Adolph Rupp won his fourth championship as he led the Kentucky Wildcats to an 84–72 win over the Seattle Chieftains and their star, Elgin Baylor. The starting unit was nicknamed the "Fiddlin' Five," after a quip by Rupp that his team were fiddlers when he really needed violinists. The Wildcats fought back from two 11-point deficits to gain the victory.[3]
Cincinnati'sOscar Robertson became the first player to lead the nation is scoring in his first varsity season. The sophomore (freshmen were ineligible) averaged 35.1 points per game for the Bearcats. He also became the first player to score 50 or more points in an NCAA tournament game when he scored 56 against Arkansas in a regional third-place game on March 15, 1958.[4]
Dom Flora, a senior point guard at Washington and Lee University, finished his college career with 2,310 points and 696 free throws made, both of which were ranked fifth in their respective categories in college basketball history at the end of the 1957–58 season.[5]
Future Hall of Fame coach Howard Cann of NYU retired at the conclusion of the season, after 35 years at the helm.
The NCAA championship game saw the first use of an orange basketball. Previously, the NCAA had used brown basketballs.[4]
Beginning in 1957–58, the following rules changes were implemented:
Offensive goaltending was banned so that no player from either team could touch the ball or basket when the ball was on the basket's rim or above the cylinder. The only exception was the shooter in the original act of shooting.
One free throw for each common foul was taken for the first six personal fouls by one team in each half, and the one-and-one was used thereafter.
On uniforms, the single-digit numbers "1" and "2" and any digit greater than "5" in player numbers were prohibited as a means of simplifying referees' hand signals to the scorer's table when calling a foul. A failure to comply resulted in the assessment of a technical foul against the offending team.[6][7][8] The single-digit numbers "1" and "2" were not permitted again until the 1999–2000 season[9] and digits greater than 5 were not permitted again until the 2023–24 season.[8]
A ball that passes over the backboard – either front-to-back or back-to-front — was considered out of bounds.[10]
The Xavier Musketeers entered the National Invitation Tournament with a 15–11 record, but surprised the field, defeating fellow Ohio school Dayton 78–74 to win the NIT.[28] The Musketeers' Hank Stein was named tournament MVP.
After taking the Chieftains to the NCAA title game, Castellani resigned amid recruiting violations that resulted in a two-year post-season ban for the university.[30]