2016 Tasmanian energy crisis

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

The 2016 Tasmanian energy crisis was an ongoing energy storage situation in the state of Tasmania, Australia in 2016. Two years of high volumes of energy exported to Victoria via the Basslink HVDC cable, followed by low rainfall, and a fault which rendered the cable inoperable, resulted in record low storage levels in Tasmania's hydro-electric system. This resulted in a number of contingency plans to be enacted by Hydro Tasmania and the Hodgman Government.

Background[edit]

Graph of Hydro Tasmania's system storage levels from March 2010 to March 2016. The blue line represents energy in storage. The green represents the period where the carbon tax was in place, and the red represents the period when Basslink was out of service.

Tasmania's electricity generation is primarily hydro-electric, having been gradually developed since 1914. As a result, the state is highly dependent on rainfall for electricity generation. An energy shortage in the 1960s resulted in the construction of the oil-fired Bell Bay Power Station. However, this station was only used as a contingency - as of 2015, hydro-electricity continued to be the primary generation method.[1] The state was self-reliant until 2005, when the Basslink HVDC interconnector to Victoria was completed. Basslink was intended to both provide energy security, in case of drought; and provide renewable energy to Victoria, which relies heavily on coal as a fuel source.[2]

Tasmania's reliance on hydro-electricity was further increased by the decommissioning of the Bell Bay Power Station in 2009, and the mothballing of several units of its replacement, the gas-fired Tamar Valley Power Station, including considering selling parts of the station.[3] Conversely, this reliance was reduced in part by the expansion of the Woolnorth wind farm in 2007 and the construction of the Musselroe wind farm in 2013.

In July 2012, an Australian carbon pricing system came into effect, providing renewable electricity generators with a competitive advantage over greenhouse gas-emitting generators. The Abbott Government had promised the repeal of the scheme in the lead-up to the 2013 federal election, in which they were successful. Anticipating that the carbon pricing scheme would be short-lived, Hydro Tasmania capitalised by increasing generation and running down storage levels over the period from July 2012 until the carbon price was repealed in July 2014. Hydro Tasmania's storage levels peaked around 62% in late 2012 before declining to 28% capacity on 1 July 2014.[4][5] Whereas Hydro Tasmania's target minimum storage levels on 1 July each year was traditionally 30%, in September 2012 it lowered this target to 25%.[5]

Hydro Tasmania's storages did not recover significantly during the second half of 2014 or 2015, despite above average inflows from May to August 2015. Storage levels began dropping sharply from September 2015 due to extremely low inflows; October inflows were just 7% of the long-term average for that month.[5]

Basslink outage[edit]

On 22 December 2015, Basslink announced[6] that the HVDC cable had experienced a fault two days earlier (20 December) and was unable to transmit electricity in either direction.[7][8] The location of the fault was identified as approximately 100 kilometres (62 mi) off the coast of Tasmania. Basslink informed the Australian Energy Market Operator that the interconnector would experience an outage of up to 60 days.[9]

To diagnose the fault, Basslink contracted a range of specialist companies, including cable joiners from Italy and the submarine cable laying ship, Ile De Re.[10] The ship, which typically services communications cables, underwent modifications in the port of Geelong to suit HVDC cables.[11] The problem continued into February 2016,[10][12] and is considered to be an expensive problem to fix.[13]

On 8 March 2016, Basslink announced they intended to cut the cable within a week and have the cable back in service by late May,[14] with the cable actually being cut on the 11th.[15]

At the end of March 2016, the fault had been identified, and the recovery date for Basslink had been put back to mid June 2016 [16]

By the second last week of April 2016, the first stage of the repair was reported as complete [17] Power through the cable was restored on 13 June 2016.[18] After 9 days a separate non-cable fault caused another failure of power flow on 22 June.[19] After almost 36 hours power flow was again restored in the evening of 23 June 2016.[20]

Response[edit]

Actions taken to minimise the consumption of water from Hydro Tasmania's storages included:

  • Recommissioning of the gas-fired Tamar Valley Power Station
  • Striking agreements with three major industrial customers - Tamar Valley smelters Bell Bay Aluminium and TEMCO, and Norske Skog's papermill at Boyer - to reduce their load by a combined 180 MW[21][22]
  • Deploying up to 200 MW of portable diesel generators[23][24]
  • Bringing Hydro Tasmania's cloud seeding program, usually scheduled to start in May each year, forward by a month[24]

Also at a political level, the unresolved problem seems to have no cross party agreement on the issues.[25] Long term ramifications are also being considered.[26][27][28] The prospect of the Basslink connection being lost permanently also is being considered.[29] The dam makers of the early dam making era of Hydro Tasmania also have offered their reflections[30] with no allowance or concession to any of the alternatives that were offered in the 1980s as viable energy generating infrastructure.

