It was released on August 23, 2005 on Ferret Records. From February to April 2006, the group toured across North America with Bleeding Through. In early May, it was announced that a video was filmed for "The New Black". Also in May, the band toured the UK with support from Protest the Hero. On June 13, a deluxe edition of Gutter Phenomenon was released, it included a DVD with footage from their tour with Bleeding Through. The band went on the 2006 edition of the Warped Tour. On August 23, it was announced that bassist Chris Byrnes left the band and was replaced by former The Chariot member Keller Harbin. In October and November, the band supported Atreyu on their tour of the U.S. The album was reissued on vinyl as part of a box set along with Last Night in Town (2001) and Hot Damn! (2003). The box set was released on December 12 through Suburban Home Records.