|Long title||A bill to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide that persons renouncing citizenship for a substantial tax avoidance purpose shall be subject to tax and withholding on capital gains, to provide that such persons shall not be admissible to the United States, and for other purposes.|
|Acronyms (colloquial)||Ex-PATRIOT Act|
The Ex-PATRIOT Act was a proposed United States federal law to raise taxes and impose entry bans on certain former citizens and departing permanent residents. The law would automatically classify all people who lost citizenship or permanent residence in the decade prior to the law's passage or any future year as having "tax avoidance intent" if they met certain asset or tax liability thresholds or had failed to file any required federal tax forms within the preceding five years. People determined to have "tax avoidance intent", referred to in the text of the law as specified expatriates, would be affected in two ways. First, they would have to pay 30% capital gains tax on any U.S. property sold after the law's enactment. Second, they would be barred from re-entry into the U.S. either under immigrant or non-immigrant categories.
The Ex-PATRIOT Act was first introduced as S. 3205 in the 112th Congress in 2012 by Senator Chuck Schumer and four co-sponsors, but died in committee. Schumer and two other senators moved similar provisions in the 113th Congress as Senate Amendment 1252 to a major immigration reform bill, but their amendment was not included in the version of the bill that passed the Senate.
The short title of the Ex-PATRIOT Act is a backronym for "Expatriation Prevention by Abolishing Tax-Related Incentives for Offshore Tenancy Act". The long title of the Ex-PATRIOT Act as given in its Section 1 is:
- A bill to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide that persons renouncing citizenship for a substantial tax avoidance purpose shall be subject to tax and withholding on capital gains, to provide that such persons shall not be admissible to the United States, and for other purposes.
It was sponsored by Chuck Schumer (D-New York) with initial co-sponsors Bob Casey, Jr. (D-Pennsylvania), Richard Blumenthal (D-Connecticut), and Tom Harkin (D-Iowa). It was introduced on May 17, 2012 and referred to the Senate Committee on Finance, of which Schumer is a member (on the Subcommittee on Taxation and IRS Oversight, among other subcommittees). Schumer's fellow Subcommittee on Taxation and IRS Oversight member Ben Cardin (D-Maryland) joined as an additional co-sponsor on May 23.
The introduction of the Ex-PATRIOT Act was motivated by the news that Facebook co-founder Eduardo Saverin had renounced his U.S. citizenship. Saverin, a native of Brazil, lived in the U.S. from 1992 to 2009 before moving to Singapore. While living in Singapore, he continued to pay U.S. taxes, as the U.S. is one of the only countries which imposes tax on non-resident citizens. In January 2011, he began the procedure to renounce U.S. citizenship in favor of retaining his existing Brazilian citizenship; he did not apply to take up Singaporean citizenship. His loss of citizenship was effective from September 2011. On April 30, 2012, his name was published in the Quarterly Publication of Individuals Who Have Chosen to Expatriate in the Federal Register as required by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996. The story was reported in Bloomberg Businessweek and other news outlets roughly ten days later. The Ex-PATRIOT Act bill received additional coverage in July 2012 when it was revealed that singer-songwriter Denise Rich had renounced her citizenship as well. However the Senate Committee on Finance did not take any action on the bill by the end of the session.
On June 12, 2013, Casey moved Senate Amendment 1252 to the Border Security, Economic Opportunity, and Immigration Modernization Act of 2013, a major immigration reform bill. His co-sponsors for the amendment were Schumer and Jack Reed (D-RI). The text of the amendment was identical to that of Schumer's Ex-PATRIOT Act the previous year. In a press release about the amendment, Reed stated, "American citizenship is a privilege. But it seems that a privileged few are trying to game the system by accumulating wealth and benefiting from the greatness of the United States and then renouncing their citizenship to avoid paying their fair share of taxes. They are welcome to leave our country, but they should not be welcomed to return without playing by the rules and paying what they owe." The immigration reform bill passed the Senate on June 27, 2013 without the inclusion of Casey's amendment.
Under current law, expatriation tax on "covered expatriates". The term "covered expatriates" is defined in as former citizens or long-term residents whose world-wide assets exceeded $2 million, whose five-year average tax liability exceeded $148,000, or who could not certify that they complied with their U.S. tax obligations for the five years preceding their loss of citizenship. The tax is equivalent to the 15% capital gains tax that would be paid on a sale at the marked-to-market value of all of the former citizen's property. When Saverin renounced, he had to pay that expatriation tax. Going forward, under existing law he receives similar treatment to other non-resident aliens: he is exempt from U.S. capital gains tax on U.S. investments, but is subject to a 30% withholding tax on U.S.-source dividends and interest payments. He is no longer subject to U.S. gift or estate taxes; however, 26 U.S.C. § 2801 imposes an equivalent inheritance tax on U.S. citizen or U.S. resident heirs of covered expatriates.imposes an
Since 1996, INA § 212(a)(10)(E) (commonly known as the Reed Amendment) makes former citizens inadmissible to the United States if the Attorney General determines that they gave up citizenship to avoid taxation; however, it has never been enforced because the Attorney General is not empowered to obtain the required information in order to make that determination. There was speculation that the Reed Amendment might be enforced against Saverin, and Reed Amendment author Senator Jack Reed (D-Rhode Island) wrote to Secretary of Homeland Security Janet Napolitano to urge that Saverin be barred from entering to the United States; however, Schumer stated that the Reed Amendment lacked an enforcement mechanism, and that his newly proposed Ex-PATRIOT Act was necessary to remedy this.
