Julia Tuttle Causeway sex offender colony
|This article needs additional citations for verification. (December 2013)|
The Julia Tuttle Causeway sex offender colony (also called "Bookville" by former residents) was an encampment of banished, registered sex offenders who were living beneath the Julia Tuttle Causeway—a highway in Miami, Florida, USA—from 2006 to April 2010. The colony was created by a lobbyist named Ron Book, who wrote ordinances in several different Miami-Dade County cities to restrict convicted sex offenders from living within 2,500 feet (760 m) of schools, parks, bus stops, or homeless shelters. Since Book was also head of the Miami Homeless Trust, he ironically was also in charge of finding housing for the released sexual offenders. In the city/county of Miami-Dade, these ordinances made it so the only legal areas sex offenders could live in Dade County were the Miami Airport and the Florida Everglades. Miami-Dade laws are significantly stricter than State of Florida laws on residency restrictions for sex offenders. Florida State Law required that no sex offender could live within 2,000 ft from "where children gather." Under that requirement, housing was possible; however, under Book's lobbying, the Dade County Commission increased that number to 2,500 ft, thereby banishing hundreds of local citizens who then began gathering under the Julia Tuttle Causeway.
Before the colony was established, the State of Florida provided sex offenders a list of locations where they could live that did not violate the boundaries set by the City of Miami, but the closest was in Broward County. Although the Florida Department of Corrections initially denied that they were forcing the offenders to live under the bridge, the Miami New Times reported that internal communication in the Department of Corrections proved this to be false and that released offenders were told to live in the colony or face more jail time. Citizens who were released were issued driver licenses by the State of Florida listing their addresses as the Julia Tuttle Causeway.
As many as 140 people lived in the colony in July 2009. They were required to be in the camp overnight from 6 pm to 7 am, when a representative from the Department of Corrections arrived to check that they were there. Most of the structures in the encampment, described by The Miami Herald as a "shantytown", were tents, improvised wood, or cardboard structures. Some had plumbing and cooking capacities, and residents of the colony shared generators for electricity to recharge cell phones and the tracking devices they were required to wear.
Conflicts over responsibility
As the number of residents grew, the City of Miami and the State of Florida disagreed over who was ultimately responsible for the sex offenders. Miami City Commissioner Marc Sarnoff, worried about how tourists perceived the colony, prompted an attorney from the Florida Department of Corrections to write a letter to the City of Miami absolving themselves of responsibility. The City of Miami responded by filing a lawsuit against the state, citing public health and safety concerns. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) had also filed a lawsuit against the City of Miami for imposing the 2,500-foot rule for sex offenders when the State of Florida's law restricts them to 1,000 feet (300 m) from where children congregate. The ACLU said that the 1,000-ft rule would allow many of the offenders to return home. Ironically, the camp was under further scrutiny for being within the forbidden area; a city park on an island in Biscayne Bay caused questions about the Julia Tuttle Causeway colony itself being in violation of the sex offender laws.
Local clergyman Vincent Spann likened the camp to a Biblical leper colony, and offered to house the sex offenders in a manner similar to that which he employed to treat those recovering from drug and alcohol addiction. He predicted it would cost more than a million dollars a year. In September 2009, a judge responding to the lawsuit filed by the ACLU ruled that the City of Miami was allowed to set its own ordinances. The ACLU promised to appeal the decision. As of 2009[update] Miami was facing other lawsuits about moving the sex offenders. In February 2010 Miami Dade County passed a new ordinance that still prevented sex offenders from living within 2,500 feet of schools but only forbade them from living within 1,000 feet of places such as parks and daycares. The county also made this ordinance effective throughout the whole county and declared any stricter ordinances passed by other Miami-Dade cities to be superseded and repealed. With this new county ordinance, various pockets of the county were now legal for sex offenders to live in, and most, but not all, of the sex offenders ceased to be homeless. Previously, the sex offenders had been banned in most parts of the county from living within 2,500 feet of schools, daycares, parks, and in some places even school bus stops. To this day, however, the problem continues.
Throughout the camp's existence, The Miami-Dade County Homeless Trust, an organization tasked by the county to help end street homelessness in Miami-Dade County, had been working to find permanent housing for all of the sex offenders living under the bridge. The trust is chaired by Ron Book, the lobbyist who helped write and pass into law the 2,500-foot restriction, prompted by the abuse of his daughter at the hands of a hired caretaker. On April 15, 2010, the Trust moved the last of the sex offenders living under the bridge into other housing. However, further protest from nearby communities ensued. Several former residents of the encampment were evicted from a Miami hotel in late April 2010.
