Shusha massacre: Difference between revisions

Shusha massacre
Shusha massacre
Part of Armenian–Azerbaijani war (1918–1920)
	Ruins of the Armenian half of Shusha after the city's destruction by Azerbaijani army in March 1920. In the center: defaced Armenian Ghazanchetsots Cathedral
Location	Nagorno-Karabakh (disputed between Azerbaijan Democratic Republic and First Republic of Armenia)
Date	March 1920
Target	Armenian civilians
Attack type	Massacre, riots, pogrom
Deaths	500 up to 20,000 Armenians
Perpetrators	Ottoman Army and Azerbaijanis

Browse history interactively

← Previous edit Next edit →

Content deleted Content added

VisualWikitext

Inline

Revision as of 20:07, 7 March 2023

The Shusha massacre or Shushi massacre (Armenian: Շուշիի ջարդեր, romanized: Shushii jarder), also known as the Shusha pogrom, was the mass killing of the Armenian population of Shusha in 22 to 26 March 1920 and the destruction and the process of "cultural de-Armenianization" of Nagorno-Karabakh.^[3]

The number of deaths varies depending on source, with the most conservative estimate being 500 and the highest estimates being 20,000.

Background

At the end of the First World War, the ownership of the territory of Nagorno-Karabakh was disputed between the newly established republics of the Armenia and Azerbaijan. Shusha – the territory's largest settlement, its centre for social and cultural life, and with a mixed population consisting mostly of ethnic Armenians and Azerbaijanis – found itself at the heart of the dispute. The government of Azerbaijan proclaimed in Baku the annexation of the disputed territory and, on January 15, 1919, appointed Khosrov bek Sultanov,^[4] as governor-general of Karabagh. The United Kingdom had a small detachment of troops stationed in Shusha and acceded to Sultanov's appointment as provisional governor, but insisted that a final decision on the territory's ownership could only be decided at a future peace conference.

In response to Sultanov's appointment, the General Assembly of the Armenians of Karabagh (Armenian National Council of Karabagh), meeting in Shusha on February 19, "rejected with legitimate indignation all pretence of Azerbaijan with regard to Armenian Karabagh, which said Assembly has declared an integral part of Armenia".^[5] On April 23, 1919, the Karabakh Council convened in Shusha and again rejected Azerbaijan's claim of sovereignty, insisting on their right of self-determination. After this, a local Azerbaijani detachment encircled the Armenian quarters of Shusha and demanded that the inhabitants to surrender the fortress. Shots were fired, but by virtue of British mediation, the Armenians agreed to surrender to them instead.^[4] According to Colonel J.C. Rhea, acting Allied high commissioner, Sultanov "countenanced a polity of extermination of Armenians".^[6]

On the 4 and 5 June 1919, armed clashes occurred in Shusha between the two communities and Sultanov began a blockade of the town's Armenian quarters. American nurses working in Shusha for Near East Relief wrote of a massacre "by Tartars of 700 of the Christian inhabitants of the town."^[7] A cease-fire was quickly organised after the Armenian side agreed to Sultanov's condition that members of the Armenian National Council leave the town. However, a new wave of violence then swept through neighbouring Armenian-populated villages: in mid-June Azerbaijani mounted "irregulars", about 2,000 strong, attacked, looted and burnt a large Armenian village, Khaibalikend, just outside Shusha, and approximately 600 Armenians lay dead.^[4]

The Seventh Congress of the Armenians of Karabagh was convened in Shusha on 13 August 1919. It concluded with the agreement of 22 August, according to which Nagorno-Karabagh would consider itself to be provisionally within the borders of the Republic of Azerbaijan until its final status was decided at the Peace Conference in Paris. Armenians remained divided on their response and a stock of arms was built up on both sides and the Armenians decided to deter a Tatar attack by staging an abortive uprising.^[8]