On 8 March 2016 Tasmanian Energy Minister Matthew Groom delivered a statement on energy security, summarising the government's actions to date and announcing future steps to manage the energy crisis, including the formation of a Tasmanian Energy Security Taskforce.[31]

The cutting of the Basslink cable also severed part of the internet link to Tasmania.[32][33][34][35]

The state government had considered requesting funding for a second cable,[36] while the fault seeking on the first cable was apparently unsuccessful.[37] The subsequent comments from the Opposition regarding the growing crisis were rebutted as scaremongering.[38] The energy crisis elicited a response for inquiries and examination of issues, including recent Hydro Tasmania management.[39][40]

Issues of residual capacity[edit]

By March 2016 Tasmanian media were discussing the extent to which Hydro Tasmania would be able to draw upon very low water levels in dams and still create energy from the downstream power stations.[41][42]

In late March 2016, with no resolution to issues in sight,[43][44][45] saw the upgrading of the Tamar Valley Power Station gas turbine capacity [46]

Some commentators saw the crisis as requiring consideration of the issues arising as imperative for the future of Tasmania.[47][48] Some businesses and business groups took steps to safeguard their power supplies regardless of official pronouncements about power cuts.[49] By late March 2016, Hydro Tasmania was to state lower levels on dam holdings than previously stated[50] and the state of the major dam of the system Lake Gordon had been recorded in its lowest record level[51] leading some commentators to suggest the option of bringing up an issue from some decades before, of the draining of the hydro-dam created new Lake Pedder back to the level of the original Lake Pedder.[52]

Energy use[edit]

Concern of change of weather conditions and potential increased energy usage was noted in March [53] with the Minister for Energy Matthew Groom calling for sensible energy usage.[54][55][56]

A series of diesel generators were installed at Meadowbank Power Station, to be part of the apparent short term solution until June.[5][57] The ABC News website explanation of the issue of energy use was regularly updated.[58] In April 2016, Hydro Tasmania commenced advertising for conservation of energy by Tasmanians with newspaper advertisements.[59]

Financial and political impact[edit]

Regardless of the timeline or subsequent resolution of some of the issues, the impact of the crisis, financially and politically, on banks[60] and the Tasmanian government, was expected to be substantial [61][62] However for industry, there were different expectation in relation to power supply for industry.[63]

Outside perspectives and comparisons[edit]

A few commentators from outside Tasmania tried to put perspective on the issues relative to the larger picture of how political and Hydro Tasmania level decisions affected the current energy issues.[64][65][66] Recent Hydro Tasmania board decisions also had been under the spotlight from former staff.[67][68] Many mainland commentators also focus upon the need to change current policies and practices relative to energy.[69]

Blackouts and plans[edit]

It was claimed in early April that:[70]

“active discussions” for more than three months about enforced blackouts and brownouts

However this did not agree with the public statements of the Minister.[71] Various sectors of the Tasmanian community, as well as regions, were concerned at the prospect of loss of energy available to support their industries.[72][73]

The explanation of how the issue developed continued in the media in May 2016,[74] as well as delays due to Bass Strait conditions[75] as well as differences as to the explanation of the cause of the break in Basslink.[76][77] Also rain had raised dam levels.[78][79]

Resolution[edit]

The power crisis was expected to be resolved by the Basslink repair, expected by mid-June 2016,[80] and increased rain for hydro storages. However strategies prior to the resolution involved further utilisation of diesel power units delegated to power stations.[81]

In March 2016 the Minister for Energy stated:[82]

"The Government can't control the rain, the Government can't control the timing of Basslink," he said. "What we can control are contingencies that we can put in place to make sure that we can meet Tasmania's ongoing energy requirements."

In April, there was a suggestion that unseasonal weather in June (18 consecutive clear days on Bass Strait) was required for a successful re-connection to occur, put the question of possible further delays.[83]

On 12 May 2016, the Hydro Tasmania website announced a return to usual practices of hydro facilities:[84]

Over the past week, Hydro Tasmania has stopped all diesel generation and wound back gas to prevent spill in smaller hydro storages because of high inflows. Yesterday, the combined cycle gas turbine (CCGT) at the Tamar Valley Power Station was turned off, as continued high inflows push storages close to spilling at a number of locations.