In November 2011, the Miami Herald reported on the fate of the former Julia Tuttle Causeway colony, which former residents nicknamed "Bookville". Analysts studying the colony unanimously agreed on two relevant issues: the inability to find a stable home for offenders increased the risk that they would re-offend, and the close proximity of offenders to schools or parks did not increase the possibility that past offenders would re-offend. Despite these findings, Book solicited for and applied federal stimulus money to buy short-term stays for offenders, eventually costing US$1,000 a month which, as noted by the Herald, would have been unnecessary without the more stringent law that Book championed. This is incorrect according to David Raymond, former executive director of the Homeless Trust: federal Stimulus funds were never utilized for this population in Miami-Dade County; the funds used were from the local Homeless Food & Beverage Tax. Rent subsidies. along with job placement services and case management were provided for up to six months. Residents of Miami's Shorecrest neighborhood protested about 13 sex offenders who had relocated there. Book placed another 43 offenders in a trailer park also housing many children. Book forewarned that the stimulus funds for housing the sex offenders would run out. The Herald reported that out of 1,960 sex offenders who had registered to live in Miami-Dade, 256 stopped reporting their locations to authorities.
Throughout 2013 and 2014, evidence began to reach the news that there is still a problem of homelessness amongst Miami-Dade sex offenders, despite the county's slight relaxation of the residency restrictions. Almost all of the Julia Tuttle Causeway residents got homes immediately after the camp was cleared, but many have gone back into homelessness since then. A hotel that once housed many of the Causeway's former residents ended up kicking all sex offenders out of the hotel after one was arrested for re-offending. Ron Book later found housing for many sex offenders in a trailer park. However, Book himself kicked the sex offenders out of the trailer park after deciding that a nearby youth shelter counted under the definition of school. Miami City Commissioner Mark Sarnoff has criticized the problem of homeless sex offenders in the county. However, Sarnoff himself has built miniature "pocket parks" in order to prevent sex offenders from being able to move into the Little River area of Miami, which Sarnoff represents. Now, many of the homeless sex offenders are sleeping on railroad tracks (although most have homes during the day since the Miami-Dade residency restriction only applies from 10 pm to 6 am.) In October 2014, the ACLU announced plans to again sue the county over the residency restrictions. A similar lawsuit by the ACLU against Miami-Dade County failed in the ironically named 2009 case Exile v Miami-Dade County, when it was ruled that Florida law does not prevent localities from enacting stricter sex offender residency restrictions. (Contrary to a New Jersey Supreme Court ruling that invalidated local sex offender ordinances on those grounds.)
A media crew, ARTE G.E.I.E from Germany, covered the story in depth, filming a 30-minute documentary in 2010. National US television news magazine programs offered little coverage and no American documentary had ever been broadcast on the topic. This American Life aired the story on their May 10, 2010 episode titled "The Bridge."
- Miami sex offenders form outcast colony, UPI (May 3, 2009). Retrieved on July 21, 2009.
- Thompson, Isaiah (February 6, 2008). Homeless Sex Offenders Face Eviction, Miami New Times. Retrieved on July 21, 2009.
- Allen, Greg (July 21, 2009) Bridge Still Home For Miami Sex Offenders, National Public Radio. Retrieved on July 21, 2009.
- Knipe, Julie (July 10, 2009). Sex offenders sue over Julia Tuttle bridge colony, The Miami Herald. Retrieved on July 21, 2009.
- Zarella, John (2007). Florida housing sex offenders under bridge", CNN.com. Retrieved on July 21, 2009.
- Garcia-Roberts, Gus (April 14, 2009). Pastor Spann's Master Plan, Miami New Times. Retrieved on July 21, 2009.
- Strict Miami-Dade sex-offender law to remain in place The Miami Herald (September 18, 2009). Retrieved on September 18, 2009.
- Valdemoro, Tania (April 25, 2010). "Shorecrest residents unhappy about relocation of sex offenders - Sex offenders? Not in my backyard, Miami residents tell their mayor and other city officials", The Miami Herald, Shorecrest.
- Lebovick, Jennifer; Beasley, Adam (April 20, 2010). "Hotel evicts sex offenders", The Miami Herald, p. 3B.
- Jonas, Valerie and Bradley, Walter (November 5, 2011). "The end of ‘Bookville’ homeless camp under the Tuttle?" Miami Herald. Retrieved on November 5, 2011.
- German Documentary, "Reportage" Arte GEIE 2010
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8P8JGFMdREs&list=PLE2FABE27A178ECC7&index=1copyright ARTE GEIE 2010
- Julia Tuttle Causeway (Sex Offender Issues)
- Julia Tuttle Causeway (YouTube)
- Julia Tuttle Miami Saga (YouTube)
- Once Fallen Julia Tuttle Causeway page (Once Fallen)
- Ira Glass (7 May 2010). "The Bridge Transcript, Act Three: Throw the Book at Them". This American Life (episode 407). Retrieved 29 July 2010.