Failed Uprising

Matters came to a head on the evening of 22 March, when "the Varanda militia entered Shusha...supposedly to receive its pay and to felicitate Governor-General Sultanov on the occasion of Novruz Bairam," writes historian Richard G. Hovannisian. "That same night, about 100 armed men led by Nerses Azbekian slipped into the city to disarm the Azerbaijani garrison in the Armenian quarter. But everything went wrong. The Varanda militiamen spent most of the night eating and drinking and were late in taking up their assigned positions, whereas Azbekian's detachment, failing to link up with the militia, began firing on the Azerbaijani fort from afar, awakening the troops and sending them scurrying to arms."^[1] This jolted the Varanda militiamen from their initial dormancy, as they "began seizing Azerbaijani officers quartered in Armenian homes. The confusion on both sides continued until dawn, when the Azerbaijanis learned that their garrison at Khankend had held and, heartened, began to spread out into the Armenian quarter. The fighting took the Armenians of Shusha by surprise."^[1]

Massacre

Immediately after the quelling of the uprising, Azerbaijani troops, along with city's Azerbaijani inhabitants, turned their wrath on Shusha' Armenian population.^[1] The city's churches were put to the flame, as were cultural institutions, schools, libraries, the business section, and the homes of wealthy Armenians. Bishop Vahan (Ter-Grigorian), who had sought a policy of accommodation with the Azerbaijani authorities, was murdered and beheaded, his "head paraded through the streets on a spike."^[1] Chief of police Avetis Ter-Ghukasian was "turned into a human torch," while hundreds of others were similarly murdered with impunity.^[1]

Aftermath

Five to six thousand Armenians managed to escape by way of Karintak to Varanda and Dizak.^[9] By 11 April 1920, some thirty villages in Nagorno-Karabakh had been "devastated" by Azerbaijani forces as a result of the uprising, leaving 25,000 homeless (including nearly 6,000 refugees from Shusha).^[10]

Death Toll

According to the 1917 edition of Kavkazskiy kalendar, there were 43,869 residents in Shusha on 14 January [O.S. 1 January] 1916—the city was composed of 23,396 Armenians who formed 53.3 percent of the population and 19,091 Shia Muslims (mainly Azerbaijanis) who formed 43.5 percent of the population.^[11]^[9]

The total death toll of the Shusha massacre remains a matter of debate among historians, with estimates ranging from 500 up to 20,000 Armenians.^[2]^[a] A conservative estimate by Hovannisian places the death toll of the massacre at 500 Armenians and the destruction of many buildings in Shusha.^[1]^[b] German historian Jörg Baberowski states that the Armenian quarter of Shusha was "wiped off the face of the earth", indicated by 25 of 1,700 homes surviving the pogrom.^[12]

Marieta Shahinyan wrote that 3–4 thousand or more than 12 thousand Armenians were killed and 7,000 homes were destroyed in three-days.^[13] The Great Soviet Encyclopedia entry for Shusha writes that "up to 20 percent of the population [of Shusha] died" when the city was burned.^[14]

Retribution

Former minister of internal affairs of Azerbaijan Behbud Khan Javanshir was assassinated during Operation Nemesis by members of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, who suspected him of involvement in the massacre.^[15]

Memory

The prominent Russian poet Osip Mandelstam, who visited Shusha in 1930, wrote the poem "The Phaeton Driver" (1931) in memory of the massacre and burning:

So in Nagorno-Karabakh
These were my fears
Forty thousand dead windows
Are visible there from all directions,
The cocoon of soulless work
Buried in the mountains.^[16]^[17]^[18]

Visiting Shusha with Osip, Nadezhda Mandelstam wrote, "in this town, which formerly, of course, was healthy and endowed with every amenity, the picture of catastrophe and massacres was terribly vivid ... They say after the massacres all the wells were full of corpses.... We didn't see anyone in the streets or on the mountain. Only in the centre of town, in the market-square, there were a lot of people, but there wasn't any Armenian among them, they were all Muslims."^[19] Numerous other communist officials recalled the destruction of the town, including, Sergo Ordzhonikidze,^[20] Olga Shatunovskaya,^[21] and Anastas Mikoyan and Marietta Shaginyan,^[22] Russian-Georgian writer Anaida Bestavashvili drew a comparison between the burning of Shusha to the destruction of Pompeii in her The People and the Monuments.^[23]