In the same week, rainfall rates in Tasmania were well above average.[85]

Senate inquiry[edit]

Early in 2016, members of the Australian Senate decided to hold an inquiry into the crisis,[86] planned to occur in April 2016.[87] The Tasmanian Minister for Energy's response to the impending inquiry on 14 April was a claim that he had not been asked to attend.[88] The Premier's perspective was to criticise the inquiry as a federal election tactic, in the face of internal documents showing serious concern from within Hydro Tasmania regarding its water levels.[89][90] The Senate inquiry commenced on 14 April[91] and the Premier advised that Hydro Tasmania staff would not attend:[92]

Mr Groom has said Hydro staff should not be distracted during the energy situation

During the Senate inquiry, a range of issues raised before the committee sat were downplayed by the Minister and government staff.[93] The Tasmanian Treasurer refused to publicly reveal costs of the crisis.[94]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Annual Planning Report, 2015, figure 3-3" (PDF). TasNetworks. Retrieved 25 February 2016. 
  2. ^ Electricity Supply Industry Expert Panel (December 2011). "Basslink: Decision making, expectations and outcomes" (PDF). 
  3. ^ "Tas Government flags partial sale of gas-fired Tamar Valley power station". ABC News. Australia. 4 December 2014. Retrieved 25 February 2016. 
  4. ^ "How much new renewable energy does Tasmania need?". RenewEconomy. 22 February 2016. Retrieved 25 February 2016. 
  5. ^ a b c d "Ministerial Statement on Energy Security". www.premier.tas.gov.au. Retrieved 2016-03-11. 
  6. ^ Basslink interconnector outage, Basslink Media release. 22 December 2015
  7. ^ "Tasmania forced to be self-reliant on power after Basslink cable outage". Basslink is planning a major operation to repair its undersea power cable which has been shut down, halting power imports to Tasmania. ABC News. 23 December 2015. Retrieved 1 April 2016. 
  8. ^ Martin, Corey (22 December 2015). "Fault found in Basslink electricity cable". Basslink has been advised that there has been no impact to Tasmanian or Victorian residential or commercial customers to date as a result of this outage,” Mr Eccles said. Fairfax Media. The Examiner. Retrieved 1 April 2016. 
  9. ^ "Busted: Basslink out of action". The Examiner. 22 December 2015. Retrieved 26 February 2016. 
  10. ^ a b "Basslink still searching for cable fault". ITNews. 28 January 2016. Retrieved 26 February 2016. 
  11. ^ "Repairs to start on Basslink power cable". The Examiner (Tasmania). 27 January 2016. Retrieved 26 February 2016. 
  12. ^ "Tasmania power crises may worsen". ABC News (Australia). 25 February 2016. Retrieved 25 February 2016. 
  13. ^ "Tasmania's energy crisis explained". ABC News. Australia. 23 February 2016. Retrieved 26 February 2016. 
  14. ^ "Basslink homes in on underwater cable fault". ABC News. Australia. 8 March 2016. Retrieved 8 March 2016. 
  15. ^ "Basslink repairs hit internet users in Tasmania". ABC News. Australia. 11 March 2016. Retrieved 15 March 2016. 
  16. ^ "Basslink pinpoints fault in undersea power cable linking Tasmania to mainland Australia". ABC News. Australia. 29 March 2016. Retrieved 15 July 2016. 
  17. ^ "Basslink repair 'on track' and should be completed on schedule, Energy Minister says". ABC News. Australia. 22 April 2016. Retrieved 15 July 2016. 
  18. ^ "Electricity flow between Tasmania and Victoria restored". ABC News. Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC). 13 June 2016. Retrieved 29 July 2016. 
  19. ^ "Basslink confirms fresh outage days after service resumes". ABC News. ABC-Australia. 22 June 2016. Retrieved 29 July 2016. 
  20. ^ "Basslink running again after 'mechanical failure' caused outage". ABC News. (ABC-Australia). 23 June 2016. Retrieved 29 July 2016. 
  21. ^ "Another big industrial trims demand as Tasmania energy crisis deepens". RenewEconomy. 1 March 2016. Retrieved 8 March 2016. 
  22. ^ "Power rationing". ABC News. Australia. 23 February 2016. Retrieved 7 March 2016. 
  23. ^ "Environmental watchdog fast tracks diesel generators". ABC News. Australia. 4 March 2016. Retrieved 7 March 2016. 
  24. ^ a b "Tasmania battles to keep lights on with cloud seeding and diesel generators". The Examiner (Tasmania). 4 March 2016. Retrieved 7 March 2016. 
  25. ^ "Energy Minister set for grilling". ABC News. Australia. 23 February 2016. Retrieved 7 March 2016. 
  26. ^ "Tasmanian frontbencher Matthew Groom". ABC News. Australia. 22 February 2016. Retrieved 7 March 2016. 
  27. ^ "Hydro Tasmania in uncharted territory". ABC News. Australia. 7 March 2016. Retrieved 7 March 2016. 
  28. ^ "Tasmanian government considers long term loss of Basslink cable". ABC News. Australia. 23 February 2016. Retrieved 7 March 2016. 
  29. ^ "Category". The Mercury. 2016-04-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  30. ^ "Talking ponit: Blocked dam would have added security". The Mercury. 2016-04-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  31. ^ "Ministerial Statement on Energy Security". www.premier.tas.gov.au. Retrieved 2016-03-09. 
  32. ^ "Basslink repairs hit internet users in Tasmania". ABC News. Australia. 12 March 2016. Retrieved 12 March 2016. 
