1979 vote of no confidence in the Callaghan ministry
A vote of no confidence in the British Labour government of James Callaghan occurred on 28 March 1979. The vote was brought by Opposition leader Margaret Thatcher and was lost by the Labour Government by one vote (311 votes to 310), which was announced at 10:19 pm. The result forced a general election which was won by Thatcher's party. The last time an election had been forced by the House of Commons was in 1924, when Ramsay MacDonald, the first Labour Prime Minister, lost a vote of confidence. Labour politician Roy Hattersley later remarked that the vote marked "the last rites" of 'old Labour'. Labour did not return to government for another 18 years. The BBC has referred to the vote as "one of the most dramatic nights in Westminster history".
To date, this is the last occasion on which a British government has lost a vote of confidence.
The general election at the end of February 1974 resulted in a hung parliament where Labour had slightly more seats than any other party but no overall majority. The Conservatives tried to negotiate a coalition with the Liberal Party but failed and Edward Heath's government resigned. Labour came to power in March 1974, its leader Harold Wilson having accepted the Royal invitation to form a minority government. Wilson called a second election for October 1974, which gave Labour a wafer-thin majority of three MPs. The Labour Government implemented pay restraint to control global inflation, coupled with stagnation and unemployment at record post-war levels. Wilson resigned in 1976 in poorer health, on turning 60, and James Callaghan became Leader of the Labour Party and Prime Minister. By-elections and defections whittled away Labour's majority, which technically was non-existent by April 1976 in the House of Commons after a by-election defeat, the defection of two Labour MPs to form the Scottish Labour Party and the defection of backbencher John Stonehouse.
In 1977 the Labour Government and the Liberal Party agreed the Lib-Lab pact by which the Liberals agreed to support the Government in return for pre-legislative consultation. The pact lasted for a year before lapsing in July 1978; at which point the Liberal Party declared that they supported a general election as soon as possible and would therefore support any no confidence motions. Callaghan was widely expected to call an election in September 1978 but decided against this, hoping he would fare better in a year's time once the economy had improved. However the winter saw a prolonged period of industrial unrest known as the Winter of Discontent which severely reduced Labour's popularity. The government survived a motion of no confidence in December 1978 by ten votes after negotiating the support of the Ulster Unionists (draft legislation was before the House to give Northern Ireland more Parliamentary seats; it cleared the House of Commons on 17 January 1979).
On 1 March 1979 a Referendum on the Scotland Act saw a majority vote for devolution, but a threshold imposed by anti-devolution MPs requiring 40% of the electorate to be in favour was not reached due to low turnout. When the Government decided not to implement the Act, the Scottish National Party MPs put down a motion of no confidence. After consulting with the Liberal Party to confirm that they were still supporting motions of no confidence, Leader of the Opposition, Margaret Thatcher put down an Opposition motion which took precedence. The debate was scheduled for Wednesday, 28 March 1979.
Motion and debate
During the debate Callaghan criticised the Scottish National Party, committed to independence for Scotland, for voting with the Conservative Party who opposed devolution. The Scottish National Party would subsequently lose all but two of their seats in the election following the no confidence vote:
"We can truly say that once the Leader of the Opposition discovered what the Liberals and the SNP would do, she found the courage of their convictions. So, tonight, the Conservative Party, which wants the Act repealed and opposes even devolution, will march through the Lobby with the SNP, which wants independence for Scotland, and with the Liberals, who want to keep the Act. What a massive display of unsullied principle! The minority parties have walked into a trap. If they win, there will be a general election. I am told that the current joke going around the House is that it is the first time in recorded history that turkeys have been known to vote for an early Christmas."
As leader of the House of Commons, Michael Foot closed the debate. During his speech he made a widely quoted put-down of Liberal leader David Steel, describing him as having "passed from rising hope to elder statesman without any intervening period whatsoever".