On March 20, 2000, a memorial stone was laid in Shusha on the site of the planned monument to the victims of the pogrom. The Nagorno-Karabakh Republic government introduced a proposal to the National Assembly to establish March 23 as a day of memorial for the victims of the pogrom.^[24]

Notes

^ Certain Armenian sources cite as high as 30,000 Armenians to account for the deaths across the region over the following days.^[2]
^ Hovannisian also writes of a "Melkumian report" that claims that 5,000–6,000 were "left behind" during the massacre whilst 8,000 escaped.

References

^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g Hovannisian 1996, p. 152.
^ ^a ^b ^c Smele, Jonathan (2015). Woronoff, Jon (ed.). Historical Dictionary of the Russian Civil Wars, 1916-1926. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield. p. 137. ISBN 9781442252813. Archived from the original on 2022-11-08. Retrieved 2022-11-08. …local Azeris attacked the Armenian community at Shusha, the number of deaths resulting remaining a matter of bitter dispute (with estimates ranging from 500 to 20,000).
^ ^a ^b Geldenhuys 2009, p. 97.
^ ^a ^b ^c Walker, Christopher J. Armenia: The Survival of a Nation, revised 2nd ed. (London: Routledge, 1990), p. 270.
^ ""letter from Avetis Aharonian, president of the delegation of the Republic of Armenia, addressed to the presidents of the delegations of Italy, France, England, and the U.S."". Archived from the original on 2007-09-14. Retrieved 2008-01-24.
^ Lieberman 2013, p. 56.
^ "Nurses Stuck to Post Archived 2021-08-15 at the Wayback Machine," The New York Times, 4 September 1919.
^ Wright 2003, p. 98.
^ ^a ^b Bagdasaryan, Gegam (March 2015). "Три нераскрытых обстоятельства резни армян в Шуши" [Three unsolved circumstances of the massacre of Armenians in Shushi]. theanalyticon.com (in Russian). Stepanakert. Archived from the original on 14 November 2022. Retrieved 15 November 2022.
^ Hovannisian 1996, pp. 157–158.
^ Кавказский календарь на 1917 год [Caucasian calendar for 1917] (in Russian) (72nd ed.). Tiflis: Tipografiya kantselyarii Ye.I.V. na Kavkaze, kazenny dom. 1917. pp. 190–192. Archived from the original on 4 November 2021.
^ Baberovski, Yorg (2010). Враг есть везде. Сталинизм на Кавказе [The enemy is everywhere. Stalinism in the Caucasus] (in Russian). Moscow: Rossiyskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya (ROSSPEN) Fond «Prezidentskiy tsentr B. N. Yeltsina». p. 171. ISBN 978-5-8243-1435-9. Archived from the original on 8 October 2022.
^ "1920 թվականի Շուշիի կոտորածը" [The Shushi Massacre of 1920]. Republic.Mediamax.am (in Armenian). Archived from the original on 19 July 2022. Retrieved 19 November 2022.
^ Great Soviet Encyclopedia. Vol. 17. New York: Macmillan. 1973. p. 301.
^ "Помимо лидеров младотурок руководство операции "Немезис" приняло решение о ликвидации некоторых деятелей мусаватистского правительства Азербайджана, виновных, по их мнению, в организации резни армян в Баку в сентябре 1918 г. – бывшего премьер-министра Фатали хана Хойского (июнь 1920 г.), а также бывшего министра Бехбуд хана Дживаншира (июль 1921 г.), организатора резни армян в Шуши (Карабах)." I. P. Dobaev, V. I. Nemchina: И.П.Добаев, В.И.Немчина. Новый терроризм в мире и на Юге России: сущность, эволюция, опыт противодействия (Ростов н/Д., 2005)
^ Osip Mandelstam, "Faetonshchik," "Мандельштам Осип | Классика.ру - электронная библиотека классической литературы". Archived from the original on 2007-08-13. Retrieved 2007-08-29.
^ Osip Mandelstam. Sochineniia. 2 vols. (Moscow, 1990) 1: pp. 517–519.
^ Baines, Jennifer. Mandelstam: The Later Poetry. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1976), pp. 41-42.
^ (in Russian) N. Ya. Mandelstam. Kniga tretia. Paris: YMCA-Ргess, 1987, pp. 162–164.
^ Partizdat TsK VKP (b), 1936, pp. 60–63.
^ (in Russian) Шатуновская О. Г . Об ушедшем веке. Рассказывает Ольга Шатуновская / сост.: Д. Кутьина, А. Бройдо, А. Кутьин. – La Jolla (Calif.) : DAA Books, 2001. – 470 с., c. 71
^ "Here during the 3 days in March 1920, 7000 houses were destroyed and burnt, and the people are marking different numbers of that who were massacred...". (in Russian) Marietta Shaginyan, "Soviet Transcaucasus", Armgiz, 1947, p. 254
^ Anaida Bestavashvili, Lyudi i pamyatniki (in Russian) Archived 2022-11-29 at the Wayback Machine // Армянский вестник, # 1–2, 2000
^ Nagornyy Karabakh marks 80th anniversary of 1920 Armenian pogroms, Noyan Tapan, 24 Mar. 2000