  33. ^ "Tasmanian internet problems: ISPs secure extra bandwidth amid Basslink repairs". ABC News. Australia. 2016-03-13. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  34. ^ "Basslink repairs: ACCC to look into concerns about ISP access to Telstra cables". ABC News. Australia. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  35. ^ "Basslink repairs: Bryan Green calls for ACCC investigation as internet disruptions continue". ABC News. Australia. 2016-03-13. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  36. ^ "Tasmanian energy crisis: State Government seeks federal funding for second Basslink cable". ABC News. Australia. 2016-03-09. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  37. ^ McIntyre, Damian (15 March 2016). "Tasmania energy crisis: Basslink still unsure where cable fault is, facing 'phenomenal' repair costs". Repair crews are still unsure where the fault in Tasmania's vital undersea cable is days after cutting it, Basslink chief executive Malcolm Eccles says. ABC News. Retrieved 1 April 2016. 
  38. ^ Hunt, Linda (15 March 2016). "Tasmanian Opposition accused of scaremongering over energy crisis". Tasmania's Energy Minister has accused the Opposition of scaremongering over the state's energy crisis, saying rain will eventually ease the situation. Australia. ABC News. Retrieved 1 April 2016. 
  39. ^ "Talknig point: Hydro water assets badly managed and heads need to roll". The Mercury. 2016-04-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  40. ^ "Talking point: Energy security crisis has its roots in Basslink business case". The Mercury. 2016-04-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  41. ^ "Lake Gordon available for power generation despite record low water levels Hydro Tasmania says". ABC News. Australia. 2016-03-24. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  42. ^ "Tasmanian energy crisis: Hydro Tasmania in uncharted territory as dam levels continue to drop". ABC News. Australia. 2016-03-07. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  43. ^ "Hydro Tasmania staff preparing their homes for 24-hour blackouts, union says". ABC News. Australia. 22 March 2016. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  44. ^ "Tasmanian energy crisis: CSIRO buys generators to protect critical facilities against power restrictions". ABC News. Australia. 2016-03-23. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  45. ^ "Tasmania's Energy Crisis : Keep Calm And Carry On". Energy Matters. 2016-03-25. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  46. ^ Papadopoulos, Toli (2016-03-26). "Tamar gas turbine to address energy crisis". The Examiner. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  47. ^ "Talking Point: New ideas needed in energy crisis". The Mercury. 2016-04-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  48. ^ Rayner, Tristan (2016-03-24). "Tasmania looks pretty f-cked: Here's why". Techly. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  49. ^ "Businesses preparing power cut plans". News.com.au. 2016-03-24. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  50. ^ "Energy crisis: Hydro Tasmania warns dam levels to drop lower than predicted". ABC News. Australia. 30 March 2016. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  51. ^ "Tasmanian energy crisis: Lake Gordon dam level fall captured in dramatic video". ABC News. Australia. 2016-03-31. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  52. ^ "Prospect of tapping Lake Pedder for water prompts calls for it to be restored to pre-flood state". ABC News. Australia. 2016-02-28. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  53. ^ "Tasmanian energy use campaign urged ahead of winter". ABC News. Australia. 2016-03-24. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  54. ^ Burgess, Georgie (2016-03-29). "Groom calls for 'sensible' energy use". The Examiner. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  55. ^ "Talking Point: Uncertainty is the most certain factor in Tasmania's energy crisis". The Mercury. 2016-04-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  56. ^ Sayer, Luke (2016-03-29). "Last one out can just forget about the lights". The Advocate. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  57. ^ Battersby, Lucy (2016-03-30). "Tasmania relying on 150 diesel generators for electricity until June". The Advocate. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  58. ^ "Tasmania power crisis: Avoiding shortages will be costly, experts say". ABC News. Australia. 23 February 2016. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  59. ^ "Tasmanian Government encourages consumers to save energy, help conserve water in dams". ABC News. Australia. 2 April 2016. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  60. ^ "Banks feel the heat of Tassies cable capers". The Australian. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  61. ^ "Talking Point: Hydro's mounting money woes will king-hit state coffers". The Mercury. 2016-04-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  62. ^ "Talking Point: Uncanny sense of deja vu". The Mercury. 