==See also==

Revision as of 17:26, 18 July 2014

Beit HaShalom, September 2008

Beit HaShalom, (Hebrew: בית השלום, lit. the House of Peace, or, otherwise, Beit HaMeriva ("The House of Contention"), or the Al Rajabi House settlement[1] is a four-story structure that formerly housed a local Hebron Jewish community of 25 families, youth and yeshiva students. The structure is located on the main road linking Kiryat Arba to the Cave of the Patriarchs in Hebron.[2] [3] In April 2014, a Jewish settler family moved in the new settlement, after Defence Minister Moshe Ya'alon gave the go-ahead. Monitoring Human Rights institutions like TIPH and "Breaking the Silence" highly criticized this step as an act of continuous settlement policy in the occupied Palestinian Territories.[citation needed]

History

The Al Rajabi House is named after the Palestinian Faez Rajabi who, together with Abdelkader Salwar, originally purchased the land and built the four-story structure.[4][5] The building, on a 1,100-square-metre property with space for some 20 apartments, was constructed in 1995 in Hebron's a-Ras neighbourhood.[4] The Palestinian developers originally designed it for their own use as shops and apartments, but the construction was not fully finished.[6]

Settlers' take-over of the building

On 19 March 2007, over 200 Jews, mostly yeshiva students from the Hebron area, entered the building in the evening hours. They reached the building by running through an Arab village. The decision to enter the building now was reached after the Jews of Hebron received information that Arabs intended to enter the building in the near future.[7]

The settlers named the house "Shalom House". Hebron Jewish Community's spokesperson Noam Arnon said the entry into the house was not meant for provocation but for peaceful residence by Jews.[7] About the importance of the building, spokesmen stressed: ″The house of peace, on the main road between Hebron and Kiryat Arba is an additional link in the growth of the City of the Patriarchs and Matriarchs. Bonding Hebron and Kiryat Arba, this building will provide homes for dozens, if not hundreds of Israelis, waiting to live in Hebron.″[8] The IDF, who arrived upon the take-over, provided security for the settlers.[8]

On the same day, Rajabi filed a complaint with the police. He charged that the settlers were trespassers, and had occupied his building by force.[5] Rajabi was summoned to Jericho by the Palestinian Authority, and detained for 6 months "for his own security".[9]

Reactions of the authorities

The settlement was politically controversial as was the legality of the purchase. The Civil Administration decided that the settler's move into the house was illegal and they must be evacuated. It suggested that then Defense Minister Amir Peretz order an immediate evacuation of the house, relying on the argument that the settlers did not receive the necessary permits from the Civil Administration.[10] The settlers could have been evacuated under Civil Administration Order 25, which determined that the occupation or transfer of ownership of homes in the West Bank by Jews requires the approval of the head of the civil administration.[11] The legal basis for the Defense Minister's decision to evacuate the home in Hebron also came from a 1980 cabinet decision, when then-prime minister Menachem Begin's government decided that the cabinet was the only body authorized to approve the expansion of the Jewish community of Hebron.[12] Defense Minister Amir Peretz and Deputy Defense Minister Efraim Sneh expected the evacuation to be completed by mid-May 2007.[10] But ministers and MKs who spoke to Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said he opposed evacuating the home at this stage, and hinted that he would prefer to block an evacuation until after the Labor primary, when Olmert was expected to have an easier defense minister with which to work. A clear majority against the evacuation was expected if the matter would come to a vote in the cabinet.[13]

Windows issue

In September 2007, the Ministry of Defense prohibited the settler families from preparing their homes for winter, upholding a court order that forbade any change in the status quo of the house. In the building were no windows, only gaps where windows were intended to be installed.[14] The gaps were sealed with plastic sheets.

Eviction order

On 27 November 2007, the Civil Administration issued eviction orders against the settlers.[15] The settlers' lawyer Attorney Nadav Ha'etzni, representing the claimed purchasers "Tal Construction and Investment of Karnei Shomron" and the "Society for the Renewal of the Jewish Community in Hebron", petitioned the High Court against the order. In January 2008, the state defended its decision to recognize the settlers as "recent trespassers", and to evict them as quickly as possible because there was insufficient evidence to prove that the sale of the building had been completed.[16] Pending the case in a military appeals court concerning the sale of the building, however, the Court decided to delay the judgement on the eviction.[15]

In November 2008, the High Court ordered the vacation of the building and named the State temporary custodian of the property, pending a ruling on the proprietary rights.[17] Ehud Olmert declared that he did not want to execute the Court's order, but merely stop the repeated settler attacks on Palestinian civilians and property.[18] After the Court had ruled in favour of the government's decision to evacuate the site, the settlers built barricades, and prepared to resist efforts to have them evicted.[19] Baruch Marzel declared that "We must go to war, using any means to prevent this crime from occurring."[20]