Bibliography

Lieberman, Benjamin (2013). Terrible Fate Ethnic Cleansing in the Making of Modern Europe. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. ISBN 9781442230385.

Geldenhuys, Deon (2009). Contested States in World Politics. Vol. 3. Berkeley: Palgrave Macmillan UK. ISBN 9780230234185.

Smith, J. (1999). The Bolsheviks and the Nation Quesstion 1917-23. Palgrave Macmillan UK. ISBN 9780230377370.

Wright, John (2003). Transcaucasian Boundaries. Palgrave Macmillan UK. ISBN 978-0805079326.

Hovannisian, Richard G. (1996a). The Republic of Armenia: From London to Sèvres, February–August 1920. Vol. 3. Berkeley: University of California Press. ISBN 978-0520088030.

External links

[12] Certain Armenian sources cite as high as 30,000 Armenians to account for the deaths across the region over the following days.^[2]

[13] Hovannisian also writes of a "Melkumian report" that claims that 5,000–6,000 were "left behind" during the massacre whilst 8,000 escaped.

[FOOTNOTEHovannisian1996152-1] ^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g Hovannisian 1996, p. 152.

[Smele-2] Smele, Jonathan (2015). Woronoff, Jon (ed.). Historical Dictionary of the Russian Civil Wars, 1916-1926. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield. p. 137. ISBN 9781442252813. Archived from the original on 2022-11-08. Retrieved 2022-11-08. …local Azeris attacked the Armenian community at Shusha, the number of deaths resulting remaining a matter of bitter dispute (with estimates ranging from 500 to 20,000).

[FOOTNOTEGeldenhuys200997-3] Geldenhuys 2009, p. 97.

[Armenia_1990,_page_270-4] Walker, Christopher J. Armenia: The Survival of a Nation, revised 2nd ed. (London: Routledge, 1990), p. 270.

[5] ""letter from Avetis Aharonian, president of the delegation of the Republic of Armenia, addressed to the presidents of the delegations of Italy, France, England, and the U.S."". Archived from the original on 2007-09-14. Retrieved 2008-01-24.

[FOOTNOTELieberman201356-6] Lieberman 2013, p. 56.

[7] "Nurses Stuck to Post Archived 2021-08-15 at the Wayback Machine," The New York Times, 4 September 1919.

[FOOTNOTEWright200398-8] Wright 2003, p. 98.

[bagdasaryan-9] Bagdasaryan, Gegam (March 2015). "Три нераскрытых обстоятельства резни армян в Шуши" [Three unsolved circumstances of the massacre of Armenians in Shushi]. theanalyticon.com (in Russian). Stepanakert. Archived from the original on 14 November 2022. Retrieved 15 November 2022.

[FOOTNOTEHovannisian1996157–158-10] Hovannisian 1996, pp. 157–158.