The government lost by one vote. Margaret Thatcher initially believed she had lost the vote after a rough calculation as to the vote's outcome had been made without counting the two Conservative tellers who had counted the votes. Due to the closeness of the vote there is some debate as to whether deals could have been made which would have kept the Government in power. Had the vote been tied, the Speaker of the House of Commons, George Thomas, would probably have followed Speaker Denison's rule and used his casting vote in favour of the status quo and thus against the motion. After the vote Conservative backbenchers cheered and Labour left-wingers sang "The Red Flag".
Vote of no confidence in the Callaghan ministry
Motion proposed by Margaret Thatcher MP
Absolute majority: 315/629
|Aye||Conservative Party (279), Liberal Party (13), Scottish National Party (11), Ulster Unionist Party (5), United Ulster Unionist Party (1), Democratic Unionist Party (1), Independent (1, James Kilfedder)|
311 / 635
|No||Labour Party (287), Labour Co-operative (16), Plaid Cymru (3), Ulster Unionist Party (2), Scottish Labour Party (2)|
310 / 635
|Abstentions||Speaker of the House (1), Labour Party (1, Sir Alfred Broughton), Social Democratic and Labour Party (1, Gerry Fitt), Independent Republican (1, Frank Maguire)|
4 / 635
|Tellers||Labour Party (2), Conservative Party (2); not counted in vote totals|
4 / 635
|Vacant||(6), not counted in vote totals|
6 / 635
Enoch Powell and Ulster Unionists
Before the vote there were some discussions between Labour, the Ulster Unionists and Enoch Powell regarding a deal over a pipeline which would provide cheap energy to Northern Ireland. Callaghan was unwilling to support the proposal due to unhappiness with minority government. There were also discussions about a separate inflation index for Northern Ireland.
Sir Alfred Broughton
One crucial vote was lost by Labour backbencher Sir Alfred Broughton who was unable to attend the vote due to ill health. Broughton (professionally a doctor) was mortally ill and died a few days after the vote but was determined to come to Westminster if it meant saving the Government, although his own doctor was strongly opposed. Parliamentary procedure would have allowed his vote to be counted even if he remained within an ambulance at Speaker's Court. However, after a debate over what would happen if Broughton died en route, Callaghan finally decided that he would not risk Broughton's health by asking him to travel, a decision which was to bring down the Government. Broughton died on 2 April 1979.
Walter Harrison and Bernard Weatherill
In the BBC documentary "A Parliamentary Coup" it was revealed that Bernard Weatherill played a critical role in the defeat of the government in the vote of confidence. As the vote loomed, Labour's deputy Chief Whip, Walter Harrison approached Weatherill to enforce the pairing convention that if a sick MP from the Government could not vote, an MP from the Opposition would abstain to compensate. Weatherill said that pairing had never been intended for votes on Matters of Confidence that meant the life or death of the Government and it would be impossible to find a Conservative MP who would agree to abstain. However, after a moment's reflection, he offered that he himself would abstain, because he felt it would be dishonourable to break his word with Harrison. Harrison was so impressed by Weatherill's offer – which would have effectively ended his political career – that he released Weatherill from his obligation and so the Government fell by one vote on the agreement of gentlemen.
During the last year of the Callaghan government it proposed reinventing the one year Lib-Lab Pact which lapsed in July 1978, to include introducing a Freedom of Information Act, long proposed by the Liberals, although Callaghan himself was opposed to this kind of legislation. When the vote of no confidence came about, Liberal MP Clement Freud, a long-time campaigner for freedom of information, was expected to follow his party and vote with the Opposition. Freud, in Liverpool on the day of the vote, received a phone call from the Prime Minister's Office at 3:00 PM asking for him to miss his train back to London for the 10:00 PM vote of no-confidence. In exchange, a "looser" version of his proposed Freedom of Information Act would be enacted. He declined the offer and voted with his party.