In the days prior to the evacuation, settlers repeatedly attacked Palestinian homes in the city and fired randomly at Palestinian homes. Settlers set fire to two Palestinian homes and a store.[21] Over three days they reportedly rioted in Hebron, attacking Palestinians with stones and clubs while Israeli soldiers and police looked on.[21] On 4 December 2008, the Jewish settlers were evacuated from the site by Israeli police. The evacuation took an hour and was carried out by some 600 members of the security forces. The confrontation was less violent than had been feared.[22]

Violence following evacuation

Following the evacuation on 4 December 2008, "Jewish extremists embarked on an unprecedented rampage through Hebron".[22] UN OCHA field worker Tareq Talahme told that "hundreds" of settlers entered Hebron and torched fields, olive groves, and yards in the nearby Wadi Nasara (Wadi al-Hussein), between Hebron and the Kiryat Arba settlement. They set fire to 5 houses near the Rajabi compound, and damaged more than 27 cars.[23] Settler youths took over a Palestinian home in the valley and caused extensive damage.[22] Settlers fired at Palestinians. A man was caught on videotape shooting at a Palestinian and his son in Wadi al-Hussein'. Both Palestinians were evacuated by the IDF in serious condition.[22] The shooting incidents and destructions in the valley were recorded in affidavits by [[Al-Haq].[24] Two Kiryat Arba residents, suspected of shooting at Palestinians at close range were arrested. The shooting was filmed by B'Tselem members. Also firing at settlers by Palestinians was reported.[25] Israelis and Palestinians clashed after settlers entered the Palestinian-controlled part of Hebron (Area H1) and set fire to at least three cars. A Palestinian news team that was filming the violence was attacked.[22] Settlers vandalized Palestinian property and pelt homes with rocks through the West Bank.[25] The US consulate reported that across the West Bank burning Palestinian fields, trees, houses and cars were seen.[23] The press reported that settlers attacked the villages of Burin and Huwara, south of Nablus, damaging homes, burning trees, agricultural fields and cars late on 4 December.[23] Rabbis for Human Rights reported that most northern West Bank roads were blocked by settlers, and widespread fires were visible in the Nablus region.[23] Settlers stopped a PRCS ambulance in Hebron and defaced the ambulance, painting "let the Arabs die".[23]

Legal battle for ownership

Contract and forged documents

According to Haaretz, the settlers moved into the house after several years of negotiating with the Palestinian owners. The settlers said they bought the house legally and signed a contract, but the Palestinians denied.[10]

On 3 July 2007, the Israeli State declared before the High Court, that the police forensics department found that documents which would support the settlers' claim of their legal ownership have been forgeries or gave serious doubt regarding their authenticity.[26] The claimed Palestinian owners admitted they made a deal to transfer ownership of the property to a third party, but said the deal was canceled later on. They did, however not provide documentation to support this claim.[26]

In response to a petition by the settlers against eviction orders, in January 2008, the state declared that the Palestinian owner of the building was undoubtedly in possession of the property when settlers took it over on 19 March 2007.[16] The state recognized the settlers as "recent trespassers", and said that there was insufficient evidence to prove that the sale of the building to the Jewish purchasers had been completed.[16] According to the state, a contract for the sale of the building was indeed signed between Rajabi and a Palestinian partner on the one side, and Ayub Jaber, a Palestinian intermediary for the purchasers, on the other, in return for 460,000 Jordanian dinars. However, many documents the alleged Jewish purchasers presented to the police Crimes Investigation Unit were forged. The state's attorney wrote ″We are talking about large-scale forgeries of many documents that were supposed to support the petitioners' [the settlers'] claims″.[16] The company that bought the house had in recent years already been involved with suspected forgery and fraud upon house purchases.[27]

In November 2008, the settler's lawyer Nadav Ha'etzni stated that his clients had purchased the building as early as 2004. A Palestinian straw man, Ayub Yosef Jaber, had signed a contract with Rajabi on 23 March 2004. A video in which, according to Jerusalem Post, Rajabi was seen signing the sales contract was submitted to the Court.[5] Ayub Jaber, who worked on behalf of the Jewish group,[4] signed the sale agreement with the Jordan company "Tal Building and Investments Karnei Shomron".[28]

The site was reportedly purchased by a descendant of the earlier Hebron Jewish community.[29]

Court rulings

In September 2012, the Jerusalem District Court ruled that the purchase was valid and the house must return to the settlers within a month.[28][30] It dismissed the claim that the purchase agreement had been annulled before it was finalized. However, the judge stressed that he was not ordering the Civil Administration to pursue legal measures that would give the settlers authorization to live in the house.[30] Nachi Eyal, Director of the Legal Forum for the Land of Israel, commented that “The Minister of Defense and representatives of the State Prosecutor need to apologize and compensate the owners in Hebron.”[28]