Section 3 of the Ex-PATRIOT Act amends INA § 212(a)(10)(E), striking the whole text of the Reed Amendment and replacing it. The new clause (i) makes "specified expatriates" inadmissible. The new clause (iii) requires the Secretary of Treasury to notify the Secretary of State and the Secretary of Homeland Security of the name of each "covered expatriate" who has been determined not to be a "specified expatriate". Section 3 of the Ex-PATRIOT Act also amends INA § 212(d)(3) to make the Secretary of Homeland Security and not the Attorney General responsible for processing waivers of inadmissibility for "specified expatriates" seeking admission to the U.S. as non-immigrants.
Senator Orrin Hatch (R-Utah), who was at the time the ranking minority member of the Senate Committee on Finance, stated in an interview that while he was unfamiliar with Schumer's proposed legislation, "[i]t always bothers me when somebody renounces his citizenship in the greatest country on Earth just to save money, save taxes ... I was really upset at Eduardo Saverin for doing that, and there are others who are doing it too." House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) described Saverin's action as "absolutely outrageous" and spoke favorably of the concept of Schumer's bill, but also stated that existing legislation should be sufficient to punish Saverin. In contrast, Ron Paul (R-Texas) expressed opposition to the Ex-PATRIOT Act, stating that it "will ensnare many ordinary middle-class Americans" due to inflation and that "control[ling] people by controlling their capital ... has no place in a free society".
Yale Law School professor Bruce Ackerman wrote an op-ed in the Los Angeles Times supporting the Ex-PATRIOT Act, stating that former citizens "should be allowed to return only under exceptional circumstances ... [T]hey either remain Americans or they repudiate their homeland forever". Matthew Yglesias wrote in Slate that the proposal "seems very reasonable", though he also parodied the more extreme reactions to Saverin's renunciation with a "modest proposal" that former citizens should be subject to targeted killing by drone attacks. Columnist Ruben Navarette also criticized Saverin for his "cavalier" renunciation while "hundreds of thousands of undocumented DREAM Act students" suffered due to their own lack of U.S. citizenship.
Conor Friedersdorf, writing in The Atlantic, stated that "it is imprudent to impulsively introduce legislation in order to target a specific high profile individual who happens to be making news, especially when doing so punishes him in a way he couldn't have anticipated for doing something that was legal. Anyone who doesn't grok that much philosophy of law doesn't deserve to be in Congress." Americans for Tax Reform president Grover Norquist spoke out against the Ex-PATRIOT Act in stronger terms, comparing it to Nazi Germany's Reich Flight Tax and East Germany's treatment of emigrants. Canadian theologian Peter W. Dunn, himself a former U.S. citizen, argued in the American Thinker that the Ex-PATRIOT Act's imposition of a form of exile on Saverin would violate the Universal Declaration of Human Rights' guarantee that everyone has the right to change his or her nationality, as well as the Expatriation Act of 1868. Schumer responded angrily to the criticism by Forbes, the American Thinker, the National Review, Norquist, and others in a speech on the Senate floor on May 24, 2012.
Saverin himself issued a statement through his spokesman Tom Goodman stating that he was "obligated to and will pay hundreds of millions of dollars in taxes to the United States government" and that he felt it was "unfortunate that my personal choice has led to a public debate, based not on the facts but entirely on speculation and misinformation".
- "Schumer, Casey announce plan to stop Facebook Co-Founder from dodging taxes by dropping U.S. citizenship". schumer.senate.gov. 2012-05-17. Retrieved 2012-05-18.
- "Two senators want to stop Facebook's Saverin from dodging taxes". Los Angeles Times. May 18, 2012. Retrieved 2012-05-21.
- "With the Facebook IPO, missing Eduardo Saverin". Washington Post. May 18, 2012. Retrieved 2012-05-21.
- "Senators unveil 'Ex-Patriot Act' for tax dodgers". UPI. May 17, 2012. Retrieved 2012-05-22.
- Casey, Robert P., Jr.; Schumer, Charles E.; Reed, Jack (2013-06-12). "S.AMDT.1252". Library of Congress THOMAS. Retrieved 2013-06-14.