Without Broughton, Labour needed the support of Irish MPs to tie the vote. Gerry Fitt, the leader of the Social Democratic and Labour Party, was sympathetic to the Labour Party and Frank Maguire, an independent republican MP, had supported the government on previous knife-edge votes but were unhappy with proposals that would increase the number of constituencies in Northern Ireland and therefore increase Unionist representation. Fitt eventually decided not to support Labour but that he would campaign for them to be re-elected if they lost. He urged Frank Maguire to do the same. Although not an abstentionist Member of Parliament, Maguire rarely attended the House of Commons. He told a journalist in London before the vote, "I have come over here to abstain in person". The BBC documentary "A Parliamentary Coup" states that Frank Maguire's wife was, unknown to Fitt, sitting in the public gallery of the House of Commons and urged her husband not to vote after hearing Fitt.
When a vote of no confidence is passed, the government must either resign or request a dissolution of Parliament from the monarch. Callaghan called a general election, stating, "We shall take our case to the country." Parliament was not dissolved immediately after the vote: a couple of days' wash-up period was allowed for the completion of uncontroversial business, with 25 bills receiving royal assent on 2 April, including a stopgap Finance Act. The resulting election was won by the Conservative Party and led to 18 years of Conservative rule. After losing, Callaghan remained Labour leader for another year before the succession of Michael Foot.
The Scottish National Party also suffered in the 1979 general election, with its group reduced from 11 members to just two. The incoming Conservative government repealed the Scotland Act and devolution was not enacted until the 1997 referendum, after Labour had returned to power at Westminster.
In popular culture
The 2012 play This House by James Graham depicted the work of the Whips from both the Government and Opposition sides during the period of minuscule and no Labour majorities. It culminated with the vote of no confidence itself.
- Norway Debate, a momentous debate in the House of Commons which led to the appointment of Winston Churchill as Prime Minister
- "Early election as Callaghan defeated". BBC News. 28 March 1979. Archived from the original on 27 June 2009. Retrieved 2 June 2009.
- "Roy Hattersley on the fall of James Callaghan's government". The Observer. Guardian News and Media. 22 March 2009. Retrieved 2 June 2009.
- "The Night the Government Fell". BBC News. 26 March 2009. Retrieved 20 April 2010.
- BBC Politics Summaries – Background to the Vote of No Confidence
- "Hansard, House of Commons, 5th series, vol. 965, col. 589". Hansard.millbanksystems.com. Retrieved 2013-10-02.
- "Hansard, House of Commons, 5th series, vol. 965, col. 471". Hansard.millbanksystems.com. Retrieved 2013-10-02.
- Nelsson, Richard (3 March 2010). "Michael Foot: key quotes". www.guardian.co.uk. Guardian Media Group. Retrieved 18 November 2012.
- Grice, Andrew (4 March 2010). "Michael Foot: More than a politician, a man of deep principle". The Independent. Retrieved 18 November 2012.
- "James Callaghan". Number10.gov.uk. Archived from the original on 3 June 2009. Retrieved 2 June 2009.
- "Kingman Daily Miner - Google News Archive Search". news.google.com. Retrieved 2016-09-20.
- "Service Widows (Provision of Pensions): 28 Mar 1979: House of Commons debates". TheyWorkForYou. Retrieved 2018-03-26.
- "News – Wales News – It could be worse, Gordon. Think of Callaghan in '79". WalesOnline. Retrieved 2 June 2009.
- The Night the Government Fell, BBC archive on the 1979 vote of confidence, audio interview of Weatherill and Harrison
- "Youtube interview with Freud". Youtube.com. Retrieved 2013-10-02.
- Mount, Ferdinand (7 April 1979). "The boycott and the bomb". The Spectator. 242 (7865): 4.
- "The Night the Government Fell". BBC News. 31 March 2009. Retrieved 20 April 2010.
- "HC Deb 04 April 1979 vol 965 c1394". Retrieved 14 November 2014.
- "HC Deb 03 April 1979 vol 965 cc1187-259". Retrieved 14 November 2014.
- "Politics | Obituary: Lord Callaghan". BBC News. 26 March 2005. Retrieved 2 June 2009.
- Black, Andrew (11 January 2012). "Scottish National Party profile". BBC News. BBC. Retrieved 18 November 2012.