[11] Кавказский календарь на 1917 год [Caucasian calendar for 1917] (in Russian) (72nd ed.). Tiflis: Tipografiya kantselyarii Ye.I.V. na Kavkaze, kazenny dom. 1917. pp. 190–192. Archived from the original on 4 November 2021.

[baberovski-14] Baberovski, Yorg (2010). Враг есть везде. Сталинизм на Кавказе [The enemy is everywhere. Stalinism in the Caucasus] (in Russian). Moscow: Rossiyskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya (ROSSPEN) Fond «Prezidentskiy tsentr B. N. Yeltsina». p. 171. ISBN 978-5-8243-1435-9. Archived from the original on 8 October 2022.

[:0-15] "1920 թվականի Շուշիի կոտորածը" [The Shushi Massacre of 1920]. Republic.Mediamax.am (in Armenian). Archived from the original on 19 July 2022. Retrieved 19 November 2022.

[16] Great Soviet Encyclopedia. Vol. 17. New York: Macmillan. 1973. p. 301.

[17] "Помимо лидеров младотурок руководство операции "Немезис" приняло решение о ликвидации некоторых деятелей мусаватистского правительства Азербайджана, виновных, по их мнению, в организации резни армян в Баку в сентябре 1918 г. – бывшего премьер-министра Фатали хана Хойского (июнь 1920 г.), а также бывшего министра Бехбуд хана Дживаншира (июль 1921 г.), организатора резни армян в Шуши (Карабах)." I. P. Dobaev, V. I. Nemchina: И.П.Добаев, В.И.Немчина. Новый терроризм в мире и на Юге России: сущность, эволюция, опыт противодействия (Ростов н/Д., 2005)

[18] Osip Mandelstam, "Faetonshchik," "Мандельштам Осип | Классика.ру - электронная библиотека классической литературы". Archived from the original on 2007-08-13. Retrieved 2007-08-29.

[19] Osip Mandelstam. Sochineniia. 2 vols. (Moscow, 1990) 1: pp. 517–519.

[20] Baines, Jennifer. Mandelstam: The Later Poetry. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1976), pp. 41-42.

[21] (in Russian) N. Ya. Mandelstam. Kniga tretia. Paris: YMCA-Ргess, 1987, pp. 162–164.

[22] Partizdat TsK VKP (b), 1936, pp. 60–63.

[23] (in Russian) Шатуновская О. Г . Об ушедшем веке. Рассказывает Ольга Шатуновская / сост.: Д. Кутьина, А. Бройдо, А. Кутьин. – La Jolla (Calif.) : DAA Books, 2001. – 470 с., c. 71

[24] "Here during the 3 days in March 1920, 7000 houses were destroyed and burnt, and the people are marking different numbers of that who were massacred...". (in Russian) Marietta Shaginyan, "Soviet Transcaucasus", Armgiz, 1947, p. 254

[25] Anaida Bestavashvili, Lyudi i pamyatniki (in Russian) Archived 2022-11-29 at the Wayback Machine // Армянский вестник, # 1–2, 2000

[26] Nagornyy Karabakh marks 80th anniversary of 1920 Armenian pogroms, Noyan Tapan, 24 Mar. 2000

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[a]

[b]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[16]

[17]

[18]

[19]

[20]

[21]

[22]

[23]

[24]