2016-04-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  63. ^ "Tasmanian energy crisis: Major industry unlikely to be left in lurch, expert says". ABC News. Australia. 2016-04-01. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  64. ^ "How Tasmania missed its nine key energy targets". Renew Economy. 2016-03-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  65. ^ "Tasmania battles to keep lights on with cloud-seeding and diesel generators". The Age. 2016-03-07. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  66. ^ "Talking point: Opportunity knocks for power". The Mercury. 2016-04-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  67. ^ "Hydro's decisions attacked". The Examiner. 2016-01-19. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  68. ^ "Hydro Tasmania's performance leaks". The Examiner. 2016-01-19. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  69. ^ "Tasmania's power crisis should galvanise change". The Australian. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  70. ^ "Tasmanian Labor reveals power blackout plans". The Mercury. 2016-04-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  71. ^ "Hydro dam levels plummet but minister says small households don't need to ration power". The Mercury. 2016-04-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  72. ^ "Tasmanian farmers calm in face of state's energy woes - ABC Rural (Australian Broadcasting Corporation)". Abc.net.au. 2016-04-07. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  73. ^ "North-west Tasmanian businesses urged to be prepared for potential power cuts". ABC News. Australia. 2016-03-31. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  74. ^ "Tasmania's power crisis". The Saturday Paper. 2016-04-30. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  75. ^ "Basslink repair delayed by wild weather, but expected completion date remains mid-June". ABC News. Australia. 3 May 2016. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  76. ^ "Basslink repairs: UK tests fail to pinpoint cause of cable's December failure". ABC News. Australia. 2016-05-10. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  77. ^ "Basslink and Groom at odds after tests on faulty cable prove inconclusive". ABC News. Australia. 2016-05-10. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  78. ^ Langenberg, Adam (2016-05-09). "Boost to energy levels". The Advocate. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  79. ^ Gurra, Bianca (2016-05-09). "Abnormally high tides and wet week forecast for Tasmania". ABC News. Australia. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  80. ^ "Tasmania's electricity crisis won't be over until June". Financial Review. Australia. 2016-03-08. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  81. ^ Gramenz, Emilie (1 April 2016). "Tasmanian energy crisis: More diesel generators fired up to boost power grid". Hydro Tasmania has almost completed rolling out the first tranche of diesel generators to boost generation capacity, as the state's energy crisis deepens. ABC News. Retrieved 1 April 2016. 
  82. ^ "Tasmania basslink power crisis: Matthew Groom aims to boost gas, form taskforce to solve energy woes". ABC News. Australia. 2016-03-08. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  83. ^ Reichert, Corinne (2016-04-15). "Basslink subsea cable repairs rely on 18 days of clear weather". ZDNet.com. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  84. ^ "Tasmania currently completely renewable | Hydro Tasmania". Hydro.com.au. 2016-05-12. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  85. ^ "Tasmania's dam catchment areas get a month of rain in a fortnight". ABC News. Australia. 2016-05-13. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  86. ^ "Tasmanian energy crisis: Labor, Greens want Senate inquiry". ABC News. Australia. 13 March 2016. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  87. ^ "Tasmanian energy crisis: Senate inquiry to have first hearing mid-April". ABC News. Australia. 2016-04-02. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  88. ^ "Senate probe into Tasmania's power crisis faces short-circuit by Energy Minister Matthew Groom". The Mercury. 2016-04-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  89. ^ Humphries, Alexandra (2016-04-03). "Dam levels 'risk extreme'". The Examiner. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  90. ^ "Tasmanian energy crisis: Labor keeps up pressure on State Government, calling for dam level data". ABC News. Australia. 2016-04-03. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  91. ^ "Tasmanian energy: Greens declare generators an 'environmental crisis' as inquiry begins". ABC News. Australia. 2016-04-14. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  92. ^ Burgess, Georgie (2016-04-13). "Turbine due for winter repairs". The Examiner. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  93. ^ "Power crisis: Energy Minister downplays Hydro Tasmania committee documents on Basslink cable failure". ABC News. Australia. 2016-04-20. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 
  94. ^ "Tasmanian energy crisis: Treasurer Peter Gutwein refuses to reveal power bill costs". ABC News. Australia. 16 April 2016. Retrieved 2016-07-15. 

External links[edit]