Jump to content

Welfare colonialism

Edit links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by OAbot (talk | contribs) at 06:38, 15 August 2023 (Open access bot: doi updated in citation with #oabot.). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Welfare colonialism is a form of colonialism where investments by the colonizer in the native population, ostensibly intended to improve their quality of life, contribute to the dissolution of indigenous institutions thus perpetuating dependency and creating a permanent underclass. Though usage of the term dates from the 1950s,[1] the concept is often associated with anthropologist Robert Paine, who expanded and developed it while observing the failed economic integration of the native population in Northern Canada.[2] In welfare colonialism, subjugated peoples typically remain impoverished despite huge sums invested nominally for their welfare while their standard of living declines.[3] The concept has been used to explain the ongoing poverty and low living standards of native populations in many countries, particularly those that that have been subject to settler colonialism.

Features

Logo of the Australian Aboriginal Progressive Association, formed to combat policies associated with Welfare Colonialism.

The features of welfare colonialism are:[4]

  1. A reversal of the traditional colonial model, so that funds flow from the colonizer to the native population rather than the reverse; these funds support development of the social institutions of the colonizer in native communities.
  2. Forced integration of the native population into the society of the colonizer in ways that radically undermine traditional livelihoods and social structures;
  3. Attempts to remedy the resulting social disintegration of the native population through welfare, unemployment and other systems of benefits, as well as introducing the colonizer’s education, health and housing systems which further erode traditional native society.

According to anthropologist Robert Paine,[4]

"Welfare colonialism identifies welfare as the vehicle for stable 'governing at a distance' through exercise of a particularly subtle, 'non-demonstrative' and dependency-generating form of neocolonial social control that preempts local autonomy through 'well-intentioned' and 'generous', but ultimately 'morally wrong', policies. Welfare colonialism creates paralyzing dependencies on the 'centre' in a peripheral population, a centre exerting control through incentives that create total economic dependency, thereby preventing political mobilization and autonomy."

Examples

Canada

Much of the work on welfare colonialism is based on the experience of the Inuit in the 1960's and 70's as the Canadian government sought to simultaneously engage, control and support native communities, a change from prior policies of forced relocation and residential schools.[5] Though the new policies involved the community in policymaking, it was clear to both government representatives and native leaders that the old relationship of colonizer to subject was still in effect, in particular the overhanging notion of 'civilizing' and 'Canadianizing' the Inuit.[6] Teachers, nurses and counselors sent to Inuit communities were trained in Canadian, not native, institutions and frequently had little awareness of Inuit language and traditions, leading to detrimental outcomes.[7]

Some social welfare and health issues which colonial culture typically sees as medical problems are, in indigenous communities, more successfully addressed through non-medical responses involving the community as a whole. Youth suicide and alcoholism in indigenous communities are examples of issues where substantial investments by the colonial government to replicate treatments used in their society have not yielded favorable results while community responses based on traditional structures and practices have been more effective.[8]

United States

The term Welfare Colonialism was used to critique Great Society anti-poverty programs in the 1960's and 70's,[9] often by community activists though also by government officials charged with implementing these programs.[10] Welfare colonialism in this context often referred specifically to the introduction of social workers and other professionals from outside the community rather than to the creation of new colonial institutions.[11][12]

Relatively little has been written about the role Welfare Colonialism played in the debasement of Native American tribal institutions and by extension their quality of life. Two studies have been published on the Seminole tribe.[13][14] More attention has been paid to the ways in which provision of medical care to native communities in Alaska has been undercut by a lack of awareness as to how the communities actually operate, which can exacerbate life-threatening conditions such as youth suicide[15]

Australia

In Australia, aboriginal people have long been subjected to forms of welfare colonialism. Although granted full citizenship in 1962,[16] Aboriginal people often live in circumstances described as 'shocking'[17] despite the investment of hundreds of millions of dollars in efforts to promote their welfare. Understanding why this investment had so little effect on Aboriginal quality of life is a major issue for Australian policymakers. According to anthropologist Nicolas Peterson, "the concept that both addresses this problem directly and proposes an explanation is that of welfare colonialism. The central proposition of welfare colonialism is that the granting of the social rights of citizenship to indigenous people in first world nation-states is, unintentionally, as debilitating as it is beneficial because of the social and political dependencies it creates."[3]

Anthropologist Jeremy Beckett spent decades working with the Torres Strait Islanders, an aboriginal group,[18] and observed that "another contradictory feature of welfare colonialism is its need to secure the assent of the subjects as evidence of their political enfranchisement ... Ironically, the subjects are often so politically weak and fragmented that the state itself is obliged to create channels of political expression and articulate indigenous' aspirations. In other words, political incorporation of the indigenous minority within the nation state can be effected only through special structures, which institutionalize colonial distinctions, while creating a political constituency which has to be simultaneously maintained and controlled."[19] This closely mirrors the experiences of the Inuit, supporting the contention that this phenomenon is not unique but rather a recognizable facet of colonialism worldwide.