On 11 March 2014, the Supreme Court affirmed the ruling of the Jerusalem District Court regarding the ownership.[31] The Court held that the original vendors had turned a blind eye to the fact that the buyer was a strawman working for a Jewish group.[4] The Court determined that the property only should be handed over after an approval of the Minister of Defense to register the property in the name of the settlers. The ruling also did not oblige the Government to register the settler’s rights.[32] The court ruled that the purchasers still owed the vendor $217,000, and could not reoccupy the dwelling until the remaining sum had been paid.[4] Peace Now called the potential new settlement "a disaster-in-the-Making".[32]

Approval of the Defense minister

Defense Minister Moshe Ya’alon was quick to respond to the Court's decision; two days later, he gave the green light for the settlers to move into the building.[33][34]

See also

References

  1. ^ OCHA Special Focus Unprotected: Israeli settler violence against Palestinian civilians and their property
  2. ^ Gov't bans Hebron settlers from winterizing controversial house. Haaretz, September 26, 2007.
  3. ^ Hebron settlers try to buy more homes, Jerusalem Post, April 13, 2007
  4. ^ a b c d e Palestinians lose appeal over Hebron house ownership. Chaim Levinson, Haaretz, 11 March 2014.
  5. ^ Hebron settlers give up comfort to expand Jewish holdings. Jerusalem Post, 15 April 2007
  6. ^ a b 200 Jews Enter New Building in Hevron: ′Peace House′. Arutz Sheva, 20 March 2007
  7. ^ a b Beit HaShalom – the House of Peace – a new Jewish building in Hebron. Jewish Community of Hebron, 19 March 2007
  8. ^ Palestinian waging long battle to live in his home. Omar Karmi, The National, 14 April 2009
  9. ^ a b c Settlers unlikely to be removed from disputed Hebron house anytime soon. Amos Harel, Haaretz, 6 June 2007
  10. ^ An ominous house of contention. Talia Sasson, Haaretz, 15 April 2007
  11. ^ Hebron settlers try to buy more homes. YAAKOV KATZ AND TOVAH LAZAROFF, Jerusalem Post, 13 April 2007.
  12. ^ Olmert won't let Peretz evacuate Hebron house. Gil Hoffman, Jerusalem Post, 12 April 2007
  13. ^ Gov't bans Hebron settlers from winterizing controversial house. Haaretz, 26 September 2007
  14. ^ a b Settlers get three more months on ′Worshipers' Way′. Dan Izenberg, Jerusalem Post, 17 January 2008
  15. ^ a b c d State backs Palestinian owner in Hebron dispute. Dan Izenberg, Jerusalem Post, 8 January 2008
  16. ^ High Court orders disputed house in Hebron vacated. Aviad Glickman, Ynet, 16 November 2008
  17. ^ Olmert hints: No forced evacuation of Hebron house; Barak to review army. Amos Harel and Aluf Benn, Haaretz, 26 November 2008
  18. ^ Showdown looming over settler evictions. ABC News Australia, 24 November 2008
  19. ^ Efrat Weiss, We'll go to war over Hebron house, warn settlers. Ynet, 17 November 2008.
  20. ^ a b Dozens injured as Israeli army removes settlers from Hebron house. Ma'an News Agency, 4 December 2008
  21. ^ a b c d e UN ME envoy slams settler violence. Jerusalem Post, 6 December 2008
  22. ^ a b c d e 08JERUSALEM2198. Wikileaks, 5 December 2008
  23. ^ Alternative Report in Response to Israel’s Third Periodic Report (CCPR/C/ISR/3) to the Human Rights Committee, Annexure (B) Affidavits, pp. 38-43. Al-Haq, 9 August 2009
  24. ^ a b VIDEO / Settlers filmed shooting at Palestinians turn themselves in. Haaretz, 6 December 2008
  25. ^ a b Settlers forged ownership of Hebron house. Aviram Zino, Ynet, 3 July 2007
  26. ^ Company that bought Hebron house already in fraud probe. Amos Harel, Haaretz, 17 April 2007
  27. ^ a b c Israeli court rules contentious Hebron house must be returned to settlers. Oz Rosenberg, Haaretz, 13 September 2012
  28. ^ Descendants of 1929 massacre survivors bought Hebron house Haaretz, 26 December 2007
  29. ^ a b Court: Settlers purchased Hebron house legally Itamar Fleishman, Ynet, 13 September 2012
  30. ^ HJC authenticates Jewish purchase of Beit HaShalom in Hebron. Tovah Lazaroff, Jerusalem Post, 11 March 2014.
  31. ^ a b A Disaster-in-the-Making: The (Potential) New Settlements in Hebron. Peace Now, 12 March 2014
  32. ^ Tovah Lazaroff,Ya'alon. Settlers can move into Hebron house. Jerusalem Post, 13 April 2014.
  33. ^ Ya'alon allows settlers to return to disputed Hebron house. AFP, 14 April 2014

External links

31°31′36.17″N 35°6′47.62″E / 31.5267139°N 35.1132278°E / 31.5267139; 35.1132278

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Beit_HaShalom&oldid=617477767"