- Godfrey, Mike (2013-06-19). "Law to Exclude US Ex-Citizens Judged To Have Avoided Tax". Global Tax news. Retrieved 2013-06-19.
- "Bill Summary & Status, 113th Congress (2013 - 2014): S.744". THOMAS. 2013-06-27. Retrieved 2013-06-29.
- "Bill Summary & Status, 112th Congress (2011 - 2012): S.3205". THOMAS. 2012-05-18. Retrieved 2012-05-21.
- Miller, Sunlen (2012-05-17). "Senators to Unveil the 'Ex-Patriot Act' to Respond to Facebook's Saverin's Tax 'Scheme'". ABC News. Retrieved 2012-05-18.
- Kucera, Danielle; Vallikappen, Sanat; Harper, Christine (2012-05-11). "Facebook Co-Founder Saverin Gives Up U.S. Citizenship Before IPO". Bloomberg. Retrieved 2012-05-11.
- Dunn, Stephen J. (2012-05-20). "Relinquishing U.S. Citizenship". Forbes. Retrieved 2012-05-21.
- "Saverin 'has no plans to become S'pore citizen'" (PDF). Today. 2012-05-17. Retrieved 2012-05-17.
- Internal Revenue Service (30 April 2012). "Quarterly Publication of Individuals, Who Have Chosen to Expatriate, as Required by Section 6039G". Federal Register.
- Kim, Susanna (2012-07-09). "Socialite-Songwriter Denise Rich Renounces Citizenship". ABC News. Retrieved 2013-01-04.
- Moffett, Dan (2012-07-17). "Congress Legislation Cracks Down on ex-Americans". immigration.about.com. Retrieved 2013-01-04.
- Hässig, Lukas (2013-06-25). "USA verbannen ihre eigenen Bürger (USA bans its own citizens)". 20 Minutes. Retrieved 2013-06-25.
- "Reed Offers Amendment to Prevent Ex-Citizen Tax Dodgers from Reentering the U.S.". reed.senate.gov. 2013-06-12. Retrieved 2013-06-14.
- "So How Much Did He Really Save". The Wall Street Journal. 2012-05-18. Retrieved 2012-05-21.
- Katzenstein, Andrew M.; Bowman, Scott A. (2012-05-25). "Facebook’s Saverin Left U.S. as a Taxpayer, Not a Traitor". Bloomberg News. Retrieved 2012-05-25.
- Bruce, Charles M.; Saret, Lewis; Lagonico, Stéphane; Trow, Steve (2006-03-13). "The Exit Tax — A Perfectly Bad Idea" (PDF). Tax Notes International 41 (10). Retrieved 2012-05-18.
- Hunter, Kathleen (2012-05-18). "Schumer Proposes Tax On People Like Facebook’s Saverin". Bloomberg News. Retrieved 2012-05-21.
- Stoll, Ira (2012-05-22). "Schumer’s Bid To Tax a Founder of Facebook Ignites Discussion of a Law Used by Nazis". The New York Sun. Retrieved 2012-05-22.
- Cohn, Alicia M. (2012-05-20). "Boehner: New law to punish tax-dodgers for renouncing citizenship 'unnecessary'". The Hill. Retrieved 2012-05-22.
- "The Egregious Ex-Patriot Act Has No Place in a Free Society". Ron Paul's Texas Straight Talk. 2012-05-28. Retrieved 2012-05-28.
- Ackerman, Brucke (2012-05-16). "Payback for a Facebook tax refugee". Log Angeles Times. Retrieved 2012-05-21.
- Yglesias, Matthew (2012-05-17). "Use Drones to Halt Tax Expatriation". Slate. Retrieved 2012-05-21.
- Navarrette, Ruben (2012-05-20). "The 'price' of citizenship". Washington Post. Retrieved 2012-05-28.
- "Why the Ex-Patriot Act Is a Creepy Law". The Atlantic. May 18, 2012. Retrieved 2012-05-21.
- Becker, Bernie; Wasson, Erik (2012-05-19). "Norquist compares Sen. Schumer's tax-dodger bill to the Nazis, communists". The Hill. Retrieved 2012-05-21.
- Dunn, Peter W. (2012-05-21). "No Civilized Country Would Ever Banish Eduardo Saverin". American Thinker. Retrieved 2012-05-21.
- "Schumer decries 'Nazi' comparison in push to punish tax-dodgers". Associated Press. 2012-05-24. Retrieved 2012-05-26.
- Schumer, Charles (2012-05-24). "Amendment No. 2146" (PDF). Congressional Record. pp. S3548–S3550. Retrieved 2012-05-26.
- Benoit, David (2012-05-17). "Facebook Co-Founder Saverin Fires Back At 'Misinformation'". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 2012-05-21.