@@ Line 10: / Line 10: @@
 | date             = March 1920
 | type             = [[Massacre]], [[riots]], [[pogrom]]
-| perpetrators     = Azerbaijanis
+| perpetrators     = Ottoman Army and Azerbaijanis{{sfn|Geldenhuys|2009|p=97}}
+| fatalities       = 500{{sfn|Hovannisian|1996|p=152}} up to 20,000 Armenians<ref name= Smele>{{cite book|author-last= Smele|author-first= Jonathan|editor-last= Woronoff|editor-first= Jon|editor-link= Jon Woronoff|title= Historical Dictionary of the Russian Civil Wars, 1916-1926|year= 2015|location= Lanham|publisher= [[Rowman & Littlefield]]|page= 137|isbn= 9781442252813|url= https://books.google.com/books?id=QwquCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA137|quote= …local Azeris attacked the Armenian community at Shusha, the number of deaths resulting remaining a matter of bitter dispute (with estimates ranging from 500 to 20,000).|access-date= 2022-11-08|archive-date= 2022-11-08|archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20221108030032/https://books.google.com/books?id=QwquCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA137|url-status= live}}</ref>}}
-| fatalities       = 500{{sfn|Hovannisian|1996|p=152}}
-}}
 The '''Shusha massacre''' or '''Shushi massacre''' ({{lang-hy|Շուշիի ջարդեր|translit=Shushii jarder}}), also known as the '''Shusha pogrom''', was the mass killing of the [[Armenians|Armenian]] population of [[Shusha]] in 22 to 26 March 1920 and the destruction and the process of "cultural de-Armenianization" of [[Nagorno-Karabakh]].{{sfn|Geldenhuys|2009|p=97}}
-The number of deaths varies depending on source, with the most conservative estimate being up to some 500 dead.
+The number of deaths varies depending on source, with the most conservative estimate being 500 and the highest estimates being 20,000.
 ==Background==
@@ Line 42: / Line 41: @@
 According to the 1917 edition of ''[[Kavkazskiy kalendar]]'', there were 43,869 residents in Shusha on {{OldStyleDate|14 January|1916|1 January}}—the city was composed of 23,396 [[Armenians]] who formed 53.3 percent of the population and 19,091 [[Shia Muslims]] (mainly [[Azerbaijanis]]) who formed 43.5 percent of the population.<ref>{{Cite book |url=https://www.prlib.ru/item/417322 |title=Кавказский календарь на 1917 год |publisher=Tipografiya kantselyarii Ye.I.V. na Kavkaze, kazenny dom |year=1917 |edition=72nd |location= |publication-place=Tiflis |pages=190–192 |language=Russian |trans-title=Caucasian calendar for 1917 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20211104233151/https://www.prlib.ru/item/417322 |archive-date=4 November 2021}}</ref><ref name="bagdasaryan">{{Cite web |last=Bagdasaryan |first=Gegam |date=March 2015 |title=Три нераскрытых обстоятельства резни армян в Шуши |trans-title=Three unsolved circumstances of the massacre of Armenians in Shushi |url=https://theanalyticon.com/ru/%d0%bd%d0%be%d0%b2%d0%be%d1%81%d1%82%d0%b8/%d1%82%d1%80%d0%b8-%d0%bd%d0%b5%d1%80%d0%b0%d1%81%d0%ba%d1%80%d1%8b%d1%82%d1%8b%d1%85-%d0%be%d0%b1%d1%81%d1%82%d0%be%d1%8f%d1%82%d0%b5%d0%bb%d1%8c%d1%81%d1%82%d0%b2%d0%b0-%d1%80%d0%b5%d0%b7%d0%bd/ |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20221114224058/https://theanalyticon.com/ru/%D0%BD%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%BE%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B8/%D1%82%D1%80%D0%B8-%D0%BD%D0%B5%D1%80%D0%B0%D1%81%D0%BA%D1%80%D1%8B%D1%82%D1%8B%D1%85-%D0%BE%D0%B1%D1%81%D1%82%D0%BE%D1%8F%D1%82%D0%B5%D0%BB%D1%8C%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B2%D0%B0-%D1%80%D0%B5%D0%B7%D0%BD/ |archive-date=14 November 2022 |access-date=15 November 2022 |website=theanalyticon.com |location=Stepanakert |language=ru}}</ref>