Investments by the colonizer in native communities in colonies without substantial settler populations can be referred to as Development Colonialism. Development Colonialism focuses not on improving the health and welfare of the native population directly but rather on large-scale infrastructure projects such as electrification and road-building.[20] These activities are often undertaken in advance of decolonization, such as in areas of Africa following the Second World War.[21]

See also

References

  1. ^ Bradley, C. Paul (1965). Welfare colonialism in the British West Indies; a study of development and welfare policy, 1938-1954. pp. 1–12. OCLC 1323009481.
  2. ^ Paine, Robert (1977). The White Arctic : anthropological essays on tutelage and ethnicity. Institute of Social and Economic Research, Memorial University of Newfoundland. pp. 7–29. ISBN 0-919666-14-0. OCLC 6199973.
  3. ^ a b Peterson, Nicolas (1998). "Welfare Colonialism and Citizenship: Politics, Economics and Agency". In Peterson, Nicolas; Sanders, Will (eds.). Citizenship and Indigenous Australians: Changing Conceptions and Possibilities. Reshaping Australian Institutions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 101–117. doi:10.1017/cbo9780511552243.006. ISBN 978-0-521-62736-8.
  4. ^ a b "Development and Social Goals: Balancing Aid and Development to Prevent 'Welfare Colonialism'". UN DESA Publications. Retrieved 2022-12-26.
  5. ^ "Inuit | The Canadian Encyclopedia". www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca. Retrieved 2022-12-27.
  6. ^ PAINE, Robert (1977). "The Nursery Game: Colonizers and Colonized in the Canadian Arctic". Études/Inuit/Studies. 1 (1): 5–32. JSTOR 42869250.
  7. ^ Weissling, Lee E. (1989). "Arctic Canada and Zambia: A Comparison of Development Processes in the Fourth and Third Worlds". Arctic. 42 (3): 208–216. doi:10.14430/arctic1659. JSTOR 40510822.
  8. ^ O'Neil, John D. (1981). "Beyond Healers and patients: The emergence of local responsibility in Inuit Health care". Études/Inuit/Studies. 5 (1): 17–26. JSTOR 42870505.
  9. ^ Silberman, Charles E. (1968). Crisis in black and white. Random. pp. 308–356. OCLC 9878686.
  10. ^ "2 U.S. AIDES BACK SOCIAL PROTESTS; Wirtz and Katzenbach Say Antipoverty Agencies Help 'Get Something Done'". The New York Times. 19 November 1964. ProQuest 115924078.
  11. ^ Gilbert, Gwendolyn C. (1974-12-01). "The Role of Social Work in Black Liberation". The Black Scholar. 6 (4): 16–23. doi:10.1080/00064246.1974.11431481.
  12. ^ Berry, Margaret E. (1989). "Confrontation at the National Conference on Social Welfare". Social Service Review. 63 (4): 630–656. doi:10.1086/603731. JSTOR 30012055. S2CID 143222842.
  13. ^ Cattelino, Jessica (July 2006). "Florida Seminole Housing and the Social Meanings of Sovereignty". Comparative Studies in Society and History. 48 (3): 699–726. doi:10.1017/S0010417506000272. S2CID 145461460. ProQuest 212680875.
  14. ^ Cattelino, Jessica R. (2009). "Fungibility: Florida Seminole Casino Dividends and the Fiscal Politics of Indigeneity". American Anthropologist. 111 (2): 190–200. doi:10.1111/j.1548-1433.2009.01112.x. JSTOR 40300821.
  15. ^ Wexler, Lisa (March 2011). "Behavioral Health Services 'Don't Work for Us': Cultural Incongruities in Human Service Systems for Alaska Native Communities". American Journal of Community Psychology. 47 (1–2): 157–169. doi:10.1007/s10464-010-9380-3. PMID 21052820. S2CID 3422338.
  16. ^ Coral, Dow (May 10, 2011). "Overview of Indigenous Affairs: Part 1: 1901 to 1991". www.aph.gov.au. Retrieved 2022-12-26.
  17. ^ "Face the facts: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples | Australian Human Rights Commission". humanrights.gov.au. Retrieved 2022-12-26.
  18. ^ "Honorary Life Members - Australian Anthropological Society". www.aas.asn.au. Retrieved 2022-12-27.
  19. ^ Beckett, Jeremy (1988). "Aboriginality, Citizenship and Nation State". Social Analysis (24): 3–18. JSTOR 23169647.
  20. ^ van der Straeten, Jonas; Hasenöhrl, Ute (December 2016). "Connecting the Empire: New Research Perspectives on Infrastructures and the Environment in the (Post)Colonial World". NTM Zeitschrift für Geschichte der Wissenschaften, Technik und Medizin. 24 (4): 355–391. doi:10.1007/s00048-017-0162-y. PMID 28251245. S2CID 253636828.
  21. ^ Cooper, Frederick (2002). Africa since 1940 : the past of the present. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press. pp. 91–132. ISBN 0-521-77241-9. OCLC 47930687.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Welfare_colonialism&oldid=1170469162"