-The total death toll of the Shusha massacre remains a matter of debate, with estimates ranging from 500 up to even 30,000 Armenians.<ref>{{cite book|author-last= Smele|author-first= Jonathan|editor-last= Woronoff|editor-first= Jon|editor-link= Jon Woronoff|title= Historical Dictionary of the Russian Civil Wars, 1916-1926|year= 2015|location= Lanham|publisher= [[Rowman & Littlefield]]|page= 137|isbn= 9781442252813|url= https://books.google.com/books?id=QwquCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA137|quote=  Certain Armenian sources cite as high as 30,000 Armenians to account for the deaths across the region over the following days.}}</ref> A conservative estimate by Hovannisian places the death toll of the massacre at 500 Armenians and the destruction of many buildings in Shusha.{{sfn|Hovannisian|1996|p=152}}{{efn|Hovannisian also writes of a "Melkumian report" that claims that 5,000–6,000 were "left behind" during the massacre whilst 8,000 escaped.}} German historian [[Jörg Baberowski]] states that the Armenian quarter of Shusha was "wiped off the face of the earth", indicated by 25 of 1,700 homes surviving the pogrom.<ref name="baberovski">{{Cite book |last=Baberovski |first=Yorg |url=http://test8.dlibrary.org/ru/nodes/1045-vrag-est-vezde-stalinizm-na-kavkaze |title=Враг есть везде. Сталинизм на Кавказе |publisher=Rossiyskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya (ROSSPEN) Fond «Prezidentskiy tsentr B. N. Yeltsina» |year=2010 |isbn=978-5-8243-1435-9 |location=Moscow |pages=171 |language=ru |trans-title=The enemy is everywhere. Stalinism in the Caucasus |author-link=Jörg Baberowski |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20221008172127/http://test8.dlibrary.org/ru/nodes/1045-vrag-est-vezde-stalinizm-na-kavkaze |archive-date=8 October 2022 |url-status=live}}</ref>
+The total death toll of the Shusha massacre remains a matter of debate among historians, with estimates ranging from 500 up to 20,000 Armenians.<ref name= Smele/>{{efn| Certain Armenian sources cite as high as 30,000 Armenians to account for the deaths across the region over the following days.<ref name= Smele/>}} A conservative estimate by Hovannisian places the death toll of the massacre at 500 Armenians and the destruction of many buildings in Shusha.{{sfn|Hovannisian|1996|p=152}}{{efn|Hovannisian also writes of a "Melkumian report" that claims that 5,000–6,000 were "left behind" during the massacre whilst 8,000 escaped.}} German historian [[Jörg Baberowski]] states that the Armenian quarter of Shusha was "wiped off the face of the earth", indicated by 25 of 1,700 homes surviving the pogrom.<ref name="baberovski">{{Cite book |last=Baberovski |first=Yorg |url=http://test8.dlibrary.org/ru/nodes/1045-vrag-est-vezde-stalinizm-na-kavkaze |title=Враг есть везде. Сталинизм на Кавказе |publisher=Rossiyskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya (ROSSPEN) Fond «Prezidentskiy tsentr B. N. Yeltsina» |year=2010 |isbn=978-5-8243-1435-9 |location=Moscow |pages=171 |language=ru |trans-title=The enemy is everywhere. Stalinism in the Caucasus |author-link=Jörg Baberowski |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20221008172127/http://test8.dlibrary.org/ru/nodes/1045-vrag-est-vezde-stalinizm-na-kavkaze |archive-date=8 October 2022 |url-status=live}}</ref>
 Marieta Shahinyan wrote that 3–4 thousand or more than 12 thousand Armenians were killed and 7,000 homes were destroyed in three-days.<ref name=":0">{{Cite web |last= |title=1920 թվականի Շուշիի կոտորածը |trans-title=The Shushi Massacre of 1920 |url=https://republic.mediamax.am/story/100 |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20220719045023/https://republic.mediamax.am/story/100/ |archive-date=19 July 2022 |access-date=19 November 2022 |website=Republic.Mediamax.am |language=hy}}</ref> The ''[[Great Soviet Encyclopedia]]'' entry for Shusha writes that "up to 20 percent of the population [of Shusha] died" when the city was burned.<ref>{{Cite book |url=https://archive.org/details/greatsovietencyc0017unse |title=Great Soviet Encyclopedia |publisher=[[Macmillan Publishers|Macmillan]] |year=1973 |volume=17 |location=New York |pages=301 |language=en}